Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank Insisting I tell them why I am making a Payment to my Daughter

358 replies

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 13:28

I usually do my banking online but thought it would be easier to set up a standing order by calling First Direct today. After going through security, I was asked a number of questions about whether I had been forced to do this, had I been told to download software, was anyone watching me online etc. This is irritating, as it is incredibly unlikely that anyone who was being scammed would say yes, but I answered them none the less.

I was then asked how I had been given the bank details. I said that I had made the transfer before, but still had to give specific details as to how my daughter had given me the bank details, that I had successfully made manual transfers to multiple times over many years. After we'd got past this, I was then told I had to tell them why I was paying money to my daughter. I declined to answer, and was prevented from setting up a standing order. Complaints department confirmed that this was their procedure and they were knowingly preventing me from moving my own money around.

I asked them how much fraud they could quantify had been prevented by these arbitratry measures, they could not answer. But if I had done this myself online, then I would not have to justify my own decisions, could just do it at the drop of a hat. Bloody annoying. But a real problem for people who can't manage to use online services, who are forced to give up their privacy by rules like this.

Does anyone have a bank that will allow you to make transactions over the phone without justifying how they spend their own money, as I would like to switch to them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SlightlyJaded · 23/08/2023 17:16

I am so sick on this nonsense.

Elenvty-billion pages of 'are you sure' on the Santander App when trying to put £20 into DS account.

I had a massive argument with the Manager of our local Nat West because iI went into branch to get £500 in cash. There is a machine inside the branch that actually lets you withdraw this amount (different to the normal cashpoint) but it was broken. So I queued. And would they give it to me? Would they fuck. I was nearly crying with frustration. There was zero logic.

Me: But if they machine was working, it wouldn't be asking me questions?
Them: But the machine isn't working.
Me: But your policy MUST BE that you can let people withdraw £500 of their own money without being interrogated, because you have a machine that lets you do just this.
Them: But the machine isn't working.
Me. I know that. But it's the same transaction
Them: You need to fill in this form.
Me: I don't. It's to pay someone
THem: We need to see the invoice
Me: You really don't. Does the machine ask that?
Them: But the machine is broken.

And on and on it went.

I had a proper meltdown. Proper.

£500. Not even £1K

Nanny-state nonsense.

LlynTegid · 23/08/2023 17:14

In answer to the OPs question, I cannot be of any help.

I support reasonable measures to prevent scams which this seems to be, to try to reduce fraud or coercive behaviour. Where I dissent from banks is that this does not seem to apply to all customer regardless of wealth, income or location.

I would be even more supportive of banks had it not been for their branch closures over recent years.

vickylou78 · 23/08/2023 17:10

This is all to protect you! There's a known scam where the scammer pretends to be your daughter and they have lost their bag which includes their phone and bank cards. The scammer is really convincing and cons mothers into transferring big sums of money to them to 'tide them over until the bank sends them new cards etc'. The bank want to know that your daughter has physically given you her bank details and it's not all going to scammers. There may be money laundering to consider toouf large amount. Just say is a gift?!

Itsagreatdaytosavelives · 23/08/2023 17:08

good luck to you finding better than first direct. 1 of the best about. my own experience of customer service has always been outstanding. as previous poster said banks are damned if they do and damned if they dont

Ormally · 23/08/2023 17:08

I've read about 70 percent of this thread and seen love in half the messages and irritation on the other for most of the banks already mentioned, most high street names and others that are newcomers.

Anyone found a bank or savings scheme that has what they consider to be sensible/ proportionate measures for situations such as the OP's? (I agree about NSI being exceptionally difficult to liberate your own funds from, yet super-easy to add more money to on an online dashboard)

Flipflipmania · 23/08/2023 16:59

I so wish they’d done this with my father when he was in the starting stage of dementia and undiagnosed

Flipflipmania · 23/08/2023 16:58

How old are you op?

stayathomer · 23/08/2023 16:57

I disagree with a lot of people here- there’s checking you’re who you say you are and that you want it to be in relation to your daughter, but the why question seems ridiculous! Banking is getting more and more difficult, there are roadblocks everywhere, the hoops that need to be jumped through only for them to send you to the app which generally stalls just as you need it, leading to the bank questioning who you are.

