Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it actually me not them? Kids and screens

237 replies

Goforththenorth · 24/08/2023 17:44

Just got back from a lovely holiday at a family friendly hotel abroad. Exclusively British/Irish clientele.

I couldn’t believe the amount of device time I saw that didn’t include the airport/plane - tablets, phones and hand held consoles. All the time - poolside, at meal times, everywhere I turned there were kids plugged into devices, a lot of the time with headphones.

My DC are neurodivergent (one certainly, suspect the other is too) and when occupied on screens, they’re quiet and don’t bother us, so I can see the appeal (I watched a film in relative peace on the return flight because they were playing games on screens the whole time).

But…I couldn’t believe it. I purposely don’t take screens to meals out in the UK because, maybe especially because my DC are the way they are, I think it helps to teach them that sometimes they have to wait, a bit of patience. I always take colouring, stickers or books and magazines. My eldest with ADHD and DCD really struggles with sitting with zero to occupy him, I’d say it’s nigh on impossible. So it really does take a lot of energy to occupy him while he’s waiting for food to arrive in a restaurant without a screen. We only go to family friendly places. Can’t say if this helps as he’s not great at controlling the ants in his pants if we’re not there to help him control them. But knowing him, having a tablet at a meal once would be a slippery slope to having one every single time.

On holiday, it was an all inclusive buffet so there was none of that waiting for food - DC were in heaven able to get up and help themselves without waiting. Still everywhere I saw kids plugged into their screens whilst eating. Same at the pool, my DC love the water so are happy for a good while, but if they had the option of a tablet or console poolside there would’ve been a lot less pool time.

But seeing as we were in the minority, I’m wondering if it’s in fact me that is old fashioned, too strict with screens, and need to relax a bit? My DM was VERY strict. My DC get what I feel is a lot of screens at home, but I have to control it. I’m wondering if that’s a problem in itself, if I was more relaxed would they want it less in the end. They are definitely not super well behaved, so it’s not like I think I’m winning at parenting!

YANBU - it’s unusual for DC to be on screens so much on holiday

YABU - it’s you, you tech dinosaur, get with the times and relax about screens

OP posts:
Goldbar · 27/08/2023 11:48

Peamock · 27/08/2023 11:27

It's not all about you though is it. It's not the case for the majority of children, no one should judge individuals that's true as you don't know the circumstances, but making general observations isn't personal. It often is the case that children are given screens solely because its easier for the parents without their being underlying reasons beyond that. Which is fine as the parents choice, but not ideal for children.

But as this thread has shown, people all have different rules that suit their families. There have been a number of posts which say "YANBU, we only allow screens in X, Y and Z situation..." Trouble is, the range of situations cover most of the day!

I could come on here and say "YANBU, I only allow screens at the evening meal, but we do puzzles and sticker books on plane and train trips, my DC play together or with their toys in the hotel room and they're either in the kids club or we're doing activities for most of the day. But I heard the family in the room next to us letting their kids have tablets in the room all afternoon, the lazy arses..."

Meanwhile, they could be saying about us, "I can't believe they let their DC have a tablet at dinner, we only allow them for downtime in the hotel room".

In reality, their family's holiday schedule is none of our business.
Our family's holiday schedule is none of their business.
The holiday schedule of any family other than your own is none of your business.

We should all show consideration for each other (always headphones!) but it is unbecomingly arrogant to judge other families, who you don't even know, just because they do things differently from your family.

Hufflemuff · 27/08/2023 11:47

I think like most things... its all about individuals. If you notice your kids struggle with face to face conversations with people not in their household (and have no additional needs) then perhaps it is worth considering if they should have screen time outside the house. I think when some kids are plonked in front of devices in public it delays their social skills because they don't participate in conversations happening around them.

Sirzy · 27/08/2023 11:42

Children wandering around restaurants is dangerous.

people not wanting to hear your child complaining doesn’t make them intolerant it makes them human!

BalancingTree · 27/08/2023 11:37

Not unreasonable it’s horrifying to see. Especially the meals out. It’s totally unnecessary and I do not get the justification. Saying kids need it to regulate is frightening- kids get bored, overwhelmed, throw tantrums- it’s part of being a kid, it’s a parents job to help them navigate that and yes it’s bloody hard and takes years, a whole childhood!

society needs to more tolerant of little kids wandering around restaurants etc and being noisy, therefore parents will feel less embarrassed and under pressure to silence children’s exploring and learning and expose them to situations where they learn those skills. Little kids can’t be expected to behave like adults, but sticking an iPad in front of them to achieve silence robs them of the opportunity to work on those their skills.

not being judgemental- but call a spade a spade.

holidays and meals out with little kids are a nightmare, but you put the hard yards in and when they are a little bit older it becomes a joy.

Peamock · 27/08/2023 11:27

Sunshinebuttercupsrainbows · 27/08/2023 10:17

Hate threads like this.

I have a 6yo with autism and adhd. You’d see him with a screen in a restaurant and judge me for being an uninterested parent. But you won’t have seen the legal battles I’ve fought to get him an education, the hours of additional tutoring I personally give him each week to help him fly academically, the days out we spend together exploring with him being completely feral - pond dipping, wild swimming, tree climbing, hiking. Trips to the library and the hundreds of books he has in his bedroom, all of which we have read together.

But I’m an uninterested parent who is turning my child’s brain to mush because he has a screen in public.

Edited

It's not all about you though is it. It's not the case for the majority of children, no one should judge individuals that's true as you don't know the circumstances, but making general observations isn't personal. It often is the case that children are given screens solely because its easier for the parents without their being underlying reasons beyond that. Which is fine as the parents choice, but not ideal for children.

Danielle9891 · 27/08/2023 11:21

I mostly allow my daughter to play on my kindle fire when we are at an airport or at a restaurant until the food arrives then I put it away. She makes a bit of a mess colouring in with throwing pens (she's just gone 2). Also, the kindle is easier to just put in my bag instead of colouring pens and pages.

There's a few apps the helps her learn her colours and numbers ect.

I don't mind her playing for a bit when she's older as she'll probably use a tablet when she goes to school but I wouldn't want her to play all day on one.

ididntwanttodoit · 27/08/2023 10:22

It's not only children. I was at the cinema recently. Phones on throughout ads and trailers, only switched off when main attraction started. In the theatre. Phones on until curtain up. Phones on again during interval. At a concert. Phones on during performance - screens held high to record gig that person was only watching at secondhand via said screen! Even people with tablets held up, blocking view for those behind!

Sunshinebuttercupsrainbows · 27/08/2023 10:17

Hate threads like this.

I have a 6yo with autism and adhd. You’d see him with a screen in a restaurant and judge me for being an uninterested parent. But you won’t have seen the legal battles I’ve fought to get him an education, the hours of additional tutoring I personally give him each week to help him fly academically, the days out we spend together exploring with him being completely feral - pond dipping, wild swimming, tree climbing, hiking. Trips to the library and the hundreds of books he has in his bedroom, all of which we have read together.

But I’m an uninterested parent who is turning my child’s brain to mush because he has a screen in public.

Straightupmom · 27/08/2023 10:13

YANBU, however, everyone’s situations are different. We don’t have a support network at home, we are never able to go for a meal/date night on our own, so when we go on holiday we take the kids iPads to dinner for a few reasons: they are 3&4, they get VERY impatient and bored waiting to be served, however if we are at an all inclusive, we don’t give them until they have eaten, just to allow us to finish ours in relative peace, if we don’t they pretend to need the toilet and a whole host of other distractions because they’re bored of sitting at a table.

We also take them to the pool, but this is because our DS (4) has strawberry blonde hair and very pale skin. He burns so easily and can’t play in the pool all day or he burns, regardless of how much sunscreen we apply and he won’t keep a hat on. He likes to sit in the shade, and without the iPad, he’s just bored and complains he wants to go sit in the room… it’s definitely a balancing act. I’d prefer not to rely on them but unfortunately we do.

Goldbar · 27/08/2023 10:10

Peamock · 27/08/2023 10:04

And yet people often went on holidays, out for meals and the like without screens- its disingenuous to suggest otherwise. Parents would talk to their children, shock horror.

Not all parents in the past were busily entertaining their children with crosswords, puzzles and interesting conversation. Children quite often behaved because they were afraid not to.

Peamock · 27/08/2023 10:04

Goldbar · 27/08/2023 10:00

People often say 'well, we didn't need screens' or 'what did people do before screens?' But life is different to how it was in the past. Expectations are different.

My great-grandparents didn't entertain their children... they were farmers and their children were either at school or working on the farm at home, from as soon as they could toddle round.

My grandparents didn't entertain their children... they just pushed them out the door and told them not to come back until dinner. That was their equivalent of screens.

Our parents didn't entertain us. They'd talk to us sometimes, yes, but other times we were just told to go away and shouted at if we annoyed them.

Many of the parenting 'techniques' (if you can call them that) that made life easier for parents in the past are no longer acceptable. When you add into that increased work and life pressure, it's unsurprising that a lot of parents entertain their children with screens now and then.

And yet people often went on holidays, out for meals and the like without screens- its disingenuous to suggest otherwise. Parents would talk to their children, shock horror.

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 10:02

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

ActDottie · 27/08/2023 10:01

Keep doing what you’re doing. Screen time needs to be limited.

Canisaysomething · 27/08/2023 10:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Pedant.

Goldbar · 27/08/2023 10:00

People often say 'well, we didn't need screens' or 'what did people do before screens?' But life is different to how it was in the past. Expectations are different.

My great-grandparents didn't entertain their children... they were farmers and their children were either at school or working on the farm at home, from as soon as they could toddle round.

My grandparents didn't entertain their children... they just pushed them out the door and told them not to come back until dinner. That was their equivalent of screens.

Our parents didn't entertain us. They'd talk to us sometimes, yes, but other times we were just told to go away and shouted at if we annoyed them.

Many of the parenting 'techniques' (if you can call them that) that made life easier for parents in the past are no longer acceptable. When you add into that increased work and life pressure, it's unsurprising that a lot of parents entertain their children with screens now and then.

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 09:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Canisaysomething · 27/08/2023 09:52

Sirzy · 27/08/2023 09:43

But unless you’re sat watching them 24/7 then how can you judge on just that snapshot?

and even if they didn’t decide to spend their holiday that way what impact did it have on you? (Other than providing you something to feel superior about!)

This is a thread about people on holiday on screens and I've posted about people on holiday on screens. Of course it didn't have an impact on me. My post seems to have had an impact on you though!

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 09:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Peamock · 27/08/2023 09:47

I agree OP, it's sad and excessive use of screens do have an impact on children. God forbid they might have to talk to and entertain their children themselves rather than handing a tablet over.

Lucyboat · 27/08/2023 09:46

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

LorW · 27/08/2023 09:46

Im fairly relaxed about TV but have chosen not to go down the handheld screens route for my LG.

My SSs (6&8) have unlimited use of their tablets/gaming devices and they sit on them all day, don’t do anything else and they can’t cope for 10 mins without them and I don’t want that for mine. I know it’s a balance as don’t want her to miss out so hopefully will teach some regulation and have a nice balance once she’s older.

Lonicerax · 27/08/2023 09:45

Ther is also 24 hour tv which wasn’t the case until 2000s (I think)
Brain is constantly being bombarded with info - not the same if you read as you control speed.

Sirzy · 27/08/2023 09:43

Canisaysomething · 27/08/2023 09:39

Sure, I mean them camping next to us on their devices the whole time just happened to be a coincidence.

But unless you’re sat watching them 24/7 then how can you judge on just that snapshot?

and even if they didn’t decide to spend their holiday that way what impact did it have on you? (Other than providing you something to feel superior about!)

Sirzy · 27/08/2023 09:42

horseyhorsey17 · 27/08/2023 09:33

I agree with you OP. I don't think the use of screens as a way of keeping kids quiet is healthy or good for them. There's already evidence that suggests screens act on the brain in the way an addiction does, which can't be good. And they're really bad in terms of manners, because they effectively put people into their own world where they're not communicating externally - just rude at the dinner table.

Maybe I'm old fashioned but I have well mannered kids!

It’s odd but my son can use a tablet AND have manners! Strange concept I know but the two aren’t dependant on each other.

Canisaysomething · 27/08/2023 09:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines - previously banned poster.

Sure, I mean them camping next to us on their devices the whole time just happened to be a coincidence.