Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have bought my sons cheap school shoes in Deichmann (light hearted)

137 replies

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 15:51

Yes a very first world problem.

Long story short my kindly dm gave me £100 for school shoes as she does every year - last year I lied when she asked if it was enough, I think 2 pairs cost me about £130. And one pair had to be glued back together at Christmas, another story

Being an old fashioned sort I know she expects me to go to Clarks so off we went today.

Nobody else in the shop. Served by teenager who was beyond useless. Brought out various shoes and couldn't give an opinion as to whether they fitted or not. DS2 wanted a particular pair and she brought out the same wrong pair THREE Times and didn't believe me when I said she was bringing out quite a different design to what he wanted. Didn't have anything that DS1 wanted at all. DS2 tried about 10 pairs of shoes too big or too small (according to him) so in the end we gave up and left.

We headed to another stockist other side of town which sells Clarks and other brands. But passed Deichmann - brightly lit, welcoming store, full of other mums and kids on the way so I thought let's give it a go. Much easier experience - ok so you find your own shoes but you don't have to rely on useless teenagers to find the ones you want, you either find them or you don't. Result was two happy boys, 2 for 1 offer, paid less than £40 for two pairs of shoes including some weatherproofing in a machine, came home, happy days.

Now I know the quality might be rubbish and that possibly some dodgy child labour was involved (anyone know?) but quite frankly Clarks is taking the piss if a. their shoes fall apart before christmas b. you don't get any actual advice when buying your shoes which tbh I always assumed was part of the cost and c. all the child options are a patchwork of smaller bits of leather which are a nightmare to clean. Added to that they have zero lace up options for a size 3 son. I think they are a rip-off.

Was I unreasonable to have bought my sons cheap (and possibly not hard-wearing) shoes. Will I be shopping again in a few weeks' time? Is Deichmann quality actually ok? At the price I paid if they lasted a few months I'd be happy. The staff person I spoke to was lovely, so much more helpful than her counterpart at Clarks.

But if I was unreasonble I will take them back and head to the other Clarks stockist (who also stocks other brands).

Before anyone says I will explain to my dm and use the other £60 on other stuff the kids need for school. And yes I know I'm extremely lucky that I have a dm to help me with such costs in a COL crisis.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
15667788c · 25/08/2023 23:38

Depends what width feet your child has ? Mine is wide foot so I only buy from start rite now. Clarks are shit they measured wrong on so many occasions, I bought a pair from Clarks and took them round to the good independent shoe shop to check because I didn’t trust Clarks and they were completely the wrong size.

Boomboom22 · 25/08/2023 21:49

I ended up in matalan! Adult size 6. Look perfect but im sure will fall apart, but then so do Clarks. For the 4 year old he loves the dinosaur ones and the half sizes and wider fit can be useful. But by age 8 I think sainsburys matalan and deichmann shoes are better. Plus anything in a 5+ in clarks is v ugly.

amy85 · 25/08/2023 20:23

I purchased school shoes from there once and never again...both pairs fell apart in less than a month

SuperiorM · 25/08/2023 20:12

RitzyMcFitzy · 25/08/2023 18:41

In the UK their shops are seen as 'pile 'em high and sell 'em cheap' type of places.

Deichman shoes I’ve bought for myself last better than Ecco and North Face and North Ridge as walking shoes

RidingMyBike · 25/08/2023 20:03

We've had Startrite, Petasil, Primigi, Ricosta and Geox at various times and they've all been excellent quality and lasted well - DD grows out of the shoe rather than the shoe wearing out first.

They've mostly still been in good enough condition to pass on too.

alizee21g · 25/08/2023 19:51

Not read entire thread but just wanted to add my daughter once had Deichmanns own boots doc martens style and they lasted whole winter no problems.
We went today hoping to take advantage of buy one get one half price offer but no luck now that she's starting secondary with their petty rules regarding school shoes. It doesn't help she's in between sizes so size 5 were too small and size 6 too big. We're heading to clarks outlet tomorrow, fingers 🤞.
I am surprised to hear all of the negativity regarding Clarks, never had a problem with them. I also often buy Startrite from their online outlet and I think they're a bit better. Last year mine had startrite and kickers and they lasted really well.

RidingMyBike · 25/08/2023 19:51

Clarks staff don't know how to fit shoes properly. I wouldn't buy shoes there again. We go to an independent shoe shop which isn't cheap either but the shoes are much better quality... and also fit properly!

