Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to not know whether to believe private diagnosis of ASD 12 year old DD

33 replies

AlwaysConfuzzled · 24/08/2023 21:32

Multiple issues with DD but only over the last few years really apart from always being much quieter than older sister and somewhat unsociable or selective with friend choices, completely ignoring children she just didn’t like ( usually louder, immature ones much like her sister! )
Some eating issues pushed me to go for an assessment and primary school had no concerns as she’s a model student so said she would be waiting years
Its come back today as a yes and now I’m struggling to know how accurate it can actually be as they didn’t even meet her, just myself and a lot of written reports from myself; teacher and some input from DD.
Has anyone been in this position? Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
JanieEyre · 25/08/2023 08:21

AlwaysConfuzzled · 24/08/2023 22:16

They just don’t offer an in person meeting with the child as part of the assessment
They do offer therapy after however DD has refused this
She does meet lots of the female presentation criteria - it’s just odd to me to only see signs this late

Late diagnosis of girls is only too common.

KajsaKavat · 25/08/2023 07:54

AlwaysConfuzzled · 24/08/2023 22:16

They just don’t offer an in person meeting with the child as part of the assessment
They do offer therapy after however DD has refused this
She does meet lots of the female presentation criteria - it’s just odd to me to only see signs this late

I only realised my daughter was autistic when she started secondary or just before. She did well in school and her issues were social always not academic.

now that I look back I can see the signs were there with eye contact and loud noises.

Mumofsend · 25/08/2023 07:51

There is no way that assessment can be valid without meeting the child.

Sirzy · 25/08/2023 07:48

I would have serious questions about the validity of the diagnosis given it seems to have used a non standard assessment approach. I think when it comes to private diagnosis you do need to pick very carefully as standards will vary a lot.

personally I think my next step would be to use this as a working diagnosis, have a conversation with the school about what is needed to support her and then push for her to be referred for an nhs assessment.

Singleandproud · 25/08/2023 07:43

@Toptipsneeded a proper diagnosis has to be made by a team of different people, educational psychologist, speech and language therapist etc.
When DD was diagnosed I first had a screening interview for 1 hr to see if assessment was appropriate, I then had a 2 hour interview with an Ed psych going over her developmental history, we then spent the best part of a day at the clinic where she did the ADOS test in the morning and cognitive tests in the afternoon. They requested both myself and school to fill out forms, interestingly school hadn't picked up any signs at but do now as she tries to mask less. It cost £2500 the 50+ page report was incredibly thorough. Yours seems incredibly cheap and sounds more like an expensive screening than an actual diagnosis. The ADOS test and cognitive test can be done over teams but not to meet her at all is highly unusual, it's a bit different if they attempt to meet her but she won't engage or if she has very obvious signs but still to diagnose a lifelong disability without meeting is bizarre.

At the end of the day though, does it matter if your DD is autistic or not? If the adjustments that are put in place help her with whatever issues she was struggling with which caused you to reach out and go for an assessment in the first place.

Abbimae · 25/08/2023 07:31

Not a specific comment you your case but in schools these private diagnosis are rife. Teams diagnosis often, at best, often incorrect too.

kkneat · 25/08/2023 07:25

Is it a full assessment op or some kind of screening assessment? Your DD sounds very much like mine. I had no idea just thought she was quirky & needed me more than my other children, it was secondary school where it all fell apart. Was on CAHMS waiting list & we decided to go private as wanted to apply for an EHCP. I paid £2300 a few years ago & she met with the psychologist three times and with a paediatrician once and I also met with both. The whole process was fine over about 4 weeks

marcopront · 25/08/2023 04:41

@AlwaysConfuzzled

Its come back today as a yes and now I’m struggling to know how accurate it can actually be as they didn’t even meet her, just myself and a lot of written reports from myself; teacher and some input from DD.

What was the input from DD?

I don't understand why now you have the diagnosis you are querying them not meeting her when you must have known they wouldn't meet her when you set it all up.

Ponderingwindow · 25/08/2023 04:31

@AlwaysConfuzzled

i just described myself and my dd.

there is a particular type of female autism and you described enough traits that given the diagnosis it seemed likely.

for us at least, this particular type comes with some challenges, but overall feels like a net positive. Obviously I can’t speak for other girls and women.

Beetlebuggy · 25/08/2023 01:07

DD was told there were no concerns when all the paperwork was submitted for NHS ADHD/autism assessment. They never met her in person. She is anxious, self harms, struggles readfully with friendships, struggles with emotional regulation, follows rigid rules, perfectionist, doesn't understand sarcasm or a lot of jokes and a host of other issues. Has other health problems that are often comorbid with autism/ADHD. Has had issues from primary school.
But nope, no diagnosis, they are not interested in seeing her in person.

goong · 25/08/2023 00:57

I agree that the assessment sounds a little ropey having not met your DD however it could well be correct.

