Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right of Way, Horse & Dog

183 replies

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 11:05

I'll try to keep this short.

I've got a dog, he's always on a lead when we're out. I live rurally, the field next to my garden is the only route to reach any public footpaths to walk my dog. The field has a public right of way across it as it's on a designated national trail.

It's owned by a neighbour who has just put a horse on the land. My dog has no reaction whatsoever to horses, he ignores all livestock. The horse he's put on the field is clearly agitated by my dog, as I try to walk across the field (I pick my time, when the horse is the furthest away) the horse will run up and sniff at the dog's back end and sort of push him, I'm assuming this is a warning of 'get away'.

Again, my dog ignores totally as I swiftly walk across the field, but the horse will follow and keep pushing him until we're out the gate. It's happened twice now.

Obviously I don't want the dog, or me, to get kicked/attacked by the horse so I can't walk across the field again to risk it - would I be unreasonable to tell the owner his horse is causing an issue? Neighbour has form for being difficult.

OP posts:
twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:58

Prescottdanni123 · 25/08/2023 11:56

@twistyizzy

Actually, the advice is if cows or horses charge at you and your dog when you are in the middle of a field, let the dog off the lead so it can run away. A dog can outrun a herd of angry cows, a human can't. That way, the cows will go after dog and leave you alone. If you keep the dog with you, there is a very high risk of being trampled.

Also, understand your dog's behaviour. If you don't think your dog has the common sense to run away from them or it will get aggressive, avoid fields with cows. My dog wants to be friends with everything so I would never go into the same field as a herd of cows with her. Tbh, I would avoid entering the same field as cows without a dog anyway. Friends of mine went on a walk with their two kids and had to turn back after a large herd charged at them from a distance. Luckily they had just entered the field and had time to grab the kids and run back to the gate.

Yes IF they charge! The horse here wasn't charging.

Cyclebabble · 25/08/2023 11:57

I own a field with a right of way at the top of it. I have certain obligations on the path which I maintain. I would not put a horse in my field which I thought was going to attack anyone, but this would be extremely rare. Horses are however curious and may come towards you to say hello. I would equally not be moving my horse to make you comfortable I am afraid and neither would I be fencing off the ROW- which would be quite expensive.

shrodingersvaccine · 25/08/2023 11:57

Where I live there are 'wild' horses and sometimes I have to walk near them. They can be quite curious because I suspect people feed them, and they don't like dogs when they have their babies or one of them is hurt.

I walk fast, as far away as possible from them, and ignore them completely, as do my dogs. If they do come near, I find either standing tall between them and my dogs and putting a hand out shout sternly at them to stop, or clapping at them and saying no makes them back off. They're not stupid just curious and a bit cowardly so trying to grandstand to protect their babies.

Natty13 · 25/08/2023 11:56

Anotherparkingthread · 25/08/2023 11:52

Used to live on a working farm with my horses.

I'd consider shooting any dog that was off the lead for bothering stock. We had lots of footpaths and most people were sensible enough to keep dogs under control.

Don't try to feed other people animals it will only cause them to be more pushy with you as you walk through the field. The horse will learn to bully you for treats.

I used to keep my bull in the bottom field and despite what walker's think they are entitled to, a beware of the bull sign is a curtesy and I certainly wouldn't be bothering to fence of a little path. The council won't do anything, they have no authority too because a horse in a field is a non event.

Keep the dog on the lead. Ignore the horse every single time, it will eventually work out that you don't pet it or feed it and will stop bothering you. It's not going to attack you, horses rarely attack when they have the option to leave.

Fellow farming childhood here (albeit abroad with different laws) and agree with all of this.

Prescottdanni123 · 25/08/2023 11:56

@twistyizzy

Actually, the advice is if cows or horses charge at you and your dog when you are in the middle of a field, let the dog off the lead so it can run away. A dog can outrun a herd of angry cows, a human can't. That way, the cows will go after dog and leave you alone. If you keep the dog with you, there is a very high risk of being trampled.

Also, understand your dog's behaviour. If you don't think your dog has the common sense to run away from them or it will get aggressive, avoid fields with cows. My dog wants to be friends with everything so I would never go into the same field as a herd of cows with her. Tbh, I would avoid entering the same field as cows without a dog anyway. Friends of mine went on a walk with their two kids and had to turn back after a large herd charged at them from a distance. Luckily they had just entered the field and had time to grab the kids and run back to the gate.

