Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:30

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 13:47

I have reservations, but some of the posts on this thread are completely mental.

  1. Corneas and faces aren’t vital organs and are transplanted to improve quality of life, so acting like transplants are only for life saving treatment is simply not true. There are many example of transplants being performed to improve QOL
  2. The NHS had nothing to do with this operation and there is no indication it will ever offer this
  3. Its not new
  4. No one is making any suggestion that men will receive wombs. This is because medically that’s a nonsense and if the anti trans brigade took some time to understand their own biology given they’re so obsessed with it, they’d know this.
  5. removing a womb does not trigger menopause, removing ovaries does.
  6. ALL dead donor transplants are conducted while a donor is brain dead and still technically alive, so ‘lining up brain dead women to steal their wombs’ is exclamatory nonsense.
  7. No one is going to kill you and steal your womb - these transplants have been performed for almost 10 years and if you think people will be more desperate for a womb than they are for eyes or kidneys and therefore would kill for one, then you’re reinforcing why womb transplants are a step forward to help infertile women.
  8. Womb transplants will not help the vast majority of infertile couples. There are very specific, mechanical reasons for infertility that a womb transplant might overcome, but the absolute majority of infertility issues are endocrine and not mechanical in nature, hence why even though these transplants have been available for years around the world, there has been very few actually performed.

There are very legitimate reasons to find surrogacy unpalatable and many fronts we as feminists have to be fighting right now. Spouting utter, utter bollocks in response to a consensual operation between 2 women to help one of them have a child; an operation I’ll add that YOU DID NOT PAY FOR because it makes you feel a bit icky is misogyny.

@SunsetBeauregarde um.... you're a little behind. This news has come out BECAUSE the trans lobby have been agitating for it. Pink News themselves released articles saying they will soon be available for men. So before you accuse people of being 'anti trans', you might want to actually get your facts straight. Th is is being pushed by the trans lobby and their media outlets. They, were the first to break the news, before the DM. If it is "nonsense" you might want to tell the trans lobby that....

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:20

Chersfrozenface · 24/08/2023 10:14

Pink News is not aiming to "create a culture war", though.

Its objectives are entirely different.

Pink News (or Prick News, as some of us refer to it as, due to their misogyny) is 100% ALL ABOUT culture wars. That's the entire reason they exist.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 10:17

Chersfrozenface · 24/08/2023 10:14

Pink News is not aiming to "create a culture war", though.

Its objectives are entirely different.

Are they?

It seems to me they’re pushing a narrative the same way the daily Mail does. Different motivations i grant you.

Chersfrozenface · 24/08/2023 10:14

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 10:10

Trans campaigning media is also client journalism, just different clients.

Pink News is not aiming to "create a culture war", though.

Its objectives are entirely different.

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:14

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 13:10

Just reposting the NHS article that @RethinkingLife linked to. Uterus and womb transplants clearly fall under non routine transplants and (currently) no one is in danger of having these organs taken from them without explicit and separate consent from your family.

https://www.organdonation.nhs.uk/helping-you-to-decide/about-organ-donation/consent/

Currently. However at the rates governments around the world have pandered to mens rights under the guise of trans and have removed womens rights, even re-defining us as a sex class, I do not governments on this. I say this very sadly, as I've always been up for donating my organs. When it comes to women-specific issues, I don't trust governments at all. I'm not in the UK so will have to check up on my country's procedures on this, but I will certainly remove myself if this is remotely looked at where I am. I am sorry to any potential recipients, but it is far too great a risk to me and my sincerely held beliefs.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 10:10

Chersfrozenface · 24/08/2023 10:08

@SunsetBeauregarde you say,
"Of course, client journalism such as it is in the U.K. is all too happy to amplify the trans debate because it benefits their clients enormously; in the depressing words of 30p Lee: the election strategy will be to create a culture war about trans people and immigrants."

But it's not just what you call the "client media" that are amplifying messages such as the possibility of womb implants (they call them transplants), it's trans campaigning media like Pink News .

https://www.thepinknews.com/2023/08/23/trans-womb-transplants-years-away/

https://www.thepinknews.com/2022/05/11/trans-uterus-transplant-pregnancy/

Trans campaigning media is also client journalism, just different clients.

Chersfrozenface · 24/08/2023 10:08

@SunsetBeauregarde you say,
"Of course, client journalism such as it is in the U.K. is all too happy to amplify the trans debate because it benefits their clients enormously; in the depressing words of 30p Lee: the election strategy will be to create a culture war about trans people and immigrants."

