Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right of Way, Horse & Dog

183 replies

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 11:05

I'll try to keep this short.

I've got a dog, he's always on a lead when we're out. I live rurally, the field next to my garden is the only route to reach any public footpaths to walk my dog. The field has a public right of way across it as it's on a designated national trail.

It's owned by a neighbour who has just put a horse on the land. My dog has no reaction whatsoever to horses, he ignores all livestock. The horse he's put on the field is clearly agitated by my dog, as I try to walk across the field (I pick my time, when the horse is the furthest away) the horse will run up and sniff at the dog's back end and sort of push him, I'm assuming this is a warning of 'get away'.

Again, my dog ignores totally as I swiftly walk across the field, but the horse will follow and keep pushing him until we're out the gate. It's happened twice now.

Obviously I don't want the dog, or me, to get kicked/attacked by the horse so I can't walk across the field again to risk it - would I be unreasonable to tell the owner his horse is causing an issue? Neighbour has form for being difficult.

OP posts:
Moanranger · 29/08/2023 09:00

A lot of silliness has been posted. I have for years walked over open pasture which may occasionally have a horse in it, and have done so with dogs. The process is, put dog on lead, enter field & walk purposefully, ignoring horse. It may approach as horses are naturally curious & also associate people with food. If it gets really close, just raise arm ( you are holding dog) and wave at horse, who will then probably back off & lose interest.( Not easy to explain, but basically wave the horse away, somewhat easier with two arms)
After you have crossed the field a few times, horse will get the message that you have no food & aren’t very interesting.
Cows are a different story.
Your welcome

CocoonofDavid · 29/08/2023 08:50

Reiterating what other sensible posters have said re food.

People feeding equines is a nightmare for owners, but unwittingly becomes a PITA for walkers too (and then owners!).

I have friends who kept a pair of donkeys in a small field (their land), that had a footpath going through the middle.

So many bloody walkers fed them that they became a nuisance- following and trying to frisk people for snacks. In the end there were complaints to the council and the donkeys weren’t allowed out there any more. A real pain as the path was right down the middle and the field too small to split, so the field/paddock now stands empty and the donkeys have been moved elsewhere. If walkers hadn’t fed them there’d never have been a problem.

Dogscanteatonions · 29/08/2023 08:46

FoodFann · 29/08/2023 08:36

Is the dog small enough to carry?
Also, maybe mention it to the owner and ask if there’s any treats you can give to the horse to help neddy understand you and the dog aren’t a threat?

That's terrible advice , you should never feed horses you don't own and even if you asked the owner (who would say no anyway almost certainly) freedom a horse treats would only ensure they are super interested in you and would hound you every single time.

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 29/08/2023 08:44

FoodFann · 29/08/2023 08:36

Is the dog small enough to carry?
Also, maybe mention it to the owner and ask if there’s any treats you can give to the horse to help neddy understand you and the dog aren’t a threat?

Noooo.

Feeding it is about the worst thing you can do - horses can get really aggressive if they think there's food available. OP would be putting herself in a lot of danger if she was to do this - and no sane owner would give permission either!

twistyizzy · 29/08/2023 08:42

FoodFann · 29/08/2023 08:36

Is the dog small enough to carry?
Also, maybe mention it to the owner and ask if there’s any treats you can give to the horse to help neddy understand you and the dog aren’t a threat?

Never ever feed horses you don't own! This is dangerous advice.
First of all it can lead to food aggression and make the situation worse and secondly you don't know if the horse is on a restricted or special diet.

FoodFann · 29/08/2023 08:36

Is the dog small enough to carry?
Also, maybe mention it to the owner and ask if there’s any treats you can give to the horse to help neddy understand you and the dog aren’t a threat?

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 29/08/2023 08:32

Isthisasgoodasitis · 28/08/2023 22:29

Field owner is legally obligated to provide a safe route for you so you can ask him to provide it or report the obstruction to the council who will demand it’s given

That's not what the law says.

