Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU? Other half preventing us from going on holiday even though I’m paying for everything

344 replies

HC1718 · 25/08/2023 14:20

This is totally a first world problem so I’m going to start by apologising for that.

AIBU to be really upset with my other half for preventing us from going on holiday with my DS(5) to Florida next year even though I will be paying for everything (literally everything!)

Our relationship has a complete imbalance as I am a high earner and his salary is fairly low. I have always paid for pretty much everything and I gave up a long time ago asking him to contribute to things for our son (I pay for all the child care, clothes, shoes, school uniform, clubs/activities, birthday/Xmas presents, birthday parties etc), the only contribution he makes is to half the food shop and a third of the mortgage, everything else (including all the bills) are paid by me. Now, I have never had an issue with this as I don’t believe that the only contribution to the family is financial. However, I’m also the one that has to organise everything, cook the dinner, make sure there is bread and milk available, deal with DS’s social life, do DSs homework with him, fix things around the house (other half has self declared he has no practical skills and refuses to even attempt these things even with a YouTube tutorial), etc. Other half goes to work, comes back, has a shower, eats dinner, washes the dishes (which he will make a massive deal about that he has done it), watches some TV and sleeps, so he has a pretty sweet deal in all of this. My biggest issue is that I take on all of the mental workload for the family.

One of the things I really need is a holiday every year. My job and home life are stressful and I need to have something to look forward to. I also want my DS to have happy holiday memories. I have approached the subject of going to Florida next August, but my other half is kicking off at even the mention of it as he has decided it is not the holiday that he wants, and he wants to decide what we do if we go anywhere. My issue is that I will be paying for literally everything (including food, drinks, attractions, car hire etc), this is somewhere that I want to go and is also where DS has been asking to go for ages (the power of the TV adverts have got to him).

AIBU for feeling that he should be more open to going on holiday and that he cannot expect to make us go on a holiday that he wants if he’s not paying for it. If I go on holiday without him, then how do I explain to DS that his Dad refused to come on holiday with us?

OP posts:
ScottishIceCream · 26/08/2023 13:35

at the end of the day he a fairly decent Dad

and

he is certainly not willing to consider want DS might want to do.

A fairly decent dad you say?

ScottishIceCream · 26/08/2023 13:31

I should clarify that I did get a dishwasher to make it easier for him and he only has to load/unload it and wash the few hand wash items, LOL. He does mow the lawn and change the light bulbs as well!

Well in that case he's a keeper for sure.

🙄

Bettelucksecondtimearoundimherewaitingforu · 26/08/2023 12:13

HC1718 · 25/08/2023 14:20

This is totally a first world problem so I’m going to start by apologising for that.

AIBU to be really upset with my other half for preventing us from going on holiday with my DS(5) to Florida next year even though I will be paying for everything (literally everything!)

Our relationship has a complete imbalance as I am a high earner and his salary is fairly low. I have always paid for pretty much everything and I gave up a long time ago asking him to contribute to things for our son (I pay for all the child care, clothes, shoes, school uniform, clubs/activities, birthday/Xmas presents, birthday parties etc), the only contribution he makes is to half the food shop and a third of the mortgage, everything else (including all the bills) are paid by me. Now, I have never had an issue with this as I don’t believe that the only contribution to the family is financial. However, I’m also the one that has to organise everything, cook the dinner, make sure there is bread and milk available, deal with DS’s social life, do DSs homework with him, fix things around the house (other half has self declared he has no practical skills and refuses to even attempt these things even with a YouTube tutorial), etc. Other half goes to work, comes back, has a shower, eats dinner, washes the dishes (which he will make a massive deal about that he has done it), watches some TV and sleeps, so he has a pretty sweet deal in all of this. My biggest issue is that I take on all of the mental workload for the family.

One of the things I really need is a holiday every year. My job and home life are stressful and I need to have something to look forward to. I also want my DS to have happy holiday memories. I have approached the subject of going to Florida next August, but my other half is kicking off at even the mention of it as he has decided it is not the holiday that he wants, and he wants to decide what we do if we go anywhere. My issue is that I will be paying for literally everything (including food, drinks, attractions, car hire etc), this is somewhere that I want to go and is also where DS has been asking to go for ages (the power of the TV adverts have got to him).

AIBU for feeling that he should be more open to going on holiday and that he cannot expect to make us go on a holiday that he wants if he’s not paying for it. If I go on holiday without him, then how do I explain to DS that his Dad refused to come on holiday with us?

Hello OP, I made my username just for you. Oh, the joy!