But it's not just what you call the "client media" that are amplifying messages such as the possibility of womb implants (they call them transplants), it's trans campaigning media like Pink News .

https://www.thepinknews.com/2023/08/23/trans-womb-transplants-years-away/

https://www.thepinknews.com/2022/05/11/trans-uterus-transplant-pregnancy/

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 10:08

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:05

You don't understand. It's the fact that however tiny, it exists at all. And it is a RISK that any deceased woman on the register might have their womb removed. Even if tiny, it's still a risk, so therefore a genuine risk. And many of us women do not want to even be in that position that we may be one of that 'tiny' few. It's not a 'mindset', it's a genuinely held belief. And you don't seem to understand that belief, nor respect the sincerity of that belief. Please try and respect people's genuinely held beliefs, even if it isn't the same as yours.

This isn’t a risk currently though, given that registering to allow your womb to be harvested is a totally separate register. I agree that in the future if the harvesting and transplanting of wombs becomes commonplace then the register would need addressing, but this is currently not the case.

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:05

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 12:51

@Megifer so you’ll be glad that not everyone is just removing themselves from the register then? I have never understood the mindset of those that will take an organ but not give. The number of requests for wombs to transplant is going to be absolutely tiny. The need for other organs is huge.

You don't understand. It's the fact that however tiny, it exists at all. And it is a RISK that any deceased woman on the register might have their womb removed. Even if tiny, it's still a risk, so therefore a genuine risk. And many of us women do not want to even be in that position that we may be one of that 'tiny' few. It's not a 'mindset', it's a genuinely held belief. And you don't seem to understand that belief, nor respect the sincerity of that belief. Please try and respect people's genuinely held beliefs, even if it isn't the same as yours.

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 09:58

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 12:36

I am honestly so depressed at how many people on here appear to have had the ultimate knee jerk reaction and removed themselves completely from the organ donor list.

So you won’t be accepting one either, should you unfortunately need it for some reason then? And the people who might have been saved by your heart/lungs/kidney/liver etc well bollocks to them anyway because at least now your womb definitely won’t be transplanted into a man!

I think you are blaming the wrong people here, @Tacocatgoatcheesepizza . People have beliefs that need to be respected. Donating organs is a gift, it should not be an expectation. Or done under pressure. This is a very serious concern many women on this thread have. It's a very serious topic, and a very private decision, and you shouldn't be shaming anyone. The ones who to blame are the idiot scientists who wasted precious funds on this stupid and self-indulgent idea, instead of concentrating on REAL issues like cancer, HIV, etc etc. That funding when to something so stupid and pointless and self-indulgent is infuriating. You're blaming and castigating the wrong people.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 09:51

I suspect it will be a blood supply taken with the uterus and rigged up somewhere. Again, it is a major vessel and that leaves a major weakness in that patients cardio vascular system.

Obv a female is highly likely to have an existing fit for purpose blood vessel so the risk is reduced. Still a risk, but less so.

Yes, they say exactly that in the Imperial College paper. They would need to take several blood vessels and connections. They say that it would probably be best with a deceased donor organ, but they speculate that "trans men" might be prepared to take the extra risk. Which is something else I found quite chilling. In and of itself.

Helleofabore · 24/08/2023 09:48

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 09:22

The mention of blood flow more generally is interesting - when women are pregnant their blood volume increases and there are a ton of other weird pregnancy things that happen as a result of a pregnancy that we don’t fully understand the mechanism for beyond ‘something to do with hormones’. There’s so many things about being pregnant that exist in this murky area between what is researched and knowable and what is not researched and possibly not even knowable.

I was having a discussion once with a religious man who was trying to explain how he saw the interaction between science and religion and he said ‘the things that we don’t know or can’t know through science is where God lives. His space to roam may be shrinking, but there will always be a place for him for humanity’ and that stuck with me. It applies here - there are many many things about pregnancy that we just don’t know and can’t know, where the scientific understanding does not expand further than ‘this has happened because she is pregnant’. There are literally hundreds of processes in the pregnant body that we would just have no way of replicating in a body not built to sustain a pregnancy, because we don’t even know they exist fully.

yes. We discuss this very regularly in both the threads around uterus transplants such as this one, surrogacy (because of the degree of unknown risks and so many people taking it for granted that the mother will be fine, women do it every single day). Plus in threads about males feeding secretions from their breasts to infants. Because so little is still known about the very real interactions between breast feeding mother and their infant.

