Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I hate my budget holiday

362 replies

ValentinaTheVampire · 23/08/2023 19:19

We have small children to do things on a budget so we tend to do self catering in the UK to avoid paying for flights and also so we aren't all squashed into a hotel room.

But ugh, it has been so miserable this time (we are away at the moment). The weather where we are staying is pretty miserable. We are staying near family where I grew up as we tried to do holiday and family visit in one and I am honestly just counting down the days. I'm so tired from all the driving about and visiting and trying to keep kids entertained in the rain with none of their usual stuff around to help.

The cottages we've had the past few holidays have been so tired looking and even then they are so expensive.

I have a small but perfectly nice house at home. Kids aren't exactly getting a cultural experience here (although they are loving seeing family).

Dh wants to do another holiday cottage for my 40th birthday which is coming up over other school holidays and I've just told him no fucking way 😂.

I'd rather spend the money on my house or save for a nicer holiday even if we don't get one as often.

I can't tell if holidays have got worse or if I have become a that who just likes staying at home.

OP posts:
ValentinaTheVampire · 24/08/2023 09:12

OK thanks @MissAtomicBomb1 and @TheWayoftheLeaf. Will look at both

OP posts:
TheWayoftheLeaf · 24/08/2023 09:06

Go on LoveHolidays.

You can find holidays abroad with flights and hotel for a family of four for £1,500 (£375pp) or less.

MissAtomicBomb1 · 24/08/2023 09:01

ValentinaTheVampire · 24/08/2023 08:43

There's no Butlins or Haven or anything in this area. There are caravan parks but they tend to only have a play area and a shop rather than what you'd get in Butlins.

I'm just looking at a short break at Butlins for next year though. Not £500, but the cheapest accommodation is £750ish for 4 days so about the same as this cottage but at least there would be activities for the kids? Or is it not worth it if it's the cheapest part?

They've rebranded their accommodation so it's a bit confusing but as a rule of thumb anything labelled 'standard' is pretty poor. We did silver once & it was just about ok. I would say anything above silver will be fine. We stayed in the comfort plus apartments recently at minehead and they were lovely. The lakeside chalets are even nicer but ££.

ValentinaTheVampire · 24/08/2023 08:43

There's no Butlins or Haven or anything in this area. There are caravan parks but they tend to only have a play area and a shop rather than what you'd get in Butlins.

I'm just looking at a short break at Butlins for next year though. Not £500, but the cheapest accommodation is £750ish for 4 days so about the same as this cottage but at least there would be activities for the kids? Or is it not worth it if it's the cheapest part?

OP posts:
DarlingCoffee · 24/08/2023 08:33

This year we have had a self catering holiday in the UK and multiple day trips out which all ended up costing ££££ despite my best efforts

I can categorically say next year I will be booking an AI abroad somewhere hot and sunny with a pool.

NerrSnerr · 24/08/2023 08:32

I find that with small children that if you pick the right holiday for them it's a much nicer holiday for you, even if it's somewhere you'd prefer not to go to. Like others our best holidays have been Butlins. I know people turn their noses up at it but it's easy with the shows, fairground, swimming etc all together. We also did the food plan so didn't need to worry about food. We also have enjoyed caravan holidays over the years with pools and stuff on site.

PinkCherryBlossoms · 24/08/2023 08:27

For £800 in the UK with younger kids, I'd have been more likely to go down the Haven or similar route.

twistyizzy · 24/08/2023 08:24

@ValentinaTheVampire sounds like a good plan! The cost of holidaying in the UK is getting crazy.

ValentinaTheVampire · 24/08/2023 08:17

You're right @twistyizzy. It's a low budget.

In years gone by we could go out of school holidays and also things were cheaper, so a cheap cottage then was actually quite nice!