Please please, when you are ready to change the slave master, I am here, free, just waiting for you and please pick me next. Why not?!

Everything will continue as it is (yep, you my DOH paying for everything just as it is), and I will even 'wash the dishes (which I will do without a word of grumpiness- oh your new joy!) and of course you are free to take us on any holiday to anywhere even to the moon or into space and I will not 'prevent' you.

Seriously, why enslave yourself to this hero? Are you stuck? And yes, many women in relationships like this, so many of them it is actually sad. He doesn't even respect you and your son (clearly not 'his' son).

You, darling slave, don't get any sympathy from me. Nada!

billy1966 · 26/08/2023 12:09

HC1718 · 25/08/2023 16:57

I know a lot of people are saying I should leave him, and I have thought about that many a time, but at the end of the day he a fairly decent Dad and my DS would be devastated if he were not around. I certainly could have done a lot worse in the baby daddy sense.

Also regarding the get a dishwasher comments, I should clarify that I did get a dishwasher to make it easier for him and he only has to load/unload it and wash the few hand wash items, LOL. He does mow the lawn and change the light bulbs as well!

When this issue has come up in the past, I have made it clear that I am happy to alternate holidays as I get he wants to go some different places, but his position is that he doesn’t want to go and it’s not even up for discussion (and he is certainly not willing to consider want DS might want to do). It’s a firm “I don’t want to go to Florida and we are not discussing this any further”. I know if I go without him it will cause arguments.

And just to clarify we both work full time, but he does longer work days (9-10hrs versus my 7-8hrs)

So he's a bully to boot.

Awful example for your child.

You sound afraid of him and his anger?

So he is abusive.

Call Womens aid for a chat.

knobkopf · 26/08/2023 12:05

BessMarvin · 26/08/2023 11:21

The problem is there's various issues going on.
I don't think that earning more means overriding decisions. However it's the dp who seems to be refusing to discuss it.
Also, doing all the thinking and planning and doing for a family is exhausting. If op is doing it all on top of her job and he's doing none, then that is not fair. It's like having a child has impacted his life zero, it's the same as if they hadn't had a child. Whereas for op it is not the case and they now have an enormous amount extra to deal with.
I guess ultimately they don't sound like a team.

Exactly. OP says Other half goes to work, comes back, has a shower, eats dinner, washes the dishes (which he will make a massive deal about that he has done it), watches some TV and sleeps, so he has a pretty sweet deal in all of this
He does not do his fair share in the home, even taking into account the fact he is working longer hours.
But you're pissing into the wind trying to respond to that poster because they keep popping up posting exactly the same stuff, conveniently ignoring quite a lot of the things the OP says about her OH and obsessing about the financial aspect.

BessMarvin · 26/08/2023 11:21

Chris002 · 26/08/2023 10:30

He isn't doing very little though in my opinion - if you read the update post she says that they both work full time he does a 10 hr day - she does a shorter day 7- 8 hrs so she has to do the organising of day to day life - the issue for her is the financial imbalance. She earns a much higher wage - I don't understand why so many posters on here are saying he is useless !! He does a 10 hour day everyday he pays a third of the mortgage and the weekly shop, he is a great dad. As snippy socks says marriage is a partnership. I think there is more going on here than just an argument over a holiday. Op is unhappy perhaps that her partner is not earning equal to her. There is much more to a relationship than who earns the most and she says she should call the shots over the holiday cos she's paying for it. No wonder he doesn't want to go !! I wouldn't enjoy myself if my oh was going on about how much they were paying for !!

The problem is there's various issues going on.
I don't think that earning more means overriding decisions. However it's the dp who seems to be refusing to discuss it.
Also, doing all the thinking and planning and doing for a family is exhausting. If op is doing it all on top of her job and he's doing none, then that is not fair. It's like having a child has impacted his life zero, it's the same as if they hadn't had a child. Whereas for op it is not the case and they now have an enormous amount extra to deal with.
I guess ultimately they don't sound like a team.

Feverly · 26/08/2023 10:36

There is no marriage, and OP says he's a 'decent' father, which probably means fairly shit. He does nothing.

Chris002 · 26/08/2023 10:30

BessMarvin · 25/08/2023 19:02

Which sounds good. But he doesn't sound like he wants fo discuss anything and they aren't a team if op is doing almost everything and he's doing very little.

