Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be a freedom project for men?

211 replies

Lilolilibet · 24/08/2023 16:59

I encouraged my friend (a bloke who is a victim of rather horrific domestic abuse) to do the freedom project. I knew there was a version for men.

On looking closer it turns out that the men's version is to help them curb their abusive behaviours. Doubtless much needed but where is the help for men who are also victims?

It is off putting to apply for help and discover an assumption that you're the perpetrator because you're not a woman. I fully understand it's men's fault that this is the way it works but it's hard on the men who are also victims. Shouldn't there be some acknowledgement of their position too?

OP posts:
AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/08/2023 18:21

Clymene · 24/08/2023 18:08

No one is saying that.

We are saying that domestic violence services and support for women were and are set up, run by and paid for by women.

There is nothing to stop men setting up equivalent services for men who are victims of DV.

The vast majority of victims of dv are women and the vast majority of perps are men. This isn't dismissive, it's a fact. It's understandable that limited services are directed to those most in need.

And your last line essentially is
"Fuck men, we need it more"
1/3 of KNOWN DV victims are men, men are also far less likely to speak up so it could be far more
That's significant and ANY victim is someone in need

Sayitaintso33 · 24/08/2023 18:20

5128gap · 24/08/2023 18:08

Well as the saying goes, with power comes responsibility. The group that has the greater power has the greater responsibility. Not to mention the greater means to bring about change.
As for caring, I care about many things but given I have finite time and resources I need to prioritise. I make no apology for placing the needs of one very much larger, more vulnerable and at higher risk group over another smaller, less vulnerable and at lower risk group.

Don't underestimate the power that white, middle-class British women have. Compared with most groups in the world they have so much power that no white, middle-class, British woman should ever be allowed to complain about anything.

To make it clear I don't know you and I am not suggesting you fall into any of those categories. I'm just making it clear that, in my opinion, white, middle-class British women along with any men that they batter shouldn't be permitted to complain about anything.

Nor should they keep their resources for themselves but they should give those resources to the much more vulnerable women who do not fall into their privileged categories - white, middle-class and British women.

Iamanisland · 24/08/2023 18:14

AuntieEsther · 24/08/2023 17:25

Domestic violence services for women were set up by women for women. Are you complaining that women haven't set up services for men?

In our local authority domestic abuse services are set up by people for people and serve men as well as women.

The Gateway programme has both women's and men's groups.

Baconisdelicious · 24/08/2023 18:13

As women we need to acknowledge that we can be abusive and harmful too. Rather than be dismissive

No one has been dismissive. Of course men experience abuse and absolutely, I imagine it’s a lonely, incredibly difficult place to be. I also imagine it is under reported and the real impact on society as a whole largely unknown. I have huge empathy and would support any man in finding a way out and achieving peace of mind, But why is do,es tic violence against men the fault of every other woman out there? Men have ruled over our society since time began. They made the rules. They are responsible for the majority of violent crime, much of it against women. They hold way more positions of power, whether that be in industry, education or local and national government. They are paid more. They have more freedoms including a pretty much free pass when it comes to financially supporting their children. They earn more with less qualifications and experience. They own more property, including vehicles, houses and commercial property. They are best placed to understand the specific and nuanced needs of men experiencing violence, they have the cash, the power and the influence to challenge social norms, to draft new legislation and to provide funding for projects and campaigns.

And yet you still insist that women should manage all of this for them? Why? I am not a man experiencing violence - there is no story for me to tell. I will listen to any man’s story and donate if persuaded the cause is worth my hard-earned cash. I will sign petitions, use resources to teach about violence in my professional role (teacher, including of pshe), join marches or other campaigns if moved to do so. What else do you expect of women?

ShineLikeA · 24/08/2023 18:12

5128gap · 24/08/2023 18:08

Well as the saying goes, with power comes responsibility. The group that has the greater power has the greater responsibility. Not to mention the greater means to bring about change.
As for caring, I care about many things but given I have finite time and resources I need to prioritise. I make no apology for placing the needs of one very much larger, more vulnerable and at higher risk group over another smaller, less vulnerable and at lower risk group.

Absolutely this.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/08/2023 18:11

Poudretteite · 24/08/2023 18:02

The reason why there's fewer and less well known services for men is evident in this thread. Because men aren't allowed to be victims.

Are you serious? No, it's because women are more often and more seriously affected by DV.

And because women need practical support with the common situation of leaving with no children and no money with their lives at risk.

