Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
happyhippiehippo · 26/08/2023 12:14

Flossflower · 26/08/2023 11:41

I am expecting to get a roasting for this. My children put in a lot of effort for their exams. I gave them something for their effort not the result. However, as parents we put in a lot of effort too. We led by example. We did not go out or have friends round while they were revising. We did not put the television on for ourselves. When we were not working we were available to test them. You can test children even if you know nothing about the subject if you have the answers in front of you.

Wow, that's dedicated. You didn't watch TV whilst they were in their revision period or have a life basically? What is the plan once they go to uni?
We do/did support but I've never been the parent to insist on testing them unless they seek it out themselves. I also hear so many parents who 'help' with homework (not implying you did btw, this is a separate issue). It's cheating in my book but each to their own.

Hmcs · 26/08/2023 12:12

id rather reward for trying their best giving it their all
or even just reward for getting through it

once my daughter did her 11+
i took her out of school for a day told then we were having a mental health day and off we went to a theme park

i feel like offering that kind of incentive can put a lot of pressure on then because they want the money
but do you really want her to burn out trying to get there

123sunshine · 26/08/2023 11:59

It’s not something I’ve done for my children. My children see their parents work hard and understand that to have a nice lifestyle which they’ve be Coe. Accustomed to they need to work hard for it. I tell my children and stepchild that it’s their life and they’ll get out of it what they put in. Work hard and you’ll get results to be successful. Motivation enough should be that desire to work hard and achieve success. If they mess up the consequences are on them. Let them be accountable for their actions. We’ve just had a successful set of a levels and GCSEs in this house, not straight 9s or A’s but some really solid good results which they aimed for to move into their next stages in life if a levels and uni. Surely the reward is in the achievement and hopefully success you make of your life. Mummy and daddy can’t be there to helicopter parent forever.

WillowCraft · 26/08/2023 11:49

Motherofacertainage · 25/08/2023 07:44

Agree with some of the PP. You are not being unreasonable because it is your choice how to parent your own child however if you want to find a way to encourage independent study skills and set your child up for future academic success, extrinsic reward ,in my experience, will not work. Unless your child values the academic success, and the intrinsic value, of great exam results, she will not work for them. Creating an environment where she is supported to study and offering lots of praise (and the odd treat) for working hard and encouraging her to see the importance of learning , and the opportunities those good exam results can offer, would be far more effective than chucking money at the issue.

Lots of praise is just as much an extrinsic reward as money.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 26/08/2023 11:46

Oh I helped DD to practise her Spanish speaking exam, not sure how useful it was with my atrocious Spanish accent (last studied Spanish 40 years ago)!

Lemonyfuckit · 26/08/2023 11:45

I personally wouldn't do it that way around (for the reasons other people mentioned) but it's up to you.

My parents did buy me a present after my GCSE results as a reward (which was a surprised, I didn't know they would in advance, the motivation was to achieve good results) - I mean, I did get good results and to a certain extent that was expected in my family growing up, mum was a teacher and dad a lecturer so we were given lots of support with schoolwork but were expected to work hard, but I think they would have given me a present as a reward regardless of my actual results, if I had worked hard and tried my best.

Flossflower · 26/08/2023 11:41

I am expecting to get a roasting for this. My children put in a lot of effort for their exams. I gave them something for their effort not the result. However, as parents we put in a lot of effort too. We led by example. We did not go out or have friends round while they were revising. We did not put the television on for ourselves. When we were not working we were available to test them. You can test children even if you know nothing about the subject if you have the answers in front of you.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 26/08/2023 11:39

Lazy and extreme. Yeah, that probably is a fair description of my mother. Married at 17, four under 5s by 21.

I grew up being told education had no value whatsoever. The peak of achievement for girls was hairdressing or shop work for a couple of years - anything else was getting ideas above your station.

