Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? Other half preventing us from going on holiday even though I’m paying for everything

344 replies

HC1718 · 25/08/2023 14:20

This is totally a first world problem so I’m going to start by apologising for that.

AIBU to be really upset with my other half for preventing us from going on holiday with my DS(5) to Florida next year even though I will be paying for everything (literally everything!)

Our relationship has a complete imbalance as I am a high earner and his salary is fairly low. I have always paid for pretty much everything and I gave up a long time ago asking him to contribute to things for our son (I pay for all the child care, clothes, shoes, school uniform, clubs/activities, birthday/Xmas presents, birthday parties etc), the only contribution he makes is to half the food shop and a third of the mortgage, everything else (including all the bills) are paid by me. Now, I have never had an issue with this as I don’t believe that the only contribution to the family is financial. However, I’m also the one that has to organise everything, cook the dinner, make sure there is bread and milk available, deal with DS’s social life, do DSs homework with him, fix things around the house (other half has self declared he has no practical skills and refuses to even attempt these things even with a YouTube tutorial), etc. Other half goes to work, comes back, has a shower, eats dinner, washes the dishes (which he will make a massive deal about that he has done it), watches some TV and sleeps, so he has a pretty sweet deal in all of this. My biggest issue is that I take on all of the mental workload for the family.

One of the things I really need is a holiday every year. My job and home life are stressful and I need to have something to look forward to. I also want my DS to have happy holiday memories. I have approached the subject of going to Florida next August, but my other half is kicking off at even the mention of it as he has decided it is not the holiday that he wants, and he wants to decide what we do if we go anywhere. My issue is that I will be paying for literally everything (including food, drinks, attractions, car hire etc), this is somewhere that I want to go and is also where DS has been asking to go for ages (the power of the TV adverts have got to him).

AIBU for feeling that he should be more open to going on holiday and that he cannot expect to make us go on a holiday that he wants if he’s not paying for it. If I go on holiday without him, then how do I explain to DS that his Dad refused to come on holiday with us?

OP posts:
Tigger1895 · 25/08/2023 20:43

If he doesn’t want to go, let him stay at home. He’s an adult and made his decision, you are an adult and can make your own decisions.
If he doesn’t want to discuss it, so be it and then there’s no argument.

Onthemaintrunkline · 25/08/2023 20:34

I can’t for the life of me understand what/how/why you are with this man.

GameOverBoys · 25/08/2023 20:32

In a normal family where both parents contribute to the household you would be unreasonable to dictate where the holiday is. It should be a family decision. But as he seems to have opted out of the family, you have no moral obligation to consult him.

MzHz · 25/08/2023 20:30

It’ll take 4-5 days without that joy sucker in your lives on a 24 hour basis for both you AND your son to bloom.

he can be a good dad EOW or 50/50 (but that sounds like too much work for him)

do not waste your life on this piss poor man

do not allow your ds to grow up thinking this is what a partner/husband looks like.

as the saying goes, you don’t stay for the dc, you need to LEAVE for the sake of your dc

andHelenknowsimmiserablenow · 25/08/2023 20:30

Have you considered that he may have something in his past that means he will not want to complete the visa application if you go to Florida OP? Is that a possibility?

User3735 · 25/08/2023 20:27

Well, mostly I agree with you. But I am a low earner and my partner is a high earner and if he wanted to go on a big expensive holiday I wasn't sure about and he said he should get to chose because he earns more money then that wouldn't be fair. So in my opinion it depends on his reasons for not wanting to go, I personally would hate Disney, but wouldn't say no to Florida entirely, there is surely compromise to be had. Is there actually somewhere else he wants to go, ask him for suggestions, if he doesn't have any at all then he is just being an arsehole, but he might have a point.

Acheyknees · 25/08/2023 20:23

So he gets to decide where you go on holiday but you have to organise it, book it and pay for it.

Duckingella · 25/08/2023 20:21

Book and go without your cocklodger.

He must be the most expensive and annoying pot washer in history.

Did he move straight out of his mummy's house and in with you?

grumpycow1 · 25/08/2023 20:18

Please go without him! You deserve to create memories with your DS in the way you want.

