Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Right of Way, Horse & Dog

183 replies

Beastiee · 25/08/2023 11:05

I'll try to keep this short.

I've got a dog, he's always on a lead when we're out. I live rurally, the field next to my garden is the only route to reach any public footpaths to walk my dog. The field has a public right of way across it as it's on a designated national trail.

It's owned by a neighbour who has just put a horse on the land. My dog has no reaction whatsoever to horses, he ignores all livestock. The horse he's put on the field is clearly agitated by my dog, as I try to walk across the field (I pick my time, when the horse is the furthest away) the horse will run up and sniff at the dog's back end and sort of push him, I'm assuming this is a warning of 'get away'.

Again, my dog ignores totally as I swiftly walk across the field, but the horse will follow and keep pushing him until we're out the gate. It's happened twice now.

Obviously I don't want the dog, or me, to get kicked/attacked by the horse so I can't walk across the field again to risk it - would I be unreasonable to tell the owner his horse is causing an issue? Neighbour has form for being difficult.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Honeyroar · 30/08/2023 22:20

I have horses. I would be worried if I saw my horse running across to walkers on a right of way. I’d be worried it could escalate into the horse kicking out, either accidentally or maliciously. I know I’d be liable if my horse hurt someone. I never understood how some owners think it’s not their problem! Wherever possible, we fence our footpaths off from grazing areas.

Bangolads · 30/08/2023 22:05

@CaroleSinger this is a popular myth, if you are injured by a farmers cattle whilst in his field he is liable and farmers have insurance for this very purpose. I live rurally and work with farmers.

Beastiee · 30/08/2023 19:05

Stormyweathr · 30/08/2023 19:00

If it’s a short walk could you not carry your dog accross

It's a big field and my dog is huge and heavy - but the horse has gone now so thankfully issue resolved.

OP posts:
Stormyweathr · 30/08/2023 19:00

If it’s a short walk could you not carry your dog accross

Iheartbobross · 30/08/2023 09:20

Very sensible OP and you've handled it brilliantly. While he's done the right thing now, really no owner should turn their horses out in fields with public access unless they are confident that animal is safe with dogs and people. Just common sense. They'd have difficulty justifying their position in court should the horse have hurt someone. If they'd introduced dogs and strangers to the horse and had someone around to observe things initially, it might be different. As a horse owner I'd have been extremely grateful for the way you've handled this, although I'd rather stick pins in my eyes than turn my horse out in a public right of way!

Beastiee · 30/08/2023 08:28

Todaywego · 30/08/2023 08:20

Fantastic!
This also shows how dangerous it is to make decisions about an unknown horse's behaviour and intentions via the Net. A lot of horse people were recommending that you engage with the horse to move him away. As his owner was concerned about his behaviour it's clear that would have been a very bad idea.

Absolutely - the owner said the horse was agitated (not curious) and likely to escalate to a bite/kick/stomp and he was grateful to know about it.

He's got plenty of other land so thankfully wasn't an issue, he'll just keep the field as it is. Phew.

Definitely confirmed never to walk through a field with an unknown horse if you have a dog.

OP posts:
Todaywego · 30/08/2023 08:20

Fantastic!
This also shows how dangerous it is to make decisions about an unknown horse's behaviour and intentions via the Net. A lot of horse people were recommending that you engage with the horse to move him away. As his owner was concerned about his behaviour it's clear that would have been a very bad idea.

Iheartbobross · 30/08/2023 07:57

Beastiee · 30/08/2023 07:03

Just to update.

I decided the risk was too high to walk through again; with hindsight, the 'feeling' I had from the horse wasn't good. I also decided to work myself up to contacting the owner to have a chat.

But I happened to have contact with him while out- (small village...) he bought up the horse and was saying he's going to put another in the field - I asked if he thought both horses would be okay with dogs walking through, as the one there now followed me and showed interest. I asked if he had any advice for staying safe and not upsetting the horse.

He was surprisingly concerned about this, so much so, he suggested we meet there so he could see the horse's behaviour. The horse was just as inquisitive this time, but more so - owner was not happy and said the horse was agitated and its behaviour could escalate.

He doesn't want an incident to happen so the horse has gone. Very pleased to have my route back, thank you for the replies and advice.

