Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:23

Your opinion of my intellect and ability to read scientific literature notwithstanding, the astroturfing of the idea that males will have womb implants some day is a problem for me and others on this thread and I feel it is a relevant point, so it's like we're talking at cross purposes. You won't drive me off the thread, no matter how patronising and sneery you are to me.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 23:22

Whatthechicken · 23/08/2023 23:10

Follow the money, it always gives a clearer picture than anything else. In my opinion research into the root causes of infertility would be far more beneficial to a much larger cohort of women than the major intervention of this type of procedure - but research like that isn’t groundbreaking or sexy is it? Or probably doesn’t come with the $$$ signs. They don’t give a shit about female reproduction or health care, I think women would be naive to think they do.

Agreed. It’s a massive issue that female health in general is desperately underfunded. It’s because it’s so difficult to make it profitable.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 23:20

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:17

Being able to disagree agreeably

Happy to disagree agreeably with people who don't call me slurs like "terf" or "the anti trans brigade" or approve of people who do. It's not up to you what I consider important, I said very early, you do you, I'll do me.

I apologise profusely if you have at any point been offended by anything I have posted. Please credit thst that was at no point my intention.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 23:19

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:10

Here we see how "research" like the Imperial college paper is used to astroturf the pie in the sky idea that males are women in every way and deserve to have equality in being able to gestate their own children in their own implanted womb.

"Transwomen who want to gestate children. Even though there has been no uterus transplant to date in transwomen that we know of, some clinicians have maintained that there are no absolute barriers in anatomy, hormones, and obstetric considerations that would rule out the possibility of successful UTx in transwomen.11 Transwomen wanting to gestate children can plausibly justify subsidy of UTx on a number of grounds, as mentioned above. Transwomen lack a trait (the ability to bear children) that may cause them to experience psychological dissonance in a way that undermines their health and well-being. The lack of a uterus also closes off the prospect of gestating a child in a way that is available to women as a class. It follows that lack of a uterus is an obstacle to full participation in the social goods attached to women’s identity."

Yes, and it is a misinterpretation of the research and the discussion section, in the same way that people here have misinterpreted it to mean the same thing. People misappropriate research all the time (bacon causes cancer, the covid vaccine causes infertility, smoking cures heart disease, vaccines cause autism and many more mental daily Mail style headlines spring to mind as examples of this) for many reasons on all sides of every debate. It’s why I believe coming to threads like this and explaining why the statements in the discussion section of a research paper don’t mean what you think it means on the face of it is so important in the absence of an education system that’s capable of teaching critical thinking effectively. People are not taught to interrogate information properly early enough in their education and for a society where information is so abundant it’s massively important we correct this, but of course not at all in the governments best interests to create an electorate that can think for itself.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:17

Being able to disagree agreeably

Happy to disagree agreeably with people who don't call me slurs like "terf" or "the anti trans brigade" or approve of people who do. It's not up to you what I consider important, I said very early, you do you, I'll do me.

PowerTulle · 23/08/2023 23:14

Whatthechicken · 23/08/2023 23:10

Follow the money, it always gives a clearer picture than anything else. In my opinion research into the root causes of infertility would be far more beneficial to a much larger cohort of women than the major intervention of this type of procedure - but research like that isn’t groundbreaking or sexy is it? Or probably doesn’t come with the $$$ signs. They don’t give a shit about female reproduction or health care, I think women would be naive to think they do.

Completely agree. All the media coverage reads basically like a massive marketing campaign.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 23:13

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:03

- i'm calling the anti trans brigade the 'anti trans brigade'

You were calling women in general on the thread who were raising this issue the anti trans brigade. The disingenuousness is really tiresome.

Again you’ve asked me for clarification on a statement I made, I’ve given you that clarification, I have explained my views, my history and my politics and you have ignored it and continued to interpret me any way you like. Being able to disagree agreeably is vital if we’re ever going to make any kind of progress in both the trans debate and any other societal divides we are experiencing at the moment, of which there are many. I have agreed with you that my initial approach was probably a bit pithy, I’ve clarified my meaning and again you have chosen to override and stick with your own interpretation rather than my clearly explained intention. With respect it’s not me being disingenuous here.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:10

Here we see how "research" like the Imperial college paper is used to astroturf the pie in the sky idea that males are women in every way and deserve to have equality in being able to gestate their own children in their own implanted womb.

"Transwomen who want to gestate children. Even though there has been no uterus transplant to date in transwomen that we know of, some clinicians have maintained that there are no absolute barriers in anatomy, hormones, and obstetric considerations that would rule out the possibility of successful UTx in transwomen.11 Transwomen wanting to gestate children can plausibly justify subsidy of UTx on a number of grounds, as mentioned above. Transwomen lack a trait (the ability to bear children) that may cause them to experience psychological dissonance in a way that undermines their health and well-being. The lack of a uterus also closes off the prospect of gestating a child in a way that is available to women as a class. It follows that lack of a uterus is an obstacle to full participation in the social goods attached to women’s identity."

