Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
Mapletreelane · 25/08/2023 08:11

Blimey! Would have cost me £1600 yesterday, mind you not sure how we would have rewarded the 6 he got as sounds an abject failure in your system.

We're on hols so went to a restaurant of his choice as a celebration. He's absolutely over the moon, completely self motivated and has worked and studied hard for his own personal self worth. I would be seriously worried about the young adult he was becoming if we'd had to offer a financial incentive for him to study to the best of his abilities.

As an side despite my opinion above it also it is not any of your SILs business. Even though I agree with her.

Characterbuilding · 25/08/2023 08:11

100% do it. Many teachers and mentors suggest this. It’s the carrot some kids need. Definitely helped me to motivate my son. In the end he actually felt bad and said not to worry about it but I gave him what he was due (less £50 for breaking my outside tap by climbing on it to get his ball back 🙄). I offered £100 for 7 and above. £50 for a 6. Also at a Grammar but was struggling with focus. It a good investment.

aSofaNearYou · 25/08/2023 08:10

For some the counter argument seems to be that they will be disappointed if they don't get the grades they wanted even if they worked hard, for others it's more that it encourages an entitled attitude and the mindset that people should pay you to do something that benefits you, not anyone else. It doesn't sit right with me, for the second reason really, but it depends on the kid. If they are already prone to being entitled I don't think it will be very good for their development.

nutbrownhare15 · 25/08/2023 08:09

tiredmama23 · 25/08/2023 07:20

I don't personally like the idea. My DD just got her results yesterday and she's comfortably achieved (in old money) 9 x A-Cs, which she is over the moon with and it's enough to secure her place to study for the A Levels she needs for uni . Im not placing any more emphasis on the As than the Cs - it literally doesn't matter to anyone. She's worked as hard for the Cs as the As and I wouldn't want to give her the message that those grades are somehow lesser than.

Incidentally, I achieved straight A* and As at GCSE. Now in my late 30s I've done 3 uni degrees including a PhD, and no one to my knowledge (apart from when I applied for A Levels) had ever asked me what specific grades I got at GCSE. Ever. I'd also add that I came from a home where academic achievement was emphasised to a large extent, and whilst it is the likely part of the reason I achieved so well at school, it's also my downfall: it's created perfectionistic and obsessive striving qualities in me, because I internalised the pressure and expectations placed upon me from a young age. I'm not saying this what you will be doing, OP. Just giving my perspective and experience.

Similar story here. I got a certain amoun for every A*, and less for every A for my GCSEs. My mum meant well but this and other aspects of my childhood emphasising that I was capable of the highest academic marks didn't pay off well later for me at university and beyond. It fueled perfectionism, procrastination and imposter syndrome. I'd have a read up on the difference between extrinsic and intrinsic motivation for kids and focusing on effort not outcome. That's what I'll be doing for my kids. All I will ask is that they do their best and I won't care what grades they get as ultimately it doesn't matter enough to set up issues later in life.

HungryandIknowit · 25/08/2023 08:09

FFSWhatToDoNow · 25/08/2023 07:59

If you imagine a small child bringing you a drawing they have done, most adults would say something like “that’s a lovely picture” or “wonderful” etc. Over time you teach them to draw how you like them to.

If you ask them what they like about the picture, or what they might do differently next time they learn that their own assessment of it is all that matters.

(this is particularly important for teens who will seek peer approval over parental. Enduring they are assured of their own worth rather than being valued by what others think of them bodes better for the future when risky behaviours, drugs etc start happening around them.)

I also recommend Drive by Daniel Pink.

Thank you!

MidnightOnceMore · 25/08/2023 08:09

Jamtartforme · 25/08/2023 08:04

I would. The message it gives is that hard work pays, which it does in adult life. I wouldn’t do hundreds of pounds though - maybe 80 for a 9, then down by £10 increments until nothing for a 5 or whatever you think he is capable of.

The problem with this is if you think 5 is what they're capable of, it is great if they get a 6. But the scale tells them you'd be even happier if they got a 7 and even more if they got an 8, even though it is unachievable.

