Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 26/08/2023 10:46

Except OP isn’t her DD’s boss. She’s her mum.

Penny dropped for anyone yet?

^ This. The amount of people on here comparing the situation to a job. 🙄 No wonder so many teens have fucked up mental health.

I can't imagine having to tell my DD that because she sadly only achieved 6s, no money. No matter how well they've done, getting GCSE results is bloody stressful and by paying them less than they could have got, you're reenforcing that they've failed in some way. I rewarded DD by giving her money to go to Nando's with friends after her really good results. Knowing how hard she'd worked I'd have given her the same if they hadn't been as good.

I think parents who do this are completely naive about how just how much about the GCSE process is outside the student's control.

Beexxxx · 26/08/2023 10:45

Ffs the kids frontal lobe hasn’t bloody developed yet! Long term consequences haven’t set in, they are more likely to be motivated by having summer holiday money than their future 😂 what you’re doing is fine people are psychoanalysing your kid under the same rules as they would an adult and it just doesn’t work that way.

also for the person who said it felt like a double punishment when they didn’t do as well. I get that but when I had a similar thing I was happy with what I had earned rather than what I hadn’t if that makes sense? (Sorry about grammar have had very little sleep in a week 😂)

MistyBean · 26/08/2023 10:44

I got nothing for getting straight As back in my day. I was entirely self motivated. Maybe you will get them to get good results from this sort of set up for these exams, but I question the longer term benefits. You can see at work the young adults who have frankly been quite spoilt. I think this sort of reward system breeds a very unpleasant attitude in life.

DameCurlyBassey · 26/08/2023 10:43

I would also add that the amount of money you are offering seems fair to me. The higher the amount the more dc will want it. Your instincts are right on this, op. Don't be swayed by the naysayers.

IsItThough · 26/08/2023 10:39

Also, I know kids who worked damned hard who had a bad day, were unlucky with the questions on the paper, misread what was asked of them....or actually had poor teaching so less to draw upon.

BUT I would also say to a degree its horses for courses - this might be something your daughter needs?

Mine would have been like - keep your money! but then in my house, from being tiny a star chart was about the most inflammatory thing you could have done.....

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/08/2023 10:37

Not everybody will have the same experiences or opinions, but my thoughts are (from 1989, hence the amounts being less than mooted in PP):

a. 'Why would I give you pocket money? I don't care what the house looks like, I'm not paying for you to vacuum the stairs or clean the bathroom when I wouldn't do it myself.'

Vs

'I really appreciate you vacuuming, mopping the floors, cleaning the bathroom and kitchen and doing the washing up. Here's five pounds for doing all of that - if you cut the hedge each Sunday morning, I'll make it up to seven and a tenner if you run the strimmer around the back garden once you've cleaned the cuttings up. It wasn't getting done before, but it makes a big difference to the house.'

b. 'What's the point of taking all those exams? It's not like you're going to be a doctor. If you're lucky and find somebody who'll have you, you'll be married by 20. You can't work when you've got children - so make sure it's a rich man or you'll need to get yourself down the council and tell them you need a house'.

Vs

'I know everybody round you has got at least two kids by the time they're twenty, I was married at 17 after all, but you're smart and you don't have to do that if you don't want to. You could go to university and become a doctor, a teacher or a lawyer - or something else, maybe live overseas, own your own home and not be dependent upon anybody else. It'll give you the freedom to make choices throughout your life'.

Which leads us onto

c. 'Do what you want. I don't care what grades you get, you don't need exams to get a job in a shop or hairdresser's. Everybody else does it and it's good enough for them, why would you think you're anything special? I did fine working in a shop until I got married'.

Vs

'You could do really, really well if you put some actual effort in for 18 months. I value you and your potential and I want to give you an extra motivation - like if you were working, you'd get a payrise, a bonus or go up a point of the salary scale. How about twenty pounds for every B and thirty for As?' (or Cs and Bs as suitable for the kid's abilities).

One tells the kid that the effort and achievement is valued, one tells them that there's no point in bothering. I had the it's not worth the effort version throughout my childhood.

IsItThough · 26/08/2023 10:34

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 26/08/2023 09:45

But the "results" from hard work should be the grades themselves, surely?!

the problem is that hard work doesn't always yield results in life, particularly not financial ones

Ariela · 26/08/2023 10:33

Whatever you promise your child is up to you, and yes it is a great motivator,. However whatever you promise if your child meets that then don't let them down, but stump up the promised reward.
Our GCSE reward for passing all was a watch. My parents promised me I could choose which watch I wanted because unlike my older siblings I was taking all mine a year early - a Timex with a red strap, they KNEW that was the one I wanted. It was £2 or so more expensive than the cheapest which came with a brown strap.....I'd even have paid the extra myself

I got all my GCSEs (grades today would be A or A*) a year early.
I got the cheap one with a brown strap. I can still feel the disappointment today (almost 50 years on), it's not as though I wear a watch now & the Timex broke and was binned many many years ago.

Hadalifeonce · 26/08/2023 10:31

We did it for both of ours, sliding scale going into negative for a bad one. They are so used to instant gratification these days, so trying to persuade them that better results will result in more choices later, or short term pain for long term gain was wasted on them. Cash is king!

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 10:23

Simbaiamyourfather · 26/08/2023 10:00

My dad made a similar deal with me and agreed to the same with my children. I consider it to be an incentive and reward for hard work and don't see the issue.

