Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
letloz · 26/08/2023 08:33

My dad did this back in the day, but it was £10 for an A*! And they talk about grade inflation...😆

fedupnow2 · 26/08/2023 08:28

@Aprilx but these are teens/kids who do not have that level of comparison or understanding as yet. So yes to them it is the money. And so what? If that motivates them to do better than they realised they could, how did they lose out?
I will use my own example. My dps did this especially during the big years. I pushed myself harder many times because yes I wanted the money. Sometimes I even surprised myself. Gave me a lot of confidence in what I could do. And somewhere along the line the money became the bonus to the reward of getting the good grades. But I wouldn't have probably realised my potential without an incentive in the first place.

Totaly · 26/08/2023 08:26

An adult is incentivised at work with bonuses and raises for performance, sportsman are paid for winning matches etc but kids should 'know better' and their reward should be good grades and they must be Happy with that!

As a SAHP when the kids were younger, I didn’t get a pay rise, I had a massive pay cut, I didn’t get any bonuses, or even tea breaks,

I was happy the kids hit their miles stones, I loved the joy in their faces when we saw something new, I loved giving them new experiences and facilitating friendships.

I had no financial motivation or reward.

I never offered them financial reward, that would have taken away the joy of their hard work and achievements.

Nor did I want their friends from pooper backgrounds to feel they weren’t good enough for financial reward based on parental finances.

whereaw · 26/08/2023 08:24

Your child your choice.

fedupnow2 · 26/08/2023 08:23

Surely they want to do well anyway and it's not about the money?

Surely if you do well at work then you should be happy that you can do the job very well and that should be enough? 🙄

Aprilx · 26/08/2023 08:23

fedupnow2 · 26/08/2023 08:15

An adult is incentivised at work with bonuses and raises for performance, sportsman are paid for winning matches etc but kids should 'know better' and their reward should be good grades and they must be Happy with that! 🙄

My own dps did the same with me and I'm in my 40s so it's nothing new. That made me work much harder and I was very happy to be rewarded. My dc did the 7+ which was very tough for that age and did really well, he knew there was a reward for that. Does it really matter that he wanted the reward, because in doing so he realised his potential and worked probably harder than he knew he could. It's not a MN thing, I know plenty of people who do this.

But again people are not motivated by pay. This is not armchair psychology, it is widely recognised. People can be demotivated by a lack of proper pay, by feeling they are not getting what they are worth, but that is not the same thing.

Also people are paid because they have entered a contract and are being paid for services. Students working for their exams are not providing anybody with a service, they are literally doing it for themselves. So this is not the same thing and yes they really should be happy with the result.

DameCurlyBassey · 26/08/2023 08:22

I say go for it. You know your child and how best to motivate them.

In the real world we are often rewarded for success with money. It is a huge motivator for many/most of us - it is one of the main reasons we go to work. Many jobs (including mine) offer financial bonuses as an incentive for specific achievements. Whenever the going gets tough and dc wants to give up she can think about the money and move through the block.

Most kids are able to fit their expectations to the real world as they mature. Some people give their kids an incentive to complete household tasks for money, but those same kids don't grow up only doing housework if they are given money. By that point they've grown used to completing chores and have grown into adult brains that temper their expectations. This incentive won't necessarily spoil the child. In fact, it might give them more of a sense of responsibility and drive.

Speaking for myself, I have always been very motivated by money because I come from a very poor background. I started working at 15 while still at school as I wanted to help my mother. I have 3 degrees (including PhD) which I was motivated to achieve because I wanted to be able to earn more but also because I loved the subject I studied. I give a lot of my money away to impoverished family members - I am not as wealthy as I may sound, but I am now fairly comfortable.

I know this is different to your situation, but I support you in this. In fact I have made a similar offer to a close relative - with their parent's consent.

Pipsquiggle · 26/08/2023 08:22

A friend said to his DD that he would give her £5 per point.
She did very, very well.
Out of a possible £450 she's receiving £420

I thought that was a good way to reward and motivate them.

