Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
MidnightOnceMore · 25/08/2023 11:50

XelaM · 25/08/2023 11:25

That's why you constantly get posts on Mumsnet about "how is it possible that they can afford holidays/big houses etc and we can't". The answer is - they earn more money.

We all have be grateful for the differences between us.

Who would clean a banker's teeth if we all cared for money more than people?

Society needs all of us. The risk of focusing only on individual wealth as a society is it degrades all of our quality of life.

Sure, we need some money-obsessed bankers and some entrepreneurs. We also need some people-focused teachers and artists.

PurpleBugz · 25/08/2023 11:46

One of the most mediocre if not below average kids in my school was paid per hour of revision when we did GCSEs. His dad was rich. He got really good grades and shocked everyone. I'd never heard of it before or since but always thought I will pay my kids to revise. I think somehow that's more acceptable than paying for the grades they get but possibly I feel like that as I have a very very bright child who I expect to do well and an average child I feel bad for when people compare him to her

vibecheck · 25/08/2023 11:36

felisha54 · 25/08/2023 09:48

I don't agree with it. When the time comes we will celebrate in whatever way she wants. I want my dc to be intrinsically motivated to work hard for themselves and their future. Using money as an external motivator is not setting them up for the real world as thats not how it works.

I’m not being combative but I’m genuinely wondering what world you live in where money is not an external motivator? That is literally exactly what a job is. Almost everyone would not do their job if they weren’t paid for it because they would not be able to work for free. Money is the primary external motivator in the real world!

Mummy08m · 25/08/2023 11:35

The grades themselves are the reward. Having some 8s and 9s are a valuable asset that your DC can keep forever.

Getting mostly 8s instead of mostly 6s and 7s is the difference between (say) becoming a solicitor vs a legal secretary. Or a doctor vs a HCA. Or an engineer vs a mechanic. Nb absolutely nothing wrong with the lower paid jobs and they are crucial for society. But we are talking about financial incentives here.

It could earn your DC more than £100,000 extra in their lifetimes, if they get mostly 8s instead of mostly 6s/7s.

What's £100 quid now, compared to that.

vibecheck · 25/08/2023 11:33

@XelaM I know, right? It so silly. I hope my kids are a bit motivated by money, not to the exclusion of anything else in their life but because statistically if you earn more money you have a longer, healthier, happier life. There’s nothing immoral about working to earn money 🙄

XelaM · 25/08/2023 11:25

MrsSchrute · 25/08/2023 10:46

Riiiight... so you would work as hard for your employer if you didn't get paid

I work just as hard in my paid job as I do in my voluntary roles. I would hate it if my DC were motivated by money. What about being a good and productive member of society, who is motivated by making life better for all of its members?

That's why you constantly get posts on Mumsnet about "how is it possible that they can afford holidays/big houses etc and we can't". The answer is - they earn more money.

Miffycat14 · 25/08/2023 11:25

Definitely reward effort not outcome. I had twins get their results yesterday - both good but one got higher grades in all but one subject. It must be tricky seeing your twin get those better scores, she doesn't need to see her getting lots of extra cash too. We celebrated both of them equally.

Growlybear83 · 25/08/2023 11:21

I think that's lovely, Catkin. I accept that financial incentives don't work and aren't appropriate for every child but I do believe it can be important in certain circumstances.

My daughter was in the top sets in a super selective grammar school and we had been told from when she had first started at the school that she was extremely able, even by that school's standards. As she got older, she realised that she could get by with doing less and less work and became increasingly lazy. I had been incredibly invested and supportive in her education from a very early age and she had been really motivated and happy to be the class geek in primary school. Once hormones kicked in halfway through secondary school and her social life became more important to her, then she became increasingly lazy with school work. Her teachers were despairing in Year 11 and thought she was throwing her education away. By that time, it didn't matter any more what sort of work ethic I had instilled in her because she wasn't interested any more and like so many 15/16 year olds thought she knew best and also knew that she was bright enough to pass her exams with the minimum of work. She didn't appreciate at the time how important the grades would be to the universities she was planning to apply to. I was always mindful thst she only had one real chance with her education and I honestly don't know what else I could have done by that stage and in her circumstances to get her to actually put in enough work to achieve the high grades she got apart from offering her money for doing so.

