Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP daughter is challenging

181 replies

Lakes11 · 24/08/2023 22:04

Most of mine and DP arguments stem from her DD. She's 11 so I know hormones are playing a role and some of her behaviour is normal pre teen. However we have been on holiday since Monday and her behaviour has been shocking and damn right rude!
First day we went shopping for the 4 of us. We went to pick ice creams for us, she saw some that she loves. Flew the door open to the freezer and said I don't care about anyone else I'm having these and put them in the basket.
I was shocked and I said to DP I thought we were choosing as a family. She said we'll I've promised for ages she could have some. I said we'll it's not fair for her DD to get them to herself and not for DS to have any. Then DD huffed and threw them back and said fine I won't have them. DP let her have them in the end. Apparently according to DP it was my fault for bringing the rude attention up at that point in front of the children.
All holiday DP, DD has said I want to do this, I want this. Never consults anyone. Tonight I had some crisps. I saw her staring at me eating them. Once I put them down she grabbed them and ate all the rest.
She's massively defiant and will ignore me and DP. She will ask me something and if I say no then I can hear her asking DP. I have confronted this and she will be like oh I forget or oh I didn't hear you.
Her DD has to be centre of attention. The loudest and screaming to get people to look. Whenever her mum is around she will be so sweet and polite but when she's not within earshot she's cheeky and rude to me. She thinks she's an adult and tries to include herself in adult decisions, if me and DP are talking she will constantly ask what we said. If I say nothing she will ask DP relentlessly. She sometimes says she gives us permission or will allow us to do this or that. I've told her we don't need permission from her.

I've just had enough. I feel DP enables this behaviour. She tells her off sometimes but let's things slip other times. I'd she's told off she will resort to crocodile tears to DP and a baby voice.
Tbh it's driving me crazy.
It's been ages since she's been this way. I thought all had settled with her. Things were like this about 6 months ago and I finally thought all was good and had built a good bond between me and Dsd but she's reverted back now.
I don't know what to do

OP posts:
LarryandLeon · 25/08/2023 12:26

I’m not sure why people are continuing to bother replying. OP clearly can’t be bothered to engage with the thread!

billy1966 · 25/08/2023 11:53

edwinbear · 25/08/2023 11:37

I can't get over the fact you begrudge her a pack of ice creams she's been promised for ages, whilst on holiday. Just buy two packs of ice creams. She sounds like a typical 11y old to me, but it's clear you really don't like her at all.

I agree with this.

She was promised the ice cream which is very different from the other behaviour.

knobkopf · 25/08/2023 11:48

I was shocked and I said to DP I thought we were choosing as a family. She said we'll I've promised for ages she could have some. I said we'll it's not fair for her DD to get them to herself and not for DS to have any

I don't understand this ice cream thing. You've posted later confirming that it was because you were buying a box for everyone to share.
I don't understand why DD would get them to herself and DS not have any?? Surely, even if she chose, everyone would share the box of ice creams.
And why not just buy a second box.

But I do think her behaviour in general is rude and there needs to be a serious discussion with DP - he needs to have strategies in place to manage her behaviour better and then you should support these strategies. But it's his place as her father to manage her behaviour - you shouldn't have to be coming up with ideas to deal with it.
She's acting up for some reason and he needs to get to the bottom of what is going on with her - anxious about a new school, feeling uncomfortable in the current family set up, some issue at her mums, struggling with puberty etc

edwinbear · 25/08/2023 11:37

I can't get over the fact you begrudge her a pack of ice creams she's been promised for ages, whilst on holiday. Just buy two packs of ice creams. She sounds like a typical 11y old to me, but it's clear you really don't like her at all.

Seaweed42 · 25/08/2023 11:31

How are things going for her in her Mum's house?
Is she starting a new school in a few weeks or something changes?

Sometimes that's a reason why a child seems to regress back to their babyish ways for a while.
Because they feel insecure, they become more controlling and seek more reassurance that their needs can be met.

That decisions that affect them won't be taken by someone else without their say so.

2weekstowait · 25/08/2023 11:24

Sounds fairly normal grumpy adolescent behaviour to me. It's not plain sailing that's for sure! How long have you been with your partner? Perhaps your partner is not used to accommodating other people in decisions she makes for her own daughter? Regarding ice creams - it's not unreasonable to decide as a family if you're buying a box, it's much cheaper obviously.

hdbs17 · 25/08/2023 11:22

You've left a lot of information out - is DS shared or just yours?

To be honest, at face value - it sounds like you're expecting her to bend to you rather than you also making an effort with her.