Landowners do have to keep rights of way clear - but that doesn't have nothing to do with their right keep horses and other types of livestock on their own land.

Whu · 29/08/2023 08:31

I’m surprised the owner hasn’t fenced off the field so the horse can’t get to the public footpath. So many people feed horses all sorts of crap and many horses have died from this so I would never let my horse be around the public and especially not around unknown dogs.
But saying that horses shouldn’t be kept alone either as they are herd animals so the poor thing is probably desperate for company.

Not sure you can do anything other than what you are doing op.

twistyizzy · 29/08/2023 08:26

Isthisasgoodasitis · 28/08/2023 22:29

Field owner is legally obligated to provide a safe route for you so you can ask him to provide it or report the obstruction to the council who will demand it’s given

A horse in a field isn't an obstruction.
Cows in fields aren't obstructions.
Sheep in fields aren't obstructions.
They are livestock and the landowner has every right to keep livestock in the field. The landowner doesn't have to provide a safe route through a field they just have to allow access to the footpath through the field, that's why bulls can be kept in fields with footpaths through.
Obviously you can't stop livestock from walking on the footpath because they aren't machines so as a walker you have to use your common sense as to whether the footpath is safe to use or not.

Cherrysoup · 28/08/2023 23:20

Be very careful. My horse hated dogs with a passion, the staff at the yard had to stop taking the yard dogs to catch in, he'd try to stamp on them. Realistically, what will the owner of the field do? He's entitled to keep whatever he wants on his land.

stichguru · 28/08/2023 22:43

The horse is in his field and not attacking you or the dog, so everything is fine. You and your dog may walk through the field on the public footpath, if you don't feel comfortable doing that, then don't. There is no law that says animals shouldn't be in fields where there are paths.

Isthisasgoodasitis · 28/08/2023 22:29

Field owner is legally obligated to provide a safe route for you so you can ask him to provide it or report the obstruction to the council who will demand it’s given

Doone21 · 28/08/2023 20:41

It sounds fine and curious and friendly, don't know what you're so scared of, tbh

HobbyHorse30 · 28/08/2023 08:31

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 17:10

He chose to own a field with a public footpath and right of way.

And you chose to live in a property where the only dog walk that you deem suitable passes through a field which will, more likely than not, contain livestock.

What exactly is it that you expect the owner of the horse to do? Because it sounds like you’re not willing to budge in terms of your dog walk but somehow expect the horse owner to resolve this

TequilaNights · 28/08/2023 04:24

If the horse is new to the land, it will naturally be inquisitive, they are by nature, nuzzling your dog isn't an act of aggression, if it was bothered by your dog in an aggressive manner, ears would be pinned back, striking out with front legs, trying to bite, turning it's rear to kick, would be the response.

In a few weeks time, it probably won't even take any notice of you.

Horses are also herd animals, it could be lonely, taken from somewhere it knew to a new home on its own.

Horses can be scary to non horsey folk, I understand that, as PP suggest, don't feed it, say hello, keep walking as usual, eventually it will get bored and pay you no attention.

k1233 · 28/08/2023 04:12

Some horses are dog killers. My experience is, if they are, they come in on the attack. They don't mosey along. That said, they're big unpredictable animals. They are strong (can rip muscle from bone with their teeth) and kicks are deadly.

Personally I won't handle my dog and horse together as I can't give each the attention needed to keep them safe. So I wouldn't walk my dog through a field with a horse I don't know.

If I were you, I'd speak to neighbours and see if there is another route to get you to where you want to be.

Todaywego · 25/08/2023 18:48

I have horses and I would suggest that you have a chat with the owner and ask how best to discourage their horse from getting too close. Ultimately safety comes by keeping distance between you and the horse.
It's OK to guess that ears forward means horse is friendly but we're not there. If you know horses then you know when you can be reasonably safe close in to them and asking them to move away, and also when it might not be the best idea. Horses being sent away sometimes spin and kick their heels.