The issue is that hard work doesn't always mean people get good exam results. And some people get good results without much work.

OilOfRoses · 26/08/2023 10:23

I wouldn't. I don't care if you do.

My kids don't all have the same capabilities. They range from academically gifted and expected to score in the top 1% to bright but with a learning disability that affects their test performance. I don't feel the grades necessarily reflect the amount of effort they put in, so it doesn't seem balanced or fair. I prefer to reward my kids for doing the best they can whether that be a 5 or 9.

Notellinganyone · 26/08/2023 10:23

CebelloRojo · 25/08/2023 07:14

It’s your choice but I wouldn’t do it for my kids. I don’t like the message it sends to them.

I agree. I’m both a secondary school teacher and a mother of three. The motivation has to come from them. It really doesn’t sit well with me. The system is flawed anyway- subjective marking in some subjects and varying grade boundaries. Plus those are huge sums you’re suggesting- that would have cost me thousands!

Johnnybegood2 · 26/08/2023 10:23

As someone who struggles to get good grades in exams but can ace coursework I would not do this with my kids.

They would get a reward for putting effort in regardless of grade achieved.

You know your daughter though and if it's what she needs to get her butt in gear then I don't see the issue 🤷‍♀️

lazysummer · 26/08/2023 10:22

Success is its own reward.
As a teacher, I witness this annually on results day. Sometimes success comes from hard work but we also see a lot of students let down by unfair marking and other circumstances beyond their control.
They don’t need the complication of financial reward/ penalty.

notacooldad · 26/08/2023 10:21

I don’t like the message it sends to them.
What? Work hard and you get rewarded.
Sounds like a good message to me and encourages a work ethics.

We did it for ds.
He was bright but the class joker. It worked for us. We knew that the teen years can be a bit bumpy but kids usually straighten themselves out by the time they are 18. An incentive kept his momentum going until he had the maturity to motivate himself.
No regrets.

DuesToTheDirt · 26/08/2023 10:20

I think it's fine in principle, but wow, £200? Shock

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 10:17

I didn't. Hard work is not always rewarded with good results. It can be devastating enough for students to not get the results they want or need if they have worked hard. You will effectively be adding to the upset if you then don't give them the money.

newwings · 26/08/2023 10:14

My dad offered me 1k per good result, I wasn't remotely motivated by that, money can't buy everything. I would have thrived a lot more in a loving calm home. I didn't do bad but no where near what he wanted.

Theborder · 26/08/2023 10:14

Totally ridiculous and encouraging an extrinsic motivation over an intrinsic one. Let her develop intrinsic motivation and you watch her flourish post GCSEs. Honestly, every kid I ever knew to get a financial reward for a GCSE has done really, really mediocre afterwards in their career.

Feralgremlin · 26/08/2023 10:14

For me, I have no issue with using financial incentives or rewards, but we reward effort over attainment in our family. So instead of it being dependent on certain grades it could look more like “if you spend x amount of time revising you will get y amount of money”

mondaytosunday · 26/08/2023 10:13

I tried this as desperate with my son (not the amounts you are speaking of though). I got him the revision books. I printed reams of past papers. I sat with him and went over his work. It didn't work, even though he is very money driven. Motivation has to come within too.

Goodenoughisgoodenough · 26/08/2023 10:12

Do you have other children? I have a 17 Yr old going into Y13, who's predicted to do well, if he studies. But I wouldn't do this. For one thing I also have a 13 Yr old with dyslexia. She's very bright but unlikely to achieve a load of As. But I try to make it very clear that her achievements are as valid as her brother's. I can't imagine how she'd feel if her brother pocketed £1000 after his exams, and she got £100. Her achievements might actually be so much more. I think paying him/ her for time spent studying is a better approach if money really is the only thing that motivates her. But do try to find something else! I've taken my son to load of uni open days and that has inspired him to do well.

TheWomanTheyCallJayne · 26/08/2023 10:10

I wouldn’t do it.
Partly because I don’t have a thousands to hand them.
But mainly because three of mine are naturally very academically able. One isn’t. The one who isn’t is not the one who works the least. There is no way I could do it fairly.
None of them seem that bothered. Their results are their own achievements.

People saying that they get paid to work hard. I’ve just done a course. I did it because the results benefit me. I got no financial reward from it, in fact it cost me. But the reward is the knowledge and the potential having it gives me. GCSEs are more like that than a job.

IsItThough · 26/08/2023 10:08

I think that approach sets you up ultimately for unhappiness and weird expectations in life - many things that are hard work do not pay well financially.

Results that reflect their ability and effort are the best incentive, and the ability to progress to what they want to the best motivation.

I have 2 teens who have just sat GCASE/A-levels and there is no way on earth either we would have offered that kind of incentive; or that it would have motivated them more. Some of their friends were offered that - it doesn't need to have made any particular difference to their results, particularly.

We rewarded our two with enough money to go on short holidays with friends after the exams finished, weeks before the outcome, as much to mark the end of a phase of school life as anything else.

DangerousAlchemy · 26/08/2023 10:06

Never even crossed my mind to award money based on the grades my DD got! Would rather treat her to a celebratory meal or pay for theatre tickets. She's v academic & got 7-9s in GCSEs & 3 x A* at A Levels. Her younger brother prob won't do as well (& that's fine) so I don't like the competitive message it sends if you have more than 1 child personally. Each to their own.