Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 25/08/2023 17:33

Yes I guess if the child is really not academic and not otherwise working can see it’s a last resort. But surely if you have to be paid to study opting for 3 years of self directed self motivated academic study isn’t a great idea.

TeenDivided · 25/08/2023 17:28

TheaBrandt · 25/08/2023 17:10

If a student has to be bribed financially to even study I would question whether university was right for them anyway. How will they have the drive to get through 3 years of that and further professional qualifications? Probably best to go straight into work.

I kind of disagree.

A 15yo is often not properly mature. They may realise too late of their wasted opportunities. Whereas by 17/18 they may be ore ambitious/motivated.

Plus not all DC are destined for university, but GCSEs still matter to get to the next step, whether that is a Level 3 BTEC, a Level 2, a Level 1 or an Apprenticeship. For some, GCSEs may be the end of their education at least for a while, so encouraging a 3/4 student to aim for those 4/5s might open doors for them later in life.

TheaBrandt · 25/08/2023 17:10

If a student has to be bribed financially to even study I would question whether university was right for them anyway. How will they have the drive to get through 3 years of that and further professional qualifications? Probably best to go straight into work.

Blanketpolicy · 25/08/2023 17:06

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 16:41

Remind me how old your DCs are ?

Adult, past school exam age. Why does it matter?

MasterBeth · 25/08/2023 16:57

TheBarbieEffect · 25/08/2023 07:23

Your DD is motivated by money because when she was a toddler you didn’t teach her intrinsic motivation.

That was a mistake, because you have taught her she shouldn’t do X, Y or Z unless there is something in it for her. This is going to make life a lot more difficult for her as she gets older and has to live her own life.

She will struggle to do anything she doesn’t want to, and of course part of life is sometimes doing things we don’t want. It has set her up to fail really, and without you there she is going to find day to day living really hard because you haven’t taught her intrinsic motivation.

Was trying to articulate this but you ^^ have explained it better than I can.

tooanxious · 25/08/2023 16:53

I mean I rewarded DS testers, £10 for a 9, £5 for an 9 or 7..... he's £30 richer than he was

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 16:53

@Blanketpolicy

You don't need to save my dc from getting money from for exams ( i hope) my dd is on course to get a flush of 7 - 9 next year without a hint of cash incentives mentioned.

But I was that child who lost their way and would have responded to anything to help me focus because that's what it comes down to. And I was nurtured and cared for and had highly literate educated loving parents who valued education as do i.
Unfortunately, they also wanted to kill each other and hated each other and it was impossible to try and digest the periodic table when I wanted to get out and escape.

You are massively over thinking it as well.

You don't set children up for life by a one off crucial time money motivator.

vibecheck · 25/08/2023 16:52

@Blanketpolicy I disagree with you here. My husband who had no motivation at school, was bright but never worked hard, scraped through a-levels and nearly failed out of his degree has found that as soon as he started working in a job his motivation to work changed completely. He often says how it’s like everything made sense suddenly for him. So it’s actually not guaranteed that a person motivated by working for financial compensation will fail in adult life, in fact I think for a lot of people who aren’t motivated at school by the mere promise of exams being their own reward excel once they start working for money.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/08/2023 16:46

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 16:41

Remind me how old your DCs are ?

Mine is an adult and I agree with @Blanketpolicy. I would have felt that I had failed to pass on basic values that I hold dear if my dd had at any point only been motivated by money!

I totally accept that some people think it's normal and natural to be motivated primarily by money. That's in line with their values and what they think is important, and they are of course entitled to their views. It isn't for me to say how others should live their lives, but honestly, I would be ashamed if I had raised my dd to think like that, and I would feel that I had failed to teach her about what really matters in life.

Blanketpolicy · 25/08/2023 16:46

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 16:33

Well, parents do fail Blanket? Children do get knocked off course. It can be hard to get across to dc with no life experience that exams are important..
Many very successful people have failed.
Does it matter to get the end result if for whatever reason rhe child isn't motivated? "

Yes it really does matter, because nurturing, modelling, encouraging and providing opportunities for instinct motivation from an early age sets them up for adult life.

Sending them out into the world not wanting to do anything unless they get handed a tenner for it sets them up for long term failure and disappointment as they watch those with the motivation fly past them.

Of course there were be bumps along the way, not many people have bump free lives/pressures and challenges and for some those bumps are so catastrophic they cannot parent effectively. But for most it is absolutely achievable in some form or another.

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 16:41

Blanketpolicy · 25/08/2023 16:26

Isn't that the parents job to teach them this from a young age? Instead of taking the easy short term route of throwing money at them because they have somehow reached 16/18 years old and still don't get it.

Baring any SEN, I would consider my dc not understanding or having any intrinsic motivation at the cusp of adulthood a huge parenting failure on my part.

Remind me how old your DCs are ?

