Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I can’t improve my body at 40?

131 replies

Fatatforty · 23/08/2023 21:03

I am 5 foot 2, at 25 I was a size 8 and 8 stone. 2 kids later and 40 years old I am 10 and a half stone and a size 14. I am also wobbly, and covered in cellulite with an overhanging stomach. I tried a bikini on for my holiday today and cried. My body just looks so pasty and un toned.

I Am disappointed as for the last 12 weeks I have been going to the gym twice a week and I cannot notice any difference. Do I just need to give it longer? The trainer gave me a routine of leg press, leg abductor, chess press, shoulder press, and i also do 10 minutes on the cross trainer as a warm up and cool down.

Diet wise I have tried slimming world but don’t enjoy all the cooking, and calorie counting but I get hungry and go over every day. I’m starting to feel like this is it for me, am I being unreasonable for thinking it’s just too difficult to get the body I want.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
soberfabulous · 24/08/2023 15:56

Totally possible!

I'm 47 and fitter than I was at 27.

Like others have said: sorry to say but twice a week isn't enough exercise. I work out 4 times a week, a mixture of gym, running, tennis , Pilates even adult ballet which I'm rubbish at but love.

Running is easy and free.

Make healthy food choices, intermittent fasting.

It's a mindset thing and I do it for my mental health and my heart.

The physical benefits are secondary...but helpfully they also motivate me too. I don't want to slide into middle age looking like a sofa.... 🤪

PaminaMozart · 24/08/2023 15:31

But it isn't about looks,@Saysoe - it's about health

Saysoe · 24/08/2023 15:10

Or just accept it and move on with this stage of your life, buying more flattering clothes to suit your shape.

MissMogwai · 24/08/2023 14:49

We've all been there! I'm 44 and piled on 3 stone during lockdown. I tried slimming world, exante shakes and I just didn't stick to it at all.

I ended up signing up to a sponsored swim as then I knew I'd have to do it and it was the best thing I've done. I built up to it and I go 4 times a week, swimming up to a mile each session. I love it.

I've lost 2 stone so far, I'm much more toned and I eat well. I do go for meals out, have the odd take away and go for drinks but I feel so balanced, healthy, and strong.

I think it's finding something you enjoy and then you feel so good you just want to keep doing it. The main benefit for me is my energy and mindset are so much improved that's it's had an impact on most aspects of my life.

WithIcePlease · 24/08/2023 14:19

Certainly possible.
There are studies of folk in nursing homes in their 70's with significant results doing basic body weight moves.

I'm with the high protein and progressive overload faction on here.
3-4 sessions of weights a week and longish walks at the weekend
No upf or sugar, loads of veg/salad for volume plus lean meat and fish
I'm nearer to 60 than 50 and my body has never been as muscled as it is now with good definition.

BogRollBOGOF · 24/08/2023 14:06

Any exercise you do is good for health.
If you've got specific goals then you need to regularly review what you do. Play with the number of reps and weight as exercises feel easier. I find gyms dull and hard for motivation so a group setting works better for me for weights. Running, I find more flexible and easy for goal setting so can do that solo.

Exercising in your 40s is an essential stage of keeping mobile, keeping strength and maintaining muscle and bone density into later adulthood. Good muscle mass does help maintain metabolic weight too. Exercise helps maintain weight, but is a small part in reducing it.

I don't diet. But sometimes I have to focus on nutrition and on adjusting habits. There is a slight distinction. I don't have to change everything in one go. That means I don't "cheat" or "fail". It's about trying to remember the role of water and nutrients in my lifestyle, and aiming for better not perfect.

Water and good hydration is essential to break down fat. Reduce sweet drinks be it sugar/ juice/ sweetners. Your body will metabolise sugars (inc in juice) first. Sugar spikes and crashes stimulate appetite within a few hours. Artificial sweetners can replicate those effects on the body and increase cravings.

Use naturally low calorie vegetables and some fruit to fill up on fibre. Then add proteins and healthy (less processed fats). I'm not anti-carb, but it is easy to consume too much. Carbs have a prominent place on the food pyramid because they were useful and cheap for filling up the post-war population when food was less abundant. If you have plenty of fibre, protein and fat on your plate, you don't need so many carbs.

Don't ban things, but work out how to fit them into your life in practical portions, e.g. save for the weekend.

Eat food as close to its natural state as possible. Reduce processing- the more recognisable the ingedients, the better.
Cooking doesn't have to take hours. If time is limited, frozen veg/ stirfries are a great time saver and often frozen in a fresher state than the food in the "fresh" section. Avoid artificually processed "low fat", the fat will sate you better and you eat less of it long run.

