Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to off DD financial reward for GCSE grades?

486 replies

BlackBean2023 · 25/08/2023 07:10

DD is going into y11 and last year I made a deal with her- every 9 gets £200, every 8 £100 and every 7 £50 (she's at a selective school- straight 7-9s not unusual). I've doubled the amount as a motivator for Spanish and chemistry where she's not trying and currently predicted a 5.

She told my SIL yesterday who said it's out of order but would tell me why she thought so. AIBU? I can afford it and DD is motivated by money. The grades are reasonable and obtainable for her.

SIL doesn't have teenagers so it's not a cousin comparison thing..

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Mummy08m · 09/09/2023 08:13

Plus it’s not like cash isn’t used as incentives in the adult world

The distinction I was making was short term cash earning and long term affluence.

For example in the workplace (say) there's an option to do some extra training... you're not getting £200 for that instantly. But there's a chance they'll consider you for that promotion, or it provides extra experience for you to apply for a better job elsewhere - that could earn you 10,000s down the line.

Or attending a networking event - you won't get £50 for doing that. But you might meet a few people who you could contact later when you're looking for a new (better paying) job.

There are hardly any situations in the adult world where you get short term small cash incentives for doing self-development things. It's mostly playing the long game, seeing the long term benefits.

Totaly · 09/09/2023 07:26

Plus it’s not like cash isn’t used as incentives in the adult world so let’s not hold kids to a higher standard than we hold ourselves.

Adults don’t get a cash incentives for a lot of chores.

Looking after children as a SAHP is not about money, caring for elderly parents or even neighbours is not a cash incentive. Clean your home - no cash to be made there. There are lots of jobs that don’t pay well.

RestartingLife · 08/09/2023 21:18

electriclight · 27/08/2023 16:58

Some of the parents of the primary children I teach offer cash rewards. I think it's horrible. One little boy cries every week if he doesn't get full marks in his spelling test to earn £2 to spend in the shop on the way home. I've seen '£1 for every goal' and other incentives too. I don't see any of them working harder, just more pressure and sad when they don't achieve it. If they've worked hard but failed anyway it seems particularly cruel.

PRIMARY AGE?! 😳😳😳

Beexxxx · 08/09/2023 13:32

sure whatever maybe you’re just far superior and you and your kids frontal lobes come out fully formed and ready to go from birth. I wasn’t saying to treat them like toddlers but expecting them to act like fully formed adults and make fully formed adult choices while their decision making equipment is still in development isn’t fair. Plus it’s not like cash isn’t used as incentives in the adult world so let’s not hold kids to a higher standard than we hold ourselves.

Mummy08m · 27/08/2023 17:33

electriclight · 27/08/2023 16:58

Some of the parents of the primary children I teach offer cash rewards. I think it's horrible. One little boy cries every week if he doesn't get full marks in his spelling test to earn £2 to spend in the shop on the way home. I've seen '£1 for every goal' and other incentives too. I don't see any of them working harder, just more pressure and sad when they don't achieve it. If they've worked hard but failed anyway it seems particularly cruel.

Wow that seems particularly harsh parenting...!

I'm sure the best way of learning spelling is just by tons of reading, anyway. Which is fun for the kid.

Anyway I maintain that the main problem is that it teaches kids that short term money-earning is the main goal.

Kids can earn £100 in just one weekend of neighbourhood odd jobs, why would they revise hours and hours to boost their GCSE grade?

It's a really bad message because it could drive kids to do cash in hand errands.

I had some friends in my teens who used to carry weed and cocaine across town for relatively tiny amounts of the drug or petty cash. I was so worried for them because if they'd got caught it would have affected the rest of their lives, amd all for £10 or whatever (I didn't grow up in the uk, but a place very strict on drugs).

Whereas if you teach kids the message: study hard and you'll have a more affluent life in the long term, that's a much better message.

electriclight · 27/08/2023 16:58

Some of the parents of the primary children I teach offer cash rewards. I think it's horrible. One little boy cries every week if he doesn't get full marks in his spelling test to earn £2 to spend in the shop on the way home. I've seen '£1 for every goal' and other incentives too. I don't see any of them working harder, just more pressure and sad when they don't achieve it. If they've worked hard but failed anyway it seems particularly cruel.