Pick up any weekly 'real life' tabloid and there will be one or more stories of a woman killed by her partner.

Male victims should have whatever they need. But it's nowhere on the scale of violence against women.

Men often struggle MORE to leave DV situations with children because the mother is always favoured over the father and because women can pull the "Oh but I was so scared of him" card.

18 men were killed by a partner or ex partner compared to 60 women. 18 is nearly 1/3 of the number. Sure seems important and on a big but I bet the papers don't report it the same because it doesn't fit the view they need to hold.

Johnny Depp v Amber Heard springs to mind. Staggering evidence she was abusive to him. Papers still tried to make him the bad guy.

Mouldyfoodhelp · 24/08/2023 18:11

Clymene · 24/08/2023 18:08

No one is saying that.

We are saying that domestic violence services and support for women were and are set up, run by and paid for by women.

There is nothing to stop men setting up equivalent services for men who are victims of DV.

The vast majority of victims of dv are women and the vast majority of perps are men. This isn't dismissive, it's a fact. It's understandable that limited services are directed to those most in need.

I feel like things can be both dismissive and fact if its presented in certain ways.

5128gap · 24/08/2023 18:08

Sayitaintso33 · 24/08/2023 17:58

But if it isn't your responsibility to help men in need then it isn't men's responsibility to help women in need and that depresses me.

And i'm also worried that it is a short step from saying it is not my responsibility to saying and frankly I don't care about them.

Well as the saying goes, with power comes responsibility. The group that has the greater power has the greater responsibility. Not to mention the greater means to bring about change.
As for caring, I care about many things but given I have finite time and resources I need to prioritise. I make no apology for placing the needs of one very much larger, more vulnerable and at higher risk group over another smaller, less vulnerable and at lower risk group.

Clymene · 24/08/2023 18:08

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/08/2023 17:56

Honestly the dismissive attitude coming over is just showing the problem.
"Well women have it worse"
"We've had to fight for this"
"Men have the power anyway"

OP isn't saying women should set this up. She's saying there should be something.
The reason why there's fewer and less well known services for men is evident in this thread. Because men aren't allowed to be victims.

No one is saying that.

We are saying that domestic violence services and support for women were and are set up, run by and paid for by women.

There is nothing to stop men setting up equivalent services for men who are victims of DV.

The vast majority of victims of dv are women and the vast majority of perps are men. This isn't dismissive, it's a fact. It's understandable that limited services are directed to those most in need.

Poudretteite · 24/08/2023 18:02

The reason why there's fewer and less well known services for men is evident in this thread. Because men aren't allowed to be victims.

Are you serious? No, it's because women are more often and more seriously affected by DV.

And because women need practical support with the common situation of leaving with no children and no money with their lives at risk.

Pick up any weekly 'real life' tabloid and there will be one or more stories of a woman killed by her partner.

Male victims should have whatever they need. But it's nowhere on the scale of violence against women.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/08/2023 17:59

Chickenkeev · 24/08/2023 17:50

I am absolutely not saying (nor did i try to infer) that woman's DV info is better. But there are way more ads, as there needs to be, because volume. But there is no excuse to ignore male on male (assume we're talking about partner) violence. It's present and it's serious. But i suppose is enveloped in the general 'men' envelope and not the intimate relationship space. And the any 'general' men are violent ads are aimed solely at women ime experience.

Er Male DV victims can be victims of female on male violence

Jibbi · 24/08/2023 17:59

I can honestly say I've never seen anything regarding abuse towards men until I got away myself and sought help. I wouldn't expect women to organize this but there needs to be more awareness because there are abusive women who are dangerous.

Not only this, these types like mine are diminishing real cases of abuse against women by continuing abuse post separation and also lying.

Sayitaintso33 · 24/08/2023 17:58

5128gap · 24/08/2023 17:48

Yes its a shame. But I'm a woman so it's neither my responsibility or on my list of priorities.
Every service available for women has been hard won by women, and capacity still doesn't touch the sides of demand, so I'm well occupied with worrying about and trying to change that at the moment.
At the top of every institution in society men hold the power and the purse strings. If as a group they wanted these services they would have had them by now. Clearly they don't care about the minority amongst their number who do. So if the idea is that women should care on their behalf, well they'd better take a ticket and get in line.

But if it isn't your responsibility to help men in need then it isn't men's responsibility to help women in need and that depresses me.

