Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
MargaretThursday · 25/08/2023 14:32

Ds asked me if I'd give £9 for a 9 going down to £1 for a 1. I said "no".
He said "bother, I thought I had an easy £14 there" (he was taking 14 subjects).

I don't think there's anything wrong with giving a financial incentive; but I would say what you're offering is way beyond anything I've heard among ds' peers.

You've also got to be careful if you have more than one dc with different abilities.
I had a friend whose parents offered her dbro a big present if he got a certain level. He was a lazy little one, and it did give him an incentive, so it worked. But she worked far harder than him without the incentive and got I think a box of chocolates for her exams, which she did feel a bit hard done by.
But being equal isn't always fair either, my dm taught a pair of siblings. The older was bright, arrogant and lazy. The younger had some birth brain damage and worked her socks off. They offered them the same incentives, when the younger was never going to achieve above a few D/E and he did like to rub it in her face that he was getting A/B/Cs without trying.

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 14:31

electriclight · 25/08/2023 14:11

I'm a teacher and think a lot of parents do this. I think it is the intuitive thing to do when you are desperate to motivate a lazy child. Unfortunately, all of the research suggests that it doesn't work and can be counter productive. But I guess advocates will never be convinced of that.

Please do link this research

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 14:30

Scarlettpixie · 25/08/2023 14:09

I didn’t say there is no difference if you want to do medicine or go to Oxbridge which is why I said ‘in most cases’.

Surely ‘in most cases’ universities are looking at A Level results over GCSEs?

GCSEs are what you have when you apply.

Will0wWeaver · 25/08/2023 14:22

I was given £1 for every O Level pass
£5 to pass maths Level

Zero for any further education

I passed, because I worked hard & enjoyed my education. I did not pass due to the monetary incentive

Is it inflation to offer such high amounts of money ?

electriclight · 25/08/2023 14:11

I'm a teacher and think a lot of parents do this. I think it is the intuitive thing to do when you are desperate to motivate a lazy child. Unfortunately, all of the research suggests that it doesn't work and can be counter productive. But I guess advocates will never be convinced of that.

Scarlettpixie · 25/08/2023 14:09

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 12:53

If you believe a 7 is the same as a 9 for medicine or Oxbridge I am afraid you are deluded.

I didn’t say there is no difference if you want to do medicine or go to Oxbridge which is why I said ‘in most cases’.

Surely ‘in most cases’ universities are looking at A Level results over GCSEs?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/08/2023 14:06

XelaM · 25/08/2023 13:37

Well, there's a difference between getting 7/8s with minimal effort and getting all 9s by working harder. My brother actually missed the 9 (equivalent) in Maths that he was almost a shoe-in for because he's a very talented mathematician, but he was lazy and complacent. He wouldn't have missed it if it meant getting more money.

And lazy kids can be charming at interviews 😂

I'm not convinced that "charm" is what they're looking for tbh. But my college was more progressive than most, so I guess it's possible that some of the backward ones still operate on this basis.

WandaWonder · 25/08/2023 13:43

So parents are paying so the children will do what the parents have decided?

"I will pay you as I have decided you have to do this"

Is this all so parents can tell all on social media?

DontCallMeBaby · 25/08/2023 13:40

dhilez · 25/08/2023 07:47

Primary school level psychology and a sneering attitude all in one post 😂

TBF it’s A level psychology, DD told me all about it while struggling with her own motivation 🙄😂 All theory, no application.

’We’ rewarded GCSE results, quotes because I was anti and DH pro. With hindsight it would have been effective had she not been 2020 cohort and not sat her exams. Extrinsic motivation to show her what she was capable of if she worked, hopefully leading to more intrinsic motivation at A level.

No rewards for A level but there’s an extrinsic reward there for specific grades anyway - university place.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/08/2023 13:39

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 12:23

It's all about expectations. People need to look at other cultures including the far East. If a child isn't doing as well as they should at school, I absolutely encourage them to put more hours in. DS of the Oxbridge success was coasting in yr 8, I implemented a strict 60 supervised minute homework slot every evening. Amazingly his grades picked up. It really isn't rocket science. Actually he now says he wishes I'd pushed him harder. I am an unashamed Tiger Mum.

Having lived in East Asia for many years, there are many, many things that I admire about East Asian culture. However, the intense pressure that they put on their children is not something that I would choose to emulate. There is a price to be paid for that pressure and it is not one that I would ever want for my dc.

Yes, it's good to encourage a strong work ethic, a growth mindset and always striving to improve. But there needs to be a balance and mental wellbeing is also very important.

It's good that your strict regime seemed to work for your ds. Of course, he may well have found his own motivation without your intervention. Lots of bright kids coast in Year 8 because they're bored, but as they start to mature, they begin to put the effort in anyway.