MrsRonaldWeasley · 27/08/2023 15:49

My DD has just done the equivalent of GCSE’s (we’re not in England). We tried to give her a reward but she looked at us like we were mad as to her the ‘reward’ is the grades that she got. This is just how her mind works - she’s very focused (and also very clever!) Our younger child is also very clever but not so focused (aka lazy 🤣) so we might need to add a bit of an incentive when it’s their turn to be sitting exams. It’s up to each individual what they do and is literally no one else’s business! Good luck to your DD this coming year OP 😊

notacooldad · 27/08/2023 14:57

Just because you can afford it and just because it might ‘work’ doesn’t mean it’s not damaging to their self-worth.
I disagree. I found it did my ds' feeling of self worth the world of good.
I said in an earlier post the ds was the class clown. When we have talked about it a few years after he finished school he realised that by being the joker was a deflection tactic and he wanted approval of his peers.

He enjoyed the carrot of the cash dangling in front of him and it spurred him on. He suprised himself at how well he could do and how far he could go when he put his mind to it.

It's only later, as he gained maturity, he appreciates education and learning without the need to be externally rewarded. However our dangling carrot made him get the grades he needed to get him into the career he wanted.
Every child and every family functions different and we did what we needed to do to support DS. Everyone else needs to do what works for them.

Sazzy6258 · 26/08/2023 23:26

Glorifried · 26/08/2023 17:37

How do you do this with siblings who were 'given' their grades due to covid? Would you / did you do this with them too?

This has been and gone get over it!

Chiswickgal · 26/08/2023 23:25

tiredmama23 · 25/08/2023 08:30

Exactly this

But GCSEs are what universities will look at when deciding whether to make an offer

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 22:56

Hopper123 · 26/08/2023 21:26

Our kids are tiny but me and my husband have already discussed that we'll do the same as you although no idea what the amounts will be. I see no problem in it. It's a good incentive, presumably parents want their children to get good results so they can go on to earn better and live lives with at least slightly less financial strain so what's the difference with this idea? Of course not every parent can afford to do it but most parents will offer some incentive even if not monetary surely? We have said we will be realistic about their academic ability and set the rewards accordingly I.e not push too much for grades that might be unrealistic but push enough to maybe just above what they are predicted so that they have a real chance of achieving it if they really work for it. Unfortunately we are now in the age of 'quiet quitters' and people used to working from home who just have to wiggle their mouse a bit every few minutes to show they are logged on rather than actually working (I have many many friends and family members who joke and gloat about the fact they do this) so the idea of hard work and reward (not only monetary but reward of achievement, success, praise and pride in oneself) being intertwined seems to be a strange notion to lots of people nowadays. I think drumming into them fairly young that they will only be genuinely rewarded through working hard and achieving the best they can themselves is a good thing.

No I don't think most parents give incentives for high grades. I think by the age of 16, most children do not need monetary awards for achieving as they are mature enough to realise that it will benefit them in the future. It would benefit your children if you focus making them realise that rather than what financial incentive you're going to give. Also hard work doesn't always mean high grades unfortunately.

BlueMarigold · 26/08/2023 22:49

We gave a pound a point. So £9 for a 9, £8 for an 8 etc. The money will be used to buy 6th form clothes.

For DD, the real motivation was that she needed certain grades to stay on for 6th form and do the A-levels she wanted to do. They are the school rules so not much we could do about that.

Casperroonie · 26/08/2023 22:37

One of my pupil's parents told me they'd said to her they'd give her £50 if she got a 4 at GCSE in my subject. She really struggled and I felt really worried for her in case she didn’t get her grade. I think i was more stressed than she was in the end because I felt so bad !!

The parents were lovely ppl BTW, maybe just didn't quite think this through and just wanted the best for her.

NewName122 · 26/08/2023 22:30

My relative promised mine £400 for every 9. I couldn't have afforded it. He didn't get any 9s though 🤣 he did end up with about £300 worth of gifts as rewards though.

PurpleHippo83 · 26/08/2023 21:35

My parents did the same for me back in 2000, think it was £25 for a C, £50 for a B, £100 for an A and £200? for an A - but they did the reverse for anything D or below so I had to pay them. Their reasoning was that I was bright and they didn’t want me to slack off in the subjects I didn’t prefer/value (GCSE Humanities I’m looking at you here) but they did badly out of it as that wasn’t my attitude and I ended up with 1 A*, 8 A’s and 2 B’s. They did say I had to save half of it though and I could have the other half to spend.
I would consider it with my kids in the future but it could be expensive as I have 4 rather than the 2 my parents had! Bit of an extra motivator when the revision becomes a bit boring!