You're simply telling them you value them less than you would if they had a different brain and base level.

It's such a negative message to give your child - I wish you were cleverer, I wish you were someone else.

Hercules12 · 25/08/2023 08:09

I’m another one who believes in intrinsic motivation. Always parented this way and encouraged dc to take pleasure in their achievements for the joy it gave them.
It would for rude for me to comment to you on what you chose but I would internally judge.

Againlosinghope · 25/08/2023 08:08

Your family your choice but I wouldn't do this for lots of reasons.

  1. The best motivation comes from wanting something for yourself. She should want to do well for her own ambition not just for money.
  1. I have 2 children who are both great but one is significantly more academic. It won't matter how much one tries or the other doesn't the one won't be able to achieve the results they other can. I don't believe in rewarding good luck. It's a bit like the attendance awards at school when one child has a chronic illness and won't get it but a peer has good health so does. It's out of the childs control.
  1. It sets the idea that grades matter above all else (physic health, mental health, sports, crafts, friends). It's one stage of life but doesn't mean that pass or failure sets the future path. Failure to achieve your expectations could set them down a self destructive path. The view that not getting 9 somehow makes there less grades peers somehow less than them.
  1. Society needs all. We can not function without the people working a spectrum of jobs. The supermarket worker, the bin collectors are just as valuable as the teachers and the nurses. Artists and preformers add colour and enjoyment to life. Everyone has value and worth and participates to our world. GCSEs are insignificant in the greater world so I don't believe in putting so much emphasis on that one small aspect out of a whole lifetime.

But it is your choice and people make different choices all the time from the money left by tooth fairy, Christmas piles, holiday destination, meals served families.
We all do what we think best

Jamtartforme · 25/08/2023 08:04

I would. The message it gives is that hard work pays, which it does in adult life. I wouldn’t do hundreds of pounds though - maybe 80 for a 9, then down by £10 increments until nothing for a 5 or whatever you think he is capable of.

Plilywhite · 25/08/2023 08:03

My dad did this for my GCSEs 15 years ago. It worked. I could either spend the money then or put it away for driving lessons or buying first car. It worked for me. All A*s, As, Bs.
I don’t think there’s anything wrong with this, you work hard, you earn the money. I have a very good work ethic and started ny career straight after leaving uni.

I was predicted good grades though. If your child is predicted lower then it’s not fair to only compensate for the highest grades.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/08/2023 08:02

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:42

Absolutely. No different to how bonuses at work would apply- you don't get rewarded for trying hard in the real world; you get rewarded for results.

This is simply not true.

There is so much more in the world of work than results and financial reward.

Think about a person who worked in end of life cancer care. Everyone died. There were no 'results'. They made people's lives better by doing their specialist and highly skilled work to the best of their abilities.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 25/08/2023 08:01

I've told my dd she will get £100 for every A she gets

Livinghappy · 25/08/2023 08:01

Academic “laziness” is often an emotionally driven phenomenon. Issues with self esteem, image, friendships and anxiety all play a role. Financial incentives won’t fix the underlying issue and could even make it worse

Agree with this. Assume you will pay similar for A levels? And then at Uni, how will they be motivated?

Children are still developing their brains and lack of effort at this stage might be more complex than a monetary reward which needs addressing now. You mention they are at a selective school so they will already have motivation to keep up with their class.

Changes17 · 25/08/2023 08:00

Thought about doing this a year ago, since DS appeared to be taking it fairly easy. But we decided to reward effort instead and gave him £250 after GCSEs finished to help pay for the stuff he had on this summer, eg going to a festival. Glad we took that approach, since we’d have paid out £1650 yesterday on your system (and we don’t have it to hand!)

We’re pretty surprised by the results but I think DS did well because he felt under less pressure. All he had to do was meet the grades for sixth form. Under your system, if he had not done so well as he did, not only would he have missed the grades, he’d have lost the money too.

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 08:00

I can understand bribery as an act of desperation if everything else has failed. But I think the battle is probably long lost by that stage.

Spendonsend · 25/08/2023 08:00

I'm not keen on the reward for grades method because I think the grade is the reward. It is the currency needed for entry to next step and cvs and the knowledge/skills to build on.