If he won’t compromise & makes life miserable because of it, why are you with him? He can still be a good dad even if you aren’t together. What does the relationship bring you?

knobkopf · 25/08/2023 20:16

I have approached the subject of going to Florida next August, but my other half is kicking off at even the mention of it as he has decided it is not the holiday that he wants, and he wants to decide what we do if we go anywhere. My issue is that I will be paying for literally everything (including food, drinks, attractions, car hire etc), this is somewhere that I want to go and is also where DS has been asking to go for ages (the power of the TV adverts have got to him)

When I read this I don't see a controlling OP. It's him who has decided he doesn't want to go to Florida and is kicking off and it's him who wants to decide what they do. He doesn't seem to care that DS wants to go there (leaving OP's wishes out of this just for a moment - but she would also like to go there).

The OP does say her issue is that she will be paying for literally everything. I didn't read that as her wanting to control and be the boss because she has more money. I think the point was more that it's not like he has to contribute a whole pile of money he doesn't have to a holiday he doesn't want to go on because the OP is paying. Also, he's sitting there kicking off and wanting to decide where they go and he still won't be paying, even if he gets his way.
Anyway, if the fucker is earning a third of the OP's salary it would be fair if he were to pay for a third of any holiday they want to go on but he won't because he is a cocklodger

Whatever way you look at it, it's one fucked up, unbalanced relationship and there needs to be serious discussions about the way forward.

PuzzledObserver · 25/08/2023 20:11

Do you have enough leave entitlement for Florida with your son AND another holiday as a whole family at another time?

If so, so that.

That way, you and your son get the holiday you both want, your DH doesn’t have to come since he doesn’t want to, AND you get another holiday for downtime as well.

Zonder · 25/08/2023 20:04

I'm amazed he gets to decide!

Dillane · 25/08/2023 20:02

Why are you with him OP?

WhenLifeGivesYouLimes · 25/08/2023 19:56

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 25/08/2023 19:42

A SAHM tends to deal with the housework, the childcare, the garden, the admin side of things to compensate for not bringing money in. She SAVES the family money.

What is he doing? It's not comparable at all and it's ridiculous to even say it.

He's working full time.

The fact that he doesn't earn as much as the OP doesn't make him a waste of space: it's his failure to pull his weight on the mental load that makes him a waste of space.

Takoneko · 25/08/2023 19:52

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 25/08/2023 19:42

A SAHM tends to deal with the housework, the childcare, the garden, the admin side of things to compensate for not bringing money in. She SAVES the family money.

What is he doing? It's not comparable at all and it's ridiculous to even say it.

He does work 45-50 hours per week, to be fair.
he obviously needs to pull his weight a bit more but he’s not a SAHD, he’s just paid a lot less than the OP even though he works anywhere between 5-15 hours per week more than the her.

Jl2014 · 25/08/2023 19:50

He sounds awful, OP. Read your post back and think of what you would advise someone else in your situation. I really don’t get how you could be in a relationship like this. It sounds like your partner is very selfish and taking advantage of you. If he really cared about you he’d be trying to do his fair share.

Unfortunately for some men this is what a relationship is for them so unlikely to change.

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 25/08/2023 19:42

stayathomer · 25/08/2023 19:39

The reason people are saying about if the tiles are reversed is that op’s main argument was that he’s not contributing to the holiday. If a sahm came on and said her dh says she has no say in the holiday are you honestly saying people would say that was okay? She’s doing that to her dh!!! As I said I work in retail and earn so much less than dh, do I just suck up every financial decision he makes?

A SAHM tends to deal with the housework, the childcare, the garden, the admin side of things to compensate for not bringing money in. She SAVES the family money.

What is he doing? It's not comparable at all and it's ridiculous to even say it.

stayathomer · 25/08/2023 19:39

Roles not tiles!!!

stayathomer · 25/08/2023 19:39

The reason people are saying about if the tiles are reversed is that op’s main argument was that he’s not contributing to the holiday. If a sahm came on and said her dh says she has no say in the holiday are you honestly saying people would say that was okay? She’s doing that to her dh!!! As I said I work in retail and earn so much less than dh, do I just suck up every financial decision he makes?

CantThinkOfANameAtAll · 25/08/2023 19:39

I know a lot of people are saying I should leave him, and I have thought about that many a time, but at the end of the day he a fairly decent Dad and my DS would be devastated if he were not around. I certainly could have done a lot worse in the baby daddy sense.

Ffs, he can still be a decent dad when he's not living with you, but actually he isn't a very good role model for your son. In fact no decent father would treat the mother of his son this way.