Rosscameasdoody · 23/08/2023 16:53

Money laundering laws changed a little while ago. Banks already ask as standard whether you have been coerced into sending money, and generally check that you’re not being scammed. But now, if it’s a substantial sum of money being transferred they have to comply with money laundering laws as well, so if it’s over a certain amount they have to ask for extra details. I deposited a cheque and a substantial amount of cash in my bank recently from my partner because we’re having a wet room installed and the company want bank transfers. When I paid it in I questioned as to where it had come from, and why. Intrusive, but the ultimately the bank are liable.

JenWillsiam · 23/08/2023 16:53

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 14:50

Like I said - they are asking the questions to attempt to protect themselves, not me. Glad you agree.

The IHT limit for a married couple who leave their estates to each other, and own their own home is £1M. Click on your own link to see this.

You can disregard it but it does protect vulnerable people as well. My father had a payment for refused for payment of a car. It was a scam.

For you there was no scam so it seems futile but for others it’s not.

This is such a weird thing to get mad about.

DonttouchthatLarry · 23/08/2023 16:45

I do understand why banks do checks like these - there was programme a few years ago where scammers targeted an elderly man and were charging him ridiculous amounts for very simple jobs. I can't remember the exact amount/job but he went to the bank to withdraw something like £10k and when they asked him what for he said to have the gutters cleared. After a bit of chatting the bank staff realised he was being scammed and the police were involved. If questions save one vulnerable person from losing all their money I'm happy to answer them.

However I was nonplussed the other week when HSBC wouldn't let me pay cash into my husband's First Direct account! We don't have a joint account so the cashier suggested paying it into mine then she could transfer it - I'm not sure how that is supposed to prevent whatever they were trying to prevent as the net result was the money went into his account but was just more of a faff.

MitchellMummy · 23/08/2023 16:43

Had a similar thing happen to me this week. But it was online! It was frustrating - but happy that banks are trying to help us not to get scammed.

AfraidToRun · 23/08/2023 16:42

I don't know your age, but elder abuse is absolutely rife sadly.

Wemetatascoutcamp · 23/08/2023 16:39

It may seem like over kill but banks have to be seen to do as much as possible to prevent people being scammed.
I worked in a bank for 8 years (including 6 months on telephone banking) and you’ve no idea the number of ways fraudsters convince people to willingly send them money and how much some people have lost.
Yes it may be an inconvenience but if just one person who is being scammed/coerced into making a payment can be identified from one of these questions its worth it. They’re asking you what its for as this could flag up that someones impersonating your daughter (the classic please send money i’m stuck somewhere/have had my bag stolen with phone/cards in it etc etc) or someones possibly about to scam your daughter or a fraudsters given you a story to tell the bank so payment goes through, the list of common scams is huge and once a scenario works they keep using it until banks pick up on it and red flag it.
As for the complaints team to be honest they are usually just trained to deal with complaints so that they are handled the way the bank ombudsman needs them to be- often they’ve got no experience of any other departments workings so probably can’t tell you much about fraud prevention (the bank also doesn’t want anyone to know the hows and whys of fraud prevention so that information doesn’t get into fraudsters hands to enable them to further evade the system).
What you have to remember is banks are all about profit so they wouldn’t ask unnecessary questions and keep you on the phone any longer than possible unless it was absolutely necessary as time is money- the person answering the calls probably hates asking them all but won’t be able to proceed without getting answers for them, will get calls checked at random so will face disciplinary action if they don’t ask them (and get a satisfactory answer) and couldn’t care less why your transferring money to your daughter.

WeetabixTowels · 23/08/2023 16:39

The “Hi mum” scam is absolutely rampant and they’re doing the right thing by checking

Cas112 · 23/08/2023 16:39

I personally think your being difficult.. either just tell them or make something up. Rather they did checks than didn't

commonsense61 · 23/08/2023 16:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the poster's request.

Playingintheshadow · 23/08/2023 16:38

I couldn't be bothered to get my knickers in a twist over this.

Banking is annoying. The End.

TheHouseElf · 23/08/2023 16:34

OP, I am with you 100% on this. Banks seem to be overreaching into unnecessary waters all the time. Yours is not the first story of this kind I have heard.

Don't bother with Nationwide - they are a nightmare. Nearly every online purchase I make requires a verification code, and these are to well established, well-known UK companies, nothing dodgy. It drives me bonkers.

Charrington · 23/08/2023 16:33

Banks are headache inducing on a good day, so I have sympathy for your frustration.

This https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xsLJZyih3Ac&vl=en about scamming the scammers is entertaining big but really opened my eyes to how they prey on the elderly, weaponise empathy and how much stigma there is for being a victim of a scam.

Banks play an important role in stopping this.

Pranks Destroy Scam Callers- GlitterBomb Payback

Please share this video and let’s shut them down. Jim’s video- https://youtu.be/0dT6jB2DbmkTrilogy Media's video- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YfQU_Qf_uTI...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=xsLJZyih3Ac&vl=en

MrsSweatyBetty · 23/08/2023 16:31

I had a relative who was in the early stages of Huntingtons disease, neither he nor his relatives suspected this disease ran in the family. He was targeted by a female 'friend' who managed to steal thousands of pounds. Once his family realized he was becoming ill and pushed for a diagnosis, the extent of the fraud was uncovered. The Garda refused to prosecute because he had given her the money.

Protections such as this could have stopped the fraud earlier.

Whilst annoying, there are lots of scenarios, such as this one, that are difficult to anticipate but they protect your money, not just the banks. That said, I see little wrong with the banks protecting their interests in this way. If everything is above board, there's no actual issue here.

I do think it's outrageous that London is a money laundering centre, estimated at £125bn last year. If better checks can out a dent in that, I'm all for it.

ChiefWiggumsBoy · 23/08/2023 16:27

@Allthegoodnamesarechosen

One of the branchmanagers when we were in trying to persuade them to let us move some of our own money to another savings institution told us that they are ‘ incentivised’ to hang on to as much deposit as they can ( he gave us a bankers draft for the money, I suspect he was planning to leave)

Someone is lying.

bringoutthebranston · 23/08/2023 16:23

YaWeeFurryBastard · 23/08/2023 15:28

Unlikely you’ll be questioned over this amount unless you’re doing it often.

Depends if its Natwest!

Dec 2021 - NatWest has been fined more than £264m for anti-money-laundering failures that involved black bin liners stuffed full of cash being deposited, and sums so large that one branch’s two floor-to-ceiling safes proved “inadequate” for storing it all.
The Bradford jeweller Fowler Oldfield’s predicted annual turnover was £15m when first taken on as a client, but it ended up depositing £365m with the bank over a five-year period, including £264m in cash.

MeridianB · 23/08/2023 16:23

Anything the banks can do to make it harder for customers to be scammed has to be a good thing. I'm happy to spend a few mins answering questions if it supports a process which might protect me or someone vulnerable.

Bromptotoo · 23/08/2023 16:18

My Dp and I bank with Santander.

Can normally set up and make one off payments or create Standing Orders online. However, making larger payments invokes the bank's protocols for security. I guess those are for mutual protection. Mine if I'm being scammed and the bank's so they can show they've done proper diligence if I might be.

I think I've hit that three times. Transferring half of an insurance payout on my Mother's death, paying off my mortgage and lending DD money for open bridging so they didn't lose their dream home after a buyer for the old place pulled out at last minute.

Each time the sum was over £50k. Each time the online xfer was paused while I called them. I explained why/wherefore each time. On each occasion I was told to cut the call off and they would recall me on my registered number.

All Done/Dusted. Making low value transfers after setting up the payee meant that the two involving family members had a footprint before I started.

If, as I thought they said, the OP had already moved several tens of £k including to builders etc in the same timeframe then there will, quite reasonably, be flags on the bank's systems.

Just one of those things. Not worth getting het up over. Tell them the SO is to help her get something she wants or needs but cannot afford.

Swipe left for the next trending thread