If she isnt motivated to put effort in without financial reward, then i think rewarding effort rather than results makes more sense as there isnt a direct correlation between effort and result and what you are aiming for is for her to have tried her best. For instance my son put the most effort into his lowest grade as it was an area of difficulty for him. It is also the grade with the most 'currency' as its an entry requirement for every qualification and most jobs. So getting a 6 in this had significantly more value than the 9 in his filler subject.

I dont actually agree work is rewarded on a results basis all the time either. Ive never had a bonus ststem and get paid when i cock up or pursue a dead end as well as when i do brilliant things. But the reward for employment is pay. The reward for study is qualifications.

However the pay per grade think is really common and easy to understand.

FFSWhatToDoNow · 25/08/2023 07:59

HungryandIknowit · 25/08/2023 07:33

Genuine question: how do you teach someone intrinsic motivation?

If you imagine a small child bringing you a drawing they have done, most adults would say something like “that’s a lovely picture” or “wonderful” etc. Over time you teach them to draw how you like them to.

If you ask them what they like about the picture, or what they might do differently next time they learn that their own assessment of it is all that matters.

(this is particularly important for teens who will seek peer approval over parental. Enduring they are assured of their own worth rather than being valued by what others think of them bodes better for the future when risky behaviours, drugs etc start happening around them.)

I also recommend Drive by Daniel Pink.

HelpMeGetThrough · 25/08/2023 07:58

Never did it for ours.

The conversation of "it's ultimately down to you to put the work in, we can't make you, but it's you making your future harder if you don't" was had.

Exams all passed and they are doing fine.

Where does it end? A grand for every A Level, £10k to pass your degree.

MidnightOnceMore · 25/08/2023 07:57

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:18

But why? Not being confrontational I just can't imagine the counter argument

I would never do this.

-I personally prioritise emotional reward over money in my life.
-I wanted my children to be intrinsically motivated not extrinsically motivated.

I always gave a small reward for good effort scores on reports but would never give a results-based reward.

JanieEyre · 25/08/2023 07:56

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:18

But why? Not being confrontational I just can't imagine the counter argument

Suppose she misses a grade through sheer bad luck, e.g she's feeling unwell that day, the teacher missed something off the syllabus? Do you double the. bad luck by withholding the reward?

If you had, say, one able child who could get those grades without trying, and one who worked their socks off and wasn't going to get anything like that, e.g. due to dyslexia, would you operate the same system for both children?

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 07:55

XelaM · 25/08/2023 07:47

🙄Riiiight... so you would work as hard for your employer if you didn't get paid?

Anyway, OP I think it's a great idea and there's nothing wrong with this. No teenager (that I know) is "intrinsically motivated" 🙄🙄🙄

All the teenagers I know are intrinsically motivated and achieve highly. Different types of people.

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 07:53

I didn’t. My kids finished school with top grades. My son was lazy but we had conversations about why results matter, and how he would feel if he did worse than others due to laziness. He got his act together and managed to get all 9s in his GCSEs and As and A stars at A Level in the end. He learned that he needed to work hard to achieve his potential.

I didn’t want to bribe him and teach him that things are only worth doing for lots of money. I didn’t want him turning into a young person who turns down work because they think they are above low-paid work as they start their careers.

I disagree with financial incentives for academic results. My other child has just got all A stars and is off to an amazing university. I bought her a small gift and took her out for dinner that night. But that is different to a bribe and her results have given her more joy than a set bribe ever would.

Summerwashout · 25/08/2023 07:51

Op I would use whatever I needed too to get them through.

But a tutor maybe better money spent?

StillWantingADog · 25/08/2023 07:51

My parents did this with me and I know it’s not that unusual. The daft thing is I was very diligent and I don’t think it made any difference

I think it’s fine for kids that need a bit of a push, I know my dh would disagree

if you do l, I’d encourage your dc to keep it to themselves. Def not sIL’s business.

ittakes2 · 25/08/2023 07:51

I don’t think it’s any of your sisters business but we reward on effort not results in our family as it’s effort that we value the most