DiscoBeat · 26/08/2023 08:21

We've got a very similar amount planned for our son (about to go into Y11) and his younger brother when the time comes. We did the same for their 11+ and they both got new PlayStations. I think a bit of financial incentive is a good idea and definitely works for our two.

fedupnow2 · 26/08/2023 08:15

mumofmanybusykids · 26/08/2023 08:09

I've never understood why people do this for their kids. Surely they want to do well anyway and it's not about the money?

My kids tried their hardest just because they wanted good grades. If I told them theyd get more money for higher grades, it wouldn't have changed how much they revised.

How academic someone is isn't always something they can control. I especially dislike this when people have several kids and one ends up getting rewarded more than another, when a lot of the time it's the children with lower grades who work harder than those who are able to sail through and get 9s

And that's a crazy amount of money.... Mumsnet people seem to live in a different world to the majority of people.

An adult is incentivised at work with bonuses and raises for performance, sportsman are paid for winning matches etc but kids should 'know better' and their reward should be good grades and they must be Happy with that! 🙄

My own dps did the same with me and I'm in my 40s so it's nothing new. That made me work much harder and I was very happy to be rewarded. My dc did the 7+ which was very tough for that age and did really well, he knew there was a reward for that. Does it really matter that he wanted the reward, because in doing so he realised his potential and worked probably harder than he knew he could. It's not a MN thing, I know plenty of people who do this.

MartyMorag · 26/08/2023 08:13

First thoughts are that that is a lot of money!

But, if you can afford it, then 🤷‍♀️

Ds just got his GCSE results from a competitive selective school and hasn't asked for anything after receiving his 7-9 results.

He was highly motivated to do well himself and a reward doesn't seem to have crossed his mind!

We are going to give him some money, but it'll be something around £250 in total, rather than the £1400 he could have got from you!

Serendipitoushedgehog · 26/08/2023 08:13

I had a friend at school whose parents did this. It’s your money, it’s your kids.

mumofmanybusykids · 26/08/2023 08:09

I've never understood why people do this for their kids. Surely they want to do well anyway and it's not about the money?

My kids tried their hardest just because they wanted good grades. If I told them theyd get more money for higher grades, it wouldn't have changed how much they revised.

How academic someone is isn't always something they can control. I especially dislike this when people have several kids and one ends up getting rewarded more than another, when a lot of the time it's the children with lower grades who work harder than those who are able to sail through and get 9s

And that's a crazy amount of money.... Mumsnet people seem to live in a different world to the majority of people.

TibetanTerrah · 26/08/2023 08:08

Loving all the armchair psychology about motivation, yet not one has mentioned the simple pleasure/pain principle.

People are generally in two camps (but can switch based on the situation). Either to move towards pleasure or away from pain. So if they lean towards moving away from pain, they may be motivated more by the fear of 'bad' grades and not be motivated by the reward of cash. However, if they don't care that much about grades, neither will motivate them.

This is why it's so divisive on here. Different people are generally motivated either by what they DO want to happen, or what they DON'T want to happen. The 'pain' teens would have to be encouraged to study by a 'fine' for every lower grade Grin but please don't do that, it's cruel!

cat1886 · 26/08/2023 08:05

If you can afford it, and it’s something she’s working towards then there’s nothing wrong with that. We all like a reward after hard work. Many adults have it in work with bonuses etc. I’m a secondary school teacher and see many teenagers become tired and they check out so to speak around spring of year 11. Anything to keep her motivated!! Best of luck to her, and if she can get those grades then she’s likely going to go to university and graduate heading into a high paid job.

Pigeon31 · 26/08/2023 08:00

Poivresel · 26/08/2023 07:57

So you’d do training courses for work outside of your paid hours?

There are plenty of jobs where you will need additional job specific qualifications and you will have to do exactly that.

Ssme92 · 26/08/2023 07:59

I don't like it because as others have said, there are other motivators for doing hard work other than money. But I work in a job where I don't get any bonuses for doing extra work, for working harder, and I don't get reprimanded for doing a half arsed job. I could do the bare minimum if I wanted as it won't effect my pay but I still do my best. Plenty of things wouldn't happen if people were only motivated by money... I think it sends a poor message at a young age. I have a friend who will not to anything unless there is something in it for her and it is painstaking to be around sometimes.