He isn't doing very little though in my opinion - if you read the update post she says that they both work full time he does a 10 hr day - she does a shorter day 7- 8 hrs so she has to do the organising of day to day life - the issue for her is the financial imbalance. She earns a much higher wage - I don't understand why so many posters on here are saying he is useless !! He does a 10 hour day everyday he pays a third of the mortgage and the weekly shop, he is a great dad. As snippy socks says marriage is a partnership. I think there is more going on here than just an argument over a holiday. Op is unhappy perhaps that her partner is not earning equal to her. There is much more to a relationship than who earns the most and she says she should call the shots over the holiday cos she's paying for it. No wonder he doesn't want to go !! I wouldn't enjoy myself if my oh was going on about how much they were paying for !!

fabmaccawhackyrhumbsaloft · 26/08/2023 10:07

Oh and I certainly would stop pandering to his demands . Just say well we're going and it's not up for discussion, there's the door if you don't like it.

fabmaccawhackyrhumbsaloft · 26/08/2023 10:01

I'd just tell him your going and is he sure he doesn't want to come, then I'd take a friend or other family member and ds and go enjoy it!

Batalax · 26/08/2023 09:55

If the op was dictating every holiday that wouldn’t be ok, but for this one off, children’s dream holiday, it’s perfectly ok for her to say she’ll go on her own.

Hibiscrubbed · 26/08/2023 05:55

”I don’t want to go to Florida and we are not discussing this any further”. I know if I go without him it will cause arguments.

Who the actual fuck does this freeloader think he is?

He’s like a second child. But considerably more unpleasant.

theGooHasGone · 26/08/2023 04:12

Honestly I voted YABU because as someone said earlier, you're being a total mug. Grow a spine and tell him he can have a say in where you go on holiday when he sacks up and pays for it. Until then, it's a lot cheaper to fly 2 people to Florida than 3!

Rainbowqueeen · 26/08/2023 01:16

I feel like he is actually only a decent dad because your DS is the age where he thinks dad is amazing and is happy to comply with whatever dad wants. When DS is old enough to have his own ideas and desires this will change and your OH sounds like he will not take that well.
So please reconsider your future with this guy.

As far as the trip goes, just tell DS that dad can’t go. Kids of his age are very accepting. Then go and have a great time

AcrossthePond55 · 26/08/2023 00:35

Takoneko · 25/08/2023 19:35

I think it makes a big difference as to whether there is a compromise situation or not.
I think there’s a big difference between him wanting to dictate the holiday location entirely vs “I don’t want to go to Florida in August”. If the issue is that he doesn’t want a holiday where the temperature could be north of 35 degrees every day with intense humidity and a strong chance of hurricanes, that could be solved by going at a different time of year. If he’s black and worried about police brutality in an increasingly right wing state then perhaps they could go to California instead.

Without knowing the reason or whether OP is willing to compromise at all, how can anyone possibly judge if he’s being unreasonable.

No, we don't know what his objections are, but even if he's NBU to not want to go there himself for whatever his reasons are, he is BU to tell the OP that she 'can't' go whenever it is she chooses to go. If he doesn't feel the need to compromise, perhaps she doesn't either. Because TBH it sounds as if there's a LOT of imbalance in their relationship and if I were OP, I wouldn't want to compromise, either. In fact, I'd be gone.

She said it will 'cause arguments'. If he's copping a nasty attitude (or worse) that IS unreasonable no matter how reasonable his reasons are. And it IS unreasonable to point blank refuse to discuss it.

There's nothing wrong with one parent taking their mutual child somewhere the other parent doesn't want to go. My DH took our boys camping in the wilderness. My idea of roughing it is a hotel with no room service. So needless to say I didn't go. But I certainly didn't try to stop him from going with the attitude of "If I don't want to go, nobody's going!" which seems to be OP's DH's attitude (according to OP). Another time because my DH will NOT fly in a commercial airliner, I took our DC to Hawaii and he arranged to go on a backpacking trip with mates. Everybody was happy, everybody had the holiday they wanted.

lemmein · 25/08/2023 22:32

I can't even imagine my DH daring to say its 'not up for discussion' - who the fuck does he think he is? 🤯

As he doesn't want to discuss it I wouldn't mention it anymore till you're waiting for the airport taxi to pick up you and your son.

Fuck him OP, he doesn't get to talk to you like a 5 year old cos he has a cock - something has gone very wrong in your relationship that he thinks this is a an acceptable way to behave.

MothBat · 25/08/2023 21:57

Should add that DP is completely unreasonable to veto the holiday without any discussion, explanation or alternative that you would all enjoy.

samqueens · 25/08/2023 21:51

You might want to read Why Does He Do That? By Lundy Bancroft in private (download on kindle/Apple Books) and see if it resonates.

