Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
AlocasiaPolly · 26/08/2023 10:05

My DD is also going into year 11 next year. We are in wales, here some schools allow students to sit some papers in yr 10 and the rest in yr 11. DD did around 40% of her papers this year. She got her results on Thursday and did brilliantly (A*s and As), far better than she expected, and for her, the sheer joy of seeing her hard work pay off, was worth more than any financial reward would have been. I think the added pressure to achieve would have been less than helpful, on top of what is already an incredibly stressful time.
Friday she got up and started making revision notes for next years Geography exam (one of the subjects that shes not sat any papers in yet), with absolutely no prompting, or even mention of next year from me. The joy of success has made her hungry for more next year.

Ohhbaby · 26/08/2023 10:00

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:18

But why? Not being confrontational I just can't imagine the counter argument

I believe the counterargument is that it teaches children to work when externally motivated.
So instead of her being internally motivated to do well in school, she needs external input/motivators to do it. Ie money.

Which is a problem longterm because you want her to do well in uni, work hard at her job, be healthy, do exercises, eat good food, anything in life without needing her parents waving a purse at her.

I believe research shows that the more kids need external motivators to do what they know is good for them, the less likely they are to ever use internal motivation. Ie they will rely on external motivation which isn't feasible in adult life

Simbaiamyourfather · 26/08/2023 10:00

My dad made a similar deal with me and agreed to the same with my children. I consider it to be an incentive and reward for hard work and don't see the issue.

Fallingthroughclouds · 26/08/2023 09:58

TheBarbieEffect · 25/08/2023 07:23

Your DD is motivated by money because when she was a toddler you didn’t teach her intrinsic motivation.

That was a mistake, because you have taught her she shouldn’t do X, Y or Z unless there is something in it for her. This is going to make life a lot more difficult for her as she gets older and has to live her own life.

She will struggle to do anything she doesn’t want to, and of course part of life is sometimes doing things we don’t want. It has set her up to fail really, and without you there she is going to find day to day living really hard because you haven’t taught her intrinsic motivation.

Wow and you got all that from this thread?

Set up to fail, will find day to day life really hard, her life is going to be difficult.

It's a very bleak prediction taken from one post.

TrustyRusty68 · 26/08/2023 09:58

Not sure that rewarding GCSE grades with cash means the child will always struggle to do anything they don’t want to! Or any of the other things you commented with! People are often motivated by money - it allows them to buy the things they want! With straight A’s she could well afford to buy a car she wouldn’t have had before - absolutely says nothing about parenting skills - that you’ve indicated here are poor from toddler age up!

converseandjeans · 26/08/2023 09:56

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so

It's not SIL place to comment. You know DD best and if she is academic but lazy then this will probably encourage her to work harder. If worst case scenario is she gets a 7 instead of an 8 then she still gets some reward.

I think a less academic child would presumably have more realistic targets. But this is not your DD so that argument isn't relevant.

@TheBarbieEffect I don't believe you can actually teach intrinsic motivation. Some people are more naturally motivated than others.

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I doubt Oxford or Cambridge would have any interest in what a student was rewarded for their GCSE exams. They just want students with high grades & good critical thinking & prepared to work hard. OP hasn't indicated that this is the goal. Not everyone wants Oxbridge or Russel Group uni.

Do what suits your family OP. We can't afford that amount but you can so it's up to you.

BelindaBears · 26/08/2023 09:54

If your child is motivated by money then crack on. I’d be pissed off with myself if I’d ended up with a child at a selective school with all educational advantages who still needed thousands of pounds dangled in front of them to make a bit of effort though.

Monkeypopcorn · 26/08/2023 09:54

My Dad did this £100 for an A. £50 for a B. £25 for a C. My predicted grades were awful because I was slowly going off the rails. Not sure he expected to turn it around as well as I did... 8As, 2Bs, 1C and 1E. Worked wonders for me and I'd do the same for my children if I thought it was going to work!

SpunkyGibbon · 26/08/2023 09:54

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/08/2023 09:45

But the "results" from hard work should be the grades themselves, surely?!

I worked hard and didn't get the grades buts as it is I'm financially better off than my siblings who were rewarded , maybe because I didn't expect anything from anyone else

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/08/2023 09:45

Applesonthelawn · 26/08/2023 09:37

I think it's absolutely fine. Consistent with the lesson that hard work yields results in life. No-one's business but yours.

But the "results" from hard work should be the grades themselves, surely?!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/08/2023 09:43

Namddf · 26/08/2023 09:39

Except OP isn’t her DD’s boss. She’s her mum.

Penny dropped for anyone yet?

Exactly.

If you work for a company, the work that you are doing is for the company's benefit and/or to achieve the company's aims.

Are kids working hard to achieve good grades doing it for their parents' benefit or to fulfil their parents' aspirations? I always taught my dd to do it for her own sake, not mine, so why would I pay her to do that?