Manthide · 26/08/2023 07:57

FightingFate · 25/08/2023 07:19

We didn’t. Our children know we expect them to try their best and that it’s in their interest to do as well as they can. That was/is enough to motivate them and I think it’s best aiming for that rather than doing it for a financial reward.

We did give our son money after GCSEs, but the amount would have been the same regardless of results. We actually transferred in into his bank when he went to collect his GCSE results, before we knew them. We’ll do the same for our daughter in a couple of years.

My son has just done his A levels, we haven’t given him money this time as we’re paying for uni accommodation, laptop etc.

I agree with you. Dd3 is predicted to get 10 9s next year and an A in FMSQ and I couldn't afford a monetary reward but I know she'll do her best anyway. I'll probably buy her something and give it to her the day of her results - or the day before.
The results are a bit unpredictable any way ds in 2019 got 6 9s, 3 8s and a 6 ( he hated languages but the school policy was you had to take one). He was one or 2 marks off a 9 in 2 of them and 3 off a 7 in the other.
Many years earlier when dd1 took her Gcses we bought her an ipod as a reward (9 A*, 2 As) and we told dd2 she'd get the same the following year after her gcses (11 A*s).
Back in the dawn of time my parents bought me a large set of caran d'ache aquarelle pencils after my O levels- and I still have them. The gift was not attached to grades or number - I got 12 but they weren't all A!
Not sure why some is in bold!!

Poivresel · 26/08/2023 07:57

SusiePevensie · 26/08/2023 07:56

Up to you, but I'd be uncomfortable. It sends the message that you learn because you get paid to do so.

So you’d do training courses for work outside of your paid hours?

SusiePevensie · 26/08/2023 07:56

Up to you, but I'd be uncomfortable. It sends the message that you learn because you get paid to do so.

Poivresel · 26/08/2023 07:56

NewDogOwner · 26/08/2023 07:43

It has been established that offering extrinsic motivation actually erodes intrinsic motivation. However, I have a kid who is work shy and is motivated by rewards. I don't know what I'll do when the time comes.

Does that depend on when it’s begun though?
If a dc has intrinsic motivation until their GCSE’s will 2 years of extrinsic motivation knock that out?
I have 2 dc, as teens one would be both intrinsically and extrinsically motivated, enjoyed a challenge but liked the reward too if there was one.
The other teen lacked motivation most of the time regardless of encouragement or reward.

DameCurlyBassey · 26/08/2023 07:51

I was offered a financial incentive at work - a considerable amount of money for specific achievements. So, why shouldn't you give your dc a taste of the real world? It also takes away a little bit of the pressure by introducing an element of gaming/fun.

Penguinmouse · 26/08/2023 07:49

My parents gave me a financial incentive for my GCSEs but that was because I had a paper round so the deal was to give it up in exchange for studying but I wouldn’t be financially worse off.

NikNak321 · 26/08/2023 07:48

I think it's absolutely fine and good to reward hard work....like the real world 👍. My mum did the same with me and I think the amounts are fine too. My mum was single mum on min wage and gave me similar amounts 25 years ago, so I don't think it can be viewed as financially excessive. I used it to help fund part of travelling round Europe several years later 🎉👍

Bedofroses2 · 26/08/2023 07:45

I think the issue is that you're teaching her the value of money, not the value of success. Where will it end? When will she start motivating herself, rather than relying on a chunk of cash from her mum, in exchange for what she should be doing anyway? A Levels? Uni? Will you be employing her?

What impact has it had so far, if you made the deal last year? Are her mocks on track for 8s now, at least? Or is she going to get to the end of y11, cram revise for 4 weeks and then experience extreme financial reward, or a sense of loss for what she could've had, on results day?

I don't think expecting that amount of money at the end of GCSEs, and probably similar at the end of A Levels or Uni, will give her realistic expectations as she enters the world of work.