He’s certainly very selfish, as this isn’t even in the realm of thinking of your son’s feelings on the matter… (The money is a big issue, but may turn out not to be the fundamental here).

Also from personal experience 5 is a great age to do a Disney park, if that’s what you’re thinking of! Fully magic

MothBat · 25/08/2023 21:32

Florida in August wouldn't be my thing either. Be careful about taking DS though as you will need DP's consent.
www.usa.gov/travel-documents-children#:~:text=Children%20traveling%20to%20the%20U.S.&text=If%20you%20travel%20or%20are,or%20signed%20by%20both%20parents.

Nanaof1 · 25/08/2023 21:21

fridascruffs · 25/08/2023 21:05

Go, but don't go in August. Worst time of year for Florida- 100 degrees fahrenheit and very very humid. Go at Feb half term or, at latest, Easter. Pleasant temperatures (80 degrees or so.) Worst month for hurricanes is September. But do go.

THIS I agree with! We went in December this last time and it was very nice. A few days were pretty warm but never hot like it is from June-September. The first time we went, it was June and the humidity and heat was not my favorite experience. Plus, it is truly beautiful in Nov/Dec with the decorations, so I am a bit biased.

For those who are saying both parents should get an equal say, this is something both the OP and her DS really want to do. If he doesn't want it, that is fine but he should not get to decide that they cannot go. Not every holiday has to be "everyone". My DH and DS wanted to go to Arizona and do some rock climbing. A friend offered use of his second home there. DH and DS would have been fine and happy if I had gone but since I am not a rock climber and not fond of heat (and strange bugs), I opted out. I felt it would be a waste of airfare etc., since it wasn't something I really wanted. I was fine and happy as heck that they got the chance to go. DH would never try and make me not go somewhere I really wanted to go either. I think OP's OH is acting like a spoiled brat. He should WANT his DS to go places he wants to go while he is of age to enjoy it.

Greengagesnfennel · 25/08/2023 21:17

I think if you did this every year (picked a holiday location you knew he hated. Refused to compromise and said it's tough I earn more so i get to choose) then yabu.
HOWEVER, as this is a one off I think YANBU but maybe you could be more conciliatory and less self-righteous in your request. Eg - I know you will hate it but it's for our ds , he's only young once and it will be more special for him if we are there as a family ( you might even like it a bit. Ask - Pls do this for me and ds and we will do something u choose next year type thing). He works and so time off is still precious. If his is not a well paid job it's likely to be less enjoyable than yours. Those days holiday feel precious to give up to something you don't want to do but family is often about compromise. I think yanbu but you sound like you might be annoying in the way you are asking.

fridascruffs · 25/08/2023 21:05

Go, but don't go in August. Worst time of year for Florida- 100 degrees fahrenheit and very very humid. Go at Feb half term or, at latest, Easter. Pleasant temperatures (80 degrees or so.) Worst month for hurricanes is September. But do go.

ihadamarveloustime · 25/08/2023 21:03

Go without him. Have a great time!

suburbophobe · 25/08/2023 20:58

^This post is beyond tragic because you are ignoring the real issue. What is it exactly that he beings to the table? He washes the dishes, chuck him and get a dishwasher. It'll be cheaper in the long run, more reliable and you can swap it out every 10 years or so for a newer model.

Take a think about what you are both modeling to your son. He is his closest male role model, are you seriously OK with your son growing up to be like him? Are you happy to demonstrate that women should just suck it up around useless lumps?

Of course yanbu. Go on the holiday you want to go on and your son wants as well. From a very simple view it is 2:1 so he is out voted. In all seriousness I'd make a list of the positives of having him in your life and the negatives, be completely honest with yourself. It isn't easy to leave a partner but he isn't what a partner should be. A true partner raises you up they don't drag you down.^

This with bells on @Sceptre86

Honestly, OP, I've brought up my child since birth just about, his father was more than useless. He's an adult now and has no trauma about his dad not being around.

You sound lovely. And you deserve so much more than what you are putting up with.
Next year August is a year away. Take this time to think about how you really want your life and that of your son going forward. And Disney can be on the top of your list, without a useless man about who only undermines you.
You really don't want your son growing up with him as a role model.

stayathomer · 25/08/2023 20:43

What is he doing? It's not comparable at all and it's ridiculous to even say it.
But that’s not the point- the point op makes is that since she earns the money to pay for it, shouldn’t she make the decision. My point is that money shouldn’t determine who makes big decisions because then a huge majority of us are fucked !!!!!