Yes but that's your mother, I would guess that very very few of us on here would say that to our children. It doesn't mean that you have to go to the opposite extreme and tell your child that educational achievement is everything.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 26/08/2023 11:34

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 26/08/2023 11:02

FFS these kids are 15/16!

c. 'Do what you want. I don't care what grades you get, you don't need exams to get a job in a shop or hairdresser's. Everybody else does it and it's good enough for them, why would you think you're anything special? I did fine working in a shop until I got married'.

Vs

'You could do really, really well if you put some actual effort in for 18 months. I value you and your potential and I want to give you an extra motivation - like if you were working, you'd get a payrise, a bonus or go up a point of the salary scale. How about twenty pounds for every B and thirty for As?' (or Cs and Bs as suitable for the kid's abilities).

That is actually saying I don't value YOU at all, I value what you can achieve and if you don't achieve it I won't be rewarding you.

And really come on, that first statement is so lazy and extreme. Firstly what's wrong with being a hairdresser or working in a shop if it's what you want to do and you work hard at it? And most of us DO care what our kids get, but we want it for them not us.

Lazy and extreme. Yeah, that probably is a fair description of my mother. Married at 17, four under 5s by 21.

I grew up being told education had no value whatsoever. The peak of achievement for girls was hairdressing or shop work for a couple of years - anything else was getting ideas above your station.

Wsmi · 26/08/2023 11:33

CebelloRojo · 25/08/2023 07:14

It’s your choice but I wouldn’t do it for my kids. I don’t like the message it sends to them.

What, that in good performance gets rewarded in life?

happyhippiehippo · 26/08/2023 11:32

I think there are studies that show that if you reward extrinsically (e.g. money) when someone enjoys doing something (learning/revising) the result is that the person comes to think it's not enjoyable anymore and so the intrinsic motivation might disappear.

Interesting conversation though as if you have a child who is not intrinsically motivated, perhaps a reward is worth giving. But, as someone else said on here, perhaps do that on the effort (I think most schools give out effort grades) and trying your hardest.

For what it's worth, the 'always try your hardest', I do agree with to an extent but I also think this, more than anything, creates perfectionists. Perhaps you don't always have to try your hardest in absolutely everything!

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 26/08/2023 11:32

I'm very much of opinion if you can get them through gcse with decent grades it's a perfect base for them then to forge their own path.

I think we all see it differently. I see GCSEs (for my DD) as the start of preparation for A levels which as we all know are a huge step up from GCSEs. So they learn what subjects they like, what they don't, what revision works for them and crucially, they can fail whilst still having that parental back up. I feel it's a more gradual way of preparing them for life. Doing whatever it takes to get them high grades at GCSE and then leaving them to get on with it at A level sounds risky to me but each to their own. I'd describe my parenting as generally 'get a grip' but I find a lot of the posts on here actually quite cold, 'you didn't get the grade, so sorry no cash'.

So many posters on here seem absolutely certain that their kids will get top grades.

ZebraDanios · 26/08/2023 11:29

Haven’t RTFT (sorry) so this may have been mentioned but, if I recall correctly, studies suggest that children who receive financial rewards (that they know about in advance) for exam results tend to forget what they’ve learned far more quickly than children who don’t. Which may or may not be a problem, but it could potentially make the jump up to A levels harder in those subjects.

Manthide · 26/08/2023 11:18

Poivresel · 26/08/2023 07:57

So you’d do training courses for work outside of your paid hours?

Dd1 is a gynaecologist and she needs to pass various exams to proceed to the next stage. She has to pay for the exam and any courses she wants to take to help her pass.

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 11:16

Beexxxx · 26/08/2023 10:45

Ffs the kids frontal lobe hasn’t bloody developed yet! Long term consequences haven’t set in, they are more likely to be motivated by having summer holiday money than their future 😂 what you’re doing is fine people are psychoanalysing your kid under the same rules as they would an adult and it just doesn’t work that way.

also for the person who said it felt like a double punishment when they didn’t do as well. I get that but when I had a similar thing I was happy with what I had earned rather than what I hadn’t if that makes sense? (Sorry about grammar have had very little sleep in a week 😂)

My children certainly understood long consequences at the age if 15 or 16 as did I. I don't think that unusual. They are not toddlers.

