Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I m right to give him notice aren't I?

77 replies

Lilly11a · 25/08/2023 04:18

I ve had someone employed since the new year for me .
Hours are 9-5.30pm with hour lunch - I m happy for people to go at 5 if work up to date .
I ve had issues with him with lateness and sickness which I had to give him a warning about at the beginning.
It has improved but he is still probably late once a week and sick a day a month ( which is now going through at ssp).
Work has picked up massively and I m having to do a lot of unpaid overtime to get something through, after which I do expect things will go back to normal.
He has had a bit more to do but has still been going at 5 - still fine with me if work is getting done .
I asked him to do something extra ,which he has done before , about 3.30pm that would have taken 10 mins .
He refused to do it and said his work load was too high .
After a 20 min somewhat circular conversation where I asked if his work load was high he wasn't staying till 530, it's that he doesn't like changing between tasks and the work can be done he just doesn't like doing it or the pace / the fact there is work all day .
It's also unfair that other people in different departments go earlier ( but anyone that works longer hours then him is nothing to do with him) and sitting at a desk 8 hours a day makes him ill.
After then discussing what happens if he gives notice and having a comment how can you monitor if I slack off - I ve had to say to him either give in your notice tomorrow or I ll give you notice.
I guess I m just frustrated that we almost seemed to be talking different languages and no doubt he would have gone home thinking how unfair it was .

OP posts:
MintJulia · 25/08/2023 04:38

Is this someone in a first job? Or someone who has been working for a while.?

If a teenager, I'd make it clear I expected them to work until 5.30 and I'd put them on a PIP. If they are an adult, I'd give a written warning and then get rid of them.

I had one like that recently. Despite wfh, she would not accept that she needed to be on-line by 9am. She'd normally start at about 9.30, and on the days we were in the office. she's stroll in at 11.

There are plenty of people who'd love regular work and a decent contract. Don't waste time and effort on someone who can't be bothered.

Whoknowswhatanymore · 25/08/2023 04:29

Have you had any formal meetings with him to discuss his conduct? Listened to his concerns/ reasons why he is acting in this way? Offered support, set targets or put an improvement plan in place? This would be the starting point and then his conduct can be monitored and measured against the targets/plan over a period of time, say three months for instance. If his conduct improves that’s great, if it doesn’t, then another meeting would be held to ascertain why. Then you could start a dismissal process - does the company have a policy in place for this kind of thing? It may be worth contacting ACAS or similar to seek further advice as last thing you would want is some claim against you.