The lack of knowledge, even basic knowledge, that the general male population has about the mother-child interactions does feed into this breezy belief that they should get wombs and have babies or they should breastfeed whatever the substance is that they secrete. (And by that I mean that no research has been done on the hormone, chemical content of that substance and what potential immediate, short term and long term side effects.) Yet, endocrinologists are providing this 'service' to males ? Why? Why is the research not into gaining a much deeper understanding about the female body? And yet it is.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 24/08/2023 09:43

Don't worry people, climate change will kill us off before they start any meaningful experiments on implanting uteruses (uteri?) in men.

Sisterpita · 24/08/2023 09:36

@SunsetBeauregarde I (and many trans people I meet through work) believe that TRA’s are actively damaging the trans community (purposefully in some cases) by saying incendiary and outrageous things on the internet for clout and that their views don’t reflect the majority of the trans community.

This is a point I regularly make as I can see the difference between people with gender dysphoria and males with paraphilias. Sadly too many women are captured with the Be Kind message.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 09:35

Stormydayagain · 24/08/2023 09:26

That just sounds like lazy excuses for not funding research into women's health.

Agreed, there’s no money in it, that’s the issue.

Stormydayagain · 24/08/2023 09:26

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 09:22

The mention of blood flow more generally is interesting - when women are pregnant their blood volume increases and there are a ton of other weird pregnancy things that happen as a result of a pregnancy that we don’t fully understand the mechanism for beyond ‘something to do with hormones’. There’s so many things about being pregnant that exist in this murky area between what is researched and knowable and what is not researched and possibly not even knowable.

I was having a discussion once with a religious man who was trying to explain how he saw the interaction between science and religion and he said ‘the things that we don’t know or can’t know through science is where God lives. His space to roam may be shrinking, but there will always be a place for him for humanity’ and that stuck with me. It applies here - there are many many things about pregnancy that we just don’t know and can’t know, where the scientific understanding does not expand further than ‘this has happened because she is pregnant’. There are literally hundreds of processes in the pregnant body that we would just have no way of replicating in a body not built to sustain a pregnancy, because we don’t even know they exist fully.

That just sounds like lazy excuses for not funding research into women's health.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 09:22

Helleofabore · 24/08/2023 09:09

I suspect it will be a blood supply taken with the uterus and rigged up somewhere. Again, it is a major vessel and that leaves a major weakness in that patients cardio vascular system.

Obv a female is highly likely to have an existing fit for purpose blood vessel so the risk is reduced. Still a risk, but less so.

The mention of blood flow more generally is interesting - when women are pregnant their blood volume increases and there are a ton of other weird pregnancy things that happen as a result of a pregnancy that we don’t fully understand the mechanism for beyond ‘something to do with hormones’. There’s so many things about being pregnant that exist in this murky area between what is researched and knowable and what is not researched and possibly not even knowable.

I was having a discussion once with a religious man who was trying to explain how he saw the interaction between science and religion and he said ‘the things that we don’t know or can’t know through science is where God lives. His space to roam may be shrinking, but there will always be a place for him for humanity’ and that stuck with me. It applies here - there are many many things about pregnancy that we just don’t know and can’t know, where the scientific understanding does not expand further than ‘this has happened because she is pregnant’. There are literally hundreds of processes in the pregnant body that we would just have no way of replicating in a body not built to sustain a pregnancy, because we don’t even know they exist fully.

Helleofabore · 24/08/2023 09:09

KimberleyClark · 24/08/2023 09:05

Women have specific blood vessels supplying the uterus. Men obviously don’t, so how would they establish a blood supply to a uterus being implanted into a male?

I suspect it will be a blood supply taken with the uterus and rigged up somewhere. Again, it is a major vessel and that leaves a major weakness in that patients cardio vascular system.

Obv a female is highly likely to have an existing fit for purpose blood vessel so the risk is reduced. Still a risk, but less so.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 09:07

KimberleyClark · 24/08/2023 09:05

Women have specific blood vessels supplying the uterus. Men obviously don’t, so how would they establish a blood supply to a uterus being implanted into a male?

It’s interesting that in the study the Chinese team did in rats saw significant cell death because of this very problem.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 09:05

Helleofabore · 24/08/2023 08:56

I understand. And I disagree with your insistence of excluding the discussion. I disagree that the “It is only by separating this conversation from the trans debate that we’ll achieve this.”

I fully agree the discussion on the female aspect should be had. I agree that the news reports should focus on the female aspect. However, again, the headlines for male uterus transplants are not new. They have not just sprung up with this surgery just happened. It is an ongoing discussion that you either are unaware of or wish to hive off.

