Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
TaigaSno · 25/08/2023 10:53

You already have a lot of replies which I haven't read through so apologies if I'm repeating. I wouldn't do this because to me, it's sending the wrong message. You are teaching that the main reason for working hard in her exams is financial gain. Instead, I'd prefer her to want to study and work hard because of the reward she perceives herself, because it's the right think to do, because of pride in herself, self-respect, satisfaction, being able to achieve what she wants academically and in terms of career goals. Teach her to do well for herself, not for you.

And yes, there is also the risk that she doesn't achieve as expected, and then is effectively penalised twice, first with a lower grade and second without your payment.

BillaBongGirl · 25/08/2023 10:53

I don’t know if the carrot 🥕 of money for higher GCSE grades is psychologically harmful per se as some posters are saying, but I do think in many cases the money might be better spent on tutors. You’re paying the child to self-tutor imho and that might not be the most cost efficient at the amounts the OP is talking. It depends on the child really. With mine it turned out that it wasn’t laziness holding them back but the fact that revision methods taught in schools were geared around NT minds so the ‘mind maps’ and ‘flash cards’ and ‘workbooks’ were useless at helping them revise. Lots of effort for no reward. So paying a professional tutor that specialised in ND teaching doing one on one revision with them and showing them methods that worked for them was invaluable as they then carried these skills on to A levels and Uni.

I experienced the stick 🦯 of beatings for lower GCSE grades and I know that was harmful psychologically. I ended up with being motivated by fear and as an adult developed anxiety to subconsciously create extra fear to motivate myself as a working adult. The extrinsic motivation eventually mirrored the intrinsic.

feemcgee · 25/08/2023 10:50

YANBU, I did this for my DD when she was doing her Nat 5s - not as much money as you offered luckily, as she got five As. My DS is now in S4 and will be doing these exams next year. As he isn't anywhere near as motivated as DD, I'll be offering him the same incentive.

Rewis · 25/08/2023 10:48

I don't really like it. But then again if it works then go for it. Ans your sil should keep her words to herself

Kazzyhoward · 25/08/2023 10:47

It's not something I agree with at all. Kids needs to realise that working hard at school and getting the best grades they can is for their benefit in the long term in terms of options and opening doors for a choice of good jobs/careers/professions, not just in terms of pay and progression, but also in terms of job satisfaction, flexibility, etc. They should do it for their own good, not because of what is effectively blackmail! They shouldn't be doing it for anyone else, not parents, not the teachers, it's all for themselves!

We didn't offer our DS any inducements for getting good grades etc, ever. We pushed him to do the best he could do for his own satisfaction. We were 100% engaged with his education, always went to parents' evenings and other school events, always checked his homework diary, looked at his books to see what marks/grades he was getting, stepped in when necessary to help him when he started struggling. We were behind him and supporting him 100% in terms of our time and help, not financial rewards. By the time he got to external exams, he wanted to do well for his own satisfaction, not because we were going to give him money!

MrsSchrute · 25/08/2023 10:46

Riiiight... so you would work as hard for your employer if you didn't get paid

I work just as hard in my paid job as I do in my voluntary roles. I would hate it if my DC were motivated by money. What about being a good and productive member of society, who is motivated by making life better for all of its members?

TooOldForThisNonsense · 25/08/2023 10:45

How many GCSEs do they do? Is it 10? There’s no way on god’s green earth I’d be handing a 15/16 year old 2 grand!! Wtaf?!

FFSWhatToDoNow · 25/08/2023 10:44

Characterbuilding · 25/08/2023 08:17

I used to think it was weird that my friend paid her teenage girls to do chores thinking they shouldn’t need paying. Her opinion was "I’m paying for clothes, toiletries etc.. anyway" so at least this way chores were guaranteed to get done. She has a really tight system that works and teaches them work=reward. Just like in adult life.

Nobody pays me to do chores though. 🤷🏻‍♀️

No different to how bonuses at work would apply- you don't get rewarded for trying hard in the real world; you get rewarded for results.

Never had a job with a bonus attached - 20 years in public sector (various bodies/roles), 5 in charitable. I’ve worked hard in every role, earned several times the average wage since my mid-20s.

SaveMeFromMyBoobs · 25/08/2023 10:44

People willing to put down money as an incentive for their kids getting higher grades than they would have otherwise?!? What a revolutionary concept. Maybe they should make special schools for people who have money which cost even more than OP was offering that will push the kids to do better ... oh wait 🤣

Zoreos · 25/08/2023 10:42

YANBU, your DSIL is unreasonable for commenting on your parenting and personally I would not be happy about that but my dad used the exact same financial incentive for me when I did my GCSES 15 years ago and I’ll be doing the same for my DC when the time comes.

Soontobe60 · 25/08/2023 10:42

Characterbuilding · 25/08/2023 08:35

That’s nice in theory but all kids are different. It wasn’t harped on about, just mentioned at the start. Also had to take away his phone at times, tell him he couldn’t go to the gym, watch him roll his eyes as I booked theatre productions for all his English texts. By any means necessary and some kids can make it hard. It’s not crap parenting, not all kids (boys especially) are perfect and see the point of exams at the time. Boys don’t want to be seen as "neeks" and pretend to each other they don’t work and don’t care. I had to override that narrative by any means possible. It didn’t cost me a fortune but he just about did well enough to stay on if he chooses. I also made it clear that no matter what the results we would find a way forward that works. He didn’t get all 9’s but he did better than even he expected and some pocket money afterwards is not a problem.

