Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feeling sad for my son. AIBU?

107 replies

User4847484982 · 25/08/2023 08:01

NC for this.
So I come from a very small family, it was only my mum and two grandparents, both have passed away now. I have very close and good relationship with my mum, she lives in mainland Europe.
And then I met my DP. He has quite a big family, both parents and 3 siblings, all of whom have a children of their own. His parents and sister lives outside of the UK, his 2 brothers are in London. Despite of this his family is absolutely the worst, according to DP. They are not close at all, they have their problems, which I’m not gonna go into, they just kinda like a bunch of strangers to each other.
His mum and sister is lovely tho and we always have a small chat when DP calls them, he sends them pictures of our DS.
So now our DS comes into the picture. He’s 3. And there are days when I feel incredibly sad for him, that he won’t have any of the “normal family stuff”. From my side he has only grandma and from his dads side…well no one really. And sadly none of them really cares about him too. His grandma lives too far, his grandpa is an a*, his uncles and their kids don’t care about him and basically are strangers to him. Even when he was born all we got was and WhatsApp message saying Congratulations.
My DS will never have a joy of big family gatherings, playing with his uncles, his cousins, his grandparents, visits, days out, nothing. I’m just feeling so incredibly sad that he will grow up and potentially look back at his life like there was no one there basically, only me and his dad.
And I shed many many tears about this, looking at his sweet innocent face and knowing that so many things he won’t experience because of this. And somehow sometimes I feel that it’s my fault, why did I choose this man to have a family with.

AIBU for feeling the way I’m feeling?

OP posts:
BalletBob · 25/08/2023 11:06

ttcat37 · 25/08/2023 11:04

You’re being very silly. To shed tears over this is ridiculous.
My family is small and it’s great, we don’t lose multiple days over the year to family events or meet ups, don’t have to see people I don’t really like but are unfortunately linked to. I wouldn’t enjoy being part of a big family.

But it's not great for OP, and she doesn't prefer it. She's not ridiculous for having different opinions and feelings to you.

BalletBob · 25/08/2023 11:04

OleMioSole · 25/08/2023 08:37

YABVVU OP.
You and his dad are his PARENTS, it's not 'basically no one'. Many kids don't even have that or if they do, abusive, violent homes. Your DS is very lucky. He has all he needs.
He's not going to miss things he never had.

Also you can make adult friends, some of my best memories are being taken out with family friends.

Stop moping and blaming your DH. It's very insulting actually to say you wouldn't choose him because of his family if he's a good husband and father.

I think this is very unfair. Of course there are lots of benefits and joys that come with having a large, close-knit and healthy wider family. That doesn't mean that people who have smaller families are automatically unhappy, but it's completely reasonable and understandable for OP to feel that she wishes her child could benefit from some of the positives of a big, happy family. And it's also a reasonable consideration when you're choosing a partner to start a family with. It's sensible to think about practicalities and bigger picture stuff. It's obviously too late for that now, but clearly it's coming from a place of concern for her son. She's not a monster for having that thought.

I really hate when people try and invalidate the feelings and experiences of others by pointing out that they are "lucky" in comparison to someone else, in this case children in "abusive, violent homes". It's not a race to the bottom. There's always someone - probably millions of people - much worse off, but we are still allowed to feel negative emotions about our own situations. Everybody does.

ttcat37 · 25/08/2023 11:04

You’re being very silly. To shed tears over this is ridiculous.
My family is small and it’s great, we don’t lose multiple days over the year to family events or meet ups, don’t have to see people I don’t really like but are unfortunately linked to. I wouldn’t enjoy being part of a big family.

olivehaters · 25/08/2023 11:03

Op I have a small family. I made local friends my family. We help each other out, go on days out, go on holiday together. At least I got to choose them.

margotchutney · 25/08/2023 11:02

I don't think you are being unreasonable to be sad but a big family is guarantee, growing up on my mums side her mum was dead and as a result her family kind of fell apart. He older brother and his new wife looked down on my mum and dad for being too working class and they never invited us to anything. Her other 2 brothers were just really young and so they were never really close to my mum and now live overseas and all she gets is the odd card from them. We did visit with my grandfather but when he remarried his wife made it clear she didn't want us around.

On my Dad's side the family was massive and pretty close until my Grandmother died almost 40 years ago now and then family gatherings got rarer and rarer. I am oddly in the middle age wise and so my cousins are all much older or younger and I am not close to any of them so as our parents die I doubt we will ever see each other again and I think many would walk right past me in the street even now and I don't feel that I could ask any for help or that they would ask me although I wouldn't mind if they did. A big family can be just as lonely as no family.

DH's family is much closer although mostly down to the efforts of his mum who is getting quite old herself now and I think once she goes the wider family will drift apart.