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:56

MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:51

Which isn’t what I said at all. Perhaps read my posts again while you’re brushing up on the Countryside Code.

Every situation (and dog) is different - there is no one size fits all here.

No but if you let your dog loose in a field with livestock, for any reason, and the owner sees you then they have a right to shoot your dog. Why risk it? Farmers around here DO shoot dogs if they are running loose on their land and quite rightly so.
You should never let your dog off the lead unless you fear for your safety. It is the reason we don't walk our dog through fields of cows at any time of the year.

MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:55

@Dotjones “None of which affects the farmer's right to shoot your dog if it is causing alarm to their animals. Even if one of their animals "started" it, the farmer has the right to finish it.”

Agreed.

maxelly · 25/08/2023 11:54

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 11:31

This is so helpful, thank you. The horse's ears were forward, he was nuzzling at me first so I gave him a pet - and he was trying to get into my dog-walk pouch, assume looking for treats? Then his attention was on the dog.

Aha, what's happening here is the horse is looking to be fed. Either his owner feeds him in the field or other walkers do (sadly this is very common even if you put up signs). So he's probably charging up to you hoping for treat. Is he all on his own as well? Horses are social animals and really shouldn't be kept without company, ideally another equine but at a push sheep or goats will do. If he's alone he probably lonely and a bit badly socialised. I doubt he'd be deliberately aggressive to you or your dog (quite rare in horses in open spaces except for breeding stallions who can be territorial or a mare feeding a baby, in enclosed spaces is different) but he could nip you looking for treats or accidentally tred on the pooch if he gets around his feet.

You could try and track down the owner and let him know but I doubt there's much they can do and if they're keeping him alone without even other horses visible that doesn't give me hope they're responsible owners. Personally I would pick up the dog if you can to avoid the treading, or otherwise just walk quickly as possible without running through the field and don't stop to interact at all, keep your shoulders angled away from him. Don't have your hands in pockets or rustle your treat pouch as he will definitely think there's something coming out of there for him! If horse approaches too close a waved lead rope as per PP and sharp 'no' should try and keep him out of your space (don't actually hit him though of course!).good luck.

Anotherparkingthread · 25/08/2023 11:52

Used to live on a working farm with my horses.

I'd consider shooting any dog that was off the lead for bothering stock. We had lots of footpaths and most people were sensible enough to keep dogs under control.

Don't try to feed other people animals it will only cause them to be more pushy with you as you walk through the field. The horse will learn to bully you for treats.

I used to keep my bull in the bottom field and despite what walker's think they are entitled to, a beware of the bull sign is a curtesy and I certainly wouldn't be bothering to fence of a little path. The council won't do anything, they have no authority too because a horse in a field is a non event.

Keep the dog on the lead. Ignore the horse every single time, it will eventually work out that you don't pet it or feed it and will stop bothering you. It's not going to attack you, horses rarely attack when they have the option to leave.

MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:51

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:46

That is different to what you said about just letting it off randomly.
In this scenario the horse isn't acting dangerously or aggressively so no need to let the dog off lead

Which isn’t what I said at all. Perhaps read my posts again while you’re brushing up on the Countryside Code.

Every situation (and dog) is different - there is no one size fits all here.

Dotjones · 25/08/2023 11:51

MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:43

Maybe you should read the Countryside Code yourself…

”Let your dog off the lead if you feel threatened by livestock or horses. Do not risk getting hurt protecting your dog. Releasing your dog will make it easier for you both to reach safety.”

None of which affects the farmer's right to shoot your dog if it is causing alarm to their animals. Even if one of their animals "started" it, the farmer has the right to finish it.

In the OP's case it sounds like a non-issue. Horse legally in field is curious about dog legally in field. It's not a problem until it is - either the horse attacks the dog/owner, in which case the owner can sue, or the dog bothers the horse and the farmer shoots it. The OP's choice is to take the risk and hope nothing happens or play it safe and not use that route. I know that "the field next to my garden is the only route to reach any public footpaths to walk my dog" but surely there is a road or something to get to the house? Or was all the furniture carried across the field when they moved in?

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:48

YellowReadingLamp · 25/08/2023 11:42

😂 the PPs joke reference obviously went over your head!

Note the clue in the sentence structure - "what about the bag of grain?" not a bag.....