You don't have to change everything in one go and it's easier to tweak one habit at a time and it also makes it less likely that all habits will collapse at once when life gets in the way because special occasions, illness, busy phases etc are all inevitable.

Being small makes it hard going because you need less energy to survive than average, but you still want to eat "normally" and enjoy food. It takes a lot of patience.

Zebedee999 · 24/08/2023 14:02

The exercising is all well and goo dbut it's what goes in your mouth that makes the biggest difference. When I want to lose weight I bin the carbs and go for high protein foods. I no longer feel hungry and lose weight rapidly.

hairyunicorn · 24/08/2023 13:59

Add Hot Yoga to your routine, it literally melted my fat away and the gym helped tone everything up.

alwaysmovingforwards · 24/08/2023 13:57

Of course you can improve your body, but the older we get the harder it is. And the further we are from the goal, the longer it will take. Exercise, diet, hydration, sleep.

Success isn't a magic formula, it's just a simple case of having the discipline to do the work that needs doing, or not.

WaltzingWaters · 24/08/2023 13:36

HIIT is the way to go. Just 20 mins a day intense. And you can just find videos on YouTube. The workouts vary a lot and are fast paced so doesn’t get boring.
4-5 times a week for 20 mins and you’ll see a difference. Add in a bit of yoga afterwards if/when you can.
When I’m exercising a lot I find I’m much more motivated to eat better too.

itsmyp4rty · 24/08/2023 13:34

kegofcoffee · 23/08/2023 21:27

Your height and pre/post 2 kids weight are pretty much exactly the same as I was.

I spent around 9 months going to the gym 2-3 times a week to do strength training plus 10minutes cardio.

After 9 months I felt deflated that I still looked wobbly. So I finally took my diet seriously, started tracking calories, and lost over 1st.

Hiding under all that fat was 12 months worth of muscle. I now look better than I did at 25, although I weight more I'm toned and have definition.

Basically you won't see the benefits of the strength training unless you loose some of the fat that's covering up the muscle.

Yes this is true - a man can have a six pack but if he has any weight on him you won't know he has it.

I think you need to look at your diet and eat healthily. Make sure it is healthy though, replace most of the white carbs you eat with wholemeal, bulk up on vegetables, don't go overboard on fruit, lots of lean protein.
Start doing exercise everyday, not the gym but either walking or swimming. It won't lose you the weight that your diet will but you will sleep better and feel better and that's important when it come to weight too.

CharlotteBog · 24/08/2023 13:28

Not there.....boo

CharlotteBog · 24/08/2023 13:27

Ignore - testing Edit function on the App

Iamuhtredsonofuhtred · 24/08/2023 13:27

I’m nearly 41 and last year I was 10st at 5’2”, my BMI was creeping out of the healthy range and I knew it was now or never to get a handle on myself. I’m now 8st 13, and a size 8, my BMI is 22 and I look better than I did in my 20’s. What I did:
I run 5-10K 3 times a week (started with couch to 5k app)
I do half an hour of Pilates or barre every evening (at home on YouTube)
I don’t count calories but I don’t drink alcohol, I don’t eat sugar or processed food. Normal diet for me would be green yogurt, fruit, granola for breakfast, brown rice, mackerel and vegetables for lunch, feta and vegetable omelette for dinner. Snacks are fruit, nuts, raw cereal bar. I drink black coffee, green tea and water. I am committed to my health, I would get up early on holiday and run in the hotel gym, I do exercise after a 12 hour shift when all I want to do is crawl into bed or watch TV and eat crisps. There’s no shortcut. And it’s taken me months to get to the point where this feels normal to me, and if I eat sugar it’s often a slippery slope to letting things slide. My mindset is the hardest thing to maintain, the rest is just habit.

Duchessofspace · 24/08/2023 13:20

coxesorangepippin · 23/08/2023 21:30

Main thing is diet

Focus on that

This …. I dropped 3 stone at 40 and boy did I look good. I’m now 10 years on and have put on 5 stone due to Covid and steriods (been on them for 3 years) and therefore constantly hungry. I’m hitting 1 st September with a bang - I’m cutting down on carbs but going zero carbs in September. It works for me - 99% is diet once you lose the weight you have more energy so you feel fitter!

horseyhorsey17 · 24/08/2023 13:16

ShirleyPhallus · 24/08/2023 13:13

But you’ve also said that staying slim is an ongoing battle now. Focusing on building weight will speed up your metabolism.

lots of plant based protein sources. Doing too much cardio without maintaining the muscle you have (with protein) is not good

Well yeah it is, it used to be easy and I didn't have to exercise at all!

