Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Toddler running indoors U or not?

153 replies

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 08:58

I live in a flat with downstairs neighbours. They are complaining about my (almost) 2 year old running indoors.

Do you think a toddler running indoors is unreasonable when you live in a flat, if so what can I do about it as we know toddlers lack impulse control and I can't leave him sitting in his play pen all day.

Any suggestions welcome

OP posts:
Coral569 · 24/08/2023 10:37

We live in a flat and have never allowed DS to run or jump around. We've always reminded him that people live below us. It's just how it is. Some noise is to be expected for sure and it does sound like your neighbours need to be a bit more reasonable. But I'd stop your child running around.

Timmytap18 · 24/08/2023 10:25

Where did you all get these toddlers that don't run in the house if they've been the park? 🤣

MolkosTeenageAngst · 24/08/2023 10:21

He sounds unreasonable, he cannot expect silence if he is living with another flat above him. It is not okay for him to be sending sweary, ranty voice notes. I would block him and tell him to direct all of his messages to your DP in future, or even better both of you block him and tell him to contact his landlord/ the council if he is concerned about noise levels. If all DS is doing is occasionally walking or even running across the floor and dropping toys etc then it is very unlikely that it will be seen as nuisance noise.

Normal, everyday noise is to be expected in a block of flats. On the other hand, rave music to 3am is not - this man is clearly unreasonable and expects complete silence which you are E ever going to be able to achieve and it is not realistic to try. Yes, you shouldn’t be encouraging DS to run around the house like it’s a playground and be jumping on/ off furniture etc, but some noise from footsteps is completely normal when you live below a flat and especially one with young children who are still learning to regulate. It is not realistic to expect you to stop all noise, seriously block the neighbour and tell him to complain using official routes (who are unlikely to find any problems if it is just normal household every day noise) - he is just trying to intimidate you.

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 10:06

I've just remembered something else. I had to install a new door threshhold plate between the living room and kitchen last week as it needed replacing and was hazardous.

I quickly took the old one up and installed the new one in 10 minutes max and he was thumping on my ceiling with something heavy for the duration. It was half past two in the afternoon.

OP posts:
EhrlicheFrau · 24/08/2023 10:05

Frabbits · 24/08/2023 10:00

A kid simply running around in their own home is not excessive noise.

Giving the kid a drum kit is excessive. The weight of a toddler moving about on a floor is not and never will be excessive.

While a small child/toddler running around the floors in a flat is fairly normal behaviour it definitely could potentially also generate excessive noise, depending on factors such as insulation, flooring type, how often they do it, if they are running or also jumping etc. I am probably more on OP's side than the neighbour, based on what she has told us, but as none of us are actually witnessing it we cannot be 100% certain either way. I do also think OP needs to keep a diary of events - when complaints are made, what is said, what she perceives her child to be doing just before the complaint etc. That way she can actually complain to the landlord about the neighbour if need be, or she has information to use if he complains about her. Give and take is always the way to go in these situations, but of course both parties need to do that.
@Onomatopoeiadoodle I've edited to tag you regarding the bit I've written regarding keep a record - you might need it at some point! Good luck. The extra info you have added further down makes me think he is more of an issue than your child, good luck!

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 10:03

There's no jumping off furniture or jumping on the floor or anything intentional like that, I would never allow that.

The noise truly is just walking/running, the occasional toy being dropped or DS tripping up (he has tibial torsion and intoeing so his balance isn't fantastic)

OP posts:
CyberCritical · 24/08/2023 10:01

A toddler running IS normal household noise.

If he was jumping on the bed all day, or jumping off the furniture loudly all day then that would be excessive, but a toddler moving around their house in a normal manner is not excessive. You can't reasonably expect a 2 yr old to tiptoe or moderate their steps.

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 10:01

urbanbuddha · 24/08/2023 09:57

If he has a funeral to go to that might explain his bad temper, but it doesn’t excuse it. Start logging your interactions so you can report to the landlord or the community police. He sounds like he could be trouble.

I think it's his character in general unfortunately.

I do feel for him if he has a funeral to go to and agree that probably does contribute to his stress levels at the minute.

I suspect he's got his own stuff going on and is fixating on us and making the problem bigger in his head than it is and taking it out on me.

OP posts:
Frabbits · 24/08/2023 10:00

EhrlicheFrau · 24/08/2023 09:59

The neighbour sounds horrible, however children are actually not allowed to run around and make so much noise that it disturbs other neighbours on a regular basis. You can call 'bllcks' as much as you like, but unfortunately there are rules regarding noise. As it is, none of us know whether OP's toddler is making extreme noise or not.

A kid simply running around in their own home is not excessive noise.

Giving the kid a drum kit is excessive. The weight of a toddler moving about on a floor is not and never will be excessive.

EhrlicheFrau · 24/08/2023 09:59

Frabbits · 24/08/2023 09:55

Bollocks. Children are allowed to run around in their own homes.

Grumpy fuckers keeping people awake at 3am with music especially don't get to moan about that.

The neighbour sounds horrible, however children are actually not allowed to run around and make so much noise that it disturbs other neighbours on a regular basis. You can call 'bllcks' as much as you like, but unfortunately there are rules regarding noise. As it is, none of us know whether OP's toddler is making extreme noise or not.

urbanbuddha · 24/08/2023 09:57

If he has a funeral to go to that might explain his bad temper, but it doesn’t excuse it. Start logging your interactions so you can report to the landlord or the community police. He sounds like he could be trouble.

NooNooTheNotSoGreat · 24/08/2023 09:57

Anyone who doesn’t have a toddler shouldn’t be commenting!!

That rules you out too then. You have a three year old not a toddler.

