Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Bank Insisting I tell them why I am making a Payment to my Daughter

358 replies

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 13:28

I usually do my banking online but thought it would be easier to set up a standing order by calling First Direct today. After going through security, I was asked a number of questions about whether I had been forced to do this, had I been told to download software, was anyone watching me online etc. This is irritating, as it is incredibly unlikely that anyone who was being scammed would say yes, but I answered them none the less.

I was then asked how I had been given the bank details. I said that I had made the transfer before, but still had to give specific details as to how my daughter had given me the bank details, that I had successfully made manual transfers to multiple times over many years. After we'd got past this, I was then told I had to tell them why I was paying money to my daughter. I declined to answer, and was prevented from setting up a standing order. Complaints department confirmed that this was their procedure and they were knowingly preventing me from moving my own money around.

I asked them how much fraud they could quantify had been prevented by these arbitratry measures, they could not answer. But if I had done this myself online, then I would not have to justify my own decisions, could just do it at the drop of a hat. Bloody annoying. But a real problem for people who can't manage to use online services, who are forced to give up their privacy by rules like this.

Does anyone have a bank that will allow you to make transactions over the phone without justifying how they spend their own money, as I would like to switch to them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
SpidersAreShitheads · 23/08/2023 16:16

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 16:02

@SpidersAreShitheads banks can't deal in the proceeds of crime. They have to rule out things like money muling. It may be overzealous in your view but how would you suggest they check?

If they were checking for the proceeds of crime then they'd be checking the source of funds from the OP, which isn't the question that she's unhappy about.

They're asking why she's transferring money to a family member which wouldn't really make any difference to what you're referring to.

As I say, I think there's a line that needs to be considered when it comes to meeting the legislative requirements without being over-zealous and trampling on privacy.

SpidersAreShitheads · 23/08/2023 16:13

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 15:56

  1. To pay her builder in cash.
  2. To buy drugs.
  3. I've been asked to give her this money by someone else...
All v unlikely but banks aren't resourced to deviate from the script on a case by case basis. The front line staff asking these questions are likely junior with no formal AML training or qualifications.

No, I absolutely agree with you that it's not the fault of the staff. They have a script to follow and they don't have the authority (or probably the in-depth knowledge of legislation) to be able to bin parts of it off as they see fit.

I think the issue here is the actual procedures of the bank. Nothing that could have been corrected on this single telephone call - it's a wider issue within the organisation with questions that could be reworded to feel less intrusive while still achieving the required aim.

Using the examples you gave - paying her builder in cash doesn't mean it's a tax scam. People aren't going to admit paying for drugs because they'd be worried about being arrested themselves. The OP had already confirmed that she'd spoken directly to her DD about the money.

I think that we're grasping at straws here to try and justify the reasons. Legislation requires checks to be proportionate - there will always be some possible wild scenario, it's impossible to cover everything.

If we're talking about preventing fraud (which seems to be the focus of this thread), the main points are that the bank needs to be certain that they're talking to the account holder, that the account holder knows who they're transferring money to, and that the account information has come from a trusted and verified source. The bank doesn't need to know how the daughter is going to spend the money to do that.

FamBae · 23/08/2023 16:12

I'm with Barclays both Personal and Business and very pleased with their balance of letting you control your own money but looking out for you. Their online banking is very good, I can set up my own standing orders online no problem, at most you get a pop up box with a warning, I can use my card abroad without having to inform them I'm away, they will contact you if something looks amiss, which I was very grateful for when I downloaded a scam parking app, they called me within five minutes; the only problem I find is that living rurally my nearest branch is 40 minutes away.

caringcarer · 23/08/2023 16:10

@Poivresel, I still was not able to exchange more than £20k per day how ever I exchanged money. Exchange rate was better than than it is now. I got a bargain on the house but it was a quick sale so I had to just go for it.

Beseen22 · 23/08/2023 16:05

I worked in a bank for 5 years and can personally remember one situation where an older couple were withdrawing large amounts of cash regularly. We asked all the questions and they kept saying it was for their granddaughter. I sat down with them and my manager as I just had a niggling concern and after a very long time it transpired that it was their neighbour who was saying she was short on cash and asking them for cash. They were a Christian couple and believed that they were not being scammed and it was their duty to give to those in need. We eventually persuaded them to call their daughter and it turns out that they had given the neighbour £7000 from their account in another bank.

Boujibroke · 23/08/2023 16:03

I bank with Santander and they ask all that information on Internet banking, then they send you a verification code. It does drive me nuts and I have been known to swear but at the same time it's good to know safety is in place.

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 16:02

@SpidersAreShitheads banks can't deal in the proceeds of crime. They have to rule out things like money muling. It may be overzealous in your view but how would you suggest they check?

Snowy2022 · 23/08/2023 15:57

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 15:51

I agree - I suspect that a customer refusing to answer questions about a transaction is likely to be a red flag for suspicion of money laundering.

I think so too, hence I don’t want to risk mine.

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 15:56

SpidersAreShitheads · 23/08/2023 15:49

I think we all accept that the questions banks ask are annoying but essential as they protect the most vulnerable individuals from being scammed.

However, the OP isn't objecting to questions being asked. She was happy to answer all of those.

The question about why she was transferring money to her daughter doesn't protect anyone. The OP had already confirmed that she had been given the details personally by her DD and that she had made transfers to the same account in the past.

Genuine question - having passed all of these previous questions and checks, what possible answer could the OP have given that would have prevented the transfer?

The question that she failed on was why she was transferring the money to her DD. Possible answers - because I want to, because I'm paying for her buy a new car, I'm giving her money for a house deposit, I'm paying for her food bill....the possibilities are endless.

I'm not sure what reason the OP could have given to that question which would have blocked the transfer?? Bearing in mind she had already passed a whole raft of security questions already relating to the authenticity of the request and the account...

If there is no answer to that question that would have blocked the transfer then that means the bank has no legitimate reason to ask the question. Security questions should be proportionate and reasonable - it's not carte blanche to demand that you provide answers to any question they see fit.

So for me, that's the crunch - what answer to that one single question would have stopped the transfer? I can't think of anything because surely it's up to the OP to give her DD money for whatever she wants?

  1. To pay her builder in cash.
  2. To buy drugs.
  3. I've been asked to give her this money by someone else...
All v unlikely but banks aren't resourced to deviate from the script on a case by case basis. The front line staff asking these questions are likely junior with no formal AML training or qualifications.
Superlegs · 23/08/2023 15:55

People accept it because they also want to be able to complain to the bank when they are defrauded, and ask for their money back

Every single thread here from someone realising they or their parent/friend/relative has been scammed has the majority of replies saying ‘complain to the bank and get them to refund the money’

So it’s totally fair that banks need to take some precautions

I had it recently moving money to DH to cover a new car. It was coming from our joint account to his sole account with the same bank, and there was nothing stopping him doing the transaction except he was driving and I was in the passenger seat.

But for 20 seconds inconvenience, you know the bank is making sure all is above board. It’s really not an imposition unless you’re doing something dodgY

Absolutely complain to bank , if you've got payment protection on a bank card after making an internet purchase, that's what it's there for.
Being defrauded of a large sum, or any sum of cash is a police matter, I wouldn't expect the bank to cover that and I doubt they would.
I would also expect the banks to be able to identify suspicious bank accounts, if they are regularly receiving large sums of money from random strangers, I would want them to monitor those closely, not average Joe buying currency for his holiday, or a used car for his kids. No common sense.

fiorentina · 23/08/2023 15:54

I had similar with Santander recently to pay for a small bathroom renovation. I work in financial services and understand the regulation and issues but the questioning felt like a police interview not a caring fraud prevention call!

Checkcurtains · 23/08/2023 15:53

Just do it online then?

You realise we are all paying to replace money lost to scams right?

SpidersAreShitheads · 23/08/2023 15:53

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 15:49

Banks have to comply with money laundering regulations. There can be criminal sanctions for bank employees if they don't. The people to aim your ire at are not the bank staff or telephone call handlers but the Regulators.

ML requirements don't specify that a customer has to disclose the reason why they are transferring funds to a family member.

That's a bank's own internal procedures, it's not required by AML rules.

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 15:51

Daphnis156 · 23/08/2023 13:42

They'll probably shut your account now because of your non-compliance.

I agree - I suspect that a customer refusing to answer questions about a transaction is likely to be a red flag for suspicion of money laundering.

Q2C4 · 23/08/2023 15:49

Banks have to comply with money laundering regulations. There can be criminal sanctions for bank employees if they don't. The people to aim your ire at are not the bank staff or telephone call handlers but the Regulators.

SpidersAreShitheads · 23/08/2023 15:49

I think we all accept that the questions banks ask are annoying but essential as they protect the most vulnerable individuals from being scammed.

However, the OP isn't objecting to questions being asked. She was happy to answer all of those.

The question about why she was transferring money to her daughter doesn't protect anyone. The OP had already confirmed that she had been given the details personally by her DD and that she had made transfers to the same account in the past.

Genuine question - having passed all of these previous questions and checks, what possible answer could the OP have given that would have prevented the transfer?

The question that she failed on was why she was transferring the money to her DD. Possible answers - because I want to, because I'm paying for her buy a new car, I'm giving her money for a house deposit, I'm paying for her food bill....the possibilities are endless.

I'm not sure what reason the OP could have given to that question which would have blocked the transfer?? Bearing in mind she had already passed a whole raft of security questions already relating to the authenticity of the request and the account...

If there is no answer to that question that would have blocked the transfer then that means the bank has no legitimate reason to ask the question. Security questions should be proportionate and reasonable - it's not carte blanche to demand that you provide answers to any question they see fit.

So for me, that's the crunch - what answer to that one single question would have stopped the transfer? I can't think of anything because surely it's up to the OP to give her DD money for whatever she wants?