And i'm also worried that it is a short step from saying it is not my responsibility to saying and frankly I don't care about them.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/08/2023 17:56

Honestly the dismissive attitude coming over is just showing the problem.
"Well women have it worse"
"We've had to fight for this"
"Men have the power anyway"

OP isn't saying women should set this up. She's saying there should be something.
The reason why there's fewer and less well known services for men is evident in this thread. Because men aren't allowed to be victims.

Chickenkeev · 24/08/2023 17:52

Chickenkeev · 24/08/2023 17:50

I am absolutely not saying (nor did i try to infer) that woman's DV info is better. But there are way more ads, as there needs to be, because volume. But there is no excuse to ignore male on male (assume we're talking about partner) violence. It's present and it's serious. But i suppose is enveloped in the general 'men' envelope and not the intimate relationship space. And the any 'general' men are violent ads are aimed solely at women ime experience.

Oh but Spatular, i am in Ireland so don't see too much english tv these days. We could definitely do with a bit of improvement.

Chickenkeev · 24/08/2023 17:50

Spatular · 24/08/2023 17:39

There are several national helplines for men who are victims of DV. I'm not sure what you think the government really does for women who are victims of DV either- the answer is...not much at all.

I am absolutely not saying (nor did i try to infer) that woman's DV info is better. But there are way more ads, as there needs to be, because volume. But there is no excuse to ignore male on male (assume we're talking about partner) violence. It's present and it's serious. But i suppose is enveloped in the general 'men' envelope and not the intimate relationship space. And the any 'general' men are violent ads are aimed solely at women ime experience.

FloydPepper · 24/08/2023 17:49

MrsTerryPratchett · 24/08/2023 17:46

How much money, time and expertise have you spent on setting these services up this year? How much lobbying, writing to male politicians and philanthropists?

Compared to how much time you spend on here telling women off? Which appears to be a full time job.

I've worked with male victims. Me and all my female colleagues. Didn't see you there in the trenches.

You know nothing about me

i was telling men off in my post. Not women

5128gap · 24/08/2023 17:48

Yes its a shame. But I'm a woman so it's neither my responsibility or on my list of priorities.
Every service available for women has been hard won by women, and capacity still doesn't touch the sides of demand, so I'm well occupied with worrying about and trying to change that at the moment.
At the top of every institution in society men hold the power and the purse strings. If as a group they wanted these services they would have had them by now. Clearly they don't care about the minority amongst their number who do. So if the idea is that women should care on their behalf, well they'd better take a ticket and get in line.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 24/08/2023 17:48

thedancingbear · 24/08/2023 17:32

How many men were killed by their abusive female partners last year? Zero? One?

The false equivalence drawn by the OP is ridiculous.

More than you'd think

And quite possibly more than are recorded. Because the women that killed them claimed self defence.

As women we need to acknowledge that we can be abusive and harmful too. Rather than be dismissive

Mouldyfoodhelp · 24/08/2023 17:47

Spatular · 24/08/2023 17:40

No one is having a pop at men who are abused.

Maybe not directly, but the majority of answers on a thread about a man seeking help for domestic violence are passive aggressive snarky comments about men or the victim himself setting up a charity to help men. This is neither helpful to OPs friend, nor would it be said to a woman who suffers domestic violence. What about all the women who suffered before the charities were set up? Presumably the posters feel that those victims were lazy and didn't deserve help as they hadn't set up the domestic violence help before that? Like it's so easy to sort out and anybody can do it

MrsTerryPratchett · 24/08/2023 17:46

FloydPepper · 24/08/2023 17:41

I think men haven’t set their own support up
properly for this as male victims are thought of as weak, not real men, should stand up for themselves, so the majority (?) of men feel they’re not worth supporting. Toxic masculinity.

How much money, time and expertise have you spent on setting these services up this year? How much lobbying, writing to male politicians and philanthropists?

Compared to how much time you spend on here telling women off? Which appears to be a full time job.

I've worked with male victims. Me and all my female colleagues. Didn't see you there in the trenches.

Jibbi · 24/08/2023 17:46

I've recently come out of one and there is support but in general other men don't understand or care and that's likely the reason. It doesn't happen to men kind of thing. I didn't even understand what it was until recently, I just took it all.

It's very similar behavior to abusive men, like identical in my case and I can relate to what women face. At the same time, not everyone obviously but a case of it must be your fault as your a man. I'm struggling to know who to trust these days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread