Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it actually me not them? Kids and screens

237 replies

Goforththenorth · 24/08/2023 17:44

Just got back from a lovely holiday at a family friendly hotel abroad. Exclusively British/Irish clientele.

I couldn’t believe the amount of device time I saw that didn’t include the airport/plane - tablets, phones and hand held consoles. All the time - poolside, at meal times, everywhere I turned there were kids plugged into devices, a lot of the time with headphones.

My DC are neurodivergent (one certainly, suspect the other is too) and when occupied on screens, they’re quiet and don’t bother us, so I can see the appeal (I watched a film in relative peace on the return flight because they were playing games on screens the whole time).

But…I couldn’t believe it. I purposely don’t take screens to meals out in the UK because, maybe especially because my DC are the way they are, I think it helps to teach them that sometimes they have to wait, a bit of patience. I always take colouring, stickers or books and magazines. My eldest with ADHD and DCD really struggles with sitting with zero to occupy him, I’d say it’s nigh on impossible. So it really does take a lot of energy to occupy him while he’s waiting for food to arrive in a restaurant without a screen. We only go to family friendly places. Can’t say if this helps as he’s not great at controlling the ants in his pants if we’re not there to help him control them. But knowing him, having a tablet at a meal once would be a slippery slope to having one every single time.

On holiday, it was an all inclusive buffet so there was none of that waiting for food - DC were in heaven able to get up and help themselves without waiting. Still everywhere I saw kids plugged into their screens whilst eating. Same at the pool, my DC love the water so are happy for a good while, but if they had the option of a tablet or console poolside there would’ve been a lot less pool time.

But seeing as we were in the minority, I’m wondering if it’s in fact me that is old fashioned, too strict with screens, and need to relax a bit? My DM was VERY strict. My DC get what I feel is a lot of screens at home, but I have to control it. I’m wondering if that’s a problem in itself, if I was more relaxed would they want it less in the end. They are definitely not super well behaved, so it’s not like I think I’m winning at parenting!

YANBU - it’s unusual for DC to be on screens so much on holiday

YABU - it’s you, you tech dinosaur, get with the times and relax about screens

OP posts:
Holidaystress11 · 26/08/2023 09:59

Scratch for the little ones. It's an app you can download and teaches them the beginnings and foundations of coding. ( I found this a few years ago and then to my delight, when they started school they started using it there too!) My 10 and 8 year old are now starting to learn to use python and have made calculators with it as a start. This isn't my doing. They spend time at the weekend with a friends son who's getting ready for uni and he teaches them. (Normal in our community, my kids will probably do the same with whatever skills they have when they are older)

And honestly it's just googling things yourself and finding things. Tech can be amazing. Just need to do a bit of research via the tech!

I can't remember up thread how old your dc was and I've typed this all out so can't go back without copying and pasting everything again.

If they do a project we use Google slides and they will make a PowerPoint. I'm quite good with tech but just through messing around with it!

My eldest now has a YouTube channel and he makes and edits videos and I have to approve them before posting. He's not got a huge following or anything but he's learning a lot of skills and improved his confidence. However, I realise this isn't ideal for kids and he is very sensible and I have to see everything and regularly check in on him.

They ofcourse play roblox and other things too but it doesn't have to be all bad!

Bbc bitesize was always good when I last looked at it. (It was a while ago)

Duo lingo for a language. Ideal for kids... and many more things

TaniaBania · 26/08/2023 09:42

I'm with you, op. I don't judge individual parents for allowing their children to use screens- after all, you never know someone else's circumstances- but I think as a society we've become far too reliant on screens both as a way of keeping children amused and for ourselves (she says, typing on a laptop). I'm pleased that my kids were little before reliance on phones and tablets became the norm as I'm sure I would have succumbed.

Goforththenorth · 26/08/2023 08:59

@Holidaystress11 we definitely got some judgement on the plane as my 5 year old played on a tablet for 2 hours solid and then when it was time to land and turn it off he cried!

The rest of your post is kind of what triggered this thread - tech is and will be such a huge part of our lives, and our kids’ future jobs. I wish I knew more about other things like what your kids do on them - more creative things. We have an iPad which my DC only play mindless games on, and then my 7 year old has a Switch, which can be a social thing too as he’s always asking for us to play with him on it. But again it’s just games, nothing creative. He doesn’t have Minecraft. I feel like I need to relax, expose them more and maybe ease off the restrictions. But have no idea how to approach that!