Fabulous stuff @Beastiee so pleased for you and your dog, and the horse and the owner!

ButterCrackers · 30/08/2023 07:13

Beastiee · 30/08/2023 07:03

Just to update.

I decided the risk was too high to walk through again; with hindsight, the 'feeling' I had from the horse wasn't good. I also decided to work myself up to contacting the owner to have a chat.

But I happened to have contact with him while out- (small village...) he bought up the horse and was saying he's going to put another in the field - I asked if he thought both horses would be okay with dogs walking through, as the one there now followed me and showed interest. I asked if he had any advice for staying safe and not upsetting the horse.

He was surprisingly concerned about this, so much so, he suggested we meet there so he could see the horse's behaviour. The horse was just as inquisitive this time, but more so - owner was not happy and said the horse was agitated and its behaviour could escalate.

He doesn't want an incident to happen so the horse has gone. Very pleased to have my route back, thank you for the replies and advice.

That’s a great outcome. Enjoy the safe walks.

Beastiee · 30/08/2023 07:03

Just to update.

I decided the risk was too high to walk through again; with hindsight, the 'feeling' I had from the horse wasn't good. I also decided to work myself up to contacting the owner to have a chat.

But I happened to have contact with him while out- (small village...) he bought up the horse and was saying he's going to put another in the field - I asked if he thought both horses would be okay with dogs walking through, as the one there now followed me and showed interest. I asked if he had any advice for staying safe and not upsetting the horse.

He was surprisingly concerned about this, so much so, he suggested we meet there so he could see the horse's behaviour. The horse was just as inquisitive this time, but more so - owner was not happy and said the horse was agitated and its behaviour could escalate.

He doesn't want an incident to happen so the horse has gone. Very pleased to have my route back, thank you for the replies and advice.

OP posts:
Crispyturtle · 29/08/2023 22:33

It’s a public right of way not a dog right of way.

Todaywego · 29/08/2023 22:14

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 29/08/2023 09:50

Which is why I was replying to the person who says her horse stamps on dogs! Most horses are fine, her’s would not be. It is a known risk. You are not entitled to put anything you want into a field with a right of way, if you know the animal responds badly or is a known aggressive breed (I think, but not sure, that friesian cows can’t) then you can’t pop then into that field.

In this case the horse is new and inquisitive and the OP has received good advise on how to continue to use the path and interact with the horse.

I said that my horse stamps on dogs. She isn't kept on a public ROW though.

Cherrysoup · 29/08/2023 19:05

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 29/08/2023 18:49

Not most horses but your horse should not be in a field with a public right of way. It is a known risk as it stamps on dogs and walkers can be expected to have a dog with them and so could very easily get hurt.

Given you have taken precautions with your horse I am not saying you would, but it has to be taken into account.

No ROWs in the field where my horse was kept, plus he is now dead.

Perfectly fine ROW come lane between 2 fenced off fields but some walker thought he could go where he liked. Wasn't pretty when all the geldings stampeded him, he sprinted for the fence, threw his dog over and swiftly followed. Animals aren't robots, one day they'd be fine with strangers in their field, other days, not so much.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 29/08/2023 18:49

Cherrysoup · 29/08/2023 14:30

Which I have read but I'm not sure you have. A horse (my area of knowledge) is not 'dangerous' according to the regs. When I said 'whatever', I didn't mean a bull, lion, tiger etc.

Not most horses but your horse should not be in a field with a public right of way. It is a known risk as it stamps on dogs and walkers can be expected to have a dog with them and so could very easily get hurt.

Given you have taken precautions with your horse I am not saying you would, but it has to be taken into account.

gemma19846 · 29/08/2023 16:18

Im suprised the horse owner hasnt taken steps themselves to put up a fence? If the horse is following people it may be being fed by walkers which in itself can be dangerous. I would personally have a word with the owner and see if they will put up a fence. If not i would avoid the field for the safety of my dog and myself. I kick from a horse can be fatal. It might be your regular dog walk but i would find somewhere else. We used to have comes in a field with a public path through it. If the cows were out i would never take my dog through. Things can escalate quickly its not worth the risk

Cherrysoup · 29/08/2023 14:30

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 29/08/2023 09:11

No he (or she, i can't remember seeing the sex of the owner) is not! Lots of people have posted the regulations.