Redfraggle24 · 25/08/2023 11:01

Honestly, he will be fine. YOU are his world and he is safe, secure and happy in it. That is all he needs to be a well adjusted adult. My oldest friend is an only child. She has a photo of us all in a frame that says 'Friends are the family we choose for ourselves'. You can do this for him and make sure he has fulfilling relationships with others.

Rotterdam · 25/08/2023 11:00

Frankly families are overrated. The majority of mine were or are toxic.

Build your own ‘family’. Good friends of your own/DH and support your DS’s friendships. Make friends with school mums when the time comes.

I remember my good friends from childhood; my family, apart from my grandmother, not so much. There was always an undercurrent of nastiness.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 25/08/2023 10:59

GameOverBoys · 25/08/2023 08:48

If you aren’t already, make a big effort to become friends with people with similar aged children. Go camping or youth hosteling where there are other kids about. Join community groups etc. there are many ways to make a wider ‘family’.

This!

We had a big gap so it sometimes felt youngest was a singleton. Lots of afterschool and clubs really helped. Also arranged lots of outings with friends. They knew they could always invite people round or bring a friend on a trip to town.
Another friend got theirs a dog so always an excuse to get out and about and friends clustered around said dog at the school gate and wanted to help walk it.

I don't think it is your DH's fault that his family are so distant. He probably wishes they weren't and you've said his mother and sister are lovely, so that's something to focus on that relationship.

Onelifeonly · 25/08/2023 10:54

Can you give him siblings? I value mine immensely but many people don't or have distant relationships with them as adults.

Other than my two siblings and parents, the only relatives I truly knew well and cared for were my maternal grandparents. I have 3 cousins, too much older and one younger. Older ones never showed any interest, younger I rarely see and have little in common with. Now I have 4 nieces and nephews but I'm not that close to them - one I have a relationship with but not the others really.

My DH also had two siblings, one now deceased and the other single with no kids. He has a niece living in another country. Since their mother died, it's basically just the two of them as they barely know their cousins.

It's not going to make your son's life unhappy even if he does stay as an only child. There are so many other factors involved in making life good or otherwise - try to get past this feeling that you are letting him down. By being a good parent you are doing the absolute opposite.

Prelapsarianhag · 25/08/2023 10:54

Small family here and only one DC. I just made lots of friends of people with kids so my DC grew up with loads of people around. You don't need to be related to have fun.

TonTonMacoute · 25/08/2023 10:54

Your OP literally makes no sense. What is 'normal' family stuff?

You say your very small family is lovely and close, and your DPs large family is a mess, yet you want your DS to have a lovely large family!

You are his family, you give him the security and love he needs, good aunts, uncles and cousins are just nice add ons, but they are hardly necessary, and bad aunts and uncles and cousins can be a complete nightmare!

Make the most of what you have got.

mynameiscalypso · 25/08/2023 10:49

You sound exactly like my best friend and her family situation. Her son may not have a big extended family but he is so loved and she has a wide network of friends who have children a similar age and/or are like aunts and uncles to her son (including me and my DH).

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 25/08/2023 10:46

YANBU

My DD is in the same situation and I always feel guilty.
She doesn’t see her dad or any of his family.

Both my parents have MH issues and seeing them is not fun and it is mentally draining and they are not supportive, so it is literally me and her.

It makes me so sad for the future and if I died she’d be all alone.

I regret not giving her a sibling and if I was you I would think about having another child.

Iamnotalemming · 25/08/2023 10:37

Your DS will only know his 'normal' and will only think it is something to be unhappy about if you tell him that through your behaviour. Families come in all shapes and sizes. Be happy for what you have, not sad for what you don't (which may not actually make you happier!).

MidnightOnceMore · 25/08/2023 10:30

You can't be blamed for how you feel, but you can unpack it and see how to make the best of where you are.

Maybe you're projecting your feelings about your own childhood onto your son? Have you any evidence your son wishes he had a bigger family or is he happy with the family he has?

What I know is there are happy big families and unhappy big families, there are happy small families and unhappy small families. All each of us can do is try to make a safe loving home in the situation we find ourselves in. I don't actually always feel confident I know how to do this, but I try to reassure myself that if I focus on trying to do what is right and healthy it'll be enough.

Cluborange666 · 25/08/2023 10:29

I think you’re probably projecting your feelings onto your child but I understand how you feel. We have a similar set up BUT I have more than one child. My kids are never lonely because they get on really well together. Also, now that they are teenagers, they have their own friends too.

Vegetus · 25/08/2023 10:27

I was an only child with both sets of grandparents already dead. Never did me any harm.

TotalOverhaul · 25/08/2023 10:23

I understand what you mean, op, but these memories can be created in different ways, and without the underlying tension of families.

