Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there should be a freedom project for men?

211 replies

Lilolilibet · 24/08/2023 16:59

I encouraged my friend (a bloke who is a victim of rather horrific domestic abuse) to do the freedom project. I knew there was a version for men.

On looking closer it turns out that the men's version is to help them curb their abusive behaviours. Doubtless much needed but where is the help for men who are also victims?

It is off putting to apply for help and discover an assumption that you're the perpetrator because you're not a woman. I fully understand it's men's fault that this is the way it works but it's hard on the men who are also victims. Shouldn't there be some acknowledgement of their position too?

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 25/08/2023 10:29

I think it's often overlooked that the vast majority of violence is perpetrated by men. Male violence is a huge problem in our society, whatever the sex of the victim, and it does seem that men tend to focus on the tiny % perpetrated by women. And yes, it is the responsibility of men to do something about it. Women can be allies and supporters, but it's men who have to say "No More."

And I do think that men would get support if they were public about providing services for male victims. Of course there will be some men and a few women who are arses about it. It's pretty unlikely that the refuge they build will be subject to arson attacks and police raids though. So there's that.

Brefugee · 25/08/2023 10:23

agree that a lot of men's issues are down to Toxic Masculinity - it is a problem for society.

(had a quick gander at a few of those orgs in the list by @CherryMaDeara they look pretty good. But as i expected some are under the Women's Aid and Refuge umbrella.)

5128gap · 25/08/2023 10:21

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 25/08/2023 10:02

Trying to say I'm wrong by continuing to prove my point 🤣

I've even provided statistics that show men are more likely to kill themselves because if DV, less likely to report it and that even then there's a significant number of male victims who do report and yet "women have to worry about it more"

DV is a massive issue for everyone. Women are a risk to men. Toxic masculinity is bad for everyone. We need to acknowledge this and do better. And not dismiss how we can harm men and perpetuate toxic masculine ideals ourselves by acting like women can't sometimes be physically abusive or acting like men's abuse is a minor problem

Oh and I bet if men did try and set up a network akin to that for women they wouldn't be lauded. They'd be mocked, mostly by other men, but there'd be a small subsect of women who'd accuse them of trying to "steal" women's thunder etc.

Men are more likely to kill themselves in general, for a number of reasons, some to do with socialisation of the different sexes, some to do with the reliability of the methods they typically choose to end their lives. Its an extremely complex area, and can't be casually thrown in out of context to support a claim of particular severity of DV against men.
Women as a class are not a risk to men and it doesn't matter how many times you say otherwise, you can't obliterate what we know. The hyperbole is self defeating as people will simply think, well I know that's not true, so why should I take any of it seriously?
If the aim is support for men then far better to frame a reasoned and proportionate argument around the issue and address it to those with the power to bring about change (other men). Which you are at liberty to do any time you choose.

Brefugee · 25/08/2023 10:18

add CALM to that list
and then one of the naysaysers can go and look and see who set them up. If it is exclusively men, i'll eat my hat.

Eleganz · 25/08/2023 10:18

We have a men's network at work which, as a member of the women's network, I do work with on certain topics. There are actually lots of men out there campaigning, fundraising and offering support for men who have suffered DV amongst many other issues. However, what seems to be clear is that they do not have access to the same official funding streams women's charities do (but they do get some and I know my local NHS trusts support a helpline for men experiencing abuse) and do experience a fair bit of prejudice and challenge about why such support for men should even exist.

I do think we, as women, need to challenge others who feel that men do not deserve any support or that these issues are not real or unimportant. Just as we are right to expect men to be supportive of improving the lives of women who are victims of abuse so should we do the same in return. Saying "it's not my problem" and "men should sort it out themselves" shows a level of indifference that we are rightly unhappy about when it is expressed by men towards women's issues.

Chickenkeev · 25/08/2023 10:18

FloydPepper · 25/08/2023 10:10

No it isn’t. Some posters are dismissive, effectively saying “help yourselves, it’s not my problem”, and a fair few are being sarcastic with that. But no, its been a different thread.

I do understand the people saying it’s not women’s jobs to help men. I think that view doesn’t separate the individual in need from the societal issues that make it hard for them to get help.

I didn't see anything here saying men shouldn't get help, or shouldn't have recources to do so. In the vast, vast majority of cases, men won't get help. They don't feel they need help. They think women should suck it up, and that there's something wrong with a woman who doesn't bend to their will. Again, it's a range of personalities etc but specifically talking about men here.

CherryMaDeara · 25/08/2023 10:15

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 25/08/2023 10:02

Trying to say I'm wrong by continuing to prove my point 🤣

I've even provided statistics that show men are more likely to kill themselves because if DV, less likely to report it and that even then there's a significant number of male victims who do report and yet "women have to worry about it more"

DV is a massive issue for everyone. Women are a risk to men. Toxic masculinity is bad for everyone. We need to acknowledge this and do better. And not dismiss how we can harm men and perpetuate toxic masculine ideals ourselves by acting like women can't sometimes be physically abusive or acting like men's abuse is a minor problem

Oh and I bet if men did try and set up a network akin to that for women they wouldn't be lauded. They'd be mocked, mostly by other men, but there'd be a small subsect of women who'd accuse them of trying to "steal" women's thunder etc.

Women are a risk to men

Bullshit. On the whole, men are a risk to women.

The large majority of defendants in domestic abuse-related prosecutions in the year ending March 2020 were recorded as male (92%) and the majority of the victims recorded as female (77%, compared with compared with 16% who were male). (ONS, 2020C). Women's Aid

Toxic masculinity is bad for everyone. We need to acknowledge this and do better.

This is not women's problem to solve. Men need to do better and get their house in order.

Your post is the same old male desire to blame women.

Oh and I bet if men did try and set up a network akin to that for women they wouldn't be lauded. They'd be mocked, mostly by other men, but there'd be a small subsect of women who'd accuse them of trying to "steal" women's thunder etc.

Men do have networks for men. A quick Google shows:

  • Mankind Initiative
  • Men's Advice Line
  • Men's Domestic Abuse Support
  • For Men
  • Refuge - Support for Men
  • Men's Aid
  • ADAM Project
  • End the Fear
  • Safer Places
  • Survivors UK
  • The Pankhurst Trust
  • Men's Advisory Project

Do you have any evidence that these services are mocked by women?

FloydPepper · 25/08/2023 10:10

CurlewKate · 25/08/2023 09:49

@FloydPepper I'm just wondering whether you feel your statement "Mumsnet has a blind spot when it comes to male victims of abuse. Posters tend to perpetuate the myths of them being somehow to blame and not really worthy of help"
still holds after reading this thread?

No it isn’t. Some posters are dismissive, effectively saying “help yourselves, it’s not my problem”, and a fair few are being sarcastic with that. But no, its been a different thread.

I do understand the people saying it’s not women’s jobs to help men. I think that view doesn’t separate the individual in need from the societal issues that make it hard for them to get help.

AnObserverInThisDarkWorld · 25/08/2023 10:02

Trying to say I'm wrong by continuing to prove my point 🤣

I've even provided statistics that show men are more likely to kill themselves because if DV, less likely to report it and that even then there's a significant number of male victims who do report and yet "women have to worry about it more"

DV is a massive issue for everyone. Women are a risk to men. Toxic masculinity is bad for everyone. We need to acknowledge this and do better. And not dismiss how we can harm men and perpetuate toxic masculine ideals ourselves by acting like women can't sometimes be physically abusive or acting like men's abuse is a minor problem

Oh and I bet if men did try and set up a network akin to that for women they wouldn't be lauded. They'd be mocked, mostly by other men, but there'd be a small subsect of women who'd accuse them of trying to "steal" women's thunder etc.

Brefugee · 25/08/2023 09:55

the major point is that if we say "men are..." the immediate response is NAMALT. Which is fair (but nobody ever says ALL MEN)

But if a woman is violent, say a husband is killed by a wife, then suddenly she is representative of all women and their is no bloody gainsaying that because it gets all "but what about da MENZ"

Yes, individuals can be absolute shits. But men as a class have more power and options on the whole than women as a class. So they should be quids in for fundraising and support, because men often support men because they're men rather than because they are good at what they're doing, and some women do that too.

OP - i hope your friend has found the pointers posted by pp useful and is getting some support

Fruitynutcase · 25/08/2023 09:51

The female equivalent to a Cocklodger is a FannyParker and I've seen plenty of those . Basically use a man financially and emotionally blackmail them then either kick them out or move on when they find someone " better " it works both ways .

Brefugee · 25/08/2023 09:50

so @FloydPepper is this thread indicative of MNs (it is not a homogenous blob, you know) hatred of men.

I think it is pretty representative of the members of MN's attitudes to men as a class: it recognises that they can be victims of DV and male violence, it recognises that DV is gendered and overwhelmingly detrimental to women, it recognises that men need DV resources, it recognises that men need MH resources, it recognises that individuals can be violent to their partners regardless of their or their partners' sex

What is it you want, exactly? for us to release a great wailing and gnashing of teeth that we haven't stepped up to provide mirror services to men?

CurlewKate · 25/08/2023 09:49

@FloydPepper I'm just wondering whether you feel your statement "Mumsnet has a blind spot when it comes to male victims of abuse. Posters tend to perpetuate the myths of them being somehow to blame and not really worthy of help"
still holds after reading this thread?

C8H10N4O2 · 25/08/2023 09:28

FloydPepper · 24/08/2023 17:39

Mumsnet has a blind spot when it comes to male victims of abuse. Posters tend to perpetuate the myths of them being somehow to blame and not really worthy of help

It doesn't. But we can always rely on you to pop along and tell us all how we are getting everything wrong about men.

C8H10N4O2 · 25/08/2023 09:26

Sayitaintso33 · 24/08/2023 17:20

In my opinion there is far less help for men. That might be because men are responsible for most of the trouble, but that doesn't help those men who are actually victims. And we know that many men won't help them they will just laugh at them.

What I don't like about your post is the dismissive implication that if they can't be bothered to set something up/advocate for themselves then that's on them and let them suffer.

Facts are better than opinions.

DV is an overwhelmingly gendered crime. Women die every week as a consequence.

Refuges and charities for male victims do exist. Its simply not true to say that they don't.

Some of the charities supporting male victims were founded largely by women.

Support work for men suffering DV is often provided by low paid women staffers.

I agree with @Clymene up thread "t's a shame that men put so little energy into supporting male victims of domestic violence"

OP: you question would be better placed on male dominated discussion groups (which would be most of them). Its not a question women can answer on their behalf.

Mumblesomething · 25/08/2023 09:20

The male domestic abuse network has a key resources page that may be helpful.

Key national resources

Lilolilibet · 25/08/2023 09:16

I hadn't thought of women providing this service. On reflection, the absence of any substantial counterpart to the freedom project does say something negative about men's failure to help each other. They do need something more than a helpline but of course they should be providing it to each other.

Obviously my friend doesn't have the expertise or resources to do anything about the lack of provision currently. If he did, he wouldn't be in need of it.

Thanks to those who have signposted further help.

OP posts:
Kingpin90 · 25/08/2023 09:09

Clymene · 24/08/2023 17:11

Yes I agree that it's a shame that men put so little energy into supporting male victims of domestic violence.

Agree

Naunet · 25/08/2023 09:00

CurlewKate · 25/08/2023 08:57

And if men chose to do this now there would be huge support for them. They'd be all over both MSM and SM. They'd be heroes. It would all happen in weeks. Which would be great, of course. They only have to do it. I'm happy to support men who actually do something.

Erin Pizzey was vilified and abused. Existed on less than a shoe string. The police took the side of the husbands of women she was trying to protect and shelter. Pubs banned them if they tried to go out for a drink. Social Services sided with their abusers. Great that it will be easier for men when they get going.

Exactly this, yet we’re meant to believe men don’t do these things because women aren’t supportive enough, like men ever fucking supported us, yet we still managed.

FourTeaFallOut · 25/08/2023 08:59

Absolutely. Men should set them up and get to helping.

Naunet · 25/08/2023 08:58

blatantly saying men will lie about being victims to escape justice when it's far more likely to be a woman who does that

Lovely. I guess you only take issue with sexism in one direction.

CurlewKate · 25/08/2023 08:57

And if men chose to do this now there would be huge support for them. They'd be all over both MSM and SM. They'd be heroes. It would all happen in weeks. Which would be great, of course. They only have to do it. I'm happy to support men who actually do something.

Erin Pizzey was vilified and abused. Existed on less than a shoe string. The police took the side of the husbands of women she was trying to protect and shelter. Pubs banned them if they tried to go out for a drink. Social Services sided with their abusers. Great that it will be easier for men when they get going.

Chickenkeev · 25/08/2023 08:30

Brefugee · 25/08/2023 08:19

I just want to be clear that i am not against anyone at all (men or women) setting up, funding (or begging for funding or fundraising) facilities for men who flee their homes due to DV.

And resources for men's mental health.
And to push men to go for prostrate cancer checks and all the other things.

My proviso is: they stop whining that the things aren't there. Sure women moaned about that and then... campaigned and raised funds to make things happen. And that they don't make a grab for the precarious funds and facilities that women already have.

👊👊👊

WeeWillyWinkie9 · 25/08/2023 08:22

Sayitaintso33 · 24/08/2023 17:25

And sod them if they don't. Let them suffer. Domestic violence isn't that bad anyway.

Could you send me a link to your fundraising campaign please, I'd like to contribute.

Brefugee · 25/08/2023 08:19

I just want to be clear that i am not against anyone at all (men or women) setting up, funding (or begging for funding or fundraising) facilities for men who flee their homes due to DV.

And resources for men's mental health.
And to push men to go for prostrate cancer checks and all the other things.

My proviso is: they stop whining that the things aren't there. Sure women moaned about that and then... campaigned and raised funds to make things happen. And that they don't make a grab for the precarious funds and facilities that women already have.

Swipe left for the next trending thread