Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
arethereanyleftatall · 25/08/2023 09:25

Wow @Gliomes - I had no idea you could be sat next to someone reading to someone else out loud - that seems massively unfair as it would totally put me off personally- I need silence to work properly.

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 09:25

Gliomes · 25/08/2023 08:59

A year ago I'd have said it's up to you, you know your own child best.

Having had DD just go through Y11 I think there is too much of a lottery element to it. Those exams are so small compared to 2 years' study and there's a huge number of variables like having a cold, or sitting next to someone with a reader who is reading out long passages for 20 mins, or a question coming up that you haven't covered. For most kids, most of the time, there's an element of luck in the difference between a 7 and a 9 and incentivising the 9s so heavily is failing to acknowledge what is and isn't in their control.

Slightly off topic but children with readers should have their own room!

OP posts:
Enoughnowbrandon · 25/08/2023 09:24

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:18

But why? Not being confrontational I just can't imagine the counter argument

Isn't a good grade and pride in achievement enough of a reward? Genuine question.

travelogue · 25/08/2023 09:23

The reason I haven't (even though DD is quite money motivated), is because she has been suffering with quite debilitating anxiety since Y9 and me saying this would be interpreted by her as me wanting her to get all 9s which would have seemed like an additional pressure, when she was stressed enough about it. I wouldn't have wanted her to feel lower grades were worth less or failures if she'd done her best.

I know she tried her best and I've tried to find other ways to be kind and encouraging along the way. A surprise bar of chocolate here, some face masks there, a new top if she'd been working really hard that week. That type of thing. Her MH is improving - I'm mostly concerned with keeping that trajectory and hope this is the thing that will help her grades the most.

EhrlicheFrau · 25/08/2023 09:23

orangegato · 25/08/2023 09:21

Excellent idea and I’d have worked my arse off for that. Carrot and stick and all that.

Give them something to aim for rather than some soggy ‘do your best’ and pat on the back for a bunch of 3s.

You are aware that some people might 'work their arse off' yet still also get lower grades, or that others might not work that hard and be naturally able to get high grades?

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 09:22

Mummy08m · 25/08/2023 09:03

I've been a teacher in selective schools over ten years and it's never the top students who have this.

Think about it logically. Let's say it's £150 for an 8, £200 for a 9.

It takes hours of extra effort and revision to get a 9. Would any intelligent kid, purely motivated by money, bother with all those extra hours for £50?! No. They'd mow someone's lawn a couple of times and get that money way quicker.

Top students (I'm talking the mostly 9s types) are motivated by pride, competitiveness, maybe even a sort of intellectual snobbery/arrogance. Not necessarily the best attributes but if, as a parent, you care more about results than anything else, that is the way to go about it.

Oh there's definitely some of arrogance and competitiveness there too - particularly in the subjects she's predicted 8's/9'a.

Some interesting viewpoints that have made me think about how we might adjust the arrangement slightly. Thanks

OP posts:
EhrlicheFrau · 25/08/2023 09:21

Firstly, I do feel that it really is each to their own on this, however these are the main reasons why I wouldn't use a system like you describe:

  1. Not every child is capable of (all) top marks, no matter how much they study!
  2. The child who got a lower grade might have worked twice as hard to get that grade than the child who got a top grade.
  3. The child who is expected/predicted a certain grade, and then doesn't meet it, will have both the disappointment of not getting their grade and also not getting the reward they were looking forward to.
There may well be other reasons, but these are the ones which jump out at me just now.

We are in Scotland, DS did well and I know he also worked hard, so as well as letting him know how proud we were he was also rewarded in gift form - however the performance in the exams wasn't tied to that and it was really a spur of the moment thing to 'reward' him in that way.

orangegato · 25/08/2023 09:21

Excellent idea and I’d have worked my arse off for that. Carrot and stick and all that.

Give them something to aim for rather than some soggy ‘do your best’ and pat on the back for a bunch of 3s.

ClarkWGriswaldd · 25/08/2023 09:19

I didn't offer it when he was doing his GCSE's as it may have placed pressure on him.

He got his results yesterday and did well so I've sent him £200 and bought him some clothes

Ilovelurchers · 25/08/2023 09:12

I wouldn't do this - I taught GCSE for years and in my experience it is not always the hardest working students who achieve their target grades or above - there is an element of luck (what questions come up); an element of pressure having an impact on the day; and in my subject and others a strong element of subjectivity in the marking.....

I would potentially provide a financial reward for hours spent revising, or revision classes attended, if I had a child who didn't work hard.

But providing she had worked as hard as reasonably possible, the rewards would come for that. The grades are a reward in themselves, in a sense - but I have seen so many hard working students upset by their grades in the past, because grades aren't always fair! I would hate to add to that for my own child ....

I do see why it seems to make sense to you OP. I would just adapt your system slightly if you can think of a way of doing it.

electriclight · 25/08/2023 09:11

It's your child so your choice, and your SIL shouldn't have said anything.

However, there is a lot of research out there that extrinsic rewards don't work and erode motivation, fulfilment and enjoyment over time.

As a teacher, we are certainly taught that extrinsic rewards do not work and are best avoided.

I have avoided them as a parent too. When dd was a toddler, I was at a friend's house when she asked her teen dd to empty the dishwasher. Her response was 'how much?' I knew that I didn't want a child who only did things because they were offered money.

BungleandGeorge · 25/08/2023 09:11

Plenty of parents do this and it’s none of sil business. If she had kids I’d understand a bit more as you are making life difficult for those parents who can’t afford to do this! Generally I think sometimes it’s the people who have not met expectations at some point who develop better motivation and GCSEs are not really that important and perhaps a good point to allow that to happen. But it might be with a bit more maturity she’ll Do it herself for a level onwards

Wakemeuuuup · 25/08/2023 09:08

I wouldn't do it. The reason for that is that dc1 will not get those 8/9s no matter how hard he works. 6/7s are really good for him.

Dc2 finds exams easier and doesn't get stressed in the exam hall so the same amount of work yields much higher grades.

Dc1's results are not worth less than dc2's, I'm proud of them both

Mummy08m · 25/08/2023 09:03

I've been a teacher in selective schools over ten years and it's never the top students who have this.

Think about it logically. Let's say it's £150 for an 8, £200 for a 9.

It takes hours of extra effort and revision to get a 9. Would any intelligent kid, purely motivated by money, bother with all those extra hours for £50?! No. They'd mow someone's lawn a couple of times and get that money way quicker.

Top students (I'm talking the mostly 9s types) are motivated by pride, competitiveness, maybe even a sort of intellectual snobbery/arrogance. Not necessarily the best attributes but if, as a parent, you care more about results than anything else, that is the way to go about it.

Thelonelygiraffe · 25/08/2023 09:03

I wouldn't. I gave my dc money for working hard, not for results. But if you think your dc would be motivated by cash, then go for it.

Aquestioningmind · 25/08/2023 09:00

YANBU.

You know your child best so if money will motivate her to do the best she possibly can, that's what you should do.

I don't know why people say GCSEs don't matter - they do. It might not impact on university choices, or even what she can sit at A level (although it did for me - anything below an A and my school said no to sitting it at A level!) but it will impact on how teachers look at her and how much teachers will push her if she stays at the same school (i.e. if she gets a 9 in English Literature, and carries it on for A level, at A level her teacher will expect her to do well and thus push her harder. If she gets 6s, teachers won't push her as hard as she'll have set a benchmark for herself).

Also from a self confidence point of view - teenagers can be incredibly critical on themselves. If she does well that will boost her confidence going into A levels and beyond.

And, let's be honest, there is no price on supporting your child to be successful - if you can afford it and it'll work for her, then go for it.

Gliomes · 25/08/2023 08:59

A year ago I'd have said it's up to you, you know your own child best.

Having had DD just go through Y11 I think there is too much of a lottery element to it. Those exams are so small compared to 2 years' study and there's a huge number of variables like having a cold, or sitting next to someone with a reader who is reading out long passages for 20 mins, or a question coming up that you haven't covered. For most kids, most of the time, there's an element of luck in the difference between a 7 and a 9 and incentivising the 9s so heavily is failing to acknowledge what is and isn't in their control.

Jamtartforme · 25/08/2023 08:54

UpdownUpdownAltogetherNow · 25/08/2023 08:50

The issue is what to do if she works really hard but then doesn’t achieve the grades (really hard paper etc). I much prefer rewarding the work rather than the final achievement. I’d be more inclined to say that if she works really hard in every subject she will get £X.

If OP staggers the amount down to say a grade 6, it’s unlikely she won’t get anything, there will be some kind of financial reward. It may not be at the top end of what she could’ve got but that’s a life lesson isn’t it? We talk about resilience, I think this is a good opportunity for that. Life isn’t fair essentially, best they learn it now in ways.

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 08:54

Whilst i am against bribery, I would never tell someone IRL their method was wrong, unless asked. Your sil needs to keep her mouth shut.

UpdownUpdownAltogetherNow · 25/08/2023 08:50

The issue is what to do if she works really hard but then doesn’t achieve the grades (really hard paper etc). I much prefer rewarding the work rather than the final achievement. I’d be more inclined to say that if she works really hard in every subject she will get £X.

MilkofMagnesia · 25/08/2023 08:50

We had financial reward for grades, I can’t remember the exact amount. He worked hard at school and he had a paper round from 13.

With A levels I told DS if he got all A grades I would buy him a car, I had to buy him a car.

orchardsquare · 25/08/2023 08:44

It never occurred to me to do this with mine. My youngest got all grade 9-7 with no revision, my eldest dropped out of school and didn't get any at the correct age. We just went out for a meal to celebrate results/efforts, eg if the eldest managed to sit an exam and not walk out.
Although, I do remember my mum did something like this when I did my exams. She didn't tell me beforehand but afterwards gave me something like £250. I felt embarrassed and undeserving (I had done fairly well but not amazingly, and hadn't put much effort in).

Jamtartforme · 25/08/2023 08:44

Also, if I can add, I think things like GCSE results are too important to ‘teach them a lesson’. It’s really in their best interests to just get as good results as they’re capable of, however that happens, rather than using it as a learning opportunity by making them deviate from their education path by retaking.

Temporaryname158 · 25/08/2023 08:43

If your daughter is lazy I’d sit down and have a serious chat with her about what the laziness will result in. Namely poorer grades and not representing herself as well as she could on results day.

and then pretty much leave her to it, other than the obvious encouragement to study. She has to want to do it for herself.

she also needs to learn the lesson that if you don’t work hard you don’t get results.

on life she will get a paid job but she’ll lose it to redundancy if she is the one in the company who does the bare minimum whilst others try hard, she will be the unfavoured colleague for the same reason if she’s lazy

let her learn early on that trying your best is the best reward (irrelevant of the grade this gets). Otherwise you set up a system where you only try hard for money. The achievement in itself is what she be the motivator, the ability to progress to anything she likes.

you are doing her a dis service long term by giving her money, particularly such high amounts - she sounds quite spoilt.

HappyKatieA · 25/08/2023 08:42

Our eldest is very motivated by money, we gave £50 for every target grade met, doubled it for those exceeded. It really worked for him.