OP posts:
Ollifer · 26/08/2023 08:42

I do have a snigger to myself reading a couple of comments from those who don't yet have children. Until you have a child you have no clue what you'll come up against, I thought I'd have no screens at all till age 5 then only an hour a day or so. Unfortunately screens are addictive, and although I don't have iPads or tablets my child asks to watch the TV a lot. So I have to either battle constantly or sometimes give in, and make sure he's getting plenty of other stimulation and activity. It's really hard work when screens are just everywhere, everyone addicted to them even out and about in public.

Holidaystress11 · 26/08/2023 08:25

To be fair op you see a screen shot into many peoples lives. When you where on the plane and watched your film and your dc had a screen, someone may have seen you and then decided you do this all the time too and judge. But you don't! And even if you did, that's no one else's business..

Unfortunately screens are the way of the world now. Adults can't even regulate themselves at the best part so not sure what people are accepting from children.

I've embraced tech. My kids aren't glued to it all day and self regulate. But that's because they have been given options. They don't just watch YouTube. They make and edit videos, learning to code. Sometimes they do a little project and research and make a presentation etc.

Screens aren't the devil and aren't all bad. Don't stop them using then teach them how to self regulate!

Alwaysdecorating · 26/08/2023 08:23

Goforththenorth · 26/08/2023 07:49

Yes my ADHD DS struggles massively with sitting still (DCD doesn’t help) and also concentrating, as you can imagine due to his condition. So part of me does think, if he can do it, surely NT DC can?! Although, again, it’s hard work keeping control of him, so who am I really trying to please, I should just give him a screen 😅

Then you are wrong.

Your ds is one child. Ju at because something works for one ND child, doesn’t mean it must work for all NT children.

I have adhd. My ds is ND. In some ways he was actually a lot easier than his NT older sister.

I was easier to raise than my NT older brother on a lot of ways. Things that worked for me, did not work for dbro and vice versa.

Why not just parent hoe you feel is best for your kids and knock the judgment of others on the head.

voxnihili · 26/08/2023 08:12

I had the same thought on holiday too. I am fairly relaxed about screen time but on holiday the screens stay in the room. DD (5) is allowed it in the morning when she wakes up as playing might wake others and in the period of time between getting back from pool / beach and dinner.

DD is, as far as we know, NT and we still need activities to keep her occupied at dinner but we tend to take colouring or a small toy or game.

There is a time and place for screens - they are a god send on the plane when other options are limited. But I hate seeing kids shoved in front of them at times that should be for social interaction - these kids will never learn to interact appropriately if they’re not given the chance.

I work in a school where phones are completely banned. It’s lovely at lunchtime seeing teenagers actually sitting around talking to each other.

Alwaysdecorating · 26/08/2023 08:06

Bingbong2000 · 25/08/2023 09:12

Apologies if I came across as rude. I do think screens can contribute to bad behaviour and not being able to concentrate - just like eating food with lots of colours and additives. If it happens alot it could contribute to a diagnosis of ADHD (if borderline ) I would have thought?

This thread is dumpster fire.

and the cynical part of my brain think it was started for this reason.

The whole ‘well my kids is and and I engage with them so they don’t need screens’ is disingenuous. What works for one child, wether ND or NT, doesn’t work for all.

My ND ds self regulates with screens really well. I wouldn’t be going round telling other parents that because I managed to get ds to self regulate they should be able to do it with their kids and there shouldn’t be upset when screen time is over.

These threads always attract the ‘oh my child never gets screen time’ or ‘I would never do that because I am an interested parent’ let’s be honest, these threads are just for people to judge other parents.

Then comes shit like the above comment as though ADHD is misbehaviour. I mean Wtf?

Most people, I know, who do use screens when eating out do it for one reason. They are nervous about kids pissing people off. They want to go out, but they are worried their child being a child will annoy someone so go prepared and let the kids do what they want that will keep them quiet.

This thread is quite ableist. It’s really judgmental. And it’s jumped straight to ‘ohhh I would never be that bad of a parent’ .