My DD2 has autism and is a model student, incredibly intelligent however she has such a limited diet, can't handle noise or certain textures, doesn't play with children her age etc. School didn't really have any concerns however I wasn't happy with them fobbing her off as being 'shy'. Autism is so different in girls compared to boys. Quite possible for her to be 'hiding' it for so long.

Ohthatsabitshit · 25/08/2023 00:56

I don’t believe for a minute anyone should or could diagnose a lifelong neurological disorder without meeting their patient.

SpaceRaiders · 25/08/2023 00:49

@Clymene £900 is incredibly cheap! Around here it’s £2800 and that’s cheap. Others I’ve looked at were £3600.

Op that sounds rather odd for them not to meet her, I know some providers carry out adult assessments online, but I’ve not come across the same for children. Dd’s haven’t had theirs yet but it’s taking place across 4 mornings. Two of which they’ll be attending.

Clymene · 25/08/2023 00:38

Singleandproud · 25/08/2023 00:07

In order to be diagnosed the signs have to be there from the early years, that's why they take the developmental history. You must have a good inkling that she was autistic to go down the private route, people don't tend to spend £2000+ for no reason.

DD was always quirky as a young child but those quirks didn't become an issue and start to impact her negatively until she started Secondary school which is a very normal time for children to start showing blatant signs as Primary school is safe and repetitive whereas high school is loud and less structured with greater demands and influx of hormones.

They charge £900

UsingChangeofName · 25/08/2023 00:29

Like everyone else says, it can't be an accurate or robust assessment if they haven't met her.
However - it is very, very normal for articulate, intelligent girls with autism to not be diagnosed until puberty, or much later in their teens.

Singleandproud · 25/08/2023 00:07

In order to be diagnosed the signs have to be there from the early years, that's why they take the developmental history. You must have a good inkling that she was autistic to go down the private route, people don't tend to spend £2000+ for no reason.

DD was always quirky as a young child but those quirks didn't become an issue and start to impact her negatively until she started Secondary school which is a very normal time for children to start showing blatant signs as Primary school is safe and repetitive whereas high school is loud and less structured with greater demands and influx of hormones.

BungleandGeorge · 24/08/2023 23:55

AlwaysConfuzzled · 24/08/2023 22:19

It does meet NICE guidelines - RTN the company was called

NICE say they need to do direct observation

AlwaysConfuzzled · 24/08/2023 23:21

That’s really interesting ponderingwindow as you’ve described her like you know her
She can’t walk to the local shop literally 2 mins from the house in case she gets kidnapped however also is incredibly bright and articulate and can’t understand how girls her age are so immature to have “ crushes “ which are likely to go precisely nowhere so are an utter waste of time and energy!

OP posts:
Ponderingwindow · 24/08/2023 22:33

Model student, avoids loud or immature children, food issues.

perhaps a bit disorganized or dis-regulated at home where she can relax? Deals with anxiety? In some ways seems young for her age and in others seems like talking to a 35 yo lawyer trapped in the body of a child?

Dogniss · 24/08/2023 22:24

DD’s NHS assessment took place online.
They didn’t complete an ADOS assessment as dd wasn’t engaging and they’d seen enough already.
She didn’t “meet” anyone in person.

Lindy2 · 24/08/2023 22:23

I'm really shocked they didn't meet her.

Did they at least do a Zoom or was it literally all paperwork?

Autism presents very differently in different people. She does have some traits from what you've listed.

What fo you hope to achieve from the diagnosis? Unfortunately, the reality is you can get a diagnosis but actual support from anywhere is generally very minimal.

Shinyandnew1 · 24/08/2023 22:22

I’m struggling to know how accurate it can actually be as they didn’t even meet her

What?!

How much did you pay for this ‘assessment’?

Splat92 · 24/08/2023 22:21

I think it's strange they didn't meet her but I also don't think it's odd that they didn't see signs until this late. I think that's fairly normal for a girl.

nimski · 24/08/2023 22:21

My daughter is Autistic, I can't believe any NICE compliant assessment can be done without meeting the child. We have a private assessment and it was very thorough, half a day of interaction with the child in various situations in addition to all the forms and parental interviews.

Dogniss · 24/08/2023 22:21

It doesn’t meet NICE guidelines if they didn’t meet her. Online assessments count though.