We used to have big gatherings of mum and baby groups - we used to picnic in the park together - even sometimes go home, cook tea and then bring it to the play park on sunny days and all sit around chatting as DC played in the late sunshine. I thought it was idyllic. They don't remember it at all! Grin

You can join a church group or befriend some like minded families and have camping weekends away together where all the children run free. Or days at the beach where all the kids play rounders and volley ball. That sense of belonging doesn;t have to exist within family a lone.

If one granny and aunt seem friendly, encourage that. Suggest a meet up or a visit or invite them to stay. Keep meet ups short and easy at first so they don't feel cornered into a level of commitment they aren't used to. Maybe all go to a panto together at Christmas, or out for a pizza together.

DC love their cousins but tell me that among their friendship group everyone else they know loathes their cousins and it's a real effort when they get together. As PP have said, he has loving parents and nothing is more important than that.

Saharafordessert · 25/08/2023 10:19

Well you can’t choose your family but you can choose your friends so maybe that’s what you need to concentrate on to widen your circle and opportunities for your son?

Drfosters · 25/08/2023 10:17

honestly this is not something to beat yourself up about. There is no guarantees a big family means closeness and there is sometimes conflict involved somewhere regarding time and resources . my friend is an only child of only children and married an only child. She is completely unbothered by this. Happy in her life and has lots of friends.

Comedycook · 25/08/2023 10:10

Luxembourgmama · 25/08/2023 09:33

Make friends? Large families and family gatherings are dreadful he wont miss anything.

I know you're trying to make the op feel better but this is not necessarily true at all.

Generally I do think it's beneficial to have extended family. My family is relatively small. I'd like to have more relatives. I'm grateful for the ones I have and luckily my DC have cousins they adore.

I do think though that huge families and huge family gatherings are becoming less and less common. People are generally having less children nowadays so those people with lots of aunts and uncles and hundreds of cousins will not be the norm any more.

I mean if everyone has one/two DC, each child would have 0-4cousins max and one or two sets of aunts and uncles .

There's not much you can do except extend your own circle with friends. I'm sure your DC will grow up happily regardless

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 25/08/2023 10:08

You feel how you feel, it's not unreasonable to feel a particular way. This is something you value and attach importance to. Realistically big families are sometimes good and sometimes bad. Stbxh and I have about 15 aunts and uncles between us, the last time we saw any of them was our wedding day, well over a decade ago. While the feelings aren't in themselves unreasonable the intensity of them, to have wept many tears over this and regret your marriage is a very extreme reaction. You're imagining some ideal family, but the reality is that many families large or small are less than ideal, some aren't close, some are too close, codependent, nasty, some are the type you need to go NC from. Yes some people have wide and deep family support networks which sounds lovely, but you're really not comparing your current circumstances to something that is realistic.

Is it possible this is a feeling from your own life, that you are imagining your DS facing this one day, feeling alone and unsupported? If you can afford it I'd suggest seeing a psychologist to work out where these feelings are coming from and trying to resolve them or meet the need that's causing them. There may be a practical solution to your fears, or an emotional one, but you do need to address this. The level of distress you're feeling over this needs to be addressed.

AlmostTotallyFake · 25/08/2023 10:02

I can't believe you are crying about this! How ridiculous.
I have cousins that I haven't seen since childhood, I saw them a couple of times before adulthood and that was it. I am NC with my parents (awful people) and have 1 sibling that I see when we have time.
Most of my husband's family are dead or NC.
My children have a full and active social life despite my family issues. We have had Christmas with friends for example, you can still have plenty of people around that are not blood related.
Stop the self pity about your family or your attitude will rub off on your child and he will feel like he's missing out, show him he's not and he will be fine.

Flakey99 · 25/08/2023 09:51

You’re being ridiculous. He has two loving parents, that’s all he needs and can’t be classed as hardly no-one. 😂

My DS is loved by two parents too, so he’s doing well. He has no grandparents because they’re all dead but I don’t feel remotely sorry for him.

I know of a friend of DS’s who’s mum died a couple of years ago and who initially went to live with his gran but then she moved, so he went to live abroad with his dad and step mum. He missed out on sitting GCSE’s in U.K. and their equivalent exams abroad, because of being moved around during those two important years.

He’s now back in the U.K. trying to find an apprenticeship at 17yrs but with no formal qualifications at all, he’s struggling. He’s clearly a resilient bright boy so I think he will do ok in life, but I do feel sorry that after his mum died, he was effectively left to fend for himself.

hopsalong · 25/08/2023 09:47

Presumably many or most of DS's friends at nursery/ locally now have a younger sibling, especially if the first born? Is this triggering the anxiety, I wonder?

Swipe left for the next trending thread