Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be upset all grandparent names have been used but mine?

234 replies

2408username · 24/08/2023 08:40

I get I might be massively unreasonable here and I just want to say that I have never said this to anyone and is just me seeing if my feelings are outrageous or most would feel the same way. I have changed my username as well by the way.

I have 3 lovely grandchildren all from my only child (my daughter). They are due their 4th and final and we are obviously all overjoyed and I love that we have a bigger family now as I was only able to have the 1.

They first had 2 boys and their first had DH's first name as a middle name, their 2nd had her husband's dad's, their 3rd was their first daughter and did give her DH's mum's name as the middle name. They are having a 2nd daughter and I must admit, I did think it would maybe be my name as her middle name. None of our names are outrageous or particularly old fashioned/bad in any way and I am very, very close to them all and the main person for childcare if and when they need.

My daughter told me the name they have decided on and the middle name is her DH's grandmother's name and she did specifically say to me that it would have been most fair/nice to use my name but she wanted them to all keep the middle names starting with J (all names do start with J and mine doesn't) both her and her husband's name also begin with J... the children don't have J first names just to clarify.

AIBU to be a bit upset by this?

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 24/08/2023 10:21

There’s nothing stopping them adding your name in addition to the J name. Plenty of people have 2 middle names.

SealHouse · 24/08/2023 10:20

Sasha19052 · 24/08/2023 09:38

YANBU, I would be upset too.

But more upset I think at realising what a shallow daughter I had.

One that would prefer my feelings to be overlooked/ hurt as long as the same alphabet letter was used.

This.

JudgeJ · 24/08/2023 10:19

PatchworkElmer · 24/08/2023 09:44

YANBU, I’d be gutted. Happy to call on your for childcare but acknowledging all grandparents but you with the children’s names? Prioritising a ridiculous ‘J’ rule over doing what your daughter clearly knows is the right thing? Awful.

Hopefully the OP will scale back on the childcare and let the favoured family do the majority.

Clefable · 24/08/2023 10:19

I think it's a bit off too. DD1 has DH's mum's name as a middle name as she died before we met, but there was never any question that if we had a a second DD, she would have my mum's name (and we did have a second DD, she has my mum's name as a middle name and my mum died a year after she was born, so I'm doubly glad we did it). I think if you're going to use family names at all, and I do really like family names rather than generic/random middle names with no meaning, then you have to be fair about it.

Hooplahooping · 24/08/2023 10:18

Haven’t read whole thread. But I wonder. Are you close to your daughter?

I’m pretty close to my lovely mum - and I would feel really strange using her name for one of my children. That’s her, my ma.

that was one of the reasons we chose not to use any family names actually!

YANBU - but I think it reflects well on you that you’re venting / discussing it elsewhere vs making it a big deal with your daughter. And you sound rationally hurt rather than bitter. It sucks to feel disappointed about family things. It’s an our choice how we manage that disappointment - A++ parenting.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 24/08/2023 10:18

BananaSpanner · 24/08/2023 09:22

I think your husband should have a quiet, non confrontational word with her just to let her know that you have found it a bit upsetting. You could do it yourself but could lead to awkwardness.

Although if they changed their minds only because of this then I suppose it would take the sentiment out of it anyway.

It’s sad that she chose a matching letter over including you in the grandparent honouring.

I tend to agree with this. I know I would if my DD hurt my DH'S feelings.
It's lovely to be so involved with your family, I have 3 DGC too but it might be the case because they know you're so amenable it's Oh Mum won't mind! You can be your own worse enemy really by acting OK with it. You're not and I wouldn't be either. I hope it's all resolved soon.

SecondhandSalute · 24/08/2023 10:17

Honestly I think the ‘naming after grandparents’ thing is pretty nearly as silly as the ‘matching J’ thing, and liable, in this case, to lead to far more hurt feelings and drama.

(This is reminding me of some HP YouTuber who does skits based on the series, and there’s a hilarious one of all the past Heads of Hogwarts portraits bragging about the next generation’s children being named after them, and poor McGonagle getting all excited when Harry and Ginny have a daughter she thinks might get Minerva as a middle name…

kweeble · 24/08/2023 10:16

Just be grateful for your lovely grandchildren. Names are very personal and if they really liked yours they’d have used it. You didn’t choose it yourself so try to take the offence out of it. At least your daughter tried to explain her reasoning even if it seems off to you.

2408username · 24/08/2023 10:16

To be fair I'm not sure it is a case of her husband deciding on 3/4 of the names and would more so be from DD wanting the matching I think. The first baby was always going to have the middle name being mine or my husband's name and I do wonder if my parent's had J names that would have maybe been used vs his grandmother's. She has always been allowed to have names she prefers as first names because son in law has always said she went through the birth and it's the least he can honour. He is a lovely man and I have nothing against him or think it was him pushing for more of his family names to be used over mine.

She has nothing diagnosed and is NT

OP posts:
MrsPositivity1 · 24/08/2023 10:16

You sound like an amazing mum and granny. Your daughter is so blessed to have you.

Dulra · 24/08/2023 10:15

That is upsetting tbh if I wasn't naming a child's middle name after a loved relative I don't think I'd bother with a middle name. I have 3 girls, eldest has middle name of me and dhs grandmother's who'd the same name, middle daughter has my mum's middle name and youngest my mil name. Your daughter most likely does not realise how this has upset you and is only thinking of her "pattern". Could the child have two middle names? My brother and Dad do

ChristmasCwtch · 24/08/2023 10:14

Focus on the children, not the genus of the names. Perhaps they don’t like your name. Nothing to be offended about as you didn’t choose it for yourself.

I like my dad’s name but it’s a bit blah, I like my mum’s name which is pretty, FIL’s name is strong but a bit old fashioned, I really dislike MIL’s name as it’s very old and probably hasn’t been used since the 50s. I like MIL and enjoy her company, but her name would be a dreadful burden for a child.

Whinge · 24/08/2023 10:12

Whitepaleness · 24/08/2023 10:10

I think you are being unreasonable. It doesn’t fit the pattern of the names she’s explained that.

But it does fit the pattern, as the only reason the others have the middle names is because they're the names of the other grandparents. The J is just an additonal quirk. If the names had started with different letters they would have still been used.

CoffeePlease1 · 24/08/2023 10:12

Why was her husband allowed to choose 3 of the 4 children's names? That's not fair. Your dd is the one who's putting her body and mind through yet another pregnancy, birth, post partum etc and her husband gets to choose all the names? Maybe this fourth child could have your name as her first middle name and then her husband's grandma's name as the second middle name.

YourNameGoesHere · 24/08/2023 10:12

Whitepaleness · 24/08/2023 10:10

I think you are being unreasonable. It doesn’t fit the pattern of the names she’s explained that.

The pattern nonsense is something she's made up though to try and minimise what a shit thing she's doing.The pattern was grandparent names not names beginning with the letter J.

Whitepaleness · 24/08/2023 10:10

I think you are being unreasonable. It doesn’t fit the pattern of the names she’s explained that.

2408username · 24/08/2023 10:10

There's even more J names going back in the family tree as well! Grin I'm not sure any of us saw how funny it was until our grandchildren came along. My grandparents had 2 J names between them! To be fair some are the same name especially the ones that cross over further back on son in law's family tree.

I'm not sure she takes me for granted me and her are so close and I love being apart of all their lives I wanted nothing more than a big family but could not have more than 1 child as was left infertile and as much as DD has always been rather career oriented (assumed she would maybe only want 1 as well) she completely changed her mind after having her first and I genuinely love it.

OP posts:
Whinge · 24/08/2023 10:09

NotQuiteHere · 24/08/2023 10:02

I find the whole idea of naming a baby in someone's honour utterly ridiculous.

And that's fine, but OPs daughter and her partner clearly don't. Or else they wouldn't have used the other 3 grandparents names.

YANBU OP, it's incredibly hurtful of her and I think taking a step back would be a good idea.

Viviennemary · 24/08/2023 10:09

Yes It's cheeky since they used all the names but yours. Big mistake under the circumstances.

willWillSmithsmith · 24/08/2023 10:08

I think you’re justified in being upset. I also hate when people have this thing about naming all their children with the same letter (or in this case middle name). Can’t they add yours in as well as the J name. Not a single person outside the parents will care or ever even know they all have J middle names.

mamamilkmachine · 24/08/2023 10:05

My daughters middle name is my mothers name. I told my mum that I wasn't giving my daughter a middle name, she was outraged, not because she thought her name should be used but because everyone should have an embarrassing middle name 😂 and then I took her the birth certificate round with her name as the middle name....not to get your hopes up but maybe she will surprise you.

NotQuiteHere · 24/08/2023 10:02

I find the whole idea of naming a baby in someone's honour utterly ridiculous.

NameChange080823 · 24/08/2023 10:02

I'd be very upset too. After your dd has registered the babys name, tell your dd that you hope the other gp's do their fair share of childcare. Don't do anymore childcare than the other grandparents are doing

Moccasin · 24/08/2023 10:01

I wonder if they could use two middle names: your name and their J name

M4J4 · 24/08/2023 10:00

it felt a bit hurtful especially when I do the most for them and feel the closest to them out of all the grandparents

I would be a lot less available for childcare from now on and also be less giving with money.

They are taking you for granted because you do so much.