I think we need to have shorter, nicer holidays less often instead of 2 weeks somewhere not great

OP posts:
twistyizzy · 24/08/2023 08:12

@ValentinaTheVampire I've seen that your accommodation cost approx £800 per week? I'm the UK I wouldn't expect a decent cottage for that price to be honest.
We love our UK holidays but that's because we plan everything before we go and have contingencies for bad weather. So we have a list of everything we want to do and I spend weeks researching locations to make sure there is enough to do. We have National Trust + Englsh Heritage membership so get free entry to places etc.
We've been all over UK from Scottish Highlands to Cornwall and enjoyed every holiday but we spend at least 1.5K per week on the accommodation and don't treat it as a budget holiday.
When DD was younger (same age as yours are now) we loved Featherdown holidays: glamping on farms where the kids could run feral and they didn't care whether it was raining or not. Always other kids around the same age so you could guarantee that she would make friends and have a blast. They are much cheaper than renting a cottage.

ValentinaTheVampire · 24/08/2023 08:05

Thanks for all the posts.

I'm reading them now.

@Onomatopoeiadoodle, that's a great deal! I will look at that for next summer maybe. Just a short break and then we can staycation the rest of the time.

@Ohdofuckofdear there is a swimming pool with slides nearby and an aquarium. Further away there are other things like fairly well known beauty spots and a zoo. There is a cinema too. It's all a bit of a drive away because we're in the countryside, but we are booking the aquarium and not seeing relatives one day. I'm trying to keep some days free of family visits to make it more of a holiday, but tbf, the kids are enjoying the family visits. There are kids their age so they run off steam as well which helps.

I think campervans are £££££ these days? That's quite a big investment. Not sure we're up for that at the moment, but I can definitely appreciate they would make travel a lot easier.

OP posts:
Ladyj84 · 24/08/2023 04:05

We learnt from last year 3 toddlers and a teen we've always stayed holiday cottages but last year was dismal rain rain rain. So this year we changed it to stay home, days out, treats,takeaways etc and it went great for 2 weeks, all seemed to enjoy it and the amount of places we had fun at we didn't even know was on our own doorstep

Crapsummer2023 · 24/08/2023 02:00

When you have small kids it’s very important you have good accommodation as you’ll probably be stuck there from 6pm onwards. You’re also best going somewhere with separate rooms, guaranteed sun and a pool. So next year book somewhere like Turkey and get a villa with a pool. You’ll all have a better holiday.

You can sometimes luckout with British cottages but it’s very hit and miss as is the weather.

sjpkgp1 · 24/08/2023 01:31

I agree with you. It is better to save up for a better shorter holiday than have two rubbish longer ones. I think that children hugely benefit from going on holiday / being somewhere different / having some quality time with parents, but probably when they are a bit older, because then "coping with their surroundings" is all part of it. Realise you cannot go in term time, and have a strict budget, but a local-ish parkdean or haven site for a Fri/Sat night off season, where they get to go to the pool, disco etc. is usually pretty cheap, and stay home with your comforts and conveniences in the summer. Premier inns are good as they offer free brekky for kids under 16. We used to use travelodges a lot - just one night. Camping is OK but takes effort and can be awful if the weather is bad. We used to go to places that had a theme park nearby, you can often get 2 for 1 tickets and it kept ours amused all day 4 kids, so needed "something" and quite often just being around other kids is enough. We have done most of Europe theme parks, coupled with cheap flights and self catering. We have always "self-organised" but this is not for the faint-hearted. It has mainly been fab, but we have had some hit and miss times too.

PyongyangKipperbang · 24/08/2023 01:06

@Marmaladesarnie Thanks for the info. I was looking at around the 1k mark, for the same reason!

Marmaladesarnie · 24/08/2023 00:48

@PyongyangKipperbang we bought a pretty old one first off about £1000 just to check we enjoyed it and wanted to do it. Then we sold it on (for not much less to another family that were testing the waters too) we loved it so much and had 8 trips in the 2 years we had it.
We have just upgraded to a newer version for £8k ready for next year!

