Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do you believe it’s unfair for a significant other to gain weight?

195 replies

TurkeyJerky · 23/08/2023 21:00

Do you believe it’s unreasonable for a partner to gain a significant amount of weight over the course of a relationship? Do we owe our husbands / wives to remain in a similarly sized body or that we should be loved at any size?

reasonable - you should remain within in a similarly sized body as when you started the relationship

unreasonable - what! No way, they should love you anyway

OP posts:
ToWhitToWhoo · 24/08/2023 02:44

YABU. You do not owe your partner a particular type of body. The chances are that, even if you don't gain significant weight, you will change somewhat in appearance as you get older, and probably become less conventionally attractive. If such things end a relationship, it was probably somewhat superficial to start with. Which doesn't mean that the partners involved were consciously selfish or dishonest; such feelings are often beyond one's control and can't be helped. But one should not be self-righteous about a partner having a duty to keep their body in a particular shape.

Panfriedscallops · 24/08/2023 00:31

Escapetofrance · 24/08/2023 00:03

I think ‘unfair’ is an odd choice of words when it comes to gaining weight. I doubt there are many overweight people who are happy about gaining weight themselves-worrying what their partners think isn’t helpful.
Ideally we would all stay young, fit and slim, but that’s not the reality in many marriages/relationships. It’s pretty shallow to say it’s unfair of them.

Agreed!
I don't think anyone is saying we have to find obesity attractive but it's not the only thing that changes as we age, believe me.
Is it unfair that my DH has gone bald? He could have a transplant. Not much to ask.

JenWillsiam · 24/08/2023 00:28

How much we talking here? Normal weight gain / body shape changing sure. Deal with it. It happens to us all.

going from healthy to morbidly obese whilst it impacts lifestyle etc? That’s a no for me. Probably wouldn’t be that keen on OH if he became super skinny and stopped enjoying nice meals out and a glass of wine. It’s lifestyle really.

call911 · 24/08/2023 00:28

people change as time goes on. Putting a bit of weight on is normal. But extreme changes that completely change your appearance eg unhealthy BMI either way, can be concerning. That sort of transformation changes your entire aesthetic. Like it or not, what your body looks like contributes to your overall aesthetic and attraction

Princessconsuelabananahammock9 · 24/08/2023 00:27

My partner is not tiny, but very fit. He used to be quite fat, and worked hard to lost over a hundred pounds.
If he gained a bunch of weight he would be miserable. It's been years since he lost the weight and eating right and exercising are really important to him.
I am not attracted to overweight people. I would still love him with all my heart, but no I wouldn't want to have sex with him. Sex is important to me, so that would be a bridge we would have to discuss and cross.

IncessantNameChanger · 24/08/2023 00:05

My dh is twice the weight he was when we got married. What bovers me is that he is still gaining weight and shows no interest in even stabilising or maintaining this weight. He always said shoot me if get like ( insert a man walking down the street with his belly flopping over his belt and by his knees) but if I point out nothing fits him he gets all defensive. That's what's unattractive. No self awareness. Not the weight gain.

Escapetofrance · 24/08/2023 00:03

I think ‘unfair’ is an odd choice of words when it comes to gaining weight. I doubt there are many overweight people who are happy about gaining weight themselves-worrying what their partners think isn’t helpful.
Ideally we would all stay young, fit and slim, but that’s not the reality in many marriages/relationships. It’s pretty shallow to say it’s unfair of them.

Dockdive · 23/08/2023 23:49

I wouldn't love or care for my partner any less if they gained a lot of weight but personally I don't find obesity sexually attractive so would struggle in that department.

I might be unreasonable for feeling that way but I think if my partner did pile the weight on purely out of laziness and greed, they would be being unreasonable for expecting me to find them as attractive as I did before.

When I talk about piling the weight on, I don't mean rounder round the edges or a lack of a six pack, I'm talking about a belly that overhangs/hides their genitals. It's not sexy, sorry.

Reddog1 · 23/08/2023 23:48

Funny how women over 14 stone “stuff their faces” but people under that just …well…”eat”

DuesToTheDirt · 23/08/2023 23:41

For health yes, it would be good if they stayed a reasonable weight (assuming they were a reasonable weight to start with), but for attractiveness I'd disagree. People change physically in all sorts of ways over the years - they generally get old and haggard for a start! Men lose their hair, women's bodies sag...

