Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have bought my sons cheap school shoes in Deichmann (light hearted)

137 replies

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 15:51

Yes a very first world problem.

Long story short my kindly dm gave me £100 for school shoes as she does every year - last year I lied when she asked if it was enough, I think 2 pairs cost me about £130. And one pair had to be glued back together at Christmas, another story

Being an old fashioned sort I know she expects me to go to Clarks so off we went today.

Nobody else in the shop. Served by teenager who was beyond useless. Brought out various shoes and couldn't give an opinion as to whether they fitted or not. DS2 wanted a particular pair and she brought out the same wrong pair THREE Times and didn't believe me when I said she was bringing out quite a different design to what he wanted. Didn't have anything that DS1 wanted at all. DS2 tried about 10 pairs of shoes too big or too small (according to him) so in the end we gave up and left.

We headed to another stockist other side of town which sells Clarks and other brands. But passed Deichmann - brightly lit, welcoming store, full of other mums and kids on the way so I thought let's give it a go. Much easier experience - ok so you find your own shoes but you don't have to rely on useless teenagers to find the ones you want, you either find them or you don't. Result was two happy boys, 2 for 1 offer, paid less than £40 for two pairs of shoes including some weatherproofing in a machine, came home, happy days.

Now I know the quality might be rubbish and that possibly some dodgy child labour was involved (anyone know?) but quite frankly Clarks is taking the piss if a. their shoes fall apart before christmas b. you don't get any actual advice when buying your shoes which tbh I always assumed was part of the cost and c. all the child options are a patchwork of smaller bits of leather which are a nightmare to clean. Added to that they have zero lace up options for a size 3 son. I think they are a rip-off.

Was I unreasonable to have bought my sons cheap (and possibly not hard-wearing) shoes. Will I be shopping again in a few weeks' time? Is Deichmann quality actually ok? At the price I paid if they lasted a few months I'd be happy. The staff person I spoke to was lovely, so much more helpful than her counterpart at Clarks.

But if I was unreasonble I will take them back and head to the other Clarks stockist (who also stocks other brands).

Before anyone says I will explain to my dm and use the other £60 on other stuff the kids need for school. And yes I know I'm extremely lucky that I have a dm to help me with such costs in a COL crisis.

OP posts:
Missingmyusername · 25/08/2023 17:42

Not really what the thread is about but I bought myself some boots from shoe zone ( boot emergency). So uncomfortable, I had them four years 😳kept going back to them they’re still waterproof, worn to death. I still have them..

Endo85 · 25/08/2023 17:40

If anyone is looking for budget shoes I'd recommend toe zone (I buy them in sainsburys) hard wearing, very comfortable and have easily lasted a full school year and still in good condition.

MrsMoastyToasty · 25/08/2023 17:39

I've always rated Clinkards shops for service and the number of different brands they sell.

stayathomer · 25/08/2023 17:38

We had to go cheap this year as all of the kids needed shoes and I just hope they’re ok as two run around so much in school and one goes on long walks at lunchtime. If they seem okay they’re probably fine op, I don’t know how Clark’s compare to others as when it comes down to it, those type of shoes aren’t made for what kids put them through- they’d probably be better off allowed to have runners

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 17:36

@SuperiorM
mine have definitely had some shoes in the past that lasted a full school year.

if these make it till Christmas I’ll be happy

OP posts:
SuperiorM · 25/08/2023 17:35

Mummyme87 · 25/08/2023 16:36

Last year I got my 4yr old start rite for £50, lasted the whole year no issues, my 8yr old had some supermarket ones and had to replace them because the quality was dreadful.

clarks I think are rubbish. We did do deichman this year, Hushpuppy brand so hopefully will be decent

A 4 year old was in the same shoe size all year??

junglejane66 · 25/08/2023 17:34

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 15:51

Yes a very first world problem.

Long story short my kindly dm gave me £100 for school shoes as she does every year - last year I lied when she asked if it was enough, I think 2 pairs cost me about £130. And one pair had to be glued back together at Christmas, another story

Being an old fashioned sort I know she expects me to go to Clarks so off we went today.

Nobody else in the shop. Served by teenager who was beyond useless. Brought out various shoes and couldn't give an opinion as to whether they fitted or not. DS2 wanted a particular pair and she brought out the same wrong pair THREE Times and didn't believe me when I said she was bringing out quite a different design to what he wanted. Didn't have anything that DS1 wanted at all. DS2 tried about 10 pairs of shoes too big or too small (according to him) so in the end we gave up and left.