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 26/08/2023 09:42

Fingeronthebutton · 26/08/2023 09:04

I think it’s a brilliant idea. It sends the message: you work hard you get rewarded.

Also sends the message if you’re unable to succeed in this way you’re worth less.

pointless thread though as those that can afford it and have never experienced a child with a disability that prevents them achieving top grades will just praise the OP. Bit like asking “Am I right or am I right!”

Namddf · 26/08/2023 09:39

ST10 · 26/08/2023 08:51

the message is that you get (financially) rewarded for working hard and achieving high - that’s the premise in most work places with promotions or bonuses so I don’t really see the problem.

Except OP isn’t her DD’s boss. She’s her mum.

Penny dropped for anyone yet?

Applesonthelawn · 26/08/2023 09:37

I think it's absolutely fine. Consistent with the lesson that hard work yields results in life. No-one's business but yours.

AkitaAtHome · 26/08/2023 09:36

My dad did it with me, we did it for my step-daughters and have done it with 3 of the grandkids. Gives them the push to revise and take it more seriously. They're being financially rewarded for working hard at something they're about to do anyway.

Namddf · 26/08/2023 09:34

No, no. Never ever.

Why? Just why? Your daughter is already heading for brilliant results and doesn’t sound like a child who needs an incentive. Why are you paying her to do even better? What good could this possibly do?

Here is the loud-and-clear message it sends:

“Your worth in my eyes is attached to your achievements.”

Aside from the practical considerations. If her sibling(s) is less academic will they get less money even if they worked just as hard? If she doesn’t get her results then will you really withdraw the offer of the money, making her feel even more of failure? Or will you pay her anyway, making the whole thing a farce? What if she works really hard and the exam just doesn’t go her way? Has she ‘failed’ your test? Are results worth more than hard work?

I think you need to ask yourself why her GCSE results (which, aside from getting her to the next stage academically do not count for anything much) matter so much to you.

Seriously.

HagoftheNorth · 26/08/2023 09:33

OP, If you think it’s making no difference to your dd, then maybe it’s not right for her, whatever anyone else thinks. Can you think of anything which would be more motivating for her, or maybe she needs help setting shorter term goals - next summer seems a long way off when you’re 15

surreygirl1987 · 26/08/2023 09:29

I would do it. Anything to motivate! That's a lot of money though!

CrossStitchX · 26/08/2023 09:26

We have never financially rewarded grades like that on a sliding scale. For both kids on the big exams done something on the night before the results like a meal out or other family trip to recognise their hard work and send the message that as long as they did their best, that's all that matters.

WisherWood · 26/08/2023 09:26

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:18

But why? Not being confrontational I just can't imagine the counter argument

As a PP has said, revising and working hard are within her control, the results aren't. So you're rewarding something outside her control.

As a method, it wouldn't have worked for me. I was stressed anyway. The thought of getting or not getting money according to my results, which were outside of my control, would have tipped me over the edge.

Also personally for me, I would not have coped well with the idea that my worth and the value of my exams were monetary. It's not a value system I appreciate. But these are personal things so if you think it will motivate your daughter, that's up to you.

RestartingLife · 26/08/2023 09:21

TheBarbieEffect · 25/08/2023 07:23

Your DD is motivated by money because when she was a toddler you didn’t teach her intrinsic motivation.

That was a mistake, because you have taught her she shouldn’t do X, Y or Z unless there is something in it for her. This is going to make life a lot more difficult for her as she gets older and has to live her own life.

She will struggle to do anything she doesn’t want to, and of course part of life is sometimes doing things we don’t want. It has set her up to fail really, and without you there she is going to find day to day living really hard because you haven’t taught her intrinsic motivation.

Such a completely self aggrandising post. Everyone is different. You are entitled to your opinion but that's all it is - an opinion. It doesn't mean that you are the best at anything nor above anyone else. Step back down off that pedestal and join the rest of us in the real world where we should be helping eachother, not putting ourselves above others.

Boomboom22 · 26/08/2023 09:19

It's not the only motivation though, it's a bonus / reward on top. 200 isn't enough if that was the only motivation for 2 years!! Throughout the 2 years effort should be rewarded in order to get good outcomes.
Nothing wrong with trying your best but they should be trying!

Andthereyougo · 26/08/2023 09:16

Your money, your choice. Have to say it never occurred to me to promise my dc money to work hard at school.
I’ll have to check with dgc if they expect this bribe incentive.

Scaryghost · 26/08/2023 09:13

If you can afford it then why not?

Totaly · 26/08/2023 09:12

the message is that you get (financially) rewarded for working hard and achieving high - that’s the premise in most work places with promotions or bonuses so I don’t really see the problem

Unless you work for government and there’s no bonuses and everyone’s paid the say. Or you are a shop worker in min pay, with 10 years experience but paid the same as the new starter. Or work in care.

But that’s not what you mean is it? These rewards are only for the academic high achievers.

Swipe left for the next trending thread