vibecheck · 25/08/2023 11:20

This is exactly what my Dad paid me for my GCSE’s 14 years ago (oh god I’m so old!). It was lovely - I was a hard worker anyway which is why he did it but it was a great extra reward, and I couldn’t work that summer because I only turned 16 on the last day of August so had no option to get a weekend job until the autumn, so it was lovely to have a chunk of money at that point of my life. It didn’t affect my work ethic at all - and I never really understand that criticism because you DO get paid for going to work as an adult! That’s one of my main motivations for working hard at my job these days! Well done to your daughter and I think it’s a lovely thing to do if you can afford it.

zingally · 25/08/2023 11:19

My parents did this for both me and my sister. I think it was £50 for every grade A* to C.

It wasn't particularly motivating, as I already had high levels of internal motivation to do well, but it was a nice little extra. I came away with a tidy sum!

I think it really depends on the kid.

Fivethirtyeight · 25/08/2023 11:10

My son has friends whose parents punish for 7s and 8s 😆

Find out the standard before you make the offer. Great to reward 9s. But what is usual in that school, how talented is your child, what can she achieve with steady work?

Research shows you should reward small improvements along the way, rather than the final result.

Mrsweasleysclock · 25/08/2023 11:10

Hi OP. Haven't rtft so apologise if someone has said this already. I would give money as a reward to the effort put it in rather than towards the grades themselves. Sit down with her and agree a study schedule including practice papers and going a bit more intense closer to exam time. If she sticks to it then x amount of money.

My main reason for saying this is that you motivate her to study for her exams without putting so much pressure on the exam itself. She'll feel more relaxed during the exam and will be more likely to do well.

Putting all the pressure on the exam itself could lead to increased stress or anxiety on exam days and hinder her chances at getting the best grade possible for her.

5128gap · 25/08/2023 11:08

I wouldn't do this, no. I think its a poor message in general. However if I were to do it I'd have linked the reward to effort rather than outcome, so 'payment' for hours spent studying rather than grades achieved. It gives encouragement where it's needed in real time. Its also a more sensible approach if you have more than one child and their abilities may prove to differ.

SlightlygrumpyBettyswaitress · 25/08/2023 11:07

You do you.
I have found praising and rewarding effort helps longer term in building resilience.

CatkinToadflax · 25/08/2023 11:06

This makes me really uncomfortable. DS2 received one grade yesterday (the others are next year). He’s very academic and was a bit disappointed in the grade 7 he received because he’d hoped for at least an 8. My brother phoned him and told him how well he’d done and told him he’d put £50 in DS’s bank account.

That was lovely and really cheered DS up. But if I’d told him beforehand that he’d get a certain sum for a 9 or less for an 8, he’d have felt even more fed up. He worked incredibly hard. Just working hard enough doesn’t necessarily guarantee the top grade that each student is capable of.

Ibetthatyoulookgoodon · 25/08/2023 11:00

This is actually an interesting philosophical question. For anyone who is interested there is a great book by Michael Sandel called "What Money Can't Buy: The Moral Limits of Markets" and it's basically about why we are comfortable with money buying some things but not others (a new kidney vs. a better education for our children, for example). He talks about incentivising kids to read (more so on an institutional level than at a family level but I guess the premise is the same) and whether there is something morally corrupting about paying children to do things which we think are inherently good for them. The book is very good (I am a big Michael Sandel fan in general) here is the link - https://www.amazon.co.uk/What-Money-Cant-Buy-Markets/dp/0241954487

For what it's worth it's worth, I would hope to not be in the situation whereby I had to pay my child to work hard for their GCSEs but equally never say never(!) Right now I have a toddler and if I could pay him for just put his god damn shoes on in a timely manner i'd be poorer for sure 😂

I know for a fact that my OH would be massively against payment for grades, or cleaning their room or doing anything that he would consider a reasonable expectation when part of a family unit and I suspect I would probably go along with that because intellectually I agree with him (albeit I might naturally lean towards being a bit more pragmatic).

DragonFly98 · 25/08/2023 11:00

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:18

But why? Not being confrontational I just can't imagine the counter argument

Because your love that you are showing through money is not unconditional.