I think you need to define what a decent dad is. He plays with him? He reads him a bedtime story? How about doing his share of the chores. Or treating his partner with respect. Just the fun stuff then, nothing what a real father actually does.

Mari9999 · 25/08/2023 19:38

@HC1718
You are correct; this is a first world problem. However, it has a first world solution. Take your son and go without him.

It is not necessary that he go on every trip with you. Of he wants a different vacation let him go where he wants to go.

It sounds a bit as though you are both being passive aggressive. You earn the larger income and you feel entitled to the vacation that you want. I suspect that he is made subtly aware that in terms of travel he is a kept man and he has decided to resist.

I doubt that travel destination is the major issue in your household. I suspect that it is just a symptom of a much larger issue.

Takoneko · 25/08/2023 19:35

AcrossthePond55 · 25/08/2023 17:59

He may have a good reason why HE doesn't want to go, but that's not necessarily a good reason for OP not to take her DS on her own. Sounds as if she can afford it so why shouldn't she go even if he has a 'good reason' for not going himself?

My DH generally didn't go with us to visit my family as he'd have had the choice of hanging out with the 'old folks' or hanging out with my (female) cousins and I as we visited gossiped or took the DC places. Neither appealed to him so he chose to save his holiday time for better things. I had no problem with this and he had no problem with us going without him.

I think it makes a big difference as to whether there is a compromise situation or not.
I think there’s a big difference between him wanting to dictate the holiday location entirely vs “I don’t want to go to Florida in August”. If the issue is that he doesn’t want a holiday where the temperature could be north of 35 degrees every day with intense humidity and a strong chance of hurricanes, that could be solved by going at a different time of year. If he’s black and worried about police brutality in an increasingly right wing state then perhaps they could go to California instead.

Without knowing the reason or whether OP is willing to compromise at all, how can anyone possibly judge if he’s being unreasonable.

Chris002 · 25/08/2023 19:35

JanieEyre · 25/08/2023 18:39

There wouldn't be uproar against the husband in this situation. I've seen threads where people on MN have not hesitated to criticise women for being fannylodgers in exactly this sort of scenario.

Sure, he doesn't have to like the holiday - but if it's something his son and wife want to do, any decent man would go along with it out of love for them. And he certainly wouldn't stop them going on their own if he really couldn't bear the prospect.

No, having to do all the organising and take all the mental load whilst fathers sit around watching TV is not what being a mum is. Not in a properly equal partnership. I'm fairly amazed that any man really wants his son see him setting such an appalling example.

Personally I don't think he is setting his son a bad example the op says that she works 7/8 hrs and he works 9/10 hrs both work full time so he is going out to work long hours everyday is this setting a bad example ? She doesn't say what kind of job he does but it could be physically demanding maybe he is tired when he gets in ?
Some one has to look after the household and the child I have seen so many posts on here where men & women seem to underestimate the amount of work that's needed to run a home and look after a child as well as go to work but you need to work like that in order to afford luxury holidays. Maybe he is concerned that florida is too much of a stretch financially or maybe he anticipates months of argument of how she is paying for everything! Personally I would be bit demoralised if I came home after long day at work to my husband complaining about how he will have to pay for everything cos I don't earn enough would def put me off wanting to go on holiday at all if I was being may to feel like I was not contributing.

MyAnacondaMight · 25/08/2023 19:35

The money thing is a red herring here. He’s unwilling to compromise or prioritise your son’s enjoyment. How terrifically selfish can you be to not want to give your wife and child a wonderful holiday? And see them enjoying that?

Realistically, you have the upper hand here. Not to punish him for low earning, but to enforce a fair model of holidays. This time is your son’s pick, then your turn, then his. If he opts out of everything but his own enjoyment, then you’re a fool for continuing to choose that as a life for yourself.

FinallyHere · 25/08/2023 19:35

*did get a dishwasher to make it easier for him and he only has to load/unload it and wash the few hand wash items, LOL. He does mow the lawn and change the light bulbs as well!

When this issue has come up in the past, I have made it clear that I am happy to alternate holidays as I get he wants to go some different places, but his position is that he doesn’t want to go and it’s not even up for discussion (and he is certainly not willing to consider want DS might want to do). It’s a firm “I don’t want to go to Florida and we are not discussing this any further”. I know if I go without him it will cause arguments.*

What a Prince amongst men he is.

And you honestly think you could have done worse in the baby daddy stakes.

I am very sorry for you and your DC.