Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What am I doing wrong? Not losing weight!

65 replies

loveabitofbluey · 24/08/2023 09:04

Started a diet three weeks ago. To give a bit of context before I started my lifestyle was ridiculously unhealthy. I ate whatever I wanted whenever I wanted, lots of chocolate, crisps etc. ate three meals a day, normally toast for breakfast, sandwich, crisps, some sort of choc for lunch and then pasta or something similar for dinner. We normally ate two takeaways a week if not more. I also drank almost a bottle of wine to myself each night. I know how bad this all is so I really want to turn my life around and make myself much healthier for the sake of my DC.

So three weeks ago I turned a corner. I stopped drinking completely (I had a couple of glasses the weekend of the first week but realised I didn't actually miss it much and haven't since then). I've started fasting which I'm actually enjoying, I start eating at about 11/12ish then finish eating at 5/6pm. That leaves me time to have two meals a day and one snack. This is usually eggs with fish or a salad and chicken for my first meal, a piece of fruit with a tablespoon of peanut butter for my snack and then a healthy meal for dinner. I've been measuring out all of my food and try to stick to 1200 calories a day. Sometimes this creeps up to 1300.

I've also started exercising, I go to the gym 4 times a week. I normally do 30 minutes HIIT training on the treadmill followed by 30 mins on the rowing machine. I'm going to swap my gym routine around a bit this week but I just started with these exercises as that's what I felt comfortable with.

When I started all of this I weighed 11 stone 12lbs. I weighed this morning and am only at 11st 9lbs. I've also started measuring myself and have lost 2cm around my waist but that's pretty much it. I really don't know where I'm going wrong! Anybody got any suggestions?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BashfulClam · 24/08/2023 23:06

When you lose loads at first it’s water and you can start losing lean muscle or, you want to burn fat not muscle as your metabolism will be affected and you will look better keeping your muscles toned.

HungryandIknowit · 24/08/2023 22:50

Sounds like you're doing brilliantly. It' fantastic that you stopped the wine. A suggestion would be to stay off the scales and reframe what you are trying to do. By making the changes you are making and sticking to them you will be fitter and stronger, and live a longer and healthier life.

Meadowlands · 24/08/2023 22:46

Well done OP, stick at it.
As someone who has been there, I can tell you that the rewards of losing weight not just physically, but mentally, are immense.

Iwantamarshmallowman · 24/08/2023 22:30

BarbaraV · 24/08/2023 09:21

Peanut butter is calorific. I would lose that if you can, no need to eat that. Just have the fruit.

it's full of protein and taste delicious.. there is every need.

Budgiegirlbob · 24/08/2023 17:55

Ihatexboxes · 24/08/2023 10:11

Your weight loss is sustainable and it sounds like you'll keep it off.

Whereas those fad diets - people just pile it back on!

I did Keto years ago and lost 2 stone. The moment I reintroduced carbs I'm back to where I started!!

Now I'm fasting like you (it's a long term strategy!) And I'm going out for my first run in ages later today. I'm scared 😬

I'm also 5ft ish and I fully understand that "need" to be 9stone ish. Drives me mad.

The thing with any diet is that if you just go back to eating how you did before, you’ll put the weight back on.

The trick is to find a way of eating that you can continue after you’ve lost the weight - easier said than done, I know! I haven’t managed it yet

Defiantjazz · 24/08/2023 17:09

A pound a week is the normal rate of loss tbh. Remember that if you lose the weight gradually there’s more chance of it staying off.