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 10:59

VitaminDee · 25/08/2023 10:16

Mine got into Oxbridge with A stars and no bribery at any stage of their school lives. Truly passionate about their subject and their dream was to study it there.

Would your child not have been able to achieve that without rewards?

At A-level yes, at GCSE not so much. Male child quite young for the academic year, a bit lazy. By A- Levels he wanted it so much, he needed no financial incentive, although we are paying him a living allowance and his fees so much more than a few hundred quid for his GCSE results.

LlynTegid · 25/08/2023 10:58

I think it's wrong and perhaps should have been spared for A levels. However as it is made, the offer should be kept to.

thecatsthecats · 25/08/2023 10:58

MrsSchrute · 25/08/2023 10:46

Riiiight... so you would work as hard for your employer if you didn't get paid

I work just as hard in my paid job as I do in my voluntary roles. I would hate it if my DC were motivated by money. What about being a good and productive member of society, who is motivated by making life better for all of its members?

I'm a good and productive member of society. Unlike most people, this has been actually measured and proven, because the effects of a project I developed had a measured positive impact on outcomes for over 60k children and 10k keyworkers for those children.

I still work for money, and know my worth.

I know far more people being shat on and undervalued because they have an intrinsic motivation to do what they do than I know well-rewarded people who add great value because they're happy.

In fact, when I was running a company, one of the first major changes I made was to cut hours and increase pay. Turns out their intrinsic motivation to do the job flourished when they were getting more pay for less work.

Zipps · 25/08/2023 10:57

I am so glad we didn't do this.
Our eldest struggled at secondary only scraped English and Maths.
Our youngest passed everything with flying colours and went to uni doing finance.
Our eldest has a successful business and bought her own house by her mid 20's. Relieved we didn't send her the message that she was inferior in some way because of a few tests or that exam results are the be all and end all and the only route to succeed.
They both strived in their own ways, no one left feeling bad about themselves, no bribery needed.

XelaM · 25/08/2023 10:56

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/08/2023 09:50

But Oxbridge really aren't going to be interested in the kind of kid who needs to be paid in order to get good grades... they are looking for a genuine interest in the academic subject. Not the kind of kid who can't be arsed...

Oxbridge are primarily looking at grades. They will not be calling a C-grade kid for an interview to discover if they're intrinsically motivated and tried hard. It's actually more likely that kids will do well at Oxbridge if academics come easily to them but they've been coasting. My brother went to Cambridge for STEM and he was one of those "very bright but spent his time gaming instead of revising"-types at school who easily got top marks without effort and needed to be pushed to work harder.

mosiacmaker · 25/08/2023 10:55

My mum did this and I think it’s a good idea, you’re literally trying to get good grades so you can get a good well paying career so I don’t see any moral issue in getting an advanced “cash bonus” for the effort now! My aunt used to give me 50p for every sheet of homework I did when I was 4 so maybe it’s just a family thing 😅

Kazzyhoward · 25/08/2023 10:55

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 09:54

Isn't it ? I don't go to work for free, few people do. I also paid them to learn their times tables in yr 2.

But surely you need to teach your kids that the qualifications they are working towards are for THEIR benefit, no one else's, so they should be motivated to do their best for their own future, i.e. more choices in terms of careers etc.

I think we have too much of a culture of not taking education seriously enough and that comes a lot of the time from parents who don't value education, so don't instil the importance of education in their children.

"Paying" children to do school work really devalues the true worth of education. They need it explaining to them how lucky they are to be getting a free quality education compared to billions of people around the World who don't have that opportunity. They need to be told the importance of qualifications and how they open up choices and opportunities.

Far too much of the "can't do maths, me" attitude from parents these days!

Itsnotrightbutitsok · 25/08/2023 10:54

I’m planning to do something similar.

I heard about someone else doing it and I thought what a fantastic idea, this would have definitely motivated me at the time!

My DD is getting £5 per grade in each subject.
She’s predicted mostly 4s so it’s not going to break the bank.
So a 4 would be £20 per subject.

She is planning to put it away for a car/driving lessons, which I wanted to help her out with anyway and so hopefully this will just motivate her to revise.

Swipe left for the next trending thread