It isn't funny when you have a £££ vet bill and your horse dies because some idiot decides they were entitled to feed your horse in its field! This happens on a regular basis across the country.

needtonamechangeforthis1 · 25/08/2023 11:46

@YellowReadingLamp it might be a joke to you but it's no joke when your horse is dangerously sick because idiots have fed it!
So yes it does need saying sadly

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:46

MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:43

Maybe you should read the Countryside Code yourself…

”Let your dog off the lead if you feel threatened by livestock or horses. Do not risk getting hurt protecting your dog. Releasing your dog will make it easier for you both to reach safety.”

That is different to what you said about just letting it off randomly.
In this scenario the horse isn't acting dangerously or aggressively so no need to let the dog off lead

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 11:45

Stickytreacle · 25/08/2023 11:40

I've had a horse that killed dogs and sheep, it would start by showing curiosity too. I think informing the owner is sensible, it would be the owner who faced strict liability if you or your dog were injured, especially if he was aware of the risks.

This is my concern.

OP posts:
twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:44

So many ill informed comments on here eg feed the horse/let your dog off the lead etc. Really shows how ignorant so many people are about walking in the countryside/through livestock etc.
Just to clarify:

  • always keep your dog on a lead around any livestock if you don't want it to get shot
  • never ever feed horses that you don't own as you could end up killing them or making them ill
  • Read up on the Countryside Code and learn correct way to behave in the countryside
PatriciaHolm · 25/08/2023 11:44

thedancingbear · 25/08/2023 11:31

But what about the bag of grain?

:-) just to say I got this @thedancingbear. Not least because of my discovery that Professor Layton now has an app...

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 11:44

primoseyellow · 25/08/2023 11:34

@Beastiee You sound like you are being very sensible and aware. I would be very wary about a horse, and I am pretty experienced. I have known horses to stomp on dogs with their front legs.

I would ignore the horse, don't pet, and if if approaches again calmly put your hand on his shoulder and push gently, very horse knows this means stop or back.

Thank you that's much appreciated - the gentle hand on the shoulder push is so helpful to know. I don't want to spook the horse, if there is a way that I can walk through safely then that would be brilliant.

He's huge (beautiful though) and with little experience of horses, it's intimidating when you can't tell what they're thinking or predict what they're going to do.

OP posts:
MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:43

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:39

Dogs should always be on a lead when around livestock. Read the Countryside Code!
Landowners have the right to shoot a dog if they think it is a danger to their animals so always, always have your dog on a lead.

Edited

Maybe you should read the Countryside Code yourself…

”Let your dog off the lead if you feel threatened by livestock or horses. Do not risk getting hurt protecting your dog. Releasing your dog will make it easier for you both to reach safety.”

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:42

JayAlfredPrufrock · 25/08/2023 11:35

Sounds to me as if the horse is just curious and probably wants to play.

Take a spare lead and waft it in the horse’s direction if it gets too close.

Never, ever take food on a walk or feed a horse that you don't own! Not only can food lead to aggression but you could end up killing the horse as many are on special/restricted diets.

YellowReadingLamp · 25/08/2023 11:42

needtonamechangeforthis1 · 25/08/2023 11:36

@thedancingbear the last thing you should ever do is feed it anything!

  1. it will always expect food from you and will harass walkers and potentially become aggressive.
  2. you should never ever feed other peoples animals without their permission. You have no idea what health issues it could cause or aggravate.

😂 the PPs joke reference obviously went over your head!

Note the clue in the sentence structure - "what about the bag of grain?" not a bag.....

Stickytreacle · 25/08/2023 11:40

I've had a horse that killed dogs and sheep, it would start by showing curiosity too. I think informing the owner is sensible, it would be the owner who faced strict liability if you or your dog were injured, especially if he was aware of the risks.

ActDottie · 25/08/2023 11:39

The more you walk through it the more the horse will get used to it and not care. But I’m both a horse and dog person so I’d have the confidence to keep walking through but understand if you don’t.

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 11:39

MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:21

What is the reason your dog is always on a lead when out on walks? If he is as you say and ignores horses and other livestock, in the situation you describe I would be inclined to let him off the lead just to cross the field with the horse in it. Then if the horse approaches him he can run ahead and it minimises the risk of either of you being hurt.

Obviously not an option if he has no recall though.

Dogs should always be on a lead when around livestock. Read the Countryside Code!
Landowners have the right to shoot a dog if they think it is a danger to their animals so always, always have your dog on a lead.

Swipe left for the next trending thread