Whatthechicken · 23/08/2023 23:10

PowerTulle · 23/08/2023 22:54

Thinking back to my time dealing with infertility before I really questioned much around womens reproductive rights, if you had told me a womb transplant would have cured me, and I could have had a child I'd have bitten your hand off immediately and twice on Sundays

I recognize that feeling of desperation from friends who are suffering fertility problems.

Now having looked at the womb transplant Charity more closely I can see their major funders were individual donations and pharmaceutical companies. Is all this innovation helping or exploiting vulnerable and desperate women and who is really benefitting? I can’t see this ever being provided by the NHS but private surgery with expert surgeon teams (who are basically all the trustees) and the ongoing medical support would be in great demand.

Follow the money, it always gives a clearer picture than anything else. In my opinion research into the root causes of infertility would be far more beneficial to a much larger cohort of women than the major intervention of this type of procedure - but research like that isn’t groundbreaking or sexy is it? Or probably doesn’t come with the $$$ signs. They don’t give a shit about female reproduction or health care, I think women would be naive to think they do.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:06

I agree it is the extremists and not all trans people who are the problem, yes.

And the extremists are running the show, and getting ethics papers published in journals about who should fund MTF trans womb implants. And round and round we go.

Relevant current thread for anyone interested.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4877653-should-uterus-transplantation-for-transwomen-and-transmen-be-subsidized

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 23:03

- i'm calling the anti trans brigade the 'anti trans brigade'

You were calling women in general on the thread who were raising this issue the anti trans brigade. The disingenuousness is really tiresome.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 22:59

PowerTulle · 23/08/2023 22:54

Thinking back to my time dealing with infertility before I really questioned much around womens reproductive rights, if you had told me a womb transplant would have cured me, and I could have had a child I'd have bitten your hand off immediately and twice on Sundays

I recognize that feeling of desperation from friends who are suffering fertility problems.

Now having looked at the womb transplant Charity more closely I can see their major funders were individual donations and pharmaceutical companies. Is all this innovation helping or exploiting vulnerable and desperate women and who is really benefitting? I can’t see this ever being provided by the NHS but private surgery with expert surgeon teams (who are basically all the trustees) and the ongoing medical support would be in great demand.

I agree and this is another point we've probably ended up distracted from here - the exploitation of people made vulnerable in their desporation for a cure is a real problem with the commercialisation of healthcare. That's not just fertility, i think it's all medicine.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 22:56

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:47

I think the problem often with the perception of trans people is that the only voices we hear are the ones shouting loudest and they're almost always on the very extreme of the argument.

If it's them calling the shots, and it is, then they are the problem for women.

I agree it is the extremists and not all trans people who are the problem, yes.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 22:55

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:45

@SunsetBeauregarde

If you want to call males "she" that's up to you, it doesn't preclude you being critical of gender or even "gender critical" as the label that most people understand it as - there are plenty of people who do and although I don't agree with you I respect your right to do so.

But sneering at other gender critical women and calling them "the anti trans brigade" and "terf" for bringing up gender critical feminist points they personally consider important, regardless of what you think. That isn't "gender critical" in the way most people understand it, which is as a feminist or feminist ally label.

I am a feminist and I'm not calling other gender critical women 'the anti trans brigade' - i'm calling the anti trans brigade the 'anti trans brigade'. Specifically, I'm referring to people (not just women) who weaponise the extremes of the trans debate to rile up anger towards trans people. Or, more specifically in this case the people who take a news story like this, that has absolutely nothing to do with trans people in its content and use it as evidence that trans people are somehow an even greater threat to them today than they were yesterday. It's the relentless beating of the anti-trans drum, not the gender critical drum that I cannot abide. There are real and present threats to womens rights brought about by SOME trans issues that SOME TRA's are pushing for, but the mental gymnastics required to turn any discussion about women into a trans debate has nothing to do with being critical of gender ideology, it crosses the line into bigotry. I feel this is a legitimate critisism but an important distinction I recognise probably wasn't clear, and that my original reply was probably a bit pithy to make it so.

PowerTulle · 23/08/2023 22:54

Thinking back to my time dealing with infertility before I really questioned much around womens reproductive rights, if you had told me a womb transplant would have cured me, and I could have had a child I'd have bitten your hand off immediately and twice on Sundays

I recognize that feeling of desperation from friends who are suffering fertility problems.

Now having looked at the womb transplant Charity more closely I can see their major funders were individual donations and pharmaceutical companies. Is all this innovation helping or exploiting vulnerable and desperate women and who is really benefitting? I can’t see this ever being provided by the NHS but private surgery with expert surgeon teams (who are basically all the trustees) and the ongoing medical support would be in great demand.