BustyDin · 25/08/2023 19:30

RedHelenB · 25/08/2023 19:02

I never get the mumsnet thing with Clarks. My ds lasted his final 2 years at secondary and he regularly played football in them at lunch. Plus a 15 min walk each way on all weathers.
Worth the money imo.

My son could make a pair of Clarks shoes last for a school year. I decided that boys' shoes were made to withstand activity, and the shit assumption of shoe designers was that girls would just sit around looking decorative.

MarshaArt · 25/08/2023 19:20

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

But then you’d have to go elsewhere to find a thread to do a ‘you do know..’ on.

Hunkydory99 · 25/08/2023 19:12

Another one who’s given up on Clark’s. I think they’ll be gone in the next year. The quality is awful and the prices are insane. Have taken both kids in store in the last three months and each have chosen shoes and trainers but Clark’s haven’t had their first choices in stock. Measured daughter at a size 11 but didn’t have any shoes she wanted in her size so tried to push us to buy the next size up even though the clearly didn’t fit. Tried to leave to order online and the assistant began badgering me to make a sale. I felt awful, was very awkward. My five year old was beginning to get upset. don’t want to be in thag position again!

RedHelenB · 25/08/2023 19:02

I never get the mumsnet thing with Clarks. My ds lasted his final 2 years at secondary and he regularly played football in them at lunch. Plus a 15 min walk each way on all weathers.
Worth the money imo.

BustyDin · 25/08/2023 19:01

My DD (who was what we called a "tomboy" back in the Olden Days) shredded Clarks within about 30 seconds, so I bought her Start Rites. She shredded those within about 35 seconds. I then bought her some school shoes in M&S which were no better, but a fraction of the price. Not that this is hugely relevant, but it might be useful to someone. BTW, I wouldn't feel bad, OP.

alwaysneedanap · 25/08/2023 18:58

I have 3 kids, and end up buying 6 pairs for them in September, we have used Deichmann shoes several times ( the trainers I buy are Sketchers from there tho) My eldest's (13) always last until he outgrows them, and the younger two (primary) are hit and miss. We usually get at least 1.5/2 terms out of the school shoes, sometimes longer. The school are happy for them to wear trainers as well, so by Summer term they just wear Sketchers every day. Just avoid patent ones, they rub through so fast!

FloweryWowery · 25/08/2023 18:57

SunWorshipping · 25/08/2023 18:22

Clarks shoes are overpriced rubbish. I got them from there once when my daughter had her first pair of school shoes for nursery (they wear uniform), they pulled this bizarre stunt with an ipad where they asked our daughter her favourite colour on a app thing, I thought it was just a fun thing to occupy her. When the shop assistant brought out the 4 pairs of school shoes I asked to try on, there were 2 extra boxes, I asked what's in there and the shop assistant whispered to me "don't open it, my boss is watching me serve". So of course I went and looked and there were 2 pairs of trainers in my daughter's favourite colour. The shop assistant apologised and said it was a thing they were made to do to get you to buy another pair, she hated doing it and didn't unless her boss was watching (she had kids too). I was already spending £45 on a pair of shoes for a 3 year old, they were wanting another £40 on trainers I didn't need or want, they were hoping pester power would work. No thanks. Never went there ever again. No idea if they still do this, it was over 4 years ago now?

We get them from next, asda or schuh now, they have all lasted as long as they still fit 9-12 months, as they are cheaper you can replace them sooner if necessary, although I've never needed to. Always worth trying a cheaper option and seeing how their fair.

This happened to us with the ipad, the colour thing and bringing out trainers. I was so cross. And trying to get you to buy shoes that clearly don't fit because they have nothing in the correct size. And getting different sizes depending on who measures. And shoes for girls being impractical and all very girly for young girls. And being crap quality. Grrrr.