You can not keep an animal known to be dangerous in a field with a public right of way. And that includes dangerous to dogs, as they were considered a reasonable expectation to be on a right of way.

So, if you own a field with a PROW then you aren't entitled to keep whatever you want on the land.

Which I have read but I'm not sure you have. A horse (my area of knowledge) is not 'dangerous' according to the regs. When I said 'whatever', I didn't mean a bull, lion, tiger etc.

Gorgeouscombes · 29/08/2023 10:03

Is the horse out all on its own? It’s probably lonely and is showing friendly interest in the dog for company. It’s still scary though when a horse runs at you in a field.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 29/08/2023 09:59

MuttsNutts · 25/08/2023 11:32

Fair enough. My dog is usually off lead when on walks but if we walk through fields with livestock she goes back on. In your situation and a horse were approaching and nudging her, I would be letting her off to allow her to move through the field more quickly. Releasing your dog is actually the advice given in situations where you are approached by animals and feel threatened (obviously not advisable if they are prone to chase or aggression).

I’d be quite worried about the dog getting too close to the horse‘s back / hind limbs tbh.

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 29/08/2023 09:50

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 29/08/2023 09:25

@OhBeAFineGuyKissMe you're incorrect - there's nothing wrong with keeping a horse on public land.

The law doesn't consider them dangerous to humans - alongside goats, sheep, cows and working dogs.

The only exception would be if this horse had previously been reported as dangerous and someone went on to get injured. The farmer would then be liable as he should have taken steps to keep the public safe.

He doesn't need to do that unless the animal has been reported though. Keeping horses in public fields is absolutely fine.

Which is why I was replying to the person who says her horse stamps on dogs! Most horses are fine, her’s would not be. It is a known risk. You are not entitled to put anything you want into a field with a right of way, if you know the animal responds badly or is a known aggressive breed (I think, but not sure, that friesian cows can’t) then you can’t pop then into that field.

In this case the horse is new and inquisitive and the OP has received good advise on how to continue to use the path and interact with the horse.

Noodles1234 · 29/08/2023 09:49

Can you walk out your own driveway and down the pavement?
we have similar here but with cows, we have right of way but I personally choose not to most of the time and walk a different path as some of the cows are huge.
Dogs can frighten livestock and humans for that matter, even if they look calm, I guess either the horse is inquisitive or maybe feels threatened.

GemluvsCoco · 29/08/2023 09:37

Can your dog be picked up and carried across the field?

andrainwillmaketheflowersgrow · 29/08/2023 09:25

@OhBeAFineGuyKissMe you're incorrect - there's nothing wrong with keeping a horse on public land.

The law doesn't consider them dangerous to humans - alongside goats, sheep, cows and working dogs.

The only exception would be if this horse had previously been reported as dangerous and someone went on to get injured. The farmer would then be liable as he should have taken steps to keep the public safe.

He doesn't need to do that unless the animal has been reported though. Keeping horses in public fields is absolutely fine.

Moanranger · 29/08/2023 09:23

OP just needs to persevere. Horse will get used to her & dog & will then ignore

twistyizzy · 29/08/2023 09:16

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 29/08/2023 09:11

No he (or she, i can't remember seeing the sex of the owner) is not! Lots of people have posted the regulations.

You can not keep an animal known to be dangerous in a field with a public right of way. And that includes dangerous to dogs, as they were considered a reasonable expectation to be on a right of way.

So, if you own a field with a PROW then you aren't entitled to keep whatever you want on the land.

A horse walking up to someone isn't dangerous though. The horse isn't showing aggressive behaviour

OhBeAFineGuyKissMe · 29/08/2023 09:11

Cherrysoup · 28/08/2023 23:20

Be very careful. My horse hated dogs with a passion, the staff at the yard had to stop taking the yard dogs to catch in, he'd try to stamp on them. Realistically, what will the owner of the field do? He's entitled to keep whatever he wants on his land.

No he (or she, i can't remember seeing the sex of the owner) is not! Lots of people have posted the regulations.

You can not keep an animal known to be dangerous in a field with a public right of way. And that includes dangerous to dogs, as they were considered a reasonable expectation to be on a right of way.

So, if you own a field with a PROW then you aren't entitled to keep whatever you want on the land.

Swipe left for the next trending thread