If she's staring at your crisps - offer her some? That's a friendly gesture from you.

The ice cream - I won't bang on but as others have said, perfectly normal for an excited 11 year old on holiday.

You need to lower your expectations, realise that a partners child isn't going to be easy on you and make the effort with her. It's possible that your partner is giving into their daughter because they feel you aren't making an equal effort into getting along with her but instead bring up her flaws.

LynetteScavo · 25/08/2023 11:18

It sounds like she doesn't know how to communicate with you politely and effectively- she's figured it out with her DM, but not test with you.

She wanted some crisps, but was nervous of asking, which is why she then grabbed them. Why didn't you offer her some crisps or put them in a bowl to share.

Why didn't you buy two types of ice cream? Or were you eating them immediately? I think it was Ok to let her have her choice this time, but she needed to be shown how to communicate that she really wanted those ice creams.

Raising children is a long game, they're not all born with beautiful manners and fabulous social skills.

billy1966 · 25/08/2023 11:17

However it is affecting the OP, male or female, their concern should be for their poor son who is caught in the middle of this, on holidays, far from home.

It sounds horribly stressful.
Obviously in a blended situation things can be a lot more complicated.

But parents bringing their children into this situation have an obligation to protect their own children.

The OP's son is collateral damage to this child and its parent and their challenging behaviour, which is obviously dominating the holiday.

The OP should be be primarily worried about their son and this stressful holiday they have been dragged on.

It's not working.

Poor boy. I really feel so sorry for children like this.

They come last, and don't they know it.

Vallmo47 · 25/08/2023 11:08

Your SD sounds infuriating OP, I feel for you. It is a difficult age like others have pointed out, young girls have a lot more going on hormone wise. That’s not an excuse, but it does explain it slightly. Parental guidance is very important at this stage and it sounds like you need to speak to your partner about her parenting because she should be nipping these naughty streaks in the bud. I’d have more issue with her attitude towards others than the ice cream choice itself, which is how I took your OP. It’s rude and entitled to just grab your favourite with no regard for others, her comment confirmed that.

mosiacmaker · 25/08/2023 11:06

She just sounds like she is 11. Try to approach her teenage years and hormonal behaviour with humour and compassion

Pollyputhekettleon · 25/08/2023 11:05

BillaBongGirl · 25/08/2023 10:56

But statistically 90% of users on MN are women so that sort of sweeps away the heteronormative stats of the rest of online.

The woman in this case also apparently has two children with two different parents, including seemingly one with the OP. That makes it much less likely that she's either bisexual or a lesbian. It's also much easier to follow comments if you can use he and she rather than neutral terms. Anyway, as I said, I'd do it just to annoy people who get annoyed about heteronormativity.

Winnipeggy · 25/08/2023 11:01

I understand if she's rude to you that must be really hard. Your DP needs to be on your side for this.

However...I would say pick your battles, the ice cream thing is a non issue, just get 2 packs of ice cream, why cause a fuss? The more attention you give to negative behaviour the more she will do it. She's at a super testing age and as you're not her mum she'll be ramping it up. Maybe take a step back, let more stuff go and let DP parent his child.

Pollyputhekettleon · 25/08/2023 11:00

Dogniss · 25/08/2023 10:51

11 yr olds might behave like this when they’ve been an only child for a long time and suddenly have to make room for a new partner and child on the scene.

11 yr olds might behave like this if their parents had a difficult break up and there’s now a new partner and child in the scene.

11 yr olds might behave like this if their step parent has been in their lives a long time and there’s a new sibling, and the step parent loves them more because they are their actual child.

The op has given minimal information.

There are so many reasons why an 11 yr old would behave like this, and the blended family situation seems the obvious reason. Particularly as the op used the ice cream situation (a complete non issue, and could be typical snapshot behaviour of any child at any age) as an example of bad behaviour.

Have a look in the step parenting topic. This is as old as the hills.

Sure. And in all that context, or without it, they're likely to behave like this if their mother:

'tells her off sometimes but let's things slip other times. I'd she's told off she will resort to crocodile tears to DP and a baby voice.'

That's also a really common way that parents react to a child who's upset by a family breakup/blended family situation. Yet there seem to be a deep-rooted reluctance here to even notice what he's said about the mother's parenting, let alone ascribe any responsibility for it to her. That makes no sense.

BillaBongGirl · 25/08/2023 10:56

Pollyputhekettleon · 25/08/2023 10:35

Because statistically most people who have a female partner are men. I also did it just to annoy the political correctness police.

But statistically 90% of users on MN are women so that sort of sweeps away the heteronormative stats of the rest of online.

Dogniss · 25/08/2023 10:51

11 yr olds might behave like this when they’ve been an only child for a long time and suddenly have to make room for a new partner and child on the scene.

11 yr olds might behave like this if their parents had a difficult break up and there’s now a new partner and child in the scene.

11 yr olds might behave like this if their step parent has been in their lives a long time and there’s a new sibling, and the step parent loves them more because they are their actual child.

The op has given minimal information.

There are so many reasons why an 11 yr old would behave like this, and the blended family situation seems the obvious reason. Particularly as the op used the ice cream situation (a complete non issue, and could be typical snapshot behaviour of any child at any age) as an example of bad behaviour.

Have a look in the step parenting topic. This is as old as the hills.

aSofaNearYou · 25/08/2023 10:49

She does sound very annoying, I feel for you. I don't think you were unreasonable about the ice cream, either, if the premise was that we were buying a family sized box, I would be having harsh words with my DC if they said "I don't care about anyone else" and I would not get the thing they wanted as a result. I totally get how much worse this behaviour feels when the parent doesn't say anything about it.

Does she live with you full time?

WeetabixTowels · 25/08/2023 10:48

OP my DD is 10 and oh my god the rudeness that has spring from nowhere from my formerly wonderful polite little girl has really riled me. So sulky and abrupt, and entitled sometimes. I’m half way between “it’s hormones, she’s showing signs of puberty, roll with it” and “nuh uh no way an I letting her talk to me like that”. Funnily enough, the worst she’s been was on our holiday recently to the point I sat crying with frustration one night. Anyway - you need to be a United front as these little cheeky bags of hormones will run rings round you given half the chance and they absolutely identify when you and your OH are not a United front. In other words - you have a DP problem. 11yo girls are gonna 11yo-girl their way through the next few months but you HAVE to nip it in the bud at times.

Pollyputhekettleon · 25/08/2023 10:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Yeah I think this is the most likely scenario. The mother feels guilty about the new relationship, the fact her daughter doesn't like the new partner, the way the previous one ended maybe, what sounds like a new stepsibling she could be jealous of, so tries to compensate by spoiling her. Common enough.

I would bet that the OP's communication skills also leave a lot to be desired, going by his post, which won't help.

Pollyputhekettleon · 25/08/2023 10:40

babbscrabbs · 25/08/2023 10:17

My 10 yo does all of these sometimes, except maybe 4 and 7 (but he is loud and cries when overwhelmed). He has ADHD. He's very impulsive. He wants to behave well but sometimes his impulses get the better of him.

Yes ADHD 11 year olds could be like this. But there's no suggestion this girl has ADHD or any similar problem, and most 11 year olds don't have ADHD. And of course a child can have ADHD and also be just badly behaved because of bad parenting.

KezzaMucklowe · 25/08/2023 10:38

Pollyputhekettleon · 25/08/2023 10:35

Because statistically most people who have a female partner are men. I also did it just to annoy the political correctness police.

Grin
Pollyputhekettleon · 25/08/2023 10:35

BillaBongGirl · 25/08/2023 10:05

Not sure why posters are assuming OP is a “he”. At any rate I’ve written my advice as equally applicable no matter the OP’s sex or gender.

Because statistically most people who have a female partner are men. I also did it just to annoy the political correctness police.

SayingwhatIreallythink · 25/08/2023 10:29

You were setting her up with the crisps. You knew she wanted some, and left them where she could just take them. When you saw her looking at them, why didn’t you offer some of her own?

KezzaMucklowe · 25/08/2023 10:25

babbscrabbs · 25/08/2023 10:19

Ok but who gets to choose then?

If DP had promised DD she could have them, it would have been better to say to everyone, "are these all ok for everyone?" Or buy two types. They'll get eaten anyway I should imagine.

Yes, this is what we do. Just buy more than one type of ice cream. My dc would certainly see this as normal thing to do. They'd be surprised if we went on holiday with another adult who had different ideas of what was going to happen when we are buying ice cream.

KezzaMucklowe · 25/08/2023 10:22

I think yabu.
As a pp said it's hard to get past the ice cream issue which is a non issue tbh. I know you're getting some for the family to share which is something we do if we are in a shop / supermarket but I can't see why you couldn't just let her choose ice cream she likes on holiday.

It's so hard to tell on MN on any thread as we only have what you say to go on but if your opinion of the ice cream situation is so biased then why wouldn't everything else be. Are you sure you're not just projecting a bit here.