Bandyarsia · 23/08/2023 23:40

I've now been making every effort to eat healthily and exercising regularly for 25 years. And I'm size 22

But you must be eating a lot of crap aswell though in fairness.

BounceyB · 23/08/2023 23:39

It's a silly question because like most things there's a more nuanced discussion about how a body ages and changes shape at different stages in life. If my partner were to continue to make an effort and be smart when it mattered I wouldn't worry about his weight. I wouldn't want to be with someone who allowed their weight to dominate their life though.

Bandyarsia · 23/08/2023 23:38

Panfriedscallops · 23/08/2023 23:34

I'm on the other side of this, I was never slim but I was smaller when I met my DH. Neither do I "stuff my face", I eat normally but I've struggled with weight my whole life. You lot would be horrified if you knew how much I weigh at the moment 😂
I can understand a lack of attraction to someone who has bad habits in general, eating crap being part of that, along with bad hygiene and laziness but for some of us, being slim is a lifelong fight and some of the attitudes here lack a huge amount of empathy. No one chooses to be fat - are you for real?!
I don't need to justify anything here but I eat well and healthily and I exercise regularly. I'm clean and well dressed, work full time and have lots of interests. I don't have osteoporosis or require new knees or hips. I'm not on any regular medication not even HRT but this thread is soul destroying.
I've spent far too much of my life feeling unattractive and trying to lose weight, even now I watch every mouthful. I have tried and tried but I'm just not capable of losing weight and keeping it off. I've spent 40 odd years being hungry and I'm done.
Is it just extra weight that puts you off? If so, have you considered it could be a prejudice. It sounds superficial to find a few pounds or even a stone or two on the person you love a dealbreaker...

For the record, in my 60s, married 35 years, still have a decent sex life.

A few pound or even a stone would not bother me, 3 or more stone and a huge belly would absolutely put me off sexually. I would still love him but would not want sex with a very overweight man. No.

Hellostrawberries · 23/08/2023 23:35

Mariposista · 23/08/2023 21:17

It wouldn't work for me. SO and I want a long, active and healthy life together my SO, so either of us slobbing on the sofa, stuffing our faces with hobnobs and chips and becoming enormous just doesn't fit.
However, if weight gain (or loss for that matter) is due to medication, an injury/illness beyond our control, that is something else. Neither of us are of the ilk that 'we don't have time' to be healthy/exercise - we make time, no matter how tired/busy/stressed we are. We just forego other things, like time watching tv.

You have literally no idea about the complexities of obesity. Did you know that one of the biggest predictors of weight gain is dieting? I was a size 12 when I met my husband 26 years ago. I wanted to be a bit thinner so I went on a diet. In common with 95% of dieters, set point theory then came into play, I was overwhelmed by hunger and cravings and ended up bigger than I was to start with. Rinse and repeat x 1000. I've now been making every effort to eat healthily and exercising regularly for 25 years. And I'm size 22 and 16 stone. Thankfully my husband still loves me.

Panfriedscallops · 23/08/2023 23:34

I'm on the other side of this, I was never slim but I was smaller when I met my DH. Neither do I "stuff my face", I eat normally but I've struggled with weight my whole life. You lot would be horrified if you knew how much I weigh at the moment 😂
I can understand a lack of attraction to someone who has bad habits in general, eating crap being part of that, along with bad hygiene and laziness but for some of us, being slim is a lifelong fight and some of the attitudes here lack a huge amount of empathy. No one chooses to be fat - are you for real?!
I don't need to justify anything here but I eat well and healthily and I exercise regularly. I'm clean and well dressed, work full time and have lots of interests. I don't have osteoporosis or require new knees or hips. I'm not on any regular medication not even HRT but this thread is soul destroying.
I've spent far too much of my life feeling unattractive and trying to lose weight, even now I watch every mouthful. I have tried and tried but I'm just not capable of losing weight and keeping it off. I've spent 40 odd years being hungry and I'm done.
Is it just extra weight that puts you off? If so, have you considered it could be a prejudice. It sounds superficial to find a few pounds or even a stone or two on the person you love a dealbreaker...

For the record, in my 60s, married 35 years, still have a decent sex life.