SataumaMeddler · 26/08/2023 08:01

Goforththenorth · 24/08/2023 18:50

Those of you who are relaxed at home, do your DC self regulate?

I don’t believe mine would from past experience. If we say no to screen time at home, my eldest (ADHD and DCD) will play with Lego, read, play with/annoy younger DC. I’d be sad to change that if I gave him free access to screens as I know he’d choose that. But equally I wish I could be more relaxed as his ways definitely respond better to collaboration rather than control.

Yup. I've got ND DC who are great at self regulation although high school age now.
Was completely horrified at an extended family Christmas Dinner about two years ago when two of the small children (aged 2 and 4) had tablets put in front of them (NT, no issues). My DC with no filter did observe loudly 'that's so rude'

Goldbar · 26/08/2023 07:57

Goforththenorth · 26/08/2023 07:49

Yes my ADHD DS struggles massively with sitting still (DCD doesn’t help) and also concentrating, as you can imagine due to his condition. So part of me does think, if he can do it, surely NT DC can?! Although, again, it’s hard work keeping control of him, so who am I really trying to please, I should just give him a screen 😅

If that's one of the battles you choose to fight, then that's a choice you've made. Other people make different choices for their families. I have limited appetite for engaging an overtired 5yo in 'family time' at 8pm at night.

Sirzy · 26/08/2023 07:52

Goforththenorth · 26/08/2023 07:47

For everyone, though? For 98% of kids I saw? I’m not disregarding what you’re saying as my youngest has definite sensory issues and hated the smell of a lot of things on holiday. But I don’t think that was the reason here, the pool side wasn’t noisy, smelly or bustling. Neither was the snack bar - plenty of outdoor seating away from it all.

Who knows but really why do you care? It seems to be your only trying to make yourself seem a better parent by dragging others down.

people are on holiday and are doing what works for them. Stop judging others and focus on enjoy your own trip!

Goforththenorth · 26/08/2023 07:49

FrenchFancie · 26/08/2023 07:45

dd is 10 but we never took screens to restaurants when she was small. She has always been expected to sit still, we used to play games with her when she was small (I spy, the alphabet game, guess the my little pony, etc) but she didn’t have access to electronic games. We have a ‘ne screens at the table’ rule at home. I would never take a tablet to the swimming pool or beach! We lived abroad from when she was 3 to 10 and we never once took a tablet to the beach or swimming pool! I’m very confused by this idea!

she doesn’t have much screen time anyway - maybe half an hour of Minecraft ever other day. We don’t game as a family and try to limit our own screen time as well. She nearly always has her head in a book though.

i work in schools and kids ability to concentrate is very low, and I think getting lower, and I’m convinced it’s to do with the over use of screens (no scientific basis for this, just my own guesswork!)

Yes my ADHD DS struggles massively with sitting still (DCD doesn’t help) and also concentrating, as you can imagine due to his condition. So part of me does think, if he can do it, surely NT DC can?! Although, again, it’s hard work keeping control of him, so who am I really trying to please, I should just give him a screen 😅

OP posts:
Goforththenorth · 26/08/2023 07:47

Sirzy · 26/08/2023 07:39

Noisy bustling places, especially with the variety of smells that come from a buffet, can be sensory overload for many people and make the need to have a distraction more important

For everyone, though? For 98% of kids I saw? I’m not disregarding what you’re saying as my youngest has definite sensory issues and hated the smell of a lot of things on holiday. But I don’t think that was the reason here, the pool side wasn’t noisy, smelly or bustling. Neither was the snack bar - plenty of outdoor seating away from it all.

OP posts:
FrenchFancie · 26/08/2023 07:45

dd is 10 but we never took screens to restaurants when she was small. She has always been expected to sit still, we used to play games with her when she was small (I spy, the alphabet game, guess the my little pony, etc) but she didn’t have access to electronic games. We have a ‘ne screens at the table’ rule at home. I would never take a tablet to the swimming pool or beach! We lived abroad from when she was 3 to 10 and we never once took a tablet to the beach or swimming pool! I’m very confused by this idea!

she doesn’t have much screen time anyway - maybe half an hour of Minecraft ever other day. We don’t game as a family and try to limit our own screen time as well. She nearly always has her head in a book though.

i work in schools and kids ability to concentrate is very low, and I think getting lower, and I’m convinced it’s to do with the over use of screens (no scientific basis for this, just my own guesswork!)