We headed to another stockist other side of town which sells Clarks and other brands. But passed Deichmann - brightly lit, welcoming store, full of other mums and kids on the way so I thought let's give it a go. Much easier experience - ok so you find your own shoes but you don't have to rely on useless teenagers to find the ones you want, you either find them or you don't. Result was two happy boys, 2 for 1 offer, paid less than £40 for two pairs of shoes including some weatherproofing in a machine, came home, happy days.

Now I know the quality might be rubbish and that possibly some dodgy child labour was involved (anyone know?) but quite frankly Clarks is taking the piss if a. their shoes fall apart before christmas b. you don't get any actual advice when buying your shoes which tbh I always assumed was part of the cost and c. all the child options are a patchwork of smaller bits of leather which are a nightmare to clean. Added to that they have zero lace up options for a size 3 son. I think they are a rip-off.

Was I unreasonable to have bought my sons cheap (and possibly not hard-wearing) shoes. Will I be shopping again in a few weeks' time? Is Deichmann quality actually ok? At the price I paid if they lasted a few months I'd be happy. The staff person I spoke to was lovely, so much more helpful than her counterpart at Clarks.

But if I was unreasonble I will take them back and head to the other Clarks stockist (who also stocks other brands).

Before anyone says I will explain to my dm and use the other £60 on other stuff the kids need for school. And yes I know I'm extremely lucky that I have a dm to help me with such costs in a COL crisis.

Added to that they have zero lace up options for a size 3 son. I think they are a rip-off.

That'll be the Velcro

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 17:34

ElfAndSafetyBored · 25/08/2023 17:30

My son insisted on £24.99 ShoeZone school shoes. Swears they are more comfortable than his Kickers were. They lasted pretty well too but I’m pretty sure two pairs of them would be cheaper than a pair of kickers anyway.

Similarly these shoes I got today the kids def felt they were far more comfy than anything in Clarks, and they look it too.

bur my dh has pointed out that the shoes that are probably best for feet usually start a bit uncomfortable and are only comfy once worn in- this was def the case when I was a kid so he’s probably got a point

OP posts:
SuperiorM · 25/08/2023 17:33

We gave up with Clarks as school shoes after one pair we had were useless in wet weather and caused DC to slip. Regarding sticking them back together at Christmas, I can’t recall ever buying any school shoes that lasted more than a term - mostly cus feet just kept growing. About to go into Yr13 and a half size bigger than last term.

Re Deichman - I buy everyday trainers for myself there. They wear out in about 8-10 months but don’t fall apart and soles don’t split. I’ve had Ecco and other premium brands that have lasted no longer and normally the soles come unstuck or the upper goes. So I rate Deichman as inexpensive but good.

Beseen22 · 25/08/2023 17:30

I bought from Diechmann too. Started school on cheap shoes (Aldi?) on a mumsnet recommendation but they were a disaster and lasted less than 3 weeks. Had to emergency order Kickers which were great and lasted a year and a half though were always a little wide for his feet. Went to Deichmann to try on kickers but couldn't get a good fit so went for Hush Puppies and they fit him great and he says they are very comfy. Hope they last!

My best friend owns a shoe shop and they do start rite but she doesn't have a lot of choice and feels awkward if a friend comes in and she doesn't have anything that suits them so she advised me to go to Deichmann.

ElfAndSafetyBored · 25/08/2023 17:30

My son insisted on £24.99 ShoeZone school shoes. Swears they are more comfortable than his Kickers were. They lasted pretty well too but I’m pretty sure two pairs of them would be cheaper than a pair of kickers anyway.

AntiHop · 25/08/2023 17:27

I think you'll regret it. After avoiding them for a few years after 2 pairs fared very badly, I bought a pair of trainers for dd. They lasted around 2 months. They were very cheap, maybe £15.

I now stick to clarks, m and s or John lewis.

Ricochetsandwhich · 25/08/2023 17:25

Spend some of the extra money on gorilla glue to stick them back together when they fail 😎

my sons last school schools were cheap and cheerful deichmanns and fell apart quite quickly but i eeked at least another term out of them with a bit of glue.

his new ones are £90 Clarkes and I’m preying they last.

my daughter has got hers from deichmanns the last 2 years and they’ve been ok so it’s a bit of a lottery!

avemariiiaa · 25/08/2023 17:19

anotheranotheranotheranother · 25/08/2023 16:00

Before anyone says I will explain to my dm and use the other £60 on other stuff the kids need for school.