XelaM · 25/08/2023 13:37

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/08/2023 13:29

Of course they look at grades but most Oxbridge applicants will have top grades in any case. What they are looking for at interview is the extent to which the applicant will respond to their way of teaching, or so I was told by the admissions tutor for my subject at my college. The grades are a prerequisite, of course, but not sufficient by themselves. I can't imagine that a kid who does well only because mum pays them to work hard is exactly going to wow at interview! There will be a few exceptions who slip through the net, of course.

As for the bright kids who apparently get top marks without effort...no need to pay them anyway, really, as they seem to be doing well enough without having to work for it?

Well, there's a difference between getting 7/8s with minimal effort and getting all 9s by working harder. My brother actually missed the 9 (equivalent) in Maths that he was almost a shoe-in for because he's a very talented mathematician, but he was lazy and complacent. He wouldn't have missed it if it meant getting more money.

And lazy kids can be charming at interviews 😂

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/08/2023 13:29

XelaM · 25/08/2023 10:56

Oxbridge are primarily looking at grades. They will not be calling a C-grade kid for an interview to discover if they're intrinsically motivated and tried hard. It's actually more likely that kids will do well at Oxbridge if academics come easily to them but they've been coasting. My brother went to Cambridge for STEM and he was one of those "very bright but spent his time gaming instead of revising"-types at school who easily got top marks without effort and needed to be pushed to work harder.

Of course they look at grades but most Oxbridge applicants will have top grades in any case. What they are looking for at interview is the extent to which the applicant will respond to their way of teaching, or so I was told by the admissions tutor for my subject at my college. The grades are a prerequisite, of course, but not sufficient by themselves. I can't imagine that a kid who does well only because mum pays them to work hard is exactly going to wow at interview! There will be a few exceptions who slip through the net, of course.

As for the bright kids who apparently get top marks without effort...no need to pay them anyway, really, as they seem to be doing well enough without having to work for it?

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 25/08/2023 13:22

I think your sis was rude to comment but I agree with her.

To me paying depending on grade is showing your child that you value them more if they achieve more. Comparing it to a job is a red herring, wtf thinks that their employer has unconditional love for their employees? Of course they want to incentivise good hard work. My DD got GCSE results yesterday so I've been on the results thread on MN and whilst DD did really well, it's pretty clear that many students worked incredibly hard, were predicted really good grades and still fell slightly short - some were clearly devastated by just missing out on a grade. I can't imagine saying to an upset child 'whoops sorry you missed out on a 9 so you only get £150 instead of £200'.

Plus sometimes being lazy and 'only' getting 7s is a kick up the arse for kids going onto A levels. I think that would be a far better way for her to learn that being lazy has consequences.

XelaM · 25/08/2023 13:21

vibecheck · 25/08/2023 11:33

@XelaM I know, right? It so silly. I hope my kids are a bit motivated by money, not to the exclusion of anything else in their life but because statistically if you earn more money you have a longer, healthier, happier life. There’s nothing immoral about working to earn money 🙄

Exactly. We can pretend that money doesn't buy happiness, but it sure helps towards it!

Anyway, I just asked my teenager if she would like to have the same deal as OP's kid and if it would motivate her to work harder. She said "Definitely- yes!" 😂So there we go. I very much doubt I'm risking £2000 given her results so far, but you never know what she might do now that the incentive is there 🤣

Daphnis156 · 25/08/2023 13:20

Will you pay her if she gets into Oxbridge, but less for St Andrews?
Will you pay her if she gets a job- call centre £0 but Cabinet Office £1,000?
Will you pay her if she has a child in wedlock? But less if not married?

Do wallets and bank transfers speak louder than love in your home?

delphi13 · 25/08/2023 13:13

Ignore your SIL and do it your way. All the people talking about intrinsic reward, that's great if that's how your kid works. My son works like that, my daughter doesn't. Both brought up the same way. Different personalities. Also some people are money motivated and will do well in sales careers and other positions where it matters. Other people aren't like that and will do well in different careers. All good as long as they are happy. My husband is money motivated, I am not. Different strokes for different folks.

justme2022 · 25/08/2023 13:08

I don't have intrinsic motivation (cheers mum for never teaching me that one 😂)
I'm similar to how you describe your daughter. I'm motivated by money but left to my own devices I'm a lazy sod. Hasn't held me back in my career. The motivation of more money makes me work for the next qualification which leads to the next promotion which gives me more money.

If it motivates her and you're comfortable with the amount it's going to cost you if she smashes them all then go for it. My only worry if I were you would be the double disappointment of missing out on money as well if she doesn't do as well as she hopes.

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 12:53

Scarlettpixie · 25/08/2023 12:48

I am not sure I agree with your approach and £2k is a lot of money!