We find startrite good for quality and width fittings. Also like Charles Clinkard.

bellac11 · 25/08/2023 18:52

Personally I want to continue to buy Clarks shoes but they are so so overpriced and dont have the support that I would expect from a retailer like that

Im finding these days that anything with real proper support and removable insoles are costing upwards of 150 quid, awfully expensive

The only condition I would always have with shoes is that they must be leather, non of this fake leather or plastic stuff, not good for feet in general or growing feet specifically

Mumof3girlsandaboy · 25/08/2023 18:50

LaurieFairyCake · 25/08/2023 16:02

I bought Start rite in the sale every year - shoes were about £40 in the sale

Lasted all year, every year

That is exactly I do for my 9 year old son. John Lewis had a lot of them on sale and all was half price bought 2 pairs for £40
1 pair school shoes
1 pair trainers for PE

icelollycraving · 25/08/2023 18:49

I am having an absolute nightmare with school shoes this year. Took Ds to Clark’s, 5 staff and just us as customers. Clearly undertrained teenager ‘fitted’ him and told me he was a 5.5. Unlikely as his shoes last year were bigger (also from Clarke’s). I went home, ordered a pair in a 7. Too small and narrow so took them back. Had another fitting. One foot they think is a 5.5 and one is a 6 but couldn’t tell me why the 7 was too small.
His school is very strict so they have to be smart and at £50+ they need to last.
She brought out about 5 pairs, all too small so I suggested perhaps a men’s shoe. Men’s size 7 too big 🤦‍♀️
Went to M&S, nothing.
I have ordered two pairs from Start Rite, both in a 7. One too small and one ok ish. £60 for a pair of ok shoes that’ll probably be wrecked soon.
If there had been ANYWHERE else in my town, I would have given it a go!!

SquirrelFeeder · 25/08/2023 18:48

Correction, Petasil are Portuguese

Needmorelego · 25/08/2023 18:47

@RitzyMcFitzy I've never thought of them as a particularly cheap retailer. But then again I see people refering to shops like Wilko as "discount" shops when they are just a standard ordinary shop that sells things at standard ordinary prices - not discounted ones 🫤

SquirrelFeeder · 25/08/2023 18:46

SuperiorM · 25/08/2023 17:33

We gave up with Clarks as school shoes after one pair we had were useless in wet weather and caused DC to slip. Regarding sticking them back together at Christmas, I can’t recall ever buying any school shoes that lasted more than a term - mostly cus feet just kept growing. About to go into Yr13 and a half size bigger than last term.

Re Deichman - I buy everyday trainers for myself there. They wear out in about 8-10 months but don’t fall apart and soles don’t split. I’ve had Ecco and other premium brands that have lasted no longer and normally the soles come unstuck or the upper goes. So I rate Deichman as inexpensive but good.

I always buy Petasil for my child due to the arch support as my child really needs it and honestly, every pair we've had have been sold on after a year. They're Italian made. Excellent quality

Procrastinatingbecauseithelps · 25/08/2023 18:43

I used to work at Clarks - fitting shoes and training staff in fitting shoes. My DS has just started school this year and was measured a full foot size smaller than he actually is. I had to show the lad in the shop how to measure properly 🤦🏻‍♀️

RitzyMcFitzy · 25/08/2023 18:43

Procrastinatingbecauseithelps · 25/08/2023 18:41

Clarks shoes haven’t been the same since they were sold to a private equity in 2020 and subsequently a majority share was sold to a Chinese firm.

any shred of quality has evaporated.

Private equity firms care about 1 thing… profit profit profit. They will cut quality, corners, and service to capture every drop of it.

All we can do is use our feet (pun intended) and not shop there.

Same with DMs and Hunter

SquirrelFeeder · 25/08/2023 18:42

RitzyMcFitzy · 25/08/2023 18:22

A lot of people seem to genuinely believe that if feet under the age of 10 make contact with non-Clarks shoes that said feet will instantly turn gnarly as well as feeble.

Truly genius marketing from Clarks that this belief went so deep for so many decades.

A bit of an exaggeration there. It stems from the fact that Clark's used to have arch support which is certainly preferable for growing feet (but obviously not essential).

Procrastinatingbecauseithelps · 25/08/2023 18:41

Clarks shoes haven’t been the same since they were sold to a private equity in 2020 and subsequently a majority share was sold to a Chinese firm.

any shred of quality has evaporated.

Private equity firms care about 1 thing… profit profit profit. They will cut quality, corners, and service to capture every drop of it.

All we can do is use our feet (pun intended) and not shop there.

RitzyMcFitzy · 25/08/2023 18:41

katepilar · 25/08/2023 18:36

Why do you think Deichmann shoes are rubbish? In my home country Deichmann does sell some good shoes that last.

Never understood why you would need a shop assistant to tell you whether your shoes fit you or not. Or your childs.

In the UK their shops are seen as 'pile 'em high and sell 'em cheap' type of places.