Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find my friend’s parenting style intensely irritating

203 replies

Hormonehell1 · 23/08/2023 11:14

Lovely friend. Her DD plays with mine really well and I don’t mind having her (friends DD) at my house playing for the day.

My friend alone is also really lovely, we never run out of things to talk about and I admire her in many ways.

BUT… whenever we meet up as two families, her DD (7) nags her constantly wanting to be bought things sweets, toys, rides etc even if my friend caves in a couple of times, her DD will continuously nag her, strop, hit her, cry, winge and ruin days out through sheer negative vibes if she doesn’t get what she wants. My DD will observe her friend getting her own way and try it on with me but I say no and hold firm not wishing to open the nagging floodgates.

Recently, we went to Alton Towers and it had cost a lot to go there. When we arrived it wasn’t long before my friend’s DD was nagging her mum for toys, sweets, and asking repeatedly to go on the paid games where they can win teddies, despite the fact that we had been to the amazing swimming pool, had eaten in the cafe and had all the rides to go on.

My friend seemed irritated with me that I wouldn’t take my DD to the paid games and ended up caving and paying for my DD to go to them. I felt as though she thought I was being mean.

I just can’t spend another day with her being too soft on her DD and both kids waking around looking miserable because they’re trying to manipulate us in to getting what they want. Especially when these are expensive supposed to be special days out.

I think her DD is like this because she gives in eventually and is sometimes brought to tears by her DD who tells her she’s a “horrible mummy”.

I’m allergic to being manipulated and if DD says anything like that to me it makes me stand firmer in my NO.

I want to see her independently of her DD and I also want to facilitate my daughter’s relationship with her DD but I can’t bear their dynamic one more time!

OP posts:
TheaBrandt · 23/08/2023 20:36

They need to be able to interact with their peers / amuse themselves for a while. Requiring full on adult attention at all times at 8 plus h Is surely not healthy unless there are SN. They are not toddlers anymore.

Polarbee · 23/08/2023 20:32

@TheaBrandt honestly after last time I was so cross because this child is also really rude and cheeky. I really like his mum but it’s impossible to have a conversation with her DS around. He seems NT but to be honest after writing down that summary of his behaviour, I wonder. DS has lots of other little friends and all of them are happy just to play together while the adults chat. If DS comes mithering me on a play date (provided he’s not hurt or upset about something) I just tell him to run and play or we’ll have to go home if he’s not capable of that. I’m quite in favour of benign neglect as a form of parenting though!

Pawpawpatrol · 23/08/2023 20:28

Sorry I realised I wasn't that clear.

I meant to say that I think you should speak to your friend. But not about her parenting. Just to explain how you parent and what your boundaries are. Eg you will not buy your daughter things from the shop or take her to the arcade etc, so will go and do something else instead if that's what she and her daughter want to do. And that you do not want her to offer to buy things for your daughter if you have said no. Then stick to this. Go somewhere else and arrange to meet if they start tat shopping or using paid for machines. Politely refuse if she offers to buy something for your daughter.

She may notice that your daughter does not constantly nag and decide to take a leaf from your book. Or she may not. But I think you'd feel less resentful if you keep your boundaries and don't let it affect your day as much, even if that means separating for parts of it.

As before, your daughter can be told it doesn't matter what her friend is allowed to have or do, you have your own family rules. And you can explain as you normally might about money spent, appreciating what we have etc

The softplay - there's really not much you can do. Either resign yourself to a coffee alone or don't arrange to go to soft play with them.

TheaBrandt · 23/08/2023 20:25

8 years old!!!

Feel your pain polar. Dh has a child in his family who demands full on focussed adult attention from at least one adult at all times. He is 8. Even my teens find him bloody annoying. We left early the last time we saw them in laws live 5 hours away and we barely got to interact with Dh brother or mil due to this demanding child. Never seen anything like it. Ours were told to “go and play” after a while at that age but this didn’t seem to be an option. Just so indulged.

Polarbee · 23/08/2023 20:18

I’ve name changed for this - I have a friend like yours, with a DC who my DS really likes, and I find their dynamic infuriating. It’s not so much that her DC asks to be bought things, it’s that he is so spoilt and attention-seeking! He absolutely won’t ever let his mum and me sit chatting - he has to climb on her and demand to be entertained, even though DS is there to play with him. He complains about being bored and talks over us and asks to have his tablet and dances around or sings for our ‘entertainment’ and when she doesn’t respond quickly or enthusiastically enough, kicks and pushes her. All forgivable in a 2 year old but this is an 8 year old! He really needs a much firmer hand and it sounds like your friend’s DD does too.

Honestly DS is by no means an angel but he’s capable of running off to play with a friend on a play date.

Pawpawpatrol · 23/08/2023 20:07

It's overstepping the mark for your friend to buy things for your daughter when you have refused.

I would keep the focus on your daughter and say that you do not buy things in shops or spend money in arcades when out and you would not want her to do this for your daughter either in your presence and after you have refused. Then you can simply explain to your daughter that different families have different rules and friend getting to play on something or buy something doesn't mean that she will. You'll need that anyway because some other kid will always have something she wants but can't have.

I don't think it's wise to comment on your friends parenting but you can ask her to respect yours. Perhaps she will observe that your daughter does not constantly nag you for things and learn by example in time.

AvocadotoastORahouse · 23/08/2023 19:40

TheaBrandt · 23/08/2023 13:17

It’s cruel to the kid too. Unless they are smart and work out how to behave themselves they become vile teens and other teens won’t be friends with them. Several acquaintances who parented like this are tearing hair out as their teens are socially isolated. Other teens don’t like tantrum throwing Verruca salt types and vote with their feet…

So true.

43ontherocksporfavor · 23/08/2023 17:55

Entrance fees should include ALL entertainment. Hate it when some things are extra, just ramps up the pestering and is a clever selling tool.

Dragonsandcats · 23/08/2023 14:37

Wenfy · 23/08/2023 11:50

I would find it massively annoying to have gone to Alton Towers with someone who then refuses to let their child have any fun. If you can’t afford to give your DD the full experience that’s fair enough but to say no to her just for the sake of it is cruel.

I personally try to do as much with DC as possible. They’re only young once and when you do stuff with them it helps them to build memories they will treasure for a long time.

Surely going to AT, including all the rides and swimming pool is fun enough?! We wouldn’t have paid for the extra games, never have.

JudgeAnderson · 23/08/2023 14:34

@theleafandnotthetree well said.

Poivresel · 23/08/2023 14:29

I would say to your friend that you and dd will meet them again in 30 minutes or so whilst the spoilt dc gets her extra treats.
The parent then has two choices, not to give in or accept that you are not going to have your dd around that sort of behaviour.

I remember standing at a zebra crossing with a friend and our 2 dc each aged 4. My ds held my hand but df’s dd refused to hold her mums hand to cross.
It seemed like an age whilst worried drivers sat and watched us too afraid to traverse the crossing and my df had a conversation about road safety and persuaded dc to hold mummy’s hand.
l would have scooped the dc up and given her the talk once over.
Indulgent parenting at its finest.

Kitcaterpillar · 23/08/2023 14:19

JudgeJ · 23/08/2023 12:56

He's possibly a good example of how the Forces can overcome poor childhood experiences! I recall how once at the end of the teaching day there was suddenly a tall, straight-backed young soldier at the door 'Hello Miss', it was one of the biggest reprobates I'd ever taught!

LOL, no. He's an example of how believing you're the centre of the universe is quite good for the old confidence.

JusthereforXmas · 23/08/2023 14:12
  • kids friends parents
JusthereforXmas · 23/08/2023 14:12

I use to think I hated other people kids, I realised I don't I hate other peoples PARENTING.

Me and my friends all have kids but we don't ever get together as 'mams' we get together as grown up friends to have drink etc... The kids start to join in the group around 16 years old.

I also don't make friends with my kids parents (I am polite but they are acquaintances) because thats DC friend not mine and I don't want us falling out over different parenting views etc...

mn29 · 23/08/2023 14:11

Totally with you, can understand why you're miffed that this spoilt a nice day out for you and your daughter. Parents who give in to nagging like this just make life difficult for themselves, my kids know that nagging will get them nowhere - so they don't do it.

aSofaNearYou · 23/08/2023 14:09

Could you not just see them at home? It seems like most of these problems are related to being out somewhere where they could be bought things.

SophieinParis · 23/08/2023 14:05

I think the soft play thing is annoying! I love playing with my children, I spend about 75% of life making up dance routines, helping them with monkey bars, listening to their “performances”. But if we’ve gone to soft play with her friend, then she’s there to play with her friend. She shouldn’t need me to dive in. She needs to know that mummy is chatting and she can go and play with her friend.

As for the extra paid things, yep I agree with you. It’s annoying. It’s not cruel to deny them literally whatever they want. Winning some game and getting a teddy really isn’t the point of Alton towers and actually giving into their every demand means you risk them not appreciating what that do have and what they are doing. Which actually I think is quite unfair to the child.

My answer would be to not do big days out and maybe just stick to house and park based play dates. Or just see the mum. It doesn’t sound like the girls are that good mates anyway if she’s constantly talking to her mum and and asking for stuff and wants her mum in soft play! When my dc are with their best friends they generally spend the whole time laughing and shrieking and having fun and attempting to avoid all conversation with us!

RonObvious · 23/08/2023 13:52

Oh man, that's a tough one. I was all ready to vote YABU for criticising other people's parenting, but I hate when my kids nag me, and have always had a zero tolerance policy on it. They know that if I've said no, repeated requests will not go anywhere. It's so much easier when you are hanging out with someone with the same parenting style, so that you can form a bit of a united front. I would probably speak to my kids in advance, warning them that nagging won't work on me, and reiterating that different families have different rules. Not sure that there's much else you can do!

miserablebitch · 23/08/2023 13:46

Physicstruck · 23/08/2023 12:13

I’d make a remark to the child directly. Stop asking your mummy for all this stuff! We’re here to have fun and it spoils everyone’s day when you have a tantrum. Sometimes they need to hear it 🤷‍♀️

Don’t do this @Hormonehell1.

It is not up to you, or anyone else (apart from the child’s parents), to discipline someone else’s child, especially in front of them! It’s a sure fire way to cause bitterness and probably end your friendship.

ChristmasCwtch · 23/08/2023 13:42

That’s irritating. But you don’t have to follow suit. I wouldn’t have allowed your DC to join in with the paid stuff. It’s sets the wrong expectations for next time.

Rosscameasdoody · 23/08/2023 13:19

Hormonehell1 · 23/08/2023 11:28

I can’t really talk to her about it because I worry that she’ll become defensive and feel criticised by me. Parenting is so sensitive and I have no comprehension of her reasoning - maybe she was deprived as a kid and wants to give her kid what she didn’t have.

I don’t care that she’s like this really, I just don’t want to waste my money on ‘nice’ days out that are spoilt by her kid’s unchecked behaviour and seemingly constant feeling of scarcity.

It feels as though they have an unhealthy dynamic and her daughter is controlling her.

She always demands that my friend goes in to the soft-play to play with her, so my friend leaves the table we are at having coffee and a nice chat, and squeezes herself through all the tunnels and gets pelted in the face by those dangling soft play punch bag things to accompany her daughter around on her hands and knees.

I’m a judgy b aren’t I!

No, I don’t think you are judgey at all. Sounds like your friend is raising a self centred and nasty child, who isn’t being taught the value of money, or that you can’t always have everything you want. Well on the way to creating a horrible control freak of an adult if something doesn’t change.

TheaBrandt · 23/08/2023 13:17

It’s cruel to the kid too. Unless they are smart and work out how to behave themselves they become vile teens and other teens won’t be friends with them. Several acquaintances who parented like this are tearing hair out as their teens are socially isolated. Other teens don’t like tantrum throwing Verruca salt types and vote with their feet…

KimGa · 23/08/2023 13:13

Have had very similar experiences with a couple of different Mum friends over the years. A couple I just stopped doing days out with as I hated the misery it brought my two saying no whilst their friends were given a second ice cream followed by a slushy and loads of money for extra paid rides etc. I couldn’t afford it, didn’t like the demand/get dynamic plus all the excess trashy food.

One friend I did manage to keep and see without her dd in the evening sometimes as her dd went off to private school which worked well! She freely talked about how she probably indulged her dd too much but after 15 years of ivf she wanted to give her everything.

I also think I’ve been ‘dropped’ in the past because I am the parent who is stricter than some others (e.g. telling kids not to swing on sculptures in an exhibition at an rhs garden, for example) and that’s fine too, I wasn’t ok with allowing that kind of behaviour so that was the end of the road…try to find people with similar parenting styles, I’m good now mine are a bit older and have found some reliably compatible friends!!!

AvocadotoastORahouse · 23/08/2023 13:09

@Wenfy you don't need to quote the whole original OP. We've all read it.

AvocadotoastORahouse · 23/08/2023 13:06

Maybe it's tolerable/kind of understandable at 3 years old - but 7??? Her daughter is going to turn into a right spoiled little madam.

I'd make sure to explain clearly to your child in front of them so they hear it too - we've paid for this day and there won't be any extras - more for their benefit than your child's who sounds more mature than the 2 of them put together!!

It's a hard one as yes she would likely get defensive but maybe just need to phase out days out until things change.