JMSA · 24/08/2023 00:46

A UK holiday in a self-catering cottage is NOT a holiday.

justjuggling · 24/08/2023 00:39

VALUE for money, sorry, typo!

justjuggling · 24/08/2023 00:38

Definitely worth looking at centre parcs in Europe. We did 2 in Belgium and one in Holland when my DDs were primary school age. Took the ferry and drove. Great blue for money. 🙂

adomizo · 24/08/2023 00:31

YANBU it's the dismal summer we have had as well I can't remember a summer as bad as this for years. Yes look at eurocamp but go further south as lots of Northern Europe had similar rubbish weather.

pantjog · 24/08/2023 00:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

PyongyangKipperbang · 24/08/2023 00:04

Marmaladesarnie · 23/08/2023 23:52

I haven’t read everything so sorry if I’m repeating a point.

we have a folding camper (a pennine pathfinder) so we can book camping/caravan sites and take it there.

I know camping (although this is posh) is not for everyone but let me give you my pros.

  1. We have proper mattress beds (not on ground)
  2. fridge, kitchen area including sink, hob and oven and small toilet area.
  3. With awning we have tons of space, bigger than most hotel rooms.
  4. Its always cleaned to my standards because I give it a quick clean at the end of trips
  5. each trip I make it more and more homely - has all the pot and pans I want.
  6. Such good value, our last trip was a week in cornwall for £250 (site had a pool and we had electricity) statics on the same site were 2k+ (I’m a teacher so stuck in hols too)
Theres an investment to begin with, and a fairly steep learning curve, but we have been on 4 trips this year and still not spent the same as your 1 trip. If I was away and not enjoying it, I would just pack up and go home knowing I wasn’t wasting a ton of money.

Did you buy new or secondhand? Do you mind if I ask what you paid (particularlty if second hand, I am never sure what is a good price!).

I have toyed with the idea of a folding camper for a few years, caravan would be perfect but way out of my price range. I am not a camper AT ALL! But the cost of the statics are eyewatering just for a week! It seems like a compromise between the two. I have camped, ordinary tent and a trailer tent, I dont like it because it isnt comfortable and its just so fucking hard to cook, wash etc. But I think that a camper would be good (the real beds/kitchenette thing are the main points for me).

Blacknosugarplease · 23/08/2023 23:57

Royalbloo · 23/08/2023 19:31

Butlins next week with my 6.5yr old. We are going to have the best time even though it's not a hat I would choose. Be grateful for what you have? Paid time off and a kid of your own? Sorry if that's harsh.

And a kid of your own…. 😂

PyongyangKipperbang · 23/08/2023 23:54

YANBU

The year before last my sister and I took my youngest DD away for a week in the UK and it cost a fortune. I was on a strict budget and it broke me for the rest of the month as I had to spend money I didnt have. We have discussed going abroad simply because although on paper it is cheaper in the uk, in reality it is so weather dependent. We spent the equivalent of a fortnight package holiday abroad just keeping busy because it pissed it down the whole time. At least in Spain you can pretty much rely on the weather so you can plan days at the beach/pool/waterpark and then evenings with dinner etc and budget accordingly.

We went again this year and hit lucky with the weather and we spent a fraction of what we spent last time. We are discussing whether to try the UK again next year or simply bite the bullet and book an AI or similar in Europe.

As it is, DD is 12 so I think our "bucket and spade" holidays will be naturally coming to an end soon anyway. I looked at Butlins as there are always activities etc but the cost of it is not disimilar to going abroad and again....weather.

Marmaladesarnie · 23/08/2023 23:52

I haven’t read everything so sorry if I’m repeating a point.

we have a folding camper (a pennine pathfinder) so we can book camping/caravan sites and take it there.

I know camping (although this is posh) is not for everyone but let me give you my pros.

  1. We have proper mattress beds (not on ground)
  2. fridge, kitchen area including sink, hob and oven and small toilet area.
  3. With awning we have tons of space, bigger than most hotel rooms.
  4. Its always cleaned to my standards because I give it a quick clean at the end of trips
  5. each trip I make it more and more homely - has all the pot and pans I want.
  6. Such good value, our last trip was a week in cornwall for £250 (site had a pool and we had electricity) statics on the same site were 2k+ (I’m a teacher so stuck in hols too)
Theres an investment to begin with, and a fairly steep learning curve, but we have been on 4 trips this year and still not spent the same as your 1 trip. If I was away and not enjoying it, I would just pack up and go home knowing I wasn’t wasting a ton of money.