Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
NewDogOwner · 26/08/2023 07:43

It has been established that offering extrinsic motivation actually erodes intrinsic motivation. However, I have a kid who is work shy and is motivated by rewards. I don't know what I'll do when the time comes.

Heronwatcher · 26/08/2023 07:41

It’s a terrible idea. Your child should want to do well for herself/ her future not for mummy’s handout. Why an earth is money also required? It’s all party if your DD learning to make good choices for herself, being self motivated and learning the value of hard work, which she especially needs if she’s a bit lazy. Also when does this stop? Are you going to offer this for A levels, her degree, or for getting a job? If you’re going to reward anything, reward hard work not pure results. What if she has a few bad exams, or just finds the exams more difficult than she expected despite working hard, and feels like she’s been hard done too as well as disappointed in herself?

On a practical level IMO this also just doesn’t work, if she’s not motivated this isn’t going to make a massive difference.

Sazzy6258 · 26/08/2023 07:40

We do something similar now with our younger children! They both got to choose something they would like and if their end of term report/ grades were good they got it. It helps to motivate them with their learning attitudes and they learn the value of hard work!
When the time comes we will be doing the same. Hard work = a reward. It's is teaching children that actions have consequences, whether they are good or bad!

Performance related bonus' are a real thing in the wider world! Parenting is all about preparing your children to be a functioning member of society, which includes teaching them how to deal with disappointment.

Ignore you Sil and do what works for you

coolcahuna · 26/08/2023 07:36

I've literally just done this for my son, he asked me. Alot lower amount though, £10 per 7 or up. It motivated him and he would have got the same results regardless I think.

Also I would have given him some money for working hard regardless of the results.

Not sure if I will do it with my younger son, he would probably find it stressful

GirlMum07 · 26/08/2023 07:33

I think it’s fine. I received a money incentive for mine and we began saving for driving lessons/a car for our kids from when they were born. They have a trust fund etc in their name which is their money but we have a ‘kids’ savings pot too - our money to spend on them. We decided to use that money and offer a decent incentive. (My daughter just received £1200 total - of which she knows she needs to put towards driving lessons and has already got her name down even though she’s not 17 for 4 months).

I was a straight A/A* kid but my daughter not so much would have probably failed a few if she wasn’t focused on this reward. She didn’t need passes for the next step in her education nor for any future career path so that thought wouldn’t motivate her like others. She struggles with exams is a more hands on learner - but I don’t care what people say GCSEs matter for the next couple years as it’s all employers/colleges can base decisions on. Yes mine don’t matter now they become irrelevant over time.

It motivated me, it motivated her. It’s not different to a salary bonus you get in many jobs so is relevant to real grown up world.

People that do it are going to agree with you and people that don’t are going to say it’s the worse I get very mixed signals but end of day my daughters sat their with 11 passes and the ones she could put the effort into are decent grades rather than scraping a pass.

Same rules will apply for my other children and A Levels etc too. You do you is what I say.

NashvilleQueen · 26/08/2023 07:32

When you say selective school do you mean fee paying or just entrance exam?

Aprilx · 26/08/2023 07:32

I don’t think it is your SIL business and “out of order” is an odd way of putting it, but essentially I think it is not good to do this. I think the amounts mentioned are insane, it may turn out to deliver a bad message to a sibling who fares better / worse and it is very well accepted in psychology that money is not a motivator anyway.

FrogsWormsandCaterpillars · 26/08/2023 07:28

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:20

I would set the reward at a reasonable level. If DD2 is predicted 5's and 6's then it would be £50 for a 5, £100 for a 6 etc.

DD1 is predicted at least a 7 in every subject so with good revision and focus there's no reason she couldn't do it. She's a lazy so and so though!

I don’t think this is particularly fair. If DD2 works as hard as/harder than DD1 but achieves 5/6s why should she get less if she has still achieved her full potential?

Mrsmch123 · 26/08/2023 07:24

I think it's a great idea. I was very offered similar as a teen and you can bet I put in the work that I wouldn't have otherwise.

Viviennemary · 26/08/2023 07:22

I think It's quite a good idea. But the amounts are far too large IMHO.

TrustyRusty68 · 26/08/2023 07:22

If you can afford it, why not? Not anyone else’s business - & if it works, great. For those saying don’t do it - would they go to work for free or work harder for the chance of a pay rise? Money is a huge motivator & if it works for you - great!

BillyNotQuiteNoMates · 26/08/2023 07:21

Do whatever works for you and your DC.
When my DS finished his A’levels, I took him abroad, to reward him for his hard work. I didn’t care what grades he got, because I knew he’d done his best, and I was proud of him no matter what the grades were. That’s what worked for US. You do you, you don’t need others validation to be the best parent you can be.

hot2trotter · 26/08/2023 07:20

Jeez I got a fiver for every C or above I got. How the other half live 😂

Mummyof32023 · 26/08/2023 07:07

Wow seriously? That's blackmail and GCSE are hard enough with a pushy parent. How about supportive your child without bribing them with money? So wrong

Ketzele · 25/08/2023 22:58

I don't do that because I can't afford it. But also because I have read research concluding that pay bonuses are a poor motivator in the workplace, contrary to wide opinion.