Frabbits · 24/08/2023 09:55

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 24/08/2023 09:51

To be clear I do think OP's neighbour sounds awful but I still don't agree that toddlers should just be allowed to run because it's "developmentally normal" or "just what toddlers do".

Bollocks. Children are allowed to run around in their own homes.

Grumpy fuckers keeping people awake at 3am with music especially don't get to moan about that.

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 09:55

Does anybody know of a file sharing site I can use to share voicenotes from WhatsApp? There's two totalling about 2-3 minutes of ranting

OP posts:
TravellingJack · 24/08/2023 09:54

Hmm, I'm not normally one to jump straight to 'police' but if he's being abusive, intimidating, threatening, on top of being a noise nuisance himself, then I'd phone 101 for advice.

A child running around, making normal amounts of child noise, even if you do shift work, is nothing like loud music at unsociable hours. I've had neighbours do both and never moved house because of children...

EhrlicheFrau · 24/08/2023 09:53

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 24/08/2023 09:51

To be clear I do think OP's neighbour sounds awful but I still don't agree that toddlers should just be allowed to run because it's "developmentally normal" or "just what toddlers do".

Yes, reading the other messages which OP has added regarding the neighbour, I agree with you.
As for those saying 'only those who have currently have toddlers can comment', nope, those have have been/are being bothered by noise and those who have had/have toddlers can comment, as well as anyone else who has something useful to say.

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 09:53

Gosh no he's not a pensioner no he's in his late twenties, very early 30's max.

OP posts:
Catsandbikes · 24/08/2023 09:52

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 09:47

How this exchange came about was he sent me a message on WhatsApp this morning before DS had even woken up saying there's just too much noise recently and am I still getting a carpet.

I replied and apologised and said yes I was but it costs substantially more than I was expecting at almost £1,000 so I can't afford to get it as soon as I'd hoped.

I explained that when he banged yesterday at 1pm it was to DS running from the living room to the kitchen and asked that he please be reasonable as he kept me up until almost 3am last week playing rave music.

He's now gone off on one ranting and swearing saying I shouldn't be comparing the two as that's not everyday whereas noise from us is. He's got a funeral to go to today so he isn't in the mood, swearing and blinding, then he said he doesn't "deal with women" so to tell DP that he'll be seeing him in a threatening way.

I assumed this was a pensioner! And he doesn't deal with women? Fuck that, I'd be buying the toddler a drum kit

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 24/08/2023 09:51

To be clear I do think OP's neighbour sounds awful but I still don't agree that toddlers should just be allowed to run because it's "developmentally normal" or "just what toddlers do".

Catsandbikes · 24/08/2023 09:51

Frabbits · 24/08/2023 09:46

Let's be real here, no toddler is constantly running around. OP says she takes him out and he will be sitting playing/napping etc. I'd bet my last penny that as soon as the kid dares to make the slightest bit of noise the neighbour is going full Meldrew.

Yep, this would be my take too! It's hard if you have neighbours who are in all day but it sounds like this guy is just being a nob. People make noise ffs

Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 09:49

Frabbits · 24/08/2023 09:46

Let's be real here, no toddler is constantly running around. OP says she takes him out and he will be sitting playing/napping etc. I'd bet my last penny that as soon as the kid dares to make the slightest bit of noise the neighbour is going full Meldrew.

Yes that's exactly right, even if DS drops a toy on the floor or trips over he's down there banging on the ceiling

OP posts:
Onomatopoeiadoodle · 24/08/2023 09:47

How this exchange came about was he sent me a message on WhatsApp this morning before DS had even woken up saying there's just too much noise recently and am I still getting a carpet.

I replied and apologised and said yes I was but it costs substantially more than I was expecting at almost £1,000 so I can't afford to get it as soon as I'd hoped.

I explained that when he banged yesterday at 1pm it was to DS running from the living room to the kitchen and asked that he please be reasonable as he kept me up until almost 3am last week playing rave music.

He's now gone off on one ranting and swearing saying I shouldn't be comparing the two as that's not everyday whereas noise from us is. He's got a funeral to go to today so he isn't in the mood, swearing and blinding, then he said he doesn't "deal with women" so to tell DP that he'll be seeing him in a threatening way.

OP posts:
Frabbits · 24/08/2023 09:46

EhrlicheFrau · 24/08/2023 09:20

They are not allowed to constantly disturb other neighbours though - there has to be compromise on both sides.

Let's be real here, no toddler is constantly running around. OP says she takes him out and he will be sitting playing/napping etc. I'd bet my last penny that as soon as the kid dares to make the slightest bit of noise the neighbour is going full Meldrew.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 24/08/2023 09:45

faban · 24/08/2023 09:38

@cinnamonfrenchtoast

Of course you can when it disrupts other people.

Don't be ridiculous. A toddler can run in his own house ffs! The neighbours will just have to deal with it. Absolutely normal toddler behaviour fgs

I don't agree, sorry 🤷‍♀️

Lots of behaviours are normal but that doesn't mean people should just have to put up with them regardless.

faban · 24/08/2023 09:42

Hollyppp · 24/08/2023 09:36

Anyone who doesn’t have a toddler shouldn’t be commenting!!

I have a 3 YO and between 1-2 YO he was an incredibly active little boy and I wouldn’t have been able to stop him moving around unless I put a strait jacket on him!! I agree children need to go to a park Once or twice a day to burn off energy. But once home you can’t just put them in front of the tv for hours to ensure ‘they don’t move around’ in their own home. This is unrealistic

Completely agree. It's really winding me up reading comments from people who have clearly never had a toddler or had them so long ago they've forgotten how active and crazy they are.

As for putting the kid in a playpen. My daughter would loose her head- I stopped using that ages ago. She knows she's being locked in and doesn't like it. I don't know any toddlers that would be okay with this 🙄