Femalefootyfan · 24/08/2023 15:50

@Hoolahoophop
The walks I do have helped enormously with the depression I used to suffer from, so much so, I’m no longer on meds.
I’m very lucky in that I don’t work so I have plenty of time to go out for a walk, that said, I’m usually out early morning and I find that really sets me up for the day and that actually helps with fatigue too, which sounds odd but it really does.
Trust me, I know I cheat on my calories some days and go over but to be honest, I didn’t in the very early days, it’s only now that I’m maintaining that I feel confident to do it.
Keep going, don’t lose heart, weight is coming off and slowly is the best way

boobies1234 · 24/08/2023 15:37

I think your calorie intake is too low tbh, especially if working out too!
I started my health journey a few months ago and have been really slow, but it's still goi g down.
Keep going but definitely look at calories around 1400 as a rule.

Hoolahoophop · 24/08/2023 15:29

@Femalefootyfan I do use My Fitness Pal alongside my Garmin tracker. But unfortunately I will count the calories, but not really care if I go over! I'm struggling with fatigue and maybe a bit of depression at the moment and think that the need to get energy, fuel is making it harder for me to stick to a limit.

Femalefootyfan · 24/08/2023 15:11

Hoolahoophop · 24/08/2023 15:05

That's amazing @Femalefootyfan wish I was dedicated enough to do this. I already run and walk everywhere......no matter how active I am its the diet part I struggle with!

I was really surprised at how easy I found it to calorie count, MFP really makes it easy as I can scan barcodes, I must admit I don’t always weigh everything, I sometimes do it by eye or scanning the barcodes can be easier if I’m sharing something with DH as I just halve the amount that I’m adding.
I only really find it a bit difficult when eating out as not everywhere adds the calorie amount and nutritional information, google is usually my friend and DH understands that I need to calorie count.

Hoolahoophop · 24/08/2023 15:05

That's amazing @Femalefootyfan wish I was dedicated enough to do this. I already run and walk everywhere......no matter how active I am its the diet part I struggle with!

Femalefootyfan · 24/08/2023 14:55

I started my weight loss journey a year ago needing to lose a minimum of 2 stone, at 5 feet nothing, I was nearly 11 stone with an obese BMI.
I started off at 1500 calories per day, walking up to a mile per day, gradually introduced workouts and increased the length of my walks. I lost a steady 1-2 lbs per week, calories were increased to 1600 after about 6/8 months and within the year I’d lost almost 3 stone and went from an almost size 14 to an 8. BMI is now around 21/22 at most.
I maintain at 1800 calories and have done for about 3 months.
I did a complete lifestyle change, lots of walking, calorie counting using MFP, although I do have a couple of days a month where I don’t calorie count, mentally, I still keep a rough tally and don’t eat foods I used to. I cut my alcohol consumption by about 2 thirds and eat much more healthily 90% of the time.

TheAOEAztec · 24/08/2023 14:17

10 per pound is like just over 20 per kg.
That sounfs ridiculously low unless one is bed bound tbh

Ecci · 24/08/2023 13:35

As a general rule of thumb you need 10 calories per pound of body weight to maintain. I'm currently 160 lbs so 1600 calories per day will keep me at that weight.

I think you're doing brilliantly. 1lb per week loss is perfect. A few years ago I was morbidly obese and decided to try losing 1lb per week for a year, did that and carried on until I'd lost 5 stones.
You will find that sometimes you don't lose anything in a week but stick with the plan. I had one whole month, sticking to the plan, weight stayed the same, I was on a great Mumsnet support thread and they kept me on track and after 4 weeks the weight started going down again.

I weighed myself every day and had a spreadsheet to show the overall downward trend, but lots of fluctuations for example if I have bacon, my weight goes up about 3lbs for a couple of days because the salt makes you retain more water.
You've made a great start. Keep at it, it's so worth it.

olderbutwiser · 24/08/2023 13:26

I’m 5’ 2” and have just lost a stone to bring me back down to 9 stone. It took me 14 weeks (had a week of holiday in that lot, and some big celebration events) and I’ve just checked, the first 3 weeks I lost about 4 lbs. Definitely slow and steady wins the day. I didn’t calorie count at all, but as an older shortie I know I need relatively few calories per day, even though I am pretty active. Ignore what others say about calorie needs and do what works for you - you need to balance short term weight loss with establishing long term sustainable eating habits. It’s very individual and not that easy.

19lottie82 · 24/08/2023 11:58

Use a weight loss and calorie counter. You put in your weight and height and it tells you how many calories you need to maintain, and how many you need to lose 1/2/3 pounds a week.

1200 is very low and unsustainable.

loveabitofbluey · 24/08/2023 11:53

@Beezknees @Menora that's amazing well done!
I think I'm just going to stay off the scales for a while. I took some pics in some clothes that were too tight at the start so I'm going to try them on again in a few weeks and hopefully see a bit of difference

OP posts:
Beezknees · 24/08/2023 11:51

Would be nice to keep this up for a weight loss thread. I started dieting (for want of a better word) a month ago today, 5'4 with a starting weight of 12st12lbs. Currently 12st7lbs. I'm pleased with it so far. I'd like to get to around 9st to feel comfortable.

Menora · 24/08/2023 11:40

Weight loss, real loss takes a while.

this is my weight loss on a graph over 3 months. I’ve spent loads of weeks losing nothing and then some losing more. It’s a long term trajectory downwards on a gradual slope. You can’t let it demoralise you this early on or you will fail, you have to keep going and then look back to see how far you have come. Stop weighing yourself for a while and just focus on feeling healthier

What am I doing wrong? Not losing weight!
loveabitofbluey · 24/08/2023 11:32

@Cookiedough123 yes I've been amazed by how many calories are in things. I've been weighing all my food every day and it's surprising how many extra calories it can add when weighed properly.

Thanks for all the other comments. Glad to hear it's usual to lose weight at this pace. And good luck to all of those that are trying as well. I can keep this thread up as a motivation/tips thread if anyone would want to join x

OP posts:
Cookiedough123 · 24/08/2023 11:30

Well done you’ve done amazing so far! I was also going to suggest looking up your TDEE! I have some days where I eat 1200 calories and some where I eat 1800 as long as I’m in a deficit overall that week then I’m happy with that! Make sure you’re using food scales and weigh everything. It’s amazing how many hidden calories there are in things such as sauces, cheeses, juice etc! For example I had a bread roll yesterday which when I scanned in MyFitnessPal it said 1 roll = 179 cal when I actually weighed it and did it by weight it was 245 cal! If you did this all day/week them extra calories would quickly add up! I’m also trying fasting which I haven’t done before but I’m enjoying it so far!

BarbaraV · 24/08/2023 11:14

Loving the peanut butter love Grin

Hoolahoophop · 24/08/2023 11:04

Sounds reasonable. You will probably find that 1500 is more sustainable long term. Particularly if that's your max (because research shows that the typically we underestimate calorie consumption) but allows you some treats or a little relaxation at weekends. Definitely monitor energy levels and listen to your body but sounds. Like you are doing brilliantly. Wish I were doing so well I'm currently in a binge mood while I wait for tests to see if there is a reason for a few health issues.

willWillSmithsmith · 24/08/2023 10:57

loveabitofbluey · 24/08/2023 09:10

Thanks both I just thought I would see a bit more loss than this. Makes me feel like I'm not doing something right.

I felt like you in the first month, it was just so slow. I’ve kept at it though and now three months later I have lost 11 kilos. There are some weeks I lose nearly a kilo and some weeks where my weight stays the same but it is coming off. Stick with it and that weight will come off.

Have the tip of using a piece of clothing that is too tight for you and once a month try it on and see if it’s getting looser. I have a pair of trousers I use. Couldn’t get the zip up at all, now the zip goes all the way up. I can see it’s still a bit too tight round the waist but I look forward to the day that it can be buttoned up with ease.

Peony654 · 24/08/2023 10:43

I think that's a good way to lose weight, more sustainable, and much healthier for you overall. Plus weight can vary anyway day to day. I'd focus more on how you feel, and how your clothes fit you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread