Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank Insisting I tell them why I am making a Payment to my Daughter

358 replies

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 13:28

I usually do my banking online but thought it would be easier to set up a standing order by calling First Direct today. After going through security, I was asked a number of questions about whether I had been forced to do this, had I been told to download software, was anyone watching me online etc. This is irritating, as it is incredibly unlikely that anyone who was being scammed would say yes, but I answered them none the less.

I was then asked how I had been given the bank details. I said that I had made the transfer before, but still had to give specific details as to how my daughter had given me the bank details, that I had successfully made manual transfers to multiple times over many years. After we'd got past this, I was then told I had to tell them why I was paying money to my daughter. I declined to answer, and was prevented from setting up a standing order. Complaints department confirmed that this was their procedure and they were knowingly preventing me from moving my own money around.

I asked them how much fraud they could quantify had been prevented by these arbitratry measures, they could not answer. But if I had done this myself online, then I would not have to justify my own decisions, could just do it at the drop of a hat. Bloody annoying. But a real problem for people who can't manage to use online services, who are forced to give up their privacy by rules like this.

Does anyone have a bank that will allow you to make transactions over the phone without justifying how they spend their own money, as I would like to switch to them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Gaggley · 23/08/2023 14:50

Like I said - they are asking the questions to attempt to protect themselves, not me. Glad you agree.

The IHT limit for a married couple who leave their estates to each other, and own their own home is £1M. Click on your own link to see this.

OP posts:
Floofydawg · 23/08/2023 14:49

Smartiepants79 · 23/08/2023 13:39

It’s to protect people from being scammed.
Just tell them what they want to know, or make something up. Do you really think the call centre person (who is probably in India) actually cares why? It’s just their job.

First Direct call centre is in Leeds.

I sacked them off as I got fed up of their shit service. Wanted me to go through a complete new application for an ISA because they had frozen my existing one due to no activity on it for 4 months. Went somewhere else for savings (better rate), took all my money out and did a current account transfer. I hate them with a passion.

JenWillsiam · 23/08/2023 14:48

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 14:17

I hadn't even got to the amount, so it was nothing to do with that. It will only be for a small amount as it happens.

Just for all the people who are giving out incorrect financial advice (very dangerous to do this when you clearly don't know what you are talking about) - there is no gift tax in the UK. We can all give as much as we like to whomever we like without paying any tax.

If you die, then it is possible that gifts made within 7 years might be considered as part of the estate. Gifts made out of income are not included. Gifts of certain values (the oft quoted £3000) are exempt, but this is irrelevant, given that I wasn't asking for financial advice (and wouldn't do so from unqualified strangers online), my estate will be under £1,000,000 (as the vast majority of estates are) and I'm happy to pay my fair share of taxes in general, as it is part of living in a civilised country.

To people saying I should make something up, I'm not prepared to lie in order to be able to access my own money. This is indeed what people would do that are being coerced by relatives or strangers, and is why this made up rule is completely pointless, as people who would be helped by it would just 'make something up'.

I can't set up a new standing order to a personal account online for some reason, which is why I was ringing up. I'd previously been making manual payments each month, presumably because I'd had a similar experience a couple of years ago. I'm switching to a different bank, and will gain a better service as well as £200 for switching.

You’ve missed the point entirely. By asking those questions they have the answers on file. It means they’ve taken adequate steps to prevent the fraud and therefore aren’t liable if it is a fraudulent transaction. But also, they do make a difference. Because people who are genuinely being defrauded wouldn’t make something up. And if the answers were suspicious bank won’t approve.

BetterWithPockets · 23/08/2023 14:47

OP, I know it’s not the point of your thread at all but the threshold for inheritance tax isn’t £1,000,000; it’s £325,000 unless you leave your home to your children, in which case it rises to £500,000. https://www.gov.uk/inheritance-tax

How Inheritance Tax works: thresholds, rules and allowances

Inheritance Tax (IHT) is paid when a person's estate is worth more than £325,000 when they die - exemptions, passing on property. Sometimes known as death duties.

https://www.gov.uk/inheritance-tax

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 14:46

I was going to recommend my bank. I transferred out over £30k this morning across 4 different (new) payments. I had no issues making the transactions. But … my bank is First Direct 😅

I paid similar amounts to a builder yesterday too, it's easy to do online, as I could have done for a manual payment to my daughter. However for my own convenience, I wanted to set up a regular payment, which I couldn't do online. I wasn't giving them any new details, as they already have them, as I've made manual transfers to the same bank details dozens of times. I had also confirmed that my daughter had told me the details orally, they insisted on that too. But there is no reason why I should have to tell them what my daughter is spending the money on, or why I am giving it to her. It is my choice!

I take on board the point about a 'current scam' related to parents making payments to children, but again this would not stop someone who wanted to make a transfer, as long as they were happy to say what it was for. So if I'd said "for my daughter to spend on holiday" it would have happened already. But apparently this is something I should be grateful for.

NB never used the term 'sheeple' and only ever read it on here, to do with Covid, which is completely irrelevant to this issue. I do care about civil liberties, particularly when they are being infringed in order to benefit the banks, which is the point of these questions - to ensure that people who are defrauded are liable for it themselves, rather than the banks. If we give up our basic freedoms so easily then one day we might regret it. But clearly having an opinion on this must mean I am covid conspiracist, LOL!

OP posts:
Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 23/08/2023 14:45

larkstar · 23/08/2023 14:27

I've had a lot of problems with Barclays paying for items I'm buying from Europe - fairly high value musical instruments (e.g. Czech guitar maker), paying back some Dutch friends who paid for everything on holiday together in Spain, paying a medical bill for my sister in France and also buying her a present - actually just paying for the insurance on her van as a birthday gift - on a few of these I went through my Wise account to convert to Euros.... I've had problems with about 6 payments this year - all around £500-£2.5k - Barclays blocked one payment then approved it after contact with me (phoned me) then blocked it again... so I'm now looking for somewhere to move a significant amount of my accessible savings - Barclays are not very keen on me using Wise but I've been making these kinds of transactions for several years now and it just doesn't get any easier.

I’ve had bank accounts with all the major UK banks, and Barclays are easily the most obstructive and unhelpful when it comes to transferring or just paying large amounts from their accounts.

One of the branchmanagers when we were in trying to persuade them to let us move some of our own money to another savings institution told us that they are ‘ incentivised’ to hang on to as much deposit as they can ( he gave us a bankers draft for the money, I suspect he was planning to leave).

I have no problem with security checks, btw.

Hangonasecondd · 23/08/2023 14:44

as there is no proof that this reduces fraud, given how easy and obvious it is to by

what...?

I have personally stopped many scams. Some involving people's life savings all due to tactful questioning about the payments. Hell, only a year ago I stopped someone losing a house deposit of around 90K when sending money to a 'solicitor' due to an email hack... ALL BY ASKING QUESTIONS 🤣

chocolatemademefat · 23/08/2023 14:43

I bank online and any transfer I make I am asked to give a reason. As I’m not doing anything underhand it doesn’t bother me. I couldn’t be bothered fussing over something so trivial.

WasThereAnotherTroyforHertoBurn · 23/08/2023 14:39

Nigel is that you ????😂

countrygirl99 · 23/08/2023 14:38

If you don't want banks to ask the questions to prevent fraud campaign to get the liability to repay fraud victims removed. Can't have it both ways.

LoveThisUsername · 23/08/2023 14:38

YABU for thinking it would be easier to ring them than just doing it online.

FarmGirl78 · 23/08/2023 14:36

Apethetic and passive? Oh give over!! Are you sure you don't want to go the whole hog and call us Sheeple?

user76541055773 · 23/08/2023 14:34

They were protecting you from a known scam.

If they had failed to protect you and you had been scammed, they could have been held liable. They are a business, and unsurprisingly don’t like losing money.

I was going to recommend my bank. I transferred out over £30k this morning across 4 different (new) payments. I had no issues making the transactions. But … my bank is First Direct 😅

loislovesstewie · 23/08/2023 14:33

They are damned if the do; damned if they don't. I'm asked several times by my bank if the transfer I am making is not one where I am being coerced ; if it's a genuine request. I have no objections as it means they are looking out for me as well as themselves, I pay trades and my kids by transfer and I'm grateful the bank does ask. And the same thing happened when I set up a direct debit.

Arthurnewyorkcity · 23/08/2023 14:32

You can write customer declined to answer and the customer will then sign their signature to say if they become a victim of fraud its tough luck. We had a man withdraw 20k in cash, he refused to answer. Just said it was his money and he wanted it out, fair enough. You can access and do things but if it goes wrong, it's on you. This obviously wouldn't apply on the phone though.

Pixiedust1234 · 23/08/2023 14:32

Don't go to Lloyds. They refused me access to my account (actually blocked it) because I asked for some cash at a branch. The staff had to call HQ and I had to answer very intrusive questions in front of other staff and customers. I was actually in tears as they said they wouldn't unblock it until I had answered all questions to their satisfaction. This was for less than £2K, and was last month.

And they wonder why I wanted cash...

FarmGirl78 · 23/08/2023 14:31

Because if your legitimate answer was "I've paid money into her account multiple times, but I can never remember the details, so she emails me every time to tell me the account number" and you don't see how that could put you at risk of a scam then you're the EXACT reason why they ask these questions.

The same way that when you want to transfer a house deposit to a solicitor they will tell you in advance that they will never email you with new account details.

It's frustrating but by refusing to tell them you just created an extra job for yourself.

AtoBtoC · 23/08/2023 14:31

I feel your pain OP. I do all my banking online and have several accounts and some (I’m looking at you Starling) ask those questions when trying to make large payments.

My DC recently turned 18 and so took control of their child trust fund. NS&I made it so bloody difficult for them to access their money. One ended up having to have a cheque sent out! The other had to send in proof her current account was hers before they’d transfer online.

I appreciate they are risk averse and want to protect themselves against fraud reimbursement claims but it’s gone too far in my view. I refuse to use banks who enforce the use of 2 factor verification / card readers.

NumberTheory · 23/08/2023 14:31

whatwasIgoingtosay · 23/08/2023 14:28

You cut off your nose to spite your face!! These checks are there for a reason. I often read stories in the financial sections of newspapers of people being scammed out of very large sums of money and the scammers are becoming ever more sophisticated and succeeding with younger more tech savvy. We should be glad banks are protecting us, even if it's a bit annoying.

If you are often reading stories about people being scammed, why do you think these checks are effective? That makes it sound like they’re just arse covering.

Snowy2022 · 23/08/2023 14:30

Quick one.

Bank is right- they are currently spending money on THIS exact scam so people are aware. Someone contacts you (parent) pretending to be your DC and say 'mum' or 'dad' they have lost their phone can you please send money to this account etc etc. I have been hearing these ads warning about this for the past 6 months or so.

It depends how much you also want to transfer. You don't say. Up to £20 is fine. more than that, they are right to ask.

I realised after a year that a company in Switzerland ( I may have purchased something from them in the past- I do a lot of online shopping) set up a standing order on my credit card ( I don't use it and bank could see my healthy bank balance) for $10 a month. By the time I saw it, it was almost over a year and half and the bank look at my everything and repaid it in full- around £150. it may not seem much, but that's bank's money being wasted. I then promise to check all my bank accounts every single month- I was embarrassed I didn't spot this sooner.

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 14:29

NB for all the people who think this is helping customers, it really isn't. The aim for all the extra questions (which I answered multiple, e.g. was I being coerced, being monitored, forced to download software etc), are to protect the bank from being found liable for people being defrauded. They know that they prevent little to no fraud, but if people have lied, as people are suggesting I do, then the bank will not have to repay the defrauded customers.

It is completely irrelevant to credit card and debit card fraud, which people are also mentioning. They have already taken me through security. I have attorney over my own financial affairs. I have already made payments to these bank details on numerous previous occasions. I have already confirmed that this is being done of my own free will. I was not asked how much I wanted to transfer. So how is this 'protecting' me?

They are intrusively forcing me to tell them how I am spending my own money. I said I was giving the money to my daughter. I was being forced to give reasons why. I declined. They decided to stop me spending my own money. I decided to switch to another bank. That's how a free society works. If you are happy to have such basic freedoms removed, without any knock on beneficial effects (as there is no proof that this reduces fraud, given how easy and obvious it is to bypass them by lying or giving another answer), I feel sorry for you that you are so apathetic and passive.

OP posts:
NumberTheory · 23/08/2023 14:29

I was once asked why I was withdrawing cash (it was quite a big amount, but not 10k!). I said “To buy stuff” and the woman behind the counter took a while to accept that I didn’t have any particular plans, I was just going to fritter it away on whatever took my fancy (I use this as my default now, though I rarely have to transfer so much).

I find it very intrusive and I’m not sure how much I accept that it’s necessary to avoid scams. I’d like to see some research into how effective this sort of approach is. Given how untrustworthy banks have been, it’s pretty laughable that your supposed to trust them with details you might consider private. And I think it should be possible to waive your right to be recompensed if you are scammed and they didn’t spot it because you didn’t answer their questions.

But even if the scamming thing wasn’t an issue, money laundering regulations might end up requiring some of the same.

whatwasIgoingtosay · 23/08/2023 14:28

You cut off your nose to spite your face!! These checks are there for a reason. I often read stories in the financial sections of newspapers of people being scammed out of very large sums of money and the scammers are becoming ever more sophisticated and succeeding with younger more tech savvy. We should be glad banks are protecting us, even if it's a bit annoying.

Qilin · 23/08/2023 14:28

Brigante9 · 23/08/2023 13:48

Also, I believe £3K is the annual limit you can give to dependents/family. Maybe that’s another issue, although generally banks don’t care too much about this. They’d be approached by HMRC in some cases re inheritance tax, although I don’t know if they get too involved, dunno, certainly no expert on this.

There is a limit re avoiding paying inheritance tax within 7 years or thereabouts, but not in general.

Many parents with students will have set up SOs for students equating to more than £3k with no issues at all, for example.

larkstar · 23/08/2023 14:27

I've had a lot of problems with Barclays paying for items I'm buying from Europe - fairly high value musical instruments (e.g. Czech guitar maker), paying back some Dutch friends who paid for everything on holiday together in Spain, paying a medical bill for my sister in France and also buying her a present - actually just paying for the insurance on her van as a birthday gift - on a few of these I went through my Wise account to convert to Euros.... I've had problems with about 6 payments this year - all around £500-£2.5k - Barclays blocked one payment then approved it after contact with me (phoned me) then blocked it again... so I'm now looking for somewhere to move a significant amount of my accessible savings - Barclays are not very keen on me using Wise but I've been making these kinds of transactions for several years now and it just doesn't get any easier.