My son got solid results yesterday and we celebrated with a takeaway and cake! His real reward is doing well enough to get onto his chosen course at college. After that I doubt anyone will care. If he hadn’t got onto his chosen course and enrolled on L2 instead of L3 we would still have celebrated his achievements.

As others have said, some of the grade boundaries are tough this year and lots of students have got lower than predicted grades. Why add to their disappointment by giving out less cash than they expected when you know they put in the work.

In most cases it really doesn’t matter if they get a 7 or a 9 in terms of next steps so why push and put them under additional stress.

If you believe a 7 is the same as a 9 for medicine or Oxbridge I am afraid you are deluded.

Scarlettpixie · 25/08/2023 12:48

I am not sure I agree with your approach and £2k is a lot of money!

My son got solid results yesterday and we celebrated with a takeaway and cake! His real reward is doing well enough to get onto his chosen course at college. After that I doubt anyone will care. If he hadn’t got onto his chosen course and enrolled on L2 instead of L3 we would still have celebrated his achievements.

As others have said, some of the grade boundaries are tough this year and lots of students have got lower than predicted grades. Why add to their disappointment by giving out less cash than they expected when you know they put in the work.

In most cases it really doesn’t matter if they get a 7 or a 9 in terms of next steps so why push and put them under additional stress.

Goldencup · 25/08/2023 12:23

It's all about expectations. People need to look at other cultures including the far East. If a child isn't doing as well as they should at school, I absolutely encourage them to put more hours in. DS of the Oxbridge success was coasting in yr 8, I implemented a strict 60 supervised minute homework slot every evening. Amazingly his grades picked up. It really isn't rocket science. Actually he now says he wishes I'd pushed him harder. I am an unashamed Tiger Mum.

CoffeeCantata · 25/08/2023 12:04

Goldencup
In our family we don't celebrate mediocrity.

So..."only winners come to dinner?"

Nice! I hope you aren't cursed with any 'mediocrities' in your family, then.

IthinkIsawahairbrushbackthere · 25/08/2023 12:02

We rewarded all our kids for their hard work but not financially and not for specific grades. The DC ranged in ability from straight A's to one for whom 5 C's was a challenge. They were all rewarded with a present and a family celebration. But they were given a reward not a motivation.

MrsSchrute · 25/08/2023 12:01

People will say "Well why should I be concerned about other people's children?" This misses the point that they are all part of a community and a well educated population that does somethings because it's the right thing to do rather than simply because they are getting paid benefits everyone.

Well said.

WestwardHo1 · 25/08/2023 11:55

Kazzyhoward · 25/08/2023 10:55

But surely you need to teach your kids that the qualifications they are working towards are for THEIR benefit, no one else's, so they should be motivated to do their best for their own future, i.e. more choices in terms of careers etc.

I think we have too much of a culture of not taking education seriously enough and that comes a lot of the time from parents who don't value education, so don't instil the importance of education in their children.

"Paying" children to do school work really devalues the true worth of education. They need it explaining to them how lucky they are to be getting a free quality education compared to billions of people around the World who don't have that opportunity. They need to be told the importance of qualifications and how they open up choices and opportunities.

Far too much of the "can't do maths, me" attitude from parents these days!

I also think it has knock on effects for other kids. There will be loads of them who won't be getting any money to do their school work. Do you think the kids who are getting paid will keep quiet about it? Of course they won't. They'll be boasting to all and sundry. This will definitely have the effect of making some children go home to parents who can't afford it or who have different values, and saying "Well x is being paid £x per GCSE" and demanding the same.

People will say "Well why should I be concerned about other people's children?" This misses the point that they are all part of a community and a well educated population that does somethings because it's the right thing to do rather than simply because they are getting paid benefits everyone.

I don't think it's good for society myself.

Kazzyhoward · 25/08/2023 11:50

We didn't pay our DS a penny for passing exams, but despite that, he's motivated by money, but he think long term, not short term. He was motivated by getting a very high paid profession (actuary) and he did his GCSEs with an eye on that kind of profession, then his A levels, the subjects which he chose for better chances of a finance profession, then his degree, again which he chose to give him the best chance of a finance profession, and now, having achieved a First in Financial Maths at a top university (for Maths), he's secured his job in a blue chip international insurance firm, in a training position to become a qualified actuary. Eye on the prize from the age of around 15, highly motivated to get there, and needed no "incentives" from us to make him work, except for our time and effort to help and support him (ensuring he had resources, a desk, books, laptop, etc.). It helped that a lot of his school friends were doing the same, i.e. looking at top careers (doctor, lawyer, IT consultant, etc) and working backwards so they knew what qualifications/subjects/grades they needed to get there.