Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a 4th attempt at breastfeeding?

66 replies

MrsPepperpotspickles · 24/08/2023 23:13

WIBU of me to have a 4th baby because I want a fourth go at breastfeeding?
DC1 - first time mum, didnt know what I was doing in regards to bf and was born during covid lockdowns so no support, gave up quickly and regretted it.
DC2 - baby born with health issues, milk allergy, tongue tie. I expressed milk for him for a short time but couldn’t commit to the pumping schedule long term.
DC3 - shoddy latch, tried all the tips and tricks to no avail. Bleeding nipples, baby throwing up blood after feeds, tried nipple shields but baby couldn’t work those out either. Was advised by health visitor to swap to FF for my own mental health 1 week in.

I love being a mum and I love my kids. I really want to do this but more so I can prove I can do it to myself at this point, but is it silly to try again for a 4th time? If we do have a fourth it will definitely be our last and my final chance to get it right.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ohthatsabitshit · 27/08/2023 18:20

fedupnow2 · 27/08/2023 04:01

3 in 3 years, crazy!!

Unnecessarily rude.

fedupnow2 · 27/08/2023 04:01

ginandtonicwithlimes · 26/08/2023 07:04

Give your body a break from all the childbirth!

3 in 3 years, crazy!!

Naominumbers · 27/08/2023 02:37

That's apart from the whole breastfeeding thing which is nuts.

Naominumbers · 27/08/2023 02:37

Maybe because your children are young, you still don't understand how expensive they're going to be. Four children is a huge financial commitment to make. Clothes, clubs, phones, gifts - everything times four as they grow up. I would only advise four children if you and your husband are in very well paid professional jobs or you are independently wealthy with an inheritance or something. I'm sorry but I think you would be mad otherwise. I have friends with four who are trying to keep their heads above water and are going under.

QueenFlamingo · 27/08/2023 01:25

Not a valid reason to have another baby. You already have 3 young children who need your focus. I can see why PPs on here are thinking "wtf" because your post literally sounds like you want a baby JUST to breastfeed. Never mind the face that it's a little human you'll be bringing up.
Wanting a 4th because you really want another with ages so close is fine, but not just for breastfeeding which may not be true but it is exactly what your OP implies.

Also, what if you did have another and couldn't BF this time for whatever reason? Would you consider a 5th to try again?

Playingintheshadow · 27/08/2023 00:08

Please don't have another baby to 'prove' you can breastfeed.

Three children are challenging enough as they grow up (mum of 3 breastfed children!)

Calistano · 26/08/2023 23:51

It's really not that important, to bring a whole person into the world so you can fulfill your dream of breastfeeding is really arrogant and quite frankly weird.

scoobysnaxx · 26/08/2023 23:46

"WIBU of me to have a 4th baby because I want a fourth go at breastfeeding?"

"I really want to do this but more so I can prove I can do it to myself at this point"

Sorry this is ridiculous.

To have another child just so you can prove to yourself that you can breastfeed? Really?

MrsPepperpotspickles · 26/08/2023 23:41

Jamtartforme · 26/08/2023 17:03

I understand how you feel. I’ve had 2 very medicalised deliveries with lots of intervention, I was determined my second would be as natural an experience as possible but some issues arose and I had to change my plans accordingly. I never got the pool birth that was supposed to be healing experience after my second. I briefly wondered whether a third would right this, but I’m not going ahead with it - firstly because I don’t actually want one. I just want the opportunity to do it ‘right’. But what if it doesn’t happen again? What if I have concerning scan results, and have to be induced again? I’ll kick myself. So I’m stopping now; making my peace with my labours is a much better solution than a third baby.

I also concentrate on what HAS gone well for me. I have 2 beautiful healthy children, not damaged from their births, my healing was relatively swift and I was lucky enough to conceive quickly. We can’t have everything can we?

That’s very true. I do feel very grateful thst I’ve had no problems fertility wise, healthy pregnancies, fairly straightforward labours and thankfully no birth trauma and of course now have 3 wonderful healthy children. Whilst I would have loved to breastfeed longer, I know I’m very lucky and extremely privaledged to have access to infant formula which kept my babies alive and growing.

OP posts:
Creepyrosemary · 26/08/2023 20:43

Summermeadowflowers · 26/08/2023 19:59

Yes I know that thanks. I have two children. The choice of wording was unfortunate at best. Couldn’t handle implied lack of committing or real desire to do it.

Well, that's how far my command of the English language goes. I'm happy to be more subtle in Dutch if you like to have the conversation in my own language.

Summermeadowflowers · 26/08/2023 19:59

Yes I know that thanks. I have two children. The choice of wording was unfortunate at best. Couldn’t handle implied lack of committing or real desire to do it.

Creepyrosemary · 26/08/2023 19:50

Summermeadowflowers · 26/08/2023 19:38

If you couldn't handle the pumping schedule or bleeding nipples or poor latch, then there is a high chance that you won't breastfeed the next

It was this that was extremely mean spirited. ‘Couldn’t handle it.’ I can’t get DD to latch on; she just cries and refuses the breast. So I couldn’t handle it? So much of the time people assume breastfeeding ‘failures’ are about the mother deciding she can’t continue: twice for me it’s been my babies, not me! And as for not handling a pumping schedule - ha. I’m expressing milk as I type this. It’s utterly gruelling and I sometimes don’t manage to keep up with it because my children need me:

There is a way to phrase things and ‘couldn’t handle m is deliberately unkind and provocative.

That doesn’t mean the OP is reasonable but none of us tend to be at our most reasonable a few weeks after having a baby!

The reason I said that is because I pumped for months before my kid finally latched on. I could handle that because I don't have other children. There is no way that I could have handled trying to get baby to latch, feed and then pump for next feed while also having other kids to take care of. It cost me 90 minutes out of every 3 hours at the time. That bit wasn't meant to be mean, but to be realistic. She has less time with each child. Do you really think it is reasonable or realistic for her to breastfeed baby nr 4 when she has no previous positive experience and child 1,2 and 3 need attention, diaper changes and food? I don't think so. Maybe when the other kids are older and she has more time for it.

Summermeadowflowers · 26/08/2023 19:38

If you couldn't handle the pumping schedule or bleeding nipples or poor latch, then there is a high chance that you won't breastfeed the next

It was this that was extremely mean spirited. ‘Couldn’t handle it.’ I can’t get DD to latch on; she just cries and refuses the breast. So I couldn’t handle it? So much of the time people assume breastfeeding ‘failures’ are about the mother deciding she can’t continue: twice for me it’s been my babies, not me! And as for not handling a pumping schedule - ha. I’m expressing milk as I type this. It’s utterly gruelling and I sometimes don’t manage to keep up with it because my children need me:

There is a way to phrase things and ‘couldn’t handle m is deliberately unkind and provocative.

That doesn’t mean the OP is reasonable but none of us tend to be at our most reasonable a few weeks after having a baby!

Jamtartforme · 26/08/2023 17:03

After my first that should say

Jamtartforme · 26/08/2023 17:03

MrsPepperpotspickles · 26/08/2023 16:54

I’m not sure if we will or won’t at this point. I only had a baby last month so its not exactly a decision that needs to be made right now, just is something I’ve thought about. Theres a few things we’d need to consider/figure out first but I’m being honest with myself and another chance to bf is on my list yes.

I understand how you feel. I’ve had 2 very medicalised deliveries with lots of intervention, I was determined my second would be as natural an experience as possible but some issues arose and I had to change my plans accordingly. I never got the pool birth that was supposed to be healing experience after my second. I briefly wondered whether a third would right this, but I’m not going ahead with it - firstly because I don’t actually want one. I just want the opportunity to do it ‘right’. But what if it doesn’t happen again? What if I have concerning scan results, and have to be induced again? I’ll kick myself. So I’m stopping now; making my peace with my labours is a much better solution than a third baby.

I also concentrate on what HAS gone well for me. I have 2 beautiful healthy children, not damaged from their births, my healing was relatively swift and I was lucky enough to conceive quickly. We can’t have everything can we?

MrsPepperpotspickles · 26/08/2023 16:54

FoodCentre · 26/08/2023 16:06

I never understood the point of these posts.

So I want a child (#4) so that you can challenge yourself or something. That's a silly reason.

But none of us will convince you otherwise. You'll have a baby. You may or may not be able to feed. You say that's not the reason you're doing it.

Why bother asking us? Will that change your thinking in any way?

I’m not sure if we will or won’t at this point. I only had a baby last month so its not exactly a decision that needs to be made right now, just is something I’ve thought about. Theres a few things we’d need to consider/figure out first but I’m being honest with myself and another chance to bf is on my list yes.

OP posts:
Gwlondon · 26/08/2023 16:36

Each attempt will get you closer to sorting it out. There are ways to get good information. Breastfeeding rates are low, so most people you speak to won’t have done it. That includes midwives. Doctors don’t really know. Best people to speak to are lactation consultants. If you can’t afford them then there are groups called “la leche league” I think. They have a good book. Or sometimes there are groups locally, council run for example. Even then don’t assume anyone you meet/ speak to actually had a good experience - I don’t mean to be harsh but unless you ask someone’s values they may actually be someone who isn’t breastfeeding friendly. My aunt was a breastfeeding support person, between her and a lactation consultant I got through my problems. But other people were not helpful! When your are in the middle of it you can’t tell who is giving you good information.

lactation consultants have to take exams and keep taking exams. But they cost. I understood what she was telling me and gave me a set of tools to help me for my particular problem. There are loads of things that can be a problem but there are always solutions. The difficult part is speaking to the right person who can tell you the solutions.

If you have 4th, you can do it, but start preparing when you are pregnant. The la leche book is called “the womanly art of breastfeeding”. It’s been in print for a long time hence the title is naff but the book is good. 1/3 of the book covers problems and solutions.

Shopper727 · 26/08/2023 16:36

I have 4, I breastfed 2 of the 4 loved it no guilt for ones I didn’t, tongue tie and nicu baby so didn’t work out but I wouldn’t have had one just to succeed in feeding them, being a good mum doesn’t equate to how I fed them tbh. Have another because you want a 4th it’s hard work having 4 and expensive. I get you want to feed yourself you’ve tried though and that’s great

Jamtartforme · 26/08/2023 16:30

There are no good reasons to have a baby. I can’t even really pinpoint my reasons if I’m honest! It’s all irrational. If you have the time and resources, do it, but I would wait a few years.

Goldcircle · 26/08/2023 16:26

Don’t do it.

Theoriginalmrscillianmurphy · 26/08/2023 16:24

I had my first child July 2006, my second June 2007 and my third Sept 2008.

Op, my advice is not to have another so close together as when they become teenagers you will be spread thin and the cost is astronomical.

WWYDIYWMRN · 26/08/2023 16:19

I get it. I also have 3 and followed a very similar pattern to you with mine, even down to DC2 having a tongue tie. I would have loved another go, but ultimately didn't want/couldn't afford a 4th child

Totallyterrific · 26/08/2023 16:07

Babies arent toys that you pop out just because you'd like the experience of bfing or vaginal birth or you fancy a new style of pram etc. You've got three who are Im sure gorgeous and adorable. Rejoice and enjoy the three wonders you already have.