One of our mares will attack dogs in the field. Not dogs out walking with us when we ride, but dogs in her territory. She starts ears forward, trotting with a high step, front legs really lifting, picking up speed towards the dog, then at the last minute her ears go back and she goes for the strike. I witnessed it once when too far away to stop her and it was pretty horrible, but luckily the dog realised at the last minute and was agile and fast. It was a wake up call for the trespassing dog walking owners though I think.
So Op I'd ask the owner what is best to do with their horse. Poor thing will be likely to attach themselves to living beings in their field. They are herd animals, not suited to living alone.

xmb53 · 25/08/2023 18:46

You only have a case if the horse is known to be dangerous. The assumption is that it is not (as is the case with sheep, goats, cats, dogs (mostly), cows etc and can be kept in a field cross by a right of way.

rainbowunicorn · 25/08/2023 18:29

CharlotteBog · 25/08/2023 17:01

No, it doesn't really work like that. People who don't pay road tax are as entitled to cross the road, or use their bike and to be protected by the same laws as road tax payers.

If the public have a right to be there, they should be able to be so safely, not 'at their own risk'.

Road tax isn't actually a thing. Itvwas abolished in 1937. It is vehicle excise duty and has absolutely nothing to do with roads.
Might be an idea to actually know what you are talking about if you are going to attempt to use comparisons.

Silverdogblue · 25/08/2023 18:05

Shadowchaser · 25/08/2023 17:36

@Silverdogblue yes- I work in an emergency vets. It’s not as uncommon as you would think sadly.

That was absolutely not clear in your post. I think it was slightly disingenuous it to say so.

Dragonwindow · 25/08/2023 18:02

I have horses and dogs. I am very wary of unknown horses (and dogs!) Absolutely no chance I'd physically push someone else's horse away from me. One of mine would keep her distance if you carried a stout walking stick and looked like you meant business. My other one would take that as unacceptably aggressive in his own field, and probably escalate the situation - you just can't always guess.

If the neighbour is part way reasonable, would they come and walk across the field with you, and show you the best way of managing that particular horse? I'll be honest though, I would always be very uncomfortable of a horse that barges into my space like that, and who is likely being stuffed with treats by other walkers which will only encourage it.

Also, it's especially likely to be unpredictable if it's being kept on its own - horses really need company. If you're lucky, the owner will take it off the grass when it gets muddy...

DixonD · 25/08/2023 17:53

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 11:20

That's very helpful to have your view. How do you know they won't be aggressive? And when you say it's not your issue if it makes someone uncomfortable, is that because you know the horse won't 'attack', or you don't care if it does?

With your knowledge and experience, if you have advice or reassurance that this horse isn't at risk of being upset/attacking then that would be appreciated. I don't want to stress a horse, either.

Horses are very rarely aggressive. They are prey animals and would usually only act defensively.

twistyizzy · 25/08/2023 17:48

CharlotteBog · 25/08/2023 17:01

No, it doesn't really work like that. People who don't pay road tax are as entitled to cross the road, or use their bike and to be protected by the same laws as road tax payers.

If the public have a right to be there, they should be able to be so safely, not 'at their own risk'.

The public only have the right to cross the land on the designated footpaths. The owner of that land has the right to put livestock in the field and it is up to the public to chose whether they then use the footpath. It is very much at their own risk as they should be aware that they are crossing a privately owned field which may, or may not, contain livestock.

Shadowchaser · 25/08/2023 17:36

@Silverdogblue yes- I work in an emergency vets. It’s not as uncommon as you would think sadly.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 25/08/2023 17:35

Nopenopenopenopenopenope · 25/08/2023 17:15

If a field with a public footpath has horses or cows in I avoid it like the plague. It's not worth it IMHO.

Same here, the risk is too great, especially if there are calves around.

Last summer I was out walking and the exit to our field was blocked with cows and calves - we chose to do a 2-3 mile detour rather than attempt to get through alone. Cows can and do kill people.

A farmer once told me that the reason cows are so dangerous is because they're both strong and stupid Grin