Very presumptuous of you.

Give the £60 back.

Very presumptuous of you to decide the DM would take the £60 back and not want it to go towards other school items.

Makinglists · 25/08/2023 17:16

If you do buy clarks always keep the receipts- I've taken a few pairs back when they lasted a few months and they have been replaced with no problem. The quality is variable some styles are bomb proof others total rubbish. I always use the line that they are not of a suitable quality for the purpose.

GettingOldB4MyTime · 25/08/2023 17:12

We gave up on Clarks years ago.... We got fitted and bought a pair, told they fit perfectly. Within a few days ds (about 3-4 at the time) had red marks on his feet and complaining his feet hurt. Took him to another Clarks in another town and told her was a whole size bigger than what they measured the week before at the other store.

Or when they told me my DD was a f fitting....she has never been an f fitting, she has narrow feet that have always measured below a d.... But they insisted she was an f.

Start rite are better imo, but we don't have anywhere local to try them on.

Past few years ds has had his from sports direct, most we've paid is £20 and they last the year.
DD we've switched to hush puppies because they have multiple insoles to switch in so they fit her better. We paid £20 in sale for her shoes for this year..
.

So yeah.....don't spend a fortune on shoes at Clarks which aren't the quality they used to be.

SquirrelFeeder · 25/08/2023 17:10

I think Clark's stopped having arch support many years ago although I could be wrong

SquirrelFeeder · 25/08/2023 17:09

The problem with cheap shoes is that they don't usually have arch support. So once they grow up, they can end up with over-pronation (which I have and is extremely painful) and/or plantar fasciitis (which can also have other causes of course).
However, there's not very many brands left which have arch support, besides Petasil and possibly Geox

Sensibletrousers · 25/08/2023 17:08

It’s so important to have well-fitting, supportive shoes for growing feet, especially ones they spend 30 hours a week running around in. I never buy labels or expensive clothes etc but school shoes are the one item that I will spend good money on.

For the last 11 years I have taken my DSs every August to a local independent children’s shoe shop in our town for a fitting appointment and shoes. They stock European brands like Primigi, Froddo and Ricosta - amazing quality, robust, leather inside and out, arch support, loads of width and style options, ideal for growing young feet, and very professional fitting service by highly trained staff. In all the years I have never had to replace a pair due to wear and tear or outgrowing - DS10’s pair from last year are still in great nick! So whilst they are slightly more expensive than Clarks (around £50-60) it’s worth every penny as I’ve never had to buy 2 pairs in one school year.

Can you find an independent shop? Clarks trade on their reputation (our mums all took us there didn’t they!) but they are overpriced, crap quality and the fitting service is unreliable.

ActDottie · 25/08/2023 17:06

I’d keep the £60 and put it towards some more shoes in case they don’t last but hopefully you get a term out of them. I remember when my mum finally allowed me to get cheap school shoes and I felt so much better with them - yes I went through a couple of pairs a year but I much preferred the style rather than clunky Clarks shoes.

oldscrappynhungry · 25/08/2023 17:04

I got DS a pair from Deichmann for July as his Clark's ones fell apart with a month to go and I didn't want to spend much for just a few weeks when he would likely grow and need a new pair again for September.

Granted they were only worn for a month, but that's walking a couple of miles a day minimum plus kicking a hall around every break and lunchtime and they still look good enough to pass down to his cousin.

I also have bought adult shoes from Deichmann and they lasted well too. Boots and Birkenstock style sandals.

coodawoodashooda · 25/08/2023 17:01

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 15:57

oh dear appreciate your honesty

Same here

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 16:55

Balloonhearts · 25/08/2023 16:49

I've had a pair of Converse style shoes from there that lasted 6 years wearing them every summer. They're fine. I buy from there.

YABU to call a teen working on minimum wage with minimum training useless. Blame the shitty company for not giving adequate training. How would you like it if your DC was called useless?

that's a fair point. My annoyance was with the company not her personally though.

OP posts:
JessieJoJames · 25/08/2023 16:51

Are they leather? - I always find cheaper shoes are plastic which is not good for the feet.

fancyfrogs · 25/08/2023 16:50

For what it's worth, I'm a nurse and worked full time, 12hr shifts constantly on my feet and had a pair of black deichmann shoes (similar to school shoes!) that were so comfy and lasted about 2.5 years. Loved them.