All the things you list that you did to support your DS are what I’d consider positives. Paying them £££s for getting a certain grade is lazy. One of my DDs sounds just like your DS - its really not a gendered thing!

LittleMonks11 · 25/08/2023 10:41

Can you reward the revision hours rather than the grades. That way she won't feel like a failure if she doesn't achieve.

AgentJohnson · 25/08/2023 10:41

She's a lazy so and so though!

And giving her money for what she should’ve doing (her best) won’t change her attitude. Unless you are planning on giving her wads of cash whenever she she should be pulling her finger out, it’s a very short term ‘possible’ solution to a longer term problem. Throwing money at problems rarely work in the longer term.

TheaBrandt · 25/08/2023 10:40

Only non academic families do this in my experience.

Also GCSEs do matter if you are doing a competitive academic course like law. There are so many good candidates they are looking for ways to weed you out.

madnessitellyou · 25/08/2023 10:40

I don't know.

All I do know is that I had to tell my parents to congratulate me after my GCSEs. They said they knew I'd do well and there was no point in praising me because I got what they thought I should have (11 at grades A* to B. Some of the best results in the year). They literally said they would not be doing anything to celebrate. That response baffled me.

I think some form of incentive would have made me feel like my parents at least were invested in my education.

Growlybear83 · 25/08/2023 10:37

CoffeeCantata · 25/08/2023 10:28

Success in life is its own reward.

I'd want a child to want to achieve for its own sake - and not connect it to monetary reward.

I've heard of parents promising kids a big gift if they passed the 11+, so that when they failed they had the double whammy of missing out on a present too.

Up to you, of course, but I'd say not. You could give something more subtly and not relate it directly to exam success - that's what we did. Then, if they make a huge effort but still don't get the desired result, you can still reward them.

I completely agree that I would have preferred my child to have been motivated by the desire to achieve, but it was clear by Year 10 that she wasn't interested in school and was very lazy with her school work. We knew what she was capable of but she wouldn't have got anywhere near the results she ended up with without a significant financial incentive. I was exactly the same at her age and was far more interested in my social life and understood exactly how she was behaving. If she hadn't got the grades she did, but had worked really hard, I would have still rewarded her to acknowledge her effort, but she didn't know that.

WandaWonder · 25/08/2023 10:35

My child needs to do good for their own future and benefit and now at 15 is slowly getting that, doing good only because they are being paid makes no sense to me so I wouldn't pay

Scarfweather · 25/08/2023 10:30

I do incentivise, but not with those amounts and then top up with a bonus for effort so it’s not all about grades. We also had a nice meal out.
I also incentivise chores, tidy rooms etc…. Because we don’t give weekly pocket money.

snowballsinhell · 25/08/2023 10:29

Yeah I've no problem with bribery for my children

No a problem

You've gotta do what you've gotta do

plantingacattree · 25/08/2023 10:28

If you are financially able, and she is motivated well by money (as you stated) then absolutely why not!
If I'd have had this incentive before I took my GCSE's I'd actually have tried. I had no incentive and no motivation at all and did pretty badly overall!
Go for it!

CoffeeCantata · 25/08/2023 10:28

Success in life is its own reward.

I'd want a child to want to achieve for its own sake - and not connect it to monetary reward.

I've heard of parents promising kids a big gift if they passed the 11+, so that when they failed they had the double whammy of missing out on a present too.

Up to you, of course, but I'd say not. You could give something more subtly and not relate it directly to exam success - that's what we did. Then, if they make a huge effort but still don't get the desired result, you can still reward them.

KittyMcKitty · 25/08/2023 10:25

I haven’t paid either of my children for either A level or gcse or 11+. I have always rewarded effort to pay for attainment is (to me) bribing them and ultimately to do well in education they need to be self motivated and work because they want to achieve the next stage. It’s an awful lot of money you’re promising - potentially £2000 for GCSEs 😱. That said it’s your money your choice.

Growlybear83 · 25/08/2023 10:20

Just to add that I think offering financial incentives at this stage probably only really works well with a lazy child who is under performing, like my daughter was. Many of her friends were also given money per grade or an overall amount based on their results.

electriclight · 25/08/2023 10:20

"This is not my experience at all. Generally children live up to thier parents expectations. Beware of setting the bar too low. Our children are emerging into a global economy, do you think parents in India and Singapore are rewarding " doing your best".?"

So a child who is trying their very best, giving 100%, can literally do no more...should never be congratulated or rewarded, unless they are also achieving at the level considered worthy of such by their parents?

Patchworksack · 25/08/2023 10:18

My oldest son just finished Y11 and we chose not to do this - he didn’t need motivation to study. I think it send the wrong message - he got 9s easily in maths and science without putting in much work, 8s in English and French but with much more effort. His lowest grade was a 7 in history which he was a bit upset about - a lot of his class dropped several grades from their prediction in history probably due to altered grade boundaries. I have no issue with the effort he put into history revision and if we were also saying with a financial reward that we valued that grade so much less than the 9s we’re compounding his internal disappointment. We went out for a celebratory dinner and we’re buying him a laptop for 6th form.
The other issue is his brother struggles much more academically and is unlikely to get anything like the same grades - we’re spending the money upfront on tutoring and as it is will have our work cut out to make him feel equally proud of himself without comparisons.
(Obviously not an issue if your DS is an only)