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 16:35

@Growlybear83 exactly, it's just better to try and open up chances isn't it.

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 16:33

Well, parents do fail Blanket? Children do get knocked off course. It can be hard to get across to dc with no life experience that exams are important..
Many very successful people have failed.
Does it matter to get the end result if for whatever reason rhe child isn't motivated? "

Blanketpolicy · 25/08/2023 16:26

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 07:50

Intrinsic motivation can often come after the fact though? Many dc don't know why they are doing these big exams and it's only on results day that the reality of their importance shows.

Isn't that the parents job to teach them this from a young age? Instead of taking the easy short term route of throwing money at them because they have somehow reached 16/18 years old and still don't get it.

Baring any SEN, I would consider my dc not understanding or having any intrinsic motivation at the cusp of adulthood a huge parenting failure on my part.

TeenDivided · 25/08/2023 15:32

I think parents do what they think best to get their kids through GCSEs. Then they always have those grades 'in their back pocket' regardless of what comes next. Kids mature at different times and you don't want them to do poorly through immaturity.
6th form, whether it is A levels, BTEC or Apprenticeship is the time for all of them to step up, even if they needed pushing through GCSEs.

XelaM · 25/08/2023 15:30

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 14:58

Do you have teens btw? If so, what are their ambitions? Apologies if I have missed it.

I have one teen (Year 9) and her ambitions don't match her school efforts unfortunately 🙈 I come from a very academic family where Bs were considered akin to Fs, but I'm a lot(!) more relaxed with my own daughter about grades. Although I have now asked her if having the OP's would motivate her to work harder for GCSEs and she said the most resounding "YES"! 😂 So we'll see how that works out

DontCallMeBaby · 25/08/2023 15:23

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 15:07

Only non academic families do this in my experience

I agree with this.

Well now I’m finally glad we did it, if only to provide a counter-example.

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 15:07

TheaBrandt · 25/08/2023 10:40

Only non academic families do this in my experience.

Also GCSEs do matter if you are doing a competitive academic course like law. There are so many good candidates they are looking for ways to weed you out.

Only non academic families do this in my experience

I agree with this.

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 14:58

XelaM · 25/08/2023 14:48

Ds asked me if I'd give £9 for a 9 going down to £1 for a 1. I said "no".
He said "bother, I thought I had an easy £14 there" (he was taking 14 subjects).

I love this 😂 Your DS sounds awesome

Do you have teens btw? If so, what are their ambitions? Apologies if I have missed it.

Peony654 · 25/08/2023 14:55

It's your choice, but I don't think it is good to reward "success", isn't it better to reward hard work? I can't imagine how she will feel if she doesn't get the highest grade given how much you've put pressure on with this. And the grades don't matter that much, just do her best and do well enough to get to the next stage. I don't know if you have others kids but I'd also worry it would create sibling resentment.

XelaM · 25/08/2023 14:48

Ds asked me if I'd give £9 for a 9 going down to £1 for a 1. I said "no".
He said "bother, I thought I had an easy £14 there" (he was taking 14 subjects).

I love this 😂 Your DS sounds awesome

Growlybear83 · 25/08/2023 14:47

*Scarlettpixie - I didn’t say there is no difference if you want to do medicine or go to Oxbridge which is why I said ‘in most cases’.

Surely ‘in most cases’ universities are looking at A Level results over GCSEs*

I know this thread is about GCSEs, and I've already said that i offered my daughter a financial incentive. Unfortunately I didn't do the same for her AS levels the next year, and she had started coasting again. She got a B for one of her history modules and was still not working when she resat it, and although she increased her marks, she still didn't quite get an A. When she got her university offers, she was turned down by the LSE on the very last day, which was her first choice over anywhere. She got feedback on the reasons for rejecting her application and was told that it came down to that one history module and not getting an A. She started working properly after that, but if I'd offered her a similar incentive to her GCSEs then she would have got her first choice offer. But it shows that universities don't just look at overall A level grades.

CoffeeCantata · 25/08/2023 14:45

Oh, and most Oxbridge interviews include a pretty testing exam for which you can't prepare except in the broadest sense of reading around your subject and having a genuine interest.

CoffeeCantata · 25/08/2023 14:44

XelaM
And lazy kids can be charming at interviews 😂

Maybe, but that won't get them through an Oxbridge interview in my experience.

Yes, the highest academic grades are the minimum requirement for Oxbridge but then they are looking for a sophisticated level of interest in the subject, the ability to think, argue logically and for the potential to benefit from the particular type of teaching which Oxbridge offers. It's not for everyone.

Oxbridge tutors/interviewers have seen it all - and they're not fooled by superficial charm. Many is the over-confident 'charming' student I've seen shocked when they didn't get a place, having felt they aced the interview.

Spirallingdownwards · 25/08/2023 14:35

The main issue with this plan is when you decide to tell other people about it