It's fine, thanks, I have a personal trainer who works on this with me.

ShirleyPhallus · 24/08/2023 13:13

horseyhorsey17 · 24/08/2023 13:10

Depends on body type. I know what works for me. I can't lift heavy and I dislike eating lots of protein. I prefer cardio and a plant based diet and I am slim and fit. The OP was wondering why she hadn't lost weight but it was quite clear from the routine she posted that she wasn't doing enough exercise or the right type - just the generic stuff they always recommend in gyms if you don't get a good trainer who spends time working out a routine that's right for the individual.

ETA - I didn't say do running or cycling in the gym, I said do additional exercise outside of the gym which could possibly be that. Up to the OP though.

Edited

But you’ve also said that staying slim is an ongoing battle now. Focusing on building weight will speed up your metabolism.

lots of plant based protein sources. Doing too much cardio without maintaining the muscle you have (with protein) is not good

horseyhorsey17 · 24/08/2023 13:10

ShirleyPhallus · 24/08/2023 13:07

walking is really good for cardio. You absolutely do not need to be doing loads of running and cycling in the gym.

lifting heavy, walking lots and eating lots of protein will do more than excessive cardio sessions

Depends on body type. I know what works for me. I can't lift heavy and I dislike eating lots of protein. I prefer cardio and a plant based diet and I am slim and fit. The OP was wondering why she hadn't lost weight but it was quite clear from the routine she posted that she wasn't doing enough exercise or the right type - just the generic stuff they always recommend in gyms if you don't get a good trainer who spends time working out a routine that's right for the individual.

ETA - I didn't say do running or cycling in the gym, I said do additional exercise outside of the gym which could possibly be that. Up to the OP though.

ShirleyPhallus · 24/08/2023 13:07

horseyhorsey17 · 24/08/2023 13:04

Twice a week at the gym won't make that much difference - needs to be at least four times, with other exercise as well, eg hiking, running, cycling. You need more cardio in the mix if you're looking to lose weight too. Your routine is good for toning but if you want to be slimmer, then you need that all important calorie deficit, which means you either need to eat less or exercise more (the sort of exercise that burns off calories, ie cardio). I am 48 and menopausal and having always been a slim size 10 and 9 and a half stone (I am 5 foot 7), I am now half a stone heavier, much more knackered, with bigger breasts and underarm spread and it's a constant battle to stay size 10. Getting older sucks.

walking is really good for cardio. You absolutely do not need to be doing loads of running and cycling in the gym.

lifting heavy, walking lots and eating lots of protein will do more than excessive cardio sessions

horseyhorsey17 · 24/08/2023 13:04

Twice a week at the gym won't make that much difference - needs to be at least four times, with other exercise as well, eg hiking, running, cycling. You need more cardio in the mix if you're looking to lose weight too. Your routine is good for toning but if you want to be slimmer, then you need that all important calorie deficit, which means you either need to eat less or exercise more (the sort of exercise that burns off calories, ie cardio). I am 48 and menopausal and having always been a slim size 10 and 9 and a half stone (I am 5 foot 7), I am now half a stone heavier, much more knackered, with bigger breasts and underarm spread and it's a constant battle to stay size 10. Getting older sucks.

JudgeAnderson · 24/08/2023 13:01

@ShirleyPhallus absolutely this. The weights I mean.

TravellingSpoon · 24/08/2023 13:00

The main reason I dont eat better is I get lunch at work for free and the cook always makes the most amazing food with enormous portions, and there is always pudding on offer that I cant say no to!

No massive salads for me.

TravellingSpoon · 24/08/2023 12:59

I agree with those saying that if you think weights dont work you are not lifting enough.

My PT also said to me that I need to mix it up, so instead of doing 3 x sets with the same weights, try using different weights across your sets. That works for me. Ive just turned 40 and have been taking it seriously for just under a year. I go 4-5 times a week. I know I could probably lose more weight if I ate better, but life is too short and its not my aim. My aim is to be strong and feel better mentally, which working out gives me. I do a pilates class a week and 1 swim session because I get a bit bored otherwise.

Ive dropped a different PT who seemed to constantly be focused on dropping weight, despite me telling him several times I didnt want to focus on that.

TheBarbieEffect · 24/08/2023 12:55

Of course you can. You just need to put the effort in.

MrsSkylerWhite · 24/08/2023 12:52

ShirleyPhallus · Today 12:47
Glad to see we are hitting MN bingo with all these “massive salads” being eaten!”

A packet of black pudding and poached eggs was my favourite lunch 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread