Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have bought my sons cheap school shoes in Deichmann (light hearted)

137 replies

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 15:51

Yes a very first world problem.

Long story short my kindly dm gave me £100 for school shoes as she does every year - last year I lied when she asked if it was enough, I think 2 pairs cost me about £130. And one pair had to be glued back together at Christmas, another story

Being an old fashioned sort I know she expects me to go to Clarks so off we went today.

Nobody else in the shop. Served by teenager who was beyond useless. Brought out various shoes and couldn't give an opinion as to whether they fitted or not. DS2 wanted a particular pair and she brought out the same wrong pair THREE Times and didn't believe me when I said she was bringing out quite a different design to what he wanted. Didn't have anything that DS1 wanted at all. DS2 tried about 10 pairs of shoes too big or too small (according to him) so in the end we gave up and left.

We headed to another stockist other side of town which sells Clarks and other brands. But passed Deichmann - brightly lit, welcoming store, full of other mums and kids on the way so I thought let's give it a go. Much easier experience - ok so you find your own shoes but you don't have to rely on useless teenagers to find the ones you want, you either find them or you don't. Result was two happy boys, 2 for 1 offer, paid less than £40 for two pairs of shoes including some weatherproofing in a machine, came home, happy days.

Now I know the quality might be rubbish and that possibly some dodgy child labour was involved (anyone know?) but quite frankly Clarks is taking the piss if a. their shoes fall apart before christmas b. you don't get any actual advice when buying your shoes which tbh I always assumed was part of the cost and c. all the child options are a patchwork of smaller bits of leather which are a nightmare to clean. Added to that they have zero lace up options for a size 3 son. I think they are a rip-off.

Was I unreasonable to have bought my sons cheap (and possibly not hard-wearing) shoes. Will I be shopping again in a few weeks' time? Is Deichmann quality actually ok? At the price I paid if they lasted a few months I'd be happy. The staff person I spoke to was lovely, so much more helpful than her counterpart at Clarks.

But if I was unreasonble I will take them back and head to the other Clarks stockist (who also stocks other brands).

Before anyone says I will explain to my dm and use the other £60 on other stuff the kids need for school. And yes I know I'm extremely lucky that I have a dm to help me with such costs in a COL crisis.

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 25/08/2023 18:40

Why wouldn't you take them back if they lasted less than two months? You'd have right of return under the fact the shoes were not fit for purpose.

BertieBotts · 25/08/2023 18:39

Weird, I live in Germany and Deichmann is basically the local version of Clarks. Never thought of it as down-market. I suppose they do have a range of brands but they tend to have a good selection and great sales. Haven't had any shoes from there fall apart, ever.

katepilar · 25/08/2023 18:36

Why do you think Deichmann shoes are rubbish? In my home country Deichmann does sell some good shoes that last.

Never understood why you would need a shop assistant to tell you whether your shoes fit you or not. Or your childs.

GellerYeller · 25/08/2023 18:33

We had awful experiences with two different Clark’s stores measuring wildly different sizes(consecutive days, not weeks apart BTW). And suggesting shoes that were far too big but with insoles in, so they would last. They were visibly slipping off but I had a very polite child who agreed to the. They looked like Ronald McDonald so back they went.
We have had very good service from Schuh if that helps.

SunWorshipping · 25/08/2023 18:27

hot2trotter · 25/08/2023 18:24

I've always bought my kids school shoes off very (Toe Zone I think? Other places stock them) and they have always lasted the full school year. Never paid more than £30 a pair either.
Only problem is not being able to try them on so I have to buy 2 sizes for each, and then send back the pairs that don't fit (simple returns procedure).

We've had these too, they lasted all year v good quality I thought, even with my then reception aged boy dragging his toes along etc, they still looked fine by the end of the year.

QueenOfThorns · 25/08/2023 18:25

SherlocksDeerstalker · 25/08/2023 15:56

I will say that I bought Deichmanns for DD last year as they were the only pair in the whole town she deemed suitable, and they fell apart in approx 13 seconds. Looked like I’d dragged her up from a pit by Christmas. Ended up buying another pair for January as the seams had split and her feet were soaked every day.

This was my experience with Clark’s last year. The replacement pair after Christmas was Startrite and they were a bit better!

hot2trotter · 25/08/2023 18:24

I've always bought my kids school shoes off very (Toe Zone I think? Other places stock them) and they have always lasted the full school year. Never paid more than £30 a pair either.
Only problem is not being able to try them on so I have to buy 2 sizes for each, and then send back the pairs that don't fit (simple returns procedure).

MrsRandom123 · 25/08/2023 18:23

SherlocksDeerstalker · 25/08/2023 15:56

I will say that I bought Deichmanns for DD last year as they were the only pair in the whole town she deemed suitable, and they fell apart in approx 13 seconds. Looked like I’d dragged her up from a pit by Christmas. Ended up buying another pair for January as the seams had split and her feet were soaked every day.

My daughter didn’t even get that long. Sole all worn away by October break & the strap broke off as well. We walk 10mins to & from school but only 3 days as drive the other 2 & they change into indoor shoes in school so not even on everyday! Bought them as she has akward feet & only pair we found anywhere that fit - couldn’t find another pair anywhere but luckily could get boots & she just had to wear those (which i usually buy her for winter anyway) this year trying a kickers pair after trying on about 50 pairs of shoes 😩

RitzyMcFitzy · 25/08/2023 18:22

A lot of people seem to genuinely believe that if feet under the age of 10 make contact with non-Clarks shoes that said feet will instantly turn gnarly as well as feeble.

Truly genius marketing from Clarks that this belief went so deep for so many decades.

SunWorshipping · 25/08/2023 18:22

Clarks shoes are overpriced rubbish. I got them from there once when my daughter had her first pair of school shoes for nursery (they wear uniform), they pulled this bizarre stunt with an ipad where they asked our daughter her favourite colour on a app thing, I thought it was just a fun thing to occupy her. When the shop assistant brought out the 4 pairs of school shoes I asked to try on, there were 2 extra boxes, I asked what's in there and the shop assistant whispered to me "don't open it, my boss is watching me serve". So of course I went and looked and there were 2 pairs of trainers in my daughter's favourite colour. The shop assistant apologised and said it was a thing they were made to do to get you to buy another pair, she hated doing it and didn't unless her boss was watching (she had kids too). I was already spending £45 on a pair of shoes for a 3 year old, they were wanting another £40 on trainers I didn't need or want, they were hoping pester power would work. No thanks. Never went there ever again. No idea if they still do this, it was over 4 years ago now?

We get them from next, asda or schuh now, they have all lasted as long as they still fit 9-12 months, as they are cheaper you can replace them sooner if necessary, although I've never needed to. Always worth trying a cheaper option and seeing how their fair.

Mummyoflittledragon · 25/08/2023 18:20

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 16:10

wow that is definitely not something I need to worry about just yet. They're at primary and I don't think have noticed what their friends have on their feet. But am sure they will when a bit older.

The other thread is about a 12 year old girl, who is just starting secondary. My dd was close to school refusal at some stage in primary and found transitions very difficult so there was no way she would have gone to school with Skechers in secondary... or any shoe, which made her feel less confident.

I used to get dd Clark’s when she was little for the width. I agree the quality isn’t brilliant.

Maybe put the money aside for later in the year. Odds on you’ll spend it on another pair each and the money will all be spent.

Needmorelego · 25/08/2023 18:11

@JudgeJ Shoe Zone sell branded shoes these days. Some are quite expensive.

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 18:10

JudgeJ · 25/08/2023 18:05

No, I think it's probably way above Shoezone, you don't get that whiff of plastic as you walk past! We used to shop there, Deichmann, when we lived in Germany, intersting that they used to own Elefanten, my very favourite children's shoes! They don't make their own shoes though, they sell a variety of brands.

Oh right the ones I got were “Memphis one” I assumed they were their own brand. But perhaps because I didn’t recognise it.

OP posts:
Hungryfrogs23 · 25/08/2023 18:09

I agree with lots of the previous posts. Clarks quality has massively deteriorated in my opinion. We bought some last year. The people "fitting" don't seem to have a clue and they looked tatty so SO fast.

Her startrite ones on the other hand have lasted a whole school year both times. Still look immaculate.

Gladtoblasto · 25/08/2023 18:09

I saw the light with Deichmanns a while back after years of expensive shoes. They are very good.

Mummyme87 · 25/08/2023 18:05

Yes @SuperiorM imagine that. His feet have grown 1/2 - a whole size in 12months. They fit perfectly throughout.. a checked after Easter to make sure they fit okay still. Is that okay with you?

JudgeJ · 25/08/2023 18:05

TheGirlWhoLived · 25/08/2023 16:07

I’ve never heard of deichmann, is it like shoezone?

No, I think it's probably way above Shoezone, you don't get that whiff of plastic as you walk past! We used to shop there, Deichmann, when we lived in Germany, intersting that they used to own Elefanten, my very favourite children's shoes! They don't make their own shoes though, they sell a variety of brands.

Illbebythesea · 25/08/2023 17:56

We went to M&S this year, they have kids foot measurers on the floor so you can do it yourself and my local almost always has a variety of sizes. They cost me £29 each, apparent scratch proof leather, one picked frozen Disney black patent ones and the other picked a standard black style pair. Can’t speak for their durability yet but clarks just seems shit and gimmicky to me, they never have the size we need and the pricing is eye watering!

MotherHubbardEmptyCupboard · 25/08/2023 17:55

Deichman are great, honestly the Clarks people talk of disappeared many years ago. My children have had them for school shoes for years usually out grow but I haven't had any problem with quality

APurpleSquirrel · 25/08/2023 17:54

Makinglists · 25/08/2023 17:16

If you do buy clarks always keep the receipts- I've taken a few pairs back when they lasted a few months and they have been replaced with no problem. The quality is variable some styles are bomb proof others total rubbish. I always use the line that they are not of a suitable quality for the purpose.

I was just going to say this - if you have the receipt or proof of purchase they will refund you in full.
I took a pair of boots back to Clark's after they developed a hole on the top of foot. I didn't have the receipt as it had been 6months since I'd bought them, but they still refunded us half the price.

Rec0veringAcademic · 25/08/2023 17:52

space before country and actually without the comma
Sorry!

Rec0veringAcademic · 25/08/2023 17:51

I live in a Deichmann-everywherebcountry, the quality is actuall, very ressonable - depending on the brand! Did you go for Caprice or Easy Street? The latter will last, the former... not so much...

Hotflushesinthesunfun · 25/08/2023 17:49

I found Asda shoes lasted well when mine were primary school age. High school we upgraded to M&S which also lasted well.

user1469207397 · 25/08/2023 17:47

Not school shoes for my children, but for myself - I’m a TA. Bought a pair of flat lace ups from their own brand and wear them every day from September round to Easter. Six years on and they are still going strong (have had them re-heeled twice, but money well spent). Very impressed!

Eleganz · 25/08/2023 17:46

School shoes are always a lottery. Have had cheap pairs last for ages and expensive pairs not make a term and vice versa. Depends what our little darlings decide to get up to in them.