Superlegs · 23/08/2023 15:48

Someone on this thread pointed out they saved a bank customer from getting scammed over buying a car that didn't exist.

The bank doesn't know if you went to see the car, did background checks on it and then had a test drive before going to pay for it in full. However if you tell then they won't have a problem with you taking the money out or doing an online transaction.

I've brought cars from dealers and they are used to people having to talk to their bank before their transactions are allowed in their offices.

If I've taken a large sum of money from my bank account, I wouldn't expect the bank to cover me in those circumstances and I doubt I would have much come back with the bank, it would be a police matter.
The person saved through these invasive questions, could equally have been save by a random conversation with the bloke behind the coop counter, it was just pure luck.
I don't need the bank to hand hold for me, I'm not a child.

CharlotteBog · 23/08/2023 15:46

Don't switch to NatWest - they will slowly destroy your soul.

Floofydawg · 23/08/2023 15:43

@Gaggley I switched to Starling as they have no fees on foreign transactions. App only but there's an online chat for any help you need. They've been great so far.

SpidersAreShitheads · 23/08/2023 15:40

BetterWithPockets · 23/08/2023 14:47

OP, I know it’s not the point of your thread at all but the threshold for inheritance tax isn’t £1,000,000; it’s £325,000 unless you leave your home to your children, in which case it rises to £500,000. https://www.gov.uk/inheritance-tax

This is correct but the combined nil rate band for spouses is £1 million which is what the OP was alluding to.

TenderDandelions · 23/08/2023 15:39

Gaggley · 23/08/2023 14:51

Who did you switch to? I've already switched my sole account but would like to switch the joint account too, so recommendations are welcome.

Not Barclays! I don't even bank with them and they're the bane of my life at the moment, re-verifying IDs of loads of businesses that I deal with!

Wouldn't mind so much but half the time they tell my clients that their records are wrong. When we check, the records are correct and it's someone at Barclays that doesn't know what they're talking about!

What's the point of doing ID re-verification if they don't understand the rules themselves??

Reugny · 23/08/2023 15:39

Superlegs · 23/08/2023 15:01

Agree with you op. Had this when I was buying a car. Wtf has it got to do with the bank how I spend my money.
Feels like an invasion of privacy, exercise in futility fraudsters are just going to lie and if you don’t want the bank to know, you’re going lie.

Someone on this thread pointed out they saved a bank customer from getting scammed over buying a car that didn't exist.

The bank doesn't know if you went to see the car, did background checks on it and then had a test drive before going to pay for it in full. However if you tell then they won't have a problem with you taking the money out or doing an online transaction.

I've brought cars from dealers and they are used to people having to talk to their bank before their transactions are allowed in their offices.

tenbob · 23/08/2023 15:39

Superlegs · 23/08/2023 15:23

Because people who are genuinely being defrauded wouldn’t make something up.

How do you know. Presumably someone being genuinely defrauded wouldn’t know. What’s the bank going to do when an old dear says the money is for a builder, even if the builders ripping them off.
if someone’s being coerced then they’re likely have someone with them when the transfer is being made, they will lie.
I just don’t think the bank have the power to do anything beyond refusing to transfer, which is likely more an inconvenience to the other 99% of customers that arent being defrauded. Totally pointless and an invasion of privacy. I’m not sure why people are so willing to accept this level of intrusion.

People accept it because they also want to be able to complain to the bank when they are defrauded, and ask for their money back

Every single thread here from someone realising they or their parent/friend/relative has been scammed has the majority of replies saying ‘complain to the bank and get them to refund the money’

So it’s totally fair that banks need to take some precautions

I had it recently moving money to DH to cover a new car. It was coming from our joint account to his sole account with the same bank, and there was nothing stopping him doing the transaction except he was driving and I was in the passenger seat.

But for 20 seconds inconvenience, you know the bank is making sure all is above board. It’s really not an imposition unless you’re doing something dodgY

YaWeeFurryBastard · 23/08/2023 15:37

LondonLass91 · 23/08/2023 15:35

It's just ridiculous tick boxing isn't it? My vulnerable dad was approached by a roofer because, the usual, a tile was loose on his roof. I was away on holiday. By the time I got back, he had scaffolding up and 4 travellers pretending the roof needed replacing. He had been frogmarched numerous times to Lloyds in Stratford ('i'll take you, mate') to withdraw money to the tune of, ultimately, 19k. They asked all the same questions, to which he said all the right answers, because he couldn't see he was being scammed. They, unbelievably, let him take out thousands in CASH. He is late 80s, deaf and partially sighted. We had no recourse, now he has lost his life savings and the scammers are obviously gone. The questions are pointless.

Please complain to the bank and ultimately the ombudsman as this is appalling and shouldn’t be happening.

Canisaysomething · 23/08/2023 15:37

Surely this is because of the widespread wellknown "mum" scam where someone gets a "hi mum" text message then a plea for help and money. Banks will be on high alert for bankers who are mums transferring money to their children. Be annoyed at the bank if you want OP but personally I'd be more annoyed at the scammers.