Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be upset all grandparent names have been used but mine?

234 replies

2408username · 24/08/2023 08:40

I get I might be massively unreasonable here and I just want to say that I have never said this to anyone and is just me seeing if my feelings are outrageous or most would feel the same way. I have changed my username as well by the way.

I have 3 lovely grandchildren all from my only child (my daughter). They are due their 4th and final and we are obviously all overjoyed and I love that we have a bigger family now as I was only able to have the 1.

They first had 2 boys and their first had DH's first name as a middle name, their 2nd had her husband's dad's, their 3rd was their first daughter and did give her DH's mum's name as the middle name. They are having a 2nd daughter and I must admit, I did think it would maybe be my name as her middle name. None of our names are outrageous or particularly old fashioned/bad in any way and I am very, very close to them all and the main person for childcare if and when they need.

My daughter told me the name they have decided on and the middle name is her DH's grandmother's name and she did specifically say to me that it would have been most fair/nice to use my name but she wanted them to all keep the middle names starting with J (all names do start with J and mine doesn't) both her and her husband's name also begin with J... the children don't have J first names just to clarify.

AIBU to be a bit upset by this?

OP posts:
Saoirse82 · 24/08/2023 15:29

Mummypie21 · 24/08/2023 09:00

It looks like she's just used names from her husband's side of the family as middle names (more than naming after grandparents).

All the grandparents have been honoured except the OP. Her husbands name has been given as have the other two grandparents.

LuluBlakey1 · 24/08/2023 15:20

Thing is, had she said from the start of it all 'We're going to give any children we have a middle name beginning with J' you would have been prepared. Instead, she didn't say that and gave them the names of the other 3 grandparents which left you with an expectation. Or she could have chosen different J names than grandparent 's names. What she has done, even though it's not meant to be hurtful, feels not very kind towards you because she has chosen J names that are the names of the other 3 grandparents. I wouldn't get too upset or make a fuss but I wouldn't be able to forget it completely.

MirandaBlu · 24/08/2023 14:52

It's course up to them ultimately which names they use, but to me the use of family names and specifically the children's grandparents names is a MUCH more significant pattern for middle names than the initial J. Among my siblings' and my middle names we have three grandparents' first names and two significant family surnames. Since there's five of us, at least one person would have had an odd name out, but it's very obvious which grandparent's name wasn't used and there were good reasons for that (and he wasn't in our lives even though he was alive when all of us were born and named). Your family situation is obviously very different, but it still seems like the ommission would likely eventually be noticeable/noticed, at least among the children themselves.

On the other hand, I've JUST consciously realized from reading this thread that I have the same middle initial as one of my brothers (the other 3 are standalones); it genuinely never crossed my mind. It also seems that the specific Js used in your case are used BECAUSE they are grandparents' names - for example, if it's Jason-Jennifer-Joshua, it wasn't just as likely that it would be Jude-Juno-Jasper, or James-Julia-Jonathan.

That said, I don't really know how you would discuss it - if she brings it up again you could say something like "of COURSE I would have LOVED it if you'd chosen my name this time..." but they've already firmly decided on a J name and you do say you're hurt and they do change it, will that feel strange as well?

heatherheathe · 24/08/2023 13:40

I don't know why other posters are so against the "j" tradition, I have something similar in my family and think it's nice!
But you are absolutely not being unreasonable to be upset - using 3/4 grandparents names isn't fair. At the very least they should have used your name as well as the g-grans for the newest dd, so either 2 middle names or hyphenated. Middle names are so rarely said out loud it hardly matters even if they don't go very well.

The only way you were U is to have said you were okay with it when you werent!! That was the ideal opportunity to mention it! Would your dh or another family member be able to mention it to her if you feel uncomfortable - you can't insist on what she names her kid but there's no point in this building up into a resentment. At least if your dd is told the middle name thing is an issue for you and explained why the ball is in her court and it's up to her if she prefers her new "J name" tradition over acknowledging someone who helps her so much with the kids and cares so much for them.

Ive got no idea why posters make petty suggestions like you stop helping her out so much which are just are cutting off your nose to spite your face given that you enjoy seeing your grandkids, rather than just addressing an issue directly, like adults.

CheshireSplat · 24/08/2023 13:31

OP, can you change your name to the new J name ? Would be a bit of a hassle from a documentation, banking perspective but would be quite funny 🤣. Shame AprilFool's Day is so far away or it'd be a good one....

BreatheAndFocus · 24/08/2023 13:18

Just to add - could you gently ask her how she’d feel if she was the grandmother in this situation? Perhaps she knows in her heart is hurtful but told you so she could tell herself that you didn’t mind?

Personally, I’d talk to her privately and explain how you feel. Don’t do it in an accusing way. Do it in a sharing, ‘just wondering’ sort of way. Explain how you’re upset and left out. Explain that the sudden change of theme from GPs names to J names makes it more hurtful. Remind her that she said her 1st DC would have had your name if they’d been a girl. Try to get her to see your hurt logically. Maybe she’ll then go for two middle names, or just your name as a middle name and forget the J idea.

I’d also point out that she’s excluding her baby by making them the only one without a GP name and that that might upset them as they get older. “Who was I named after, Mummy?” “Oh no-one, dear. We just chose Jenny because it began with J and so fitted with your brothers and sister.” It sounds so silly.

hiredandsqueak · 24/08/2023 12:43

I can understand why you are upest and can see that the reasoning makes sense to your dd and I don't blame you for being hurt. Have you raised how hurt you feel with dd? Your post has made me realise I'm glad I've got an awful name that my dc won't saddle any future grandchildren with though so avoiding this hurt.

Hapagirl48 · 24/08/2023 12:36

Your daughter sounds pretty self centered tbh. And the whole names starting with a certain letter makes my teeth itch. Especially at the cost of hurt feelings to someone close.

bunchofboys · 24/08/2023 12:31

Try not to get upset about something like this. Its honestly not a big deal but is the sort of thing that leads to big rifts and hurt. Don't turn it into a big snub or let it ruin the arrival of your granddaughter.

Rainbowqueeen · 24/08/2023 12:22

I’d be really upset too.

They have essentially changed the reason for choosing the DCs middle names. No doubt you have been anticipating for sone time that your band would be used, which only adds to the feeling of being let down.

I can see it being an issue as the children grow up and struggle to understand why you have been left out. If I was a family member/ family friend I would find it most odd and it would change how I felt about your DD and her husband that they would behave in such a shallow and hurtful way.

becarefulofyourheart · 24/08/2023 12:15

It says a lot for you that your daughter believes you wouldn’t be bothered. You must be pretty easy-going, as well as doing lots of childcare! That doesn’t make it less hurtful to be omitted though.

As other PPs have said it’s a pity, cos it’s not like you can ask. You could jokingly offer to change your name to Jane😜

We proposed to use MIL and DM’s names as our DD’s middle names but slightly tweaked (put together as they are it all sounded a bit disjointed). My mother-in-law didn’t like the proposal and said ‘we needn’t bother on her account’ so we took her at her word. My mum laughed when I told her and said sod it just call the baby something completely her own. I’d have liked my DD to have my mum’s name but I didn’t want it to be a thing with MIL so in the end we left them both out -I regret it now. That said, DD does have a name which is one letter away from my mum’s dad’s name and she often talks about how nice that is to say and hear, so it’s not a total disaster.

I know that’s not the case here but I suspect your daughter has just prioritised her own logic and hasn’t considered what non-inclusion feels like to you. It’s funny how it goes because you must be very important to her and the DGC. This is what happens sometimes when you’re the one everyone depends on, innit, people sometimes forget you’ve got feelings a wee bit.

rolvus · 24/08/2023 12:12

BiIIie · 24/08/2023 08:45

I wouldnt be upset no, because their reasoning makes sense to them. Middle names are never used anyway.

I agree with this to be honest. I really wouldn't have given it a second thought. It's just a name. And it makes sense to them that they wanted them all to start with a J.

RudsyFarmer · 24/08/2023 12:06

They are picking family ‘J’ names. It’s as simple as that.

LookItsMeAgain · 24/08/2023 12:04

@MarshmaIIow - though your kids that you're putting into this naming convention may not want it, in years to come when they actually have their own voice.
Every one is unique, so why not embrace the uniqueness by calling people by names that they might want to be called had they been given the opportunity?

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/08/2023 11:50

Wouldn’t bother me at all but if you’re upset, can you tell her?

heartofglass23 · 24/08/2023 11:49

2 middle names?

Inyournewdress · 24/08/2023 11:43

I would feel upset too. The J thing is ridiculous, probably no one will ever even notice including the kids.

Wimpod · 24/08/2023 11:34

Yanbu really.

I still feel a little guilty for one of the grandparents, because we have 3 kids so only used 3/4 grandparents names 😳 Didn't really think it through. There is a cousin with their name, so hopefully it balances out for them 😬

If we'd had a 4th kid (not happening no matter how much DC2 and 3 like the idea!) I definitely would have used it. It would have worked out for either sex, or we would have used their surname or something special to them.

Gothambutnotahamster · 24/08/2023 11:31

OhHolyMoly · 24/08/2023 11:06

Haven’t RTFT.

Honestly, just allow yourself to be a tiny bit upset by this, and then actively move on.

I’m not always an advocate of cherishing what you have as an antidote to what you don’t, but this is TINY in the scheme of things.

You have a lovely DD and SIL and will soon have four happy, healthy DGC. This is more than some people could ever dream of and is objectively absolutely wonderful.

I’ve always been sad to be an only child myself… loads of friends, but never had a child called after me, no godchildren, no blood nieces and nephews. I am however thankful for the wonderful friends and in-laws that I have.

Edited

I would be upset & feel hurt by it, however i agree with the above.

Cherish what you have and move on (hoping you can).

Seashor · 24/08/2023 11:31

Shed not she’d!

Seashor · 24/08/2023 11:30

I’d be terribly upset and I would say something. We used family members names as first names for our children and both of those people she’d tears, they were humbled and overwhelmed. These things matter.

MrsMarzetti · 24/08/2023 11:22

My Grandchildren do not have my name but one has my Mums name and i am fine with that but in your case i would be upset. Even your daughter knows that it is very hurtful.

jumphopskip · 24/08/2023 11:19

It's not exactly the same circumstance but DD's middle name begins with quite an unusual letter, although it's not a family name. I'm expecting a second DD (who will most likely be our last child) and we've chosen a middle name we like beginning with same letter as DD1's. It feels nice that it will be a bit of a link between the two of them, but in a low key way as the two middle names are very different despite starting with the same letter.

The reason I share this is that I felt this approach was quite nice and I think (I hope!) that I'm quite a sensible / pragmatic person. It might be that the J thing just feels more important to your DD in the context of her DC as a group. I do get though why it would still feel hurtful in the circumstances you've set out.

DailyMaui · 24/08/2023 11:18

I used both my grandparent's names for my two. I loved my grandad's name and it was always going to be a middle name for my son. When I had my daughter I knew that my gran would be upset if we'd used his and not hers. So my daughter has two middle names - one that I wanted and my gran's name. Luckily it was a lovely name so no issues.

We did not carry on the middle name tradition from my husband's family as it sounds like you're swearing. Obvs different in his original language but he was agreed that he'e the last xxxx in the family!

MarshmaIIow · 24/08/2023 11:15

I can’t stand the thing of using family names, always seemed naff, and I say that as someone who was given a grandmother’s name for my middle name.

I do, however, love a letter theme, and my children and I all have matching middle initials (their father doesn’t have a middle name).

That said, as they have done three out of four GPs so far, it does seem harsh that the initial theme is more important to them than making you feel not left out. Though ultimately, because I too like our matching initials, and J especially is a good letter, I see their point.
I’m also a fan of a good sibset match, and many others aren’t. So I can see the appeal of:
John J Smith
Peter J Smith
Sarah J Smith
and how
Kate K Smith doesn’t look like part of the team.

Ultimately what matters most is your relationship with them all, not a name.