CornishBarbie · 23/08/2023 23:31

No, I definitely don't. I'd expect my fiancée to tbh at different times in his life. Life is a hard slog sometimes and wonderful at others when you're thriving. I find weight and body tends to reflect that. If he puts in weight it's probably because his gym sessions are less of a priority to our circumstances. He's gorgeous and kind and I love him all ways as he would with me.

Hibiscrubbed · 23/08/2023 23:31

I admit I would find my partner less attractive if he put on a lot of weight.

Hibiscrubbed · 23/08/2023 23:30

Animallover87 · 23/08/2023 21:04

I wouldn't be impressed if my DH put on a significant amount of weight. But I wouldn't pile on loads and expect him to be OK with it either.

Medical conditions aside obviously in both cases.

Well, yes. This, basically.

Health conditions aside, you cannot expect to dramatically change your appearance and expect the other party to still find you as physically attractive as before. Equally, you cannot expect to control someone to the point they they’re ‘not allowed’ to gain weight.

CarpetSlipper · 23/08/2023 23:28

It depends, I would be concerned about the health of someone who gained a large amount of weight and I want my partner to be around as long as possible and be as healthy and happy as possible.
Would I be less attracted to or stop loving my partner because he gained weight? Absolutely not! I love him regardless and want him to feel good about himself at any weight.

Jennybeans401 · 23/08/2023 23:27

I think I'd still love the person regardless and I'd see it as supportive to help them become healthier. Marriage is really about being there for each other regardless.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/08/2023 23:27

FunnysInLaJardin · Today 23:12
MrsSkylerWhite · Today 23:06

Grossly overweight? FFS you can still look and be attractive at 14.5 stone. Its not HUGE”

Not sure about that. Was 14.5 stone after our first child at 5ft 8.5 inches tall. Looked and felt awful and had to wear a size 20 to be comfortable. That’s not good, however you look at it. Health wise, not great either.
all this faux concern about the health of folk you dont know.

I am 14.5 stone and 5.6. I am a size 18. You must have carried your weight very differently to be size 20 at 5.8

I agree its not ideal, but physically I am in good shape, blood pressure, lung capacity etc and walk about an hour a day. So weight isn't the only indicator of health”

It isn’t faux concern at all, please don’t be rude. I’m nearly 60 now and know from experience that weighing 14.5 stones is too heavy for most women and lots of men. It increases your risk of all sorts of Illnesses (I had breast cancer myself in 2016, no family history but I was fat). I don’t know your age but what works at 30, for example, doesn’t work at 60. Most British people would benefit from loosing a bit of weight.

Bandyarsia · 23/08/2023 23:27

MummyJ36 · 23/08/2023 23:24

Bodies change, bodies age. You cannot maintain the figure you had when you met someone because you will never be that age again. What if you lose a limb? Does you partner deserve to be with someone with two arms and two legs? There are plenty of reasons why people’s bodies change, sometimes it is totally not within their control, sometimes it is something they lose control of. Either way you do not “owe”
your partner a physical aesthetic.

No you don't owe a certain body shape to anyone but you cannot expect someone to still fancy you if you are obese. Some people won't care but it would really bother me if my husband was stones overweight in how I see him sexually.

FettleOfKish · 23/08/2023 23:26

Well it's all contextual isn't it? If DH had an injury that rendered him less mobile, or had to take drugs that increased his weight that's one thing. Same as us both quietly expanding a bit with age.

If he just decided to quit exercise and sit on his backside eating cake all day that's another. Same goes for me.

Some things are outside of our control, other things aren't. I'd lose respect for him if he voluntarily became a couch potato, and with that my desire would dissolve.

MumblesParty · 23/08/2023 23:25

oaktable · 23/08/2023 22:28

Well, if you're married, you've literally promised, in front of witnesses, to stay together for better or worse. So unreasonable.

I think if you fundamentally don’t agree with divorce, as you clearly don’t, it’s hard to participate in the debate. Most people will agree there are many circumstances in which it’s OK to break those vows.

MummyJ36 · 23/08/2023 23:24

Bodies change, bodies age. You cannot maintain the figure you had when you met someone because you will never be that age again. What if you lose a limb? Does you partner deserve to be with someone with two arms and two legs? There are plenty of reasons why people’s bodies change, sometimes it is totally not within their control, sometimes it is something they lose control of. Either way you do not “owe”
your partner a physical aesthetic.

Swipe left for the next trending thread