Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DP daughter is challenging

181 replies

Lakes11 · 24/08/2023 22:04

Most of mine and DP arguments stem from her DD. She's 11 so I know hormones are playing a role and some of her behaviour is normal pre teen. However we have been on holiday since Monday and her behaviour has been shocking and damn right rude!
First day we went shopping for the 4 of us. We went to pick ice creams for us, she saw some that she loves. Flew the door open to the freezer and said I don't care about anyone else I'm having these and put them in the basket.
I was shocked and I said to DP I thought we were choosing as a family. She said we'll I've promised for ages she could have some. I said we'll it's not fair for her DD to get them to herself and not for DS to have any. Then DD huffed and threw them back and said fine I won't have them. DP let her have them in the end. Apparently according to DP it was my fault for bringing the rude attention up at that point in front of the children.
All holiday DP, DD has said I want to do this, I want this. Never consults anyone. Tonight I had some crisps. I saw her staring at me eating them. Once I put them down she grabbed them and ate all the rest.
She's massively defiant and will ignore me and DP. She will ask me something and if I say no then I can hear her asking DP. I have confronted this and she will be like oh I forget or oh I didn't hear you.
Her DD has to be centre of attention. The loudest and screaming to get people to look. Whenever her mum is around she will be so sweet and polite but when she's not within earshot she's cheeky and rude to me. She thinks she's an adult and tries to include herself in adult decisions, if me and DP are talking she will constantly ask what we said. If I say nothing she will ask DP relentlessly. She sometimes says she gives us permission or will allow us to do this or that. I've told her we don't need permission from her.

I've just had enough. I feel DP enables this behaviour. She tells her off sometimes but let's things slip other times. I'd she's told off she will resort to crocodile tears to DP and a baby voice.
Tbh it's driving me crazy.
It's been ages since she's been this way. I thought all had settled with her. Things were like this about 6 months ago and I finally thought all was good and had built a good bond between me and Dsd but she's reverted back now.
I don't know what to do

OP posts:
Sigmama · 26/08/2023 09:17

Poor kid, so her dad was never with her mum and was with someone else before you? her upbringing has not been the most stable, she's acting out, lean in to her rather than resist her and don't argue about icecream and crisps

Codependantnomore · 26/08/2023 09:16

Seriously the silly nitpicking over the ice cream, crisps and yearbook is absolutely pathetic. Break up OP because you seriously dislike this child. Your OH must be sick and tired on you jumping in every silly, normal thing she does.

YukoandHiro · 26/08/2023 09:12

Pollyputhekettleon · 24/08/2023 22:21

She sounds horrible. How long have you been together? Have you discussed this with your DP and what does she say?

"She sounds horrible"?!

No she doesn't. She sounds like a child on the verge of the teen years. Which she is.

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 09:11

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 26/08/2023 09:02

It's the kind of joke parents make. Are you not a parent? She's not literally saying that's the case, or if she does she wants committing as it literally can't be anyone's "world". It's like when people talk about people being the slave of their cat. It's a joke. Anyone who would take that seriously is way too uptight to survive parenting, a relationship, or life in general frankly.

It does sound like the SD's mum is a bit indulgent. She's an only child to a single mother who's father has never been a part of their family setup, I imagine they're very bonded and it's easy to spoil your child when you only have one of them - I know I did, simply because I had the resources of time and no competition so in most things DD could have her way with no harm done to anyone else. They'll be some adapting when entering a new family situation, she'll have to learn to share her mother, resources and (child level) decisions like which ice cream to have and it will take some adjustment. That's normal!

However OP is the wrong person for the mum to be starting that process with as she so clearly dislikes the child. There's no affection there, and this there's no possibility of a family shaking down together.

It's kind of bizarre that in one paragraph you just know it was a joke and in the second you admit se sounds 'a bit indulgent' (nice understatement). You then explain exactly why the mother probably ended up spoiling her so badly. Do you even notice the problem with that?

And by the way, people often say things that are kind of joking and kind of not. Especially when it's something that's obviously been the subject of major rows between her and her partner, this is not some lighthearted subject in this family. People can admit things in a 'jokey' way that they otherwise would furiously deny. This mother knows she's spoiled her daughter.

OP actually sounds like he liked DSD previously, he says they got along well. It's perfectly fine though to dislike a child who, as you admit, has been spoiled. I'm sure she's not horribly behaved all the time, there's a decent little human in there underneath it all, and he knows her behaviour is the result of her mother's parenting, so it's most likely he has mixed feelings about her. It would be good for DSD if her mother took OP's parenting advice, whether they stay together or not.

Motherofacertainage · 26/08/2023 09:10

Dogniss · 25/08/2023 10:51

11 yr olds might behave like this when they’ve been an only child for a long time and suddenly have to make room for a new partner and child on the scene.

11 yr olds might behave like this if their parents had a difficult break up and there’s now a new partner and child in the scene.

11 yr olds might behave like this if their step parent has been in their lives a long time and there’s a new sibling, and the step parent loves them more because they are their actual child.

The op has given minimal information.

There are so many reasons why an 11 yr old would behave like this, and the blended family situation seems the obvious reason. Particularly as the op used the ice cream situation (a complete non issue, and could be typical snapshot behaviour of any child at any age) as an example of bad behaviour.

Have a look in the step parenting topic. This is as old as the hills.

Absolutely all of this! I think trying to understand why the 11 year old is behaving this way and working hard to build a good relationship with her is the best way to proceed. If it was your biological child you would work hard to get to the root cause of the behaviour and solve the issues. If you're not prepared to do that then the step parent relationship is doomed to failure.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 26/08/2023 09:02

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 08:51

'A few days ago, we were swimming and DP said to me its DSD world and we all just live in it.'

If you think this is normal or healthy parenting, it's no wonder you think it's typical for an 11 year old to behave like this. This DSD has a far bigger problem than OP, and that's her own useless mother.

It's the kind of joke parents make. Are you not a parent? She's not literally saying that's the case, or if she does she wants committing as it literally can't be anyone's "world". It's like when people talk about people being the slave of their cat. It's a joke. Anyone who would take that seriously is way too uptight to survive parenting, a relationship, or life in general frankly.

It does sound like the SD's mum is a bit indulgent. She's an only child to a single mother who's father has never been a part of their family setup, I imagine they're very bonded and it's easy to spoil your child when you only have one of them - I know I did, simply because I had the resources of time and no competition so in most things DD could have her way with no harm done to anyone else. They'll be some adapting when entering a new family situation, she'll have to learn to share her mother, resources and (child level) decisions like which ice cream to have and it will take some adjustment. That's normal!

However OP is the wrong person for the mum to be starting that process with as she so clearly dislikes the child. There's no affection there, and this there's no possibility of a family shaking down together.

JMSA · 26/08/2023 08:52

The ice-cream example you picked is ridiculous. Jesus, it's a box of ice-creams and she's on holiday. Just let her have them.
Your partner must constantly feel torn in the middle, especially as you don't seem to know how to pick your battles.
Honestly, this stuff is why I remain a single parent.

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 08:51

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 26/08/2023 08:46

OP you are getting down on a level with your SD. You are petty and nitpicking - seriously the follow up examples of the guestbook - who on EARTH cares if she writes in it twice or writes a lot? What had that got to do with what your own child put? - and your kids playing a game - you do know most kids want their own way when playing, and learning to negotiate that is part of what they learn whilst playing? - make you sound like you just hate her and are looking for anything to criticise her for. No wonder she is "earwigging" and wants to know what you're saying behind closed doors - she probably suspects, rightly, that you are slagging her off and trying to turn her mother against her. Because you are.

Seriously sounds like your relationship with her mother is shit too. So why not call it a day and get out of this child's life before your relentless dislike and negativity does her some real damage? She sounds exactly like a typically self-centred child in the middle of a difficult situation,being forced into family situations with an adult who dislikes her and takes every opportunity to find fault. I'd be acting up too.

'A few days ago, we were swimming and DP said to me its DSD world and we all just live in it.'

If you think this is normal or healthy parenting, it's no wonder you think it's typical for an 11 year old to behave like this. This DSD has a far bigger problem than OP, and that's her own useless mother.

determinedtomakethiswork · 26/08/2023 08:50

Your partner doesn't sound very nice at all actually. And yes, silent treatment is abusive. It's highly abusive when it goes on for a long time.

herewegoroundthebastardbush · 26/08/2023 08:46

OP you are getting down on a level with your SD. You are petty and nitpicking - seriously the follow up examples of the guestbook - who on EARTH cares if she writes in it twice or writes a lot? What had that got to do with what your own child put? - and your kids playing a game - you do know most kids want their own way when playing, and learning to negotiate that is part of what they learn whilst playing? - make you sound like you just hate her and are looking for anything to criticise her for. No wonder she is "earwigging" and wants to know what you're saying behind closed doors - she probably suspects, rightly, that you are slagging her off and trying to turn her mother against her. Because you are.

Seriously sounds like your relationship with her mother is shit too. So why not call it a day and get out of this child's life before your relentless dislike and negativity does her some real damage? She sounds exactly like a typically self-centred child in the middle of a difficult situation,being forced into family situations with an adult who dislikes her and takes every opportunity to find fault. I'd be acting up too.

ChristmasFluff · 26/08/2023 08:45

I couldn't be with someone whose parenting was so different to mine. And no way on this earth would I be with any one who did the silent treatment.

It's been 4 years - it's not going to get better and will probably get worse - you do need to end this relationship.

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 08:45

SunRainStorm · 26/08/2023 08:38

@Pollyputhekettleon

OP could be a woman, they haven't said. But you're right that DP is a woman.

I know. I had a conversation upthread about why I think OP is most likely a man and why comments are easier to follow if you do that. I also said I deliberately assumed so to annoy the political correctness police.

SunRainStorm · 26/08/2023 08:38

@Pollyputhekettleon

OP could be a woman, they haven't said. But you're right that DP is a woman.

Gatehouse77 · 26/08/2023 08:37

Sounds like your DP is confusing parenting with being her child’s friend and doesn’t want to upset her and deal with the consequences. If DSD knows that her mum will give in at some point then she’ll just keep going.

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 08:35

PixieLaLar · 26/08/2023 08:30

A few days ago, we were swimming and DP said to me its DSD world and we all just live in it.

Well that explains her bratty self entitled behaviour.

Absolutely. A normal parent of an 11 year old saying something like that would be admitting there's a big problem, but this one is instead getting defensive and attacking him when OP suggests this is not healthy. She sounds very unassertive, both in her relationship with OP and with her daughter, hence the passive aggressive silent treatment etc.

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 08:30

KajsaKavat · 26/08/2023 02:26

You don’t come across well here AT ALL, you say she was territorial about the crisps , I 100% believe you are the territorial one here.
shw is a child who wants her dad back and you are a jealous new gf, u really hope your bf realised that you are not good for his daughter and takes sensible steps.

You literally didn't even read the OP well enough to realize DP is a woman. Why should he pay any attention to your opinion?

PixieLaLar · 26/08/2023 08:30

A few days ago, we were swimming and DP said to me its DSD world and we all just live in it.

Well that explains her bratty self entitled behaviour.

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 08:25

Thanks for the update. It's great you don't share DS with her, you don't live together and you're not together that long. That makes it easier to break up, which is what you know you need to do. DSD is imitating her mother and it won't get better any time soon. This whole setup is bad for you but more importantly bad for your DS.

Pollyputhekettleon · 26/08/2023 08:17

BillaBongGirl · 25/08/2023 22:18

Nothing in the description to indicate anxiety and desire to know what was said except for asking her mum “relentlessly” until she gets a real answer that isn’t a rude brush off of “nothing”.

It’s you who are assuming that an 11yr old is manipulative and controlling when she’s literally a child in a difficult living situation created by the adults around her.

No, the only reason you are trying to interpret it as something other than manipulative and controlling is because you subscribe to a demented ideology that believes it's evil to think that children are capable of being motivated by that.

mum11970 · 26/08/2023 08:17

WtfHormones · 26/08/2023 07:23

Sorry but you're coming across self centred and unkind. She's a kid who presumably hasn't had a say in being on a blended holiday.

Get out of it. It’s purely bad, bratty behaviour that needs addressing. Very few kids get a say on who they go on holiday with. My grand kids have spent pretty much the whole summer holidaying with all manner of family set ups you could imagine and an organised holiday without that kind of behaviour.

mum11970 · 26/08/2023 07:51

It’s certainly not normal 11 year old behaviour that we’ve experienced with our kids and we’ve brought up 5. Unfortunately the spoilt child behaviour has been learnt from her mother and is only likely to get worse as she hits her teens if her mother carries on indulging it but, from what you’ve gone on to say, the apple doesn’t seem to have fallen far from the tree. I would be thinking long and hard whether to carry on with this relationship, as things may get even bumpier when high school and teenage years come in to play. Whatever you do, do not move in with your dp.

WtfHormones · 26/08/2023 07:23

Sorry but you're coming across self centred and unkind. She's a kid who presumably hasn't had a say in being on a blended holiday.

billy1966 · 26/08/2023 07:22

So you are in an abusive relationship and you are inflicting it on your son.

Your poor child.

Why are you allowing him to be exposed to this?

Summerwashout · 26/08/2023 07:20

Ragwort is right though op this situation isn't fair.

My dc play role play and one will say no your my servant!
I've heard dd friends say this to her she was ones dog all the time on a pretend lead!

The ice cream thing is utter nonsense, children get excited by food and a child forgetton her self in the face of her favourite ice-cream on holiday... Big deal.

Re listening in she probably feels massively insecure in her life and doesn't wants to feel some type control by tyring to listen to what adults are saying.

Ultimate non of this sounds positive and I think you should reframe the whole thing perhaps just don't go into holidays with each other, keep your relationship away from there children.

Summerwashout · 26/08/2023 07:16

@Ragwort.. So what if she had? She's allowed too isn't she?
Sometimes mn gives completely different advice on many sides of one issue and if she has and doesn't want to discloses this surely that's her perogative?

I've been on mn a long time and seen similar gf /partner posts quibbling over nonsense.