MidnightOnceMore · 26/08/2023 07:41

Goforththenorth · 24/08/2023 18:09

DP and I totally addicted to our phones by the way, hate it. They were left in the safe a lot on holiday which meant not much use, was so much nicer to be able to give DC full attention as neither of us regulate use well.

Buy a lock box for home and do the same.

Screens are shit really. They make you miss out on your own life.

I think your screen approach with your kids is fine. Don't change your parenting because other people do things differently, it's your family.

Sirzy · 26/08/2023 07:39

Noisy bustling places, especially with the variety of smells that come from a buffet, can be sensory overload for many people and make the need to have a distraction more important

Goforththenorth · 26/08/2023 07:37

I would never, ever judge any parent for their DC having a public tantrum. I have been that parent many a time and endured judgy looks from others.

We went on holiday abroad last year too but not to an all inclusive and British guests were hugely in the minority. I didn’t notice much in the way of screens in places I didn’t expect - lots of posters saying they use iPads in the hotel room to relax or in a restaurant with a long wait. I wouldn’t be surprised to see screens here, what I was surprised about in terms of meals when we were away recently was the use at the all inclusive buffet, breakfast, the snack bar. All informal, noisy bustling places where it doesn’t matter if your child isn’t sitting and behaving; they’re up and down getting their own food anyway. And at the evening entertainment. And it wasn’t one or two families I’m talking about as that wouldn’t be surprising - what surprised me was that we were totally in the minority!

And like I’ve said PP, my DC are most certainly not impeccably behaved so rather than judging, I’m wondering if actually we need to get with the times and stop making rods for our backs based on what exactly - snobbery maybe like people have said upthread? I grew up with a very screen-strict DM and I can tell she has a little inward tut when my DC put the TV on straight after school to relax! So I fully accept I have a skewed perception of what’s “normal” - equally DP doesn’t and he was also really surprised about what we saw on holiday screen wise.

OP posts:
Goldbar · 25/08/2023 10:47

Jamtartforme · 25/08/2023 10:24

I sort of agree but I don’t think those ‘designated screen time’ slots should be times when human interaction is at the heart of the event, for example meals out. I can understand half an hour a week on a Saturday morning for an older child, but seeing a 2 year old on a tablet is just depressing.

People put human interaction at the heart of different events.

For us, eating out in the evening on holiday is mostly about getting everyone fed and then DH and I having a nice time out. It's usually past my DC's bedtime since everything happens later on holiday so DC is never going to be their sparkly best. Earlier in the day is better for family interaction.

And yes, I don't personally see how a tablet could be that beneficial for a 2yo and would prefer to avoid it but my DC is 5 so a bit different. That said, we'll have to change our approach somewhat when the little one gets a bit older, but all families have constantly evolving needs.

Ivyusername · 25/08/2023 10:31

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Jamtartforme · 25/08/2023 10:24

Goldbar · 25/08/2023 09:58

They're just copying the adults. Most adults I see are glued to their phones. I try to leave mine in another room at home when I'm playing with my DC so I'm not tempted to pick it up.

My DH is dreadful. I'll ask him to feed the baby and come down to find him checking work emails while the baby is trying to catch his attention. He's improved since I videoed one of their interactions and sent it to him together with that clip showing the effect that being ignored by their caregivers has on babies. Apparently he didn't even realise he was doing it.

I actually think this sort of usage and the insidious way it creeps into daily life is more harmful than scheduled screen time (whether over meals or not). If you promise your kids you're going to spend time as a family but are never fully engaged, then that's a problem. It's something I'm constantly fighting against with my DH. There's even a term for it now, "phubbing".

I sort of agree but I don’t think those ‘designated screen time’ slots should be times when human interaction is at the heart of the event, for example meals out. I can understand half an hour a week on a Saturday morning for an older child, but seeing a 2 year old on a tablet is just depressing.

crocsaremybf · 25/08/2023 10:17

Also from my last holiday abroad which was in a upmarket resort and what I've noticed was the normal folks engaging and playing with their kids all day and using screen time in the evenings but there were many family's presumably from southern European countries (they spoke Italian, Greek and Spanish passing by) that came with their nannies and despite that, the kids were still on their screens and then escorted back to their rooms with their nannies. During the day the kids were only on the beach after 4pm with their nannies and the parents wondering out of silent beach around that time.