Hankunamatata · 26/08/2023 11:09

I'm very much of opinion if you can get them through gcse with decent grades it's a perfect base for them then to forge their own path.
I flopped my A levels but it was a huge life lesson (and much easier to resit imo)

Hankunamatata · 26/08/2023 11:07

If you have the money and it will motivate them it's actually a very good idea.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 26/08/2023 11:05

And so they don't put in the effort that they could put in and cry on results day and have to resit a couple of GCSE's alongside their college course or don't get on to the course that they wanted which potentially changes the direction of their future.

And sometimes it is the absolute making of them. What's that saying, you learn more from your failures than your successes?

elliejjtiny · 26/08/2023 11:05

Personally I wouldn't do this because it wouldn't work for my dc but if you think it will work for yours then go for it.

ichundich · 26/08/2023 11:04

Not sure I would but Imight see it differently when I get there with my kids. When I was at school / uni good grades were a motivator for themselves.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 26/08/2023 11:02

FFS these kids are 15/16!

c. 'Do what you want. I don't care what grades you get, you don't need exams to get a job in a shop or hairdresser's. Everybody else does it and it's good enough for them, why would you think you're anything special? I did fine working in a shop until I got married'.

Vs

'You could do really, really well if you put some actual effort in for 18 months. I value you and your potential and I want to give you an extra motivation - like if you were working, you'd get a payrise, a bonus or go up a point of the salary scale. How about twenty pounds for every B and thirty for As?' (or Cs and Bs as suitable for the kid's abilities).

That is actually saying I don't value YOU at all, I value what you can achieve and if you don't achieve it I won't be rewarding you.

And really come on, that first statement is so lazy and extreme. Firstly what's wrong with being a hairdresser or working in a shop if it's what you want to do and you work hard at it? And most of us DO care what our kids get, but we want it for them not us.

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 11:00

There is a high level of naivety with some parents on here. For many reasons hard work is not always rewarded with good exam results. I appreciate that may be true of life in general but parents are meant to be on the side of their children not potentially kicking them when they are already down from not getting the results they worked hard for.

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 10:55

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:20

I would set the reward at a reasonable level. If DD2 is predicted 5's and 6's then it would be £50 for a 5, £100 for a 6 etc.

DD1 is predicted at least a 7 in every subject so with good revision and focus there's no reason she couldn't do it. She's a lazy so and so though!

Even more inequitable to go on predicted results, particularly as a child with higher predicted grades may be harder working than the one with lower predicted grades.

blackbeardsballsack · 26/08/2023 10:55

I will absolutely do this in a couple of years if I think that it will encourage my DC to revise and work harder. I work with children who are GCSE age and plenty of them just do not listen to the speeches imparted on them about the importance of GCSE's at certain grades to get into college, for their future etc. And so they don't put in the effort that they could put in and cry on results day and have to resit a couple of GCSE's alongside their college course or don't get on to the course that they wanted which potentially changes the direction of their future. I wouldn't expect every 15 or 16 year old to truly, meaningfully understand how important getting good GCSE results are. It's just a case of us getting on their backs and giving them speeches like we do about countless other things. I would expect many of the children that I work with, however, to be motivated by having a few hundred quid for the summer.

Workbabysleeprepeat · 26/08/2023 10:46

I would do this. My experience of the world as an adult is that results/outcomes are rewarded. Nobody cares about the hard work, they just want the result. It’s just about finding the right reward for that person/child. Some kids value money and some don’t.
In my experience, learning this early means a faster journey up the ladder in career terms.
I appreciate that it’s dependent on the child and the capability of that child.

Swipe left for the next trending thread