Hopper123 · 26/08/2023 21:26

Our kids are tiny but me and my husband have already discussed that we'll do the same as you although no idea what the amounts will be. I see no problem in it. It's a good incentive, presumably parents want their children to get good results so they can go on to earn better and live lives with at least slightly less financial strain so what's the difference with this idea? Of course not every parent can afford to do it but most parents will offer some incentive even if not monetary surely? We have said we will be realistic about their academic ability and set the rewards accordingly I.e not push too much for grades that might be unrealistic but push enough to maybe just above what they are predicted so that they have a real chance of achieving it if they really work for it. Unfortunately we are now in the age of 'quiet quitters' and people used to working from home who just have to wiggle their mouse a bit every few minutes to show they are logged on rather than actually working (I have many many friends and family members who joke and gloat about the fact they do this) so the idea of hard work and reward (not only monetary but reward of achievement, success, praise and pride in oneself) being intertwined seems to be a strange notion to lots of people nowadays. I think drumming into them fairly young that they will only be genuinely rewarded through working hard and achieving the best they can themselves is a good thing.

notacooldad · 26/08/2023 21:16

Getting the grades is the reward. Giving money is just so crass and reeks of desperation
To be fair, we were when it came to Ds1. It was a solution to a temporary problem and got us over the bumpy hill.
However it worked and he is now an adult. His work have put him through his degree and he is planning on doing his masters.
He had no interest at doing further ed at 16. He got an apprenticeship and found d his place in the world.
Without an incentive I doubt he would have got any GCSE at all.
What doesn't work for some kids and families may work for others.
Ds is now highly ambitious and doing well on his field.
No regrets for giving him a financial perk.

Theborder · 26/08/2023 21:01

@Scarfweather

Exactly. Getting the grades is the reward. Giving money is just so crass and reeks of desperation. Kids pick up on that.

ScarletWitchM · 26/08/2023 20:55

Never needed to financially motivate my DD - getting the grades she needed for sixth form and uni was enough motivation. DS is starting y10 in sept and will be same for him. I can’t understand bribery to get better results myself

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 20:35

Caerulea · 26/08/2023 20:22

Depends on which type of school you went to & which area. You can compare the grade boundaries online between the years & see, quite clearly, this cohort has suffered vs other years. Eg, a friend's daughter failed her maths resit, but her score on 2019 boundaries would have seen her pass. As a result she can't continue her mechanics course at college.

The questions aren't exactly the same each year so grade boundaries don't tell you that much. The grade boundary might be higher but maybe the questions were easier. To get a true idea of how hard or easy it was this year compare the proportion of people who got each grade with pre pandemic years.

Caerulea · 26/08/2023 20:22

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 19:25

Grades were higher this year than 2019 though so either the pandemic didn't affect their learning or there was still some leniency compared with pre pandemic.

Depends on which type of school you went to & which area. You can compare the grade boundaries online between the years & see, quite clearly, this cohort has suffered vs other years. Eg, a friend's daughter failed her maths resit, but her score on 2019 boundaries would have seen her pass. As a result she can't continue her mechanics course at college.

ChiefAdjusterOfRubensShorts · 26/08/2023 19:35

We offered DS £50 for every Grade 4 or above, he needed to get a minimum of 4 Grade 4’s including Maths and English to get on his college course.

It worked like a charm and he passed all 9 at Grades 6 and 7.

If you can afford it then do it!

WomblingTree86 · 26/08/2023 19:25

Caerulea · 26/08/2023 17:25

Solidarity with you, fellow mum. Hope yours got what they needed (grateful mine did), they got really screwed over didn't they. Pre-pandemic expectations yet pandemic learning. What crap.

Grades were higher this year than 2019 though so either the pandemic didn't affect their learning or there was still some leniency compared with pre pandemic.

Namddf · 26/08/2023 18:05

I wanted to make it clear that the results didn’t matter to me, what mattered was how hard he tried……. I suppose I want my kids to know that they’re good enough to me. Always.

Absolutely this.

Just because you can afford it and just because it might ‘work’ doesn’t mean it’s not damaging to their self-worth.

People on this thread are missing the point spectacularly.

TeddybearBaby · 26/08/2023 18:01

It doesn’t sit well with me because I don’t believe that it’s good for a child to be judged by their parent/s on the basis of something that I class as superficial like a grade. My DS has just done his GCSE’s and I did give him a financial reward but that was before the results were in. We also booked a celebratory meal before the results were in because I wanted to make it clear that the results didn’t matter to me, what mattered was how hard he tried……. I suppose I want my kids to know that they’re good enough to me. Always.

What you’re suggesting has worked for my son’s friend though so there’s that side to it. I think you know your dd so trust your own judgement and don’t let anyone tell you what’s best for your your child, they’re all different after all!

Good luck, I’m glad I’m not doing it again for a couple of years 😂