Scaredycatttt · 25/08/2023 10:16

My kids usually get bored of screens after about 30 minutes anyway so they sort of self regulate. Unlike me and dp who definitely have full blown phone addictions. It's definitely not just a problem with kids. I also think some parents can't win, some small kids are incapable of sitting nicely at a table for a whole meal and that's fine and perfectly normal. If they aren't being judged for letting them play on a screen, they are being judged for letting them wander around.

SilverSpooooons · 25/08/2023 10:09

FWIW I feel very much the same as you OP. I have 2 ND (ADHD / ASD) children and we have never allowed screens at the dining table or on holiday (except very limited back in the room) but never in public. I want them to understand how to have a conversation, how to engage and interact with people. We play 'I spy' or similar games at the table if they're getting bored or colouring or sometimes a game - Dobble is great.

Personally, it does make me sad seeing screens in so many children's faces when being pushed along in strollers and in restaurants and trains. I DO get that there are some instances where they are helpful in calming a child down, etc. But I also think a lot of times it comes down to what's easiest for the parent and sometimes it's a screen - also because then it allows the parent to go on their own screen. I've seen it loads before. Not saying it's the case every time.

Ultimately I'm in charge of my own children and not other peoples, so despite what I say above I really don't judge those parents much UNLESS their child's screen is disturbing me and / or my family. I CANNOT stand it when children have the volume up and other people can hear it. Same with adults btw! Boggles my mind what selfish people think it's ok that they or their children don't need to use headphones so the rest of the people around them have to listen to video game & TV sounds and music.

I recently went out with my family to a very nice restaurant to celebrate a special occasion. Shortly after we were seated a couple and their 2-3 year old sat down. All looked fine. Child was fine. Then out pops the screen on the table with volume so loud we could hear it 3 tables down. So rude! For people saying they use it to keep the child from having a tantrum, please consider that the noise from a screen in a public place is just as disturbing as the tantrum itself and invest in some headphones!

crocsaremybf · 25/08/2023 10:00

We use screen time for restaurants as it's the only way he will sit. Usually in the uk our meal in a restaurant will last 60/90 mins max but on holiday we would like to sit longer or go to a bar area. He plays all day at the beach chasing waves and making sandcastles together. We take him to the hotels playground after meal time too to burn that last bit of energy before bed but during meals once he has finished, he wants to wonder off and gets extremely stressed (he has sensory issues). Never been a child that was interested In colouring or stickers hell I've done legos with him at the bloody restaurant and bar a few weeks ago on holiday. Holidays are for relaxing and I want to enjoy that cocktail too unless I take him back to the room. There's later bedtime, change of routine so a bit of sceentime so parents can stay out a little longer won't harm anyone. Of course in the UK he goes to preschool and then he has extra clubs so by the time we get home it's dinner and bath and story time and then bed. On the weekends we are out and a about so we barely use any screen time at home. What I notice on holiday especially from my own experience I only have time to take pictures on my phone let alone scroll through things.

Goldbar · 25/08/2023 09:58

Jamtartforme · 25/08/2023 09:33

Well, yes I do. Because those kids (who will end up impatient, emotionally unbalanced and hyperactive) will one day be adults churned out into society that we have to work with and live alongside.

They're just copying the adults. Most adults I see are glued to their phones. I try to leave mine in another room at home when I'm playing with my DC so I'm not tempted to pick it up.

My DH is dreadful. I'll ask him to feed the baby and come down to find him checking work emails while the baby is trying to catch his attention. He's improved since I videoed one of their interactions and sent it to him together with that clip showing the effect that being ignored by their caregivers has on babies. Apparently he didn't even realise he was doing it.

I actually think this sort of usage and the insidious way it creeps into daily life is more harmful than scheduled screen time (whether over meals or not). If you promise your kids you're going to spend time as a family but are never fully engaged, then that's a problem. It's something I'm constantly fighting against with my DH. There's even a term for it now, "phubbing".

Swipe left for the next trending thread