Hearmeout · 23/08/2023 22:49

I listened to the interview with both of the main surgeons who performed this , I think whilst it's noble and very brave of the woman to donate her womb to her sister , the surgeons definitely seem to have a Frankenstein type vibe about them...

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:47

I think the problem often with the perception of trans people is that the only voices we hear are the ones shouting loudest and they're almost always on the very extreme of the argument.

If it's them calling the shots, and it is, then they are the problem for women.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 22:45

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:29

"Gender critical" is a label associated with people who campaign against gender identity ideology.

Further to this - "campaign against the overreach of gender identity ideology" would be more accurate. If people admitted that they were the sex they were, and males left women's stuff alone, and both sexes didn't try to change the language women need to fight for ourselves, I imagine most people would coexist fine with people who believe in gender identity ideology.

I agree - I think the vast, vast majority of trans people would very much like to be left alone too and have no interest in changing language for anyone not directly refering to them personally. I have only ever met 2 trans people I would describe as TRA's, both chronically online and spoke entirely in memes, even in person. As I've mentioned I meet probably more trans people in person than is typical, and most have been just the other side of the centre of the argument to me - meaning there's often a lot of middle ground we meet on.

I think the problem often with the perception of trans people is that the only voices we hear are the ones shouting loudest and they're almost always on the very extreme of the argument. So many trans people I meet absolutely HATE TRA's for how much damage they do to the community as a whole. Many don't really see them as genuine trans people.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:45

@SunsetBeauregarde

If you want to call males "she" that's up to you, it doesn't preclude you being critical of gender or even "gender critical" as the label that most people understand it as - there are plenty of people who do and although I don't agree with you I respect your right to do so.

But sneering at other gender critical women and calling them "the anti trans brigade" and "terf" for bringing up gender critical feminist points they personally consider important, regardless of what you think. That isn't "gender critical" in the way most people understand it, which is as a feminist or feminist ally label.

ArabeIIaScott · 23/08/2023 22:42

Clymene · 23/08/2023 22:40

I think this is something we can all agree with.

Absolutely.

FWIW re organ transplants, I removed my name when they reversed the consent from opt-in to opt-out. I find that coercive, and morally reprehensible.

Clymene · 23/08/2023 22:40

PowerTulle · 23/08/2023 22:04

I think you can absolutely empathize with individual women who grab the opportunity for fertility treatments, and those that take great risks and personal sacrifice to help other women. And at the same time it’s possible to question and even be critical of the moral and ethical ramifications of the same treatments.

I think this is something we can all agree with.

NeighbourhoodWatchPotholeDivision · 23/08/2023 22:38

Tinysoxx · 23/08/2023 21:52

Yes I was illustrating how long it’s been going on for and that it has and will have been happening for some time. There have been some grim experiments done over the years in lots of countries. Even in humans.

The surgeon who operated on Einar went on to conduct appalling, torturous experiments on people at one of the concentration camps.

https://twitter.com/TwisterFilm/status/1408150587175227396

https://twitter.com/TwisterFilm/status/1408150587175227396?s=19&t=zn6dO6Y9QUPt9k2J1FY_dA

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 22:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:26

Reality-based. As most people are. Not a believer in a bizarre ideology where people tell men they might have wombs if they want them.

"Gender critical" is a label associated with people who campaign against gender identity ideology. "Terfs" to trans rights activists. As you would be.

I have no doubt a TRA would call my views terfy in fact I know they do Grin I have no issue with that though, I have also been called a TRA for the exact same views by a self proclaimed TERF because I'm happy to use the pronouns someone asks me to use for them. As i said, extremism on either side of the argument is a bit bonkers to me.

Happy for you to refer to me as a realist or anything else you like really as long as it accurately represents my views, I'll continue to describe my views as gender critical because that's what they are - critical of gender identity ideology.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:34

I agree with this and it's where I'm landing I think. Thinking back to my time dealing with infertility before I really questioned much around womens reproductive rights, if you had told me a womb transplant would have cured me, and I could have had a child I'd have bitten your hand off immediately and twice on Sundays. I'd like to think now I'd feel differently, but I say that as a mother now from a massive position of privilage in that I've had my child. I can't say even now im better informed, I wouldnt make the same choice if I was still struggling.

That's understandable.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 22:29

"Gender critical" is a label associated with people who campaign against gender identity ideology.

Further to this - "campaign against the overreach of gender identity ideology" would be more accurate. If people admitted that they were the sex they were, and males left women's stuff alone, and both sexes didn't try to change the language women need to fight for ourselves, I imagine most people would coexist fine with people who believe in gender identity ideology.