Beezknees · 25/08/2023 22:48

I have a DS the same age and I wouldn't do this. He knows at his age why it's important to get good grades if he wants to do his chosen career. I don't bribe my teenager.

Characterbuilding · 25/08/2023 22:30

Gosh people love this "intrinsic motivation” buzz word. Such a broad notion that becomes meaningless if said motivation doesn’t fit in with the prescribed path defined by society. What human is motivated by this way for everything? Wouldn’t everyone who ever participated in a p.e lesson be intrinsically motivated to pursue sport for the health benefits? But alas not everyone enjoys this. My son is intrinsically motivated by health, fitness and achieving in sport. Other people I know are intrinsically motivated by the outdoors. But you cannot opt out of exams to focus on these other pursuits no matter how much satisfaction or pride you find in them. So if humans who are not motivated in this way need other incentives so be it. This also applies to people who do not develop this intrinsic motivation early enough to fit the timescale set by the education system.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 25/08/2023 20:49

TheBarbieEffect · 25/08/2023 07:23

Your DD is motivated by money because when she was a toddler you didn’t teach her intrinsic motivation.

That was a mistake, because you have taught her she shouldn’t do X, Y or Z unless there is something in it for her. This is going to make life a lot more difficult for her as she gets older and has to live her own life.

She will struggle to do anything she doesn’t want to, and of course part of life is sometimes doing things we don’t want. It has set her up to fail really, and without you there she is going to find day to day living really hard because you haven’t taught her intrinsic motivation.

I agree with this. I would also be more inclined to praise for doing revision, rather than final grades. Rewarding by grade can slso seem unfair to other siblings

electriclight · 25/08/2023 20:10

"Please do link this research"

I can't be bothered. There's loads. You can google it if sufficiently interested or pretend it doesn't exist if you prefer. It doesn't make a jot of difference to me either way.

JackGrealishsCalves · 25/08/2023 19:03

We did it as an after the event for 9's at GCSE and A* at A Level but we didn't use it as a carrot, just a well done for the hard work he put in once he got his results so it was a lovely surprise for him as he wasn't expecting it.
If you bribe it makes it about what you want rather than DD doing it for herself

Blanketpolicy · 25/08/2023 18:50

vibecheck · 25/08/2023 16:52

@Blanketpolicy I disagree with you here. My husband who had no motivation at school, was bright but never worked hard, scraped through a-levels and nearly failed out of his degree has found that as soon as he started working in a job his motivation to work changed completely. He often says how it’s like everything made sense suddenly for him. So it’s actually not guaranteed that a person motivated by working for financial compensation will fail in adult life, in fact I think for a lot of people who aren’t motivated at school by the mere promise of exams being their own reward excel once they start working for money.

The grades you get at exams are not just their "own reward", the reward is the awareness of your development, the skills you have learned and the potential doors they open to the next stage. Whether that is making you competitive in the job market or uni applications. The same at work, doing the best job you can not for the wage packet but to get that promotion, or next opportunity, or to work on a project that interests you or even just for personal satisfaction that you delivered something great. If a child does not understand that by the time they are 16/18 well before their exams then someone, probably a few people, has let them down.

Something changed for your dh when he entered the work place probably as a young man from having role models/mentors in the work place that were missing in his childhood and/or school education.

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 18:47

Blanket no.

I feel we are playing blind man's bluff and you are wandering around in the dark.

Unfortunately I see your thinking on this subject is immovable and ridged and there is little point in my trying to explain further.

MargaretThursday · 25/08/2023 18:44

Why does anyone want to do well?

Maybe because they simply want to achieve
Maybe because they want bragging rights
Maybe because they want to be seen as better than others
Maybe because they want to please someone else
Maybe because it gets them material things
Maybe because they're afraid of failure

Why is it being argued that wanting to do well for material things is a negative thing in comparison to the others?

People get a bonus at work for doing well and it motivates some people. This has been happening probably since people paid wages (even non-money wages). Does anyone criticise that?
So why shouldn't a balanced 16yo be motivated by money? It's not necessarily saying it's the only motivation, but if it helps some people, then that's between them and their parents.

Blanketpolicy · 25/08/2023 18:38

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 16:53

@Blanketpolicy

You don't need to save my dc from getting money from for exams ( i hope) my dd is on course to get a flush of 7 - 9 next year without a hint of cash incentives mentioned.

But I was that child who lost their way and would have responded to anything to help me focus because that's what it comes down to. And I was nurtured and cared for and had highly literate educated loving parents who valued education as do i.
Unfortunately, they also wanted to kill each other and hated each other and it was impossible to try and digest the periodic table when I wanted to get out and escape.

You are massively over thinking it as well.

You don't set children up for life by a one off crucial time money motivator.

Exactly my point, your parents didn't do their job when it came to instilling the motivation in you in those crucial years, as they were too focussed on their own issues, so you yearned for something else

I totally understand a one off money motivator can be a temporary solution to a problem that has been allowed to happen. It shouldn't have been needed in the first place.

TeenDivided · 25/08/2023 17:52

TheaBrandt · 25/08/2023 17:33

Yes I guess if the child is really not academic and not otherwise working can see it’s a last resort. But surely if you have to be paid to study opting for 3 years of self directed self motivated academic study isn’t a great idea.

I agree, that if not motivated in 6th form then uni would be a high risk

Swipe left for the next trending thread