How can you separate the two discussions at this point? I don’t believe it is even appropriate to do so. Narrowing the scope of discussion is where bad decisions are made.

Should the surgery be banned because potentially it could lead to male people having the surgery? No! However, discussion around how male people may end up recipients should be considered and planned for.

A poster up thread had a very good way to separate the debate and ensure we can talk about the 2 related problems separately which I will be using going forward, we are on the cusp of womb transplants, where a woman can receive a womb from another woman. Putting a womb in a man however would be a womb implant, not a transplant. I think this distinction is a great way to ensure any implications of giving a man a womb can be separated from transplanting a womb into a woman.

KimberleyClark · 24/08/2023 09:05

Women have specific blood vessels supplying the uterus. Men obviously don’t, so how would they establish a blood supply to a uterus being implanted into a male?

Helleofabore · 24/08/2023 09:02

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 08:46

The research paper quoted earlier actually refers to trans men being a potential pool of healthy wombs for transplant into women. I’m not sure of the stats on detransitioning trans men, but I imagine the numbers are significant enough to need discussion. It’s another reason why surgical gender affirmation beyond reversible cosmetics is massively problematic.

Theres another point on that too: I’d be very interested to understand how many transwomen actually opt to take up surgery vs how many say they would like the option.

A better question would be, how many prospective patients will be checked to ensure they fully understand ALL the negative side effects?

We already know that clinicians and surgeons have given gender affirming medical treatment without the full negative side effects being fully understood. We also know through clinician papers that patients arriving for gender dysphoria are being guided by over invested people and by lobby groups who seem to gloss over negative side effects. Plus the patient feels pressure to continue to remain included.

There are many aspects to this.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 09:02

Helleofabore · 24/08/2023 07:56

“Pelvic shape is one of many anatomical reasons why men can’t carry babies), the likelihood of the procedure ever becoming publicly available is I think none existent.”.

According to two male posters, one of which declared this was most definitely something they wanted (they did declare something about abortion but that may have been purely goading), all that is needed is a c-section.

“I don’t think it’s beyond possible that the medical community would lobby to transplant wombs into biological males and risk their lives in the name of gender affirmation.”

I, as others on this thread, believe the lobbying in this vein has already started. There are too many male people who believe this will happen. Rather than it being speculative and remaining theoretical, media and academics have made it seem to be just around the corner.

“I actually believe puberty blockers would probably be an existing example of when ideology has been prioritised against avoiding doing medical damage to someone in the name of gender affirmation,”

I agree puberty blockers are a very good example. And they are still now being described in media as ‘fully reversible’. Hence I no longer have confidence in clinicians and academics who are supposed to be leading the way for medical treatments for trans people. Media should always be treated with considerable care and fact checked. However, many people do no fact checking for many very different reasons.

Who benefits from making trans people believe that this procedure will be viable for male humans? I don’t believe ultimately it is trans people who benefit.

I don’t disagree with anything here, but I put far less stay in what a small number of men say on the internet. Saying it and even researching it does not make it possible, imminent or legal.

I agree that it is not the trans community that benefit from constantly being dragged through the media spotlight. Of course, there are some trans people who relish it but that in my experience is certainly not the majority. I (and many trans people I meet through work) believe that TRA’s are actively damaging the trans community (purposefully in some cases) by saying incendiary and outrageous things on the internet for clout and that their views don’t reflect the majority of the trans community.

Of course, client journalism such as it is in the U.K. is all too happy to amplify the trans debate because it benefits their clients enormously; in the depressing words of 30p Lee: the election strategy will be to create a culture war about trans people and immigrants.

I would so much rather we discuss research into women’s health as it applies to women.

Helleofabore · 24/08/2023 08:56

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 08:40

I agree with you that discussing it does not constitute rolling U.K. U.K. and beating the trans community with it - however I do believe that articles posted here with headlines proclaiming ‘wombs could be transplanted into trans women in the future study finds’ DOES constitute this. The only purpose of taking this research and drawing thst headline from it is to stir up anti trans sentiment, when the research they quote is about women.

i do separate the trans debate from a discussion about womb transplants because I want to be able to have a discussion about advancements in women’s health without needing to consider how it applies to men. As misguided, troubling and flawed as womb transplants might be, I want the thrust of that discussion to be about women and how it applies to women, not shouted over by the abstract concept that it may, at some point in the future, apply to men too. I also don’t want a woman who could benefit from a womb transplant to be prevented from receiving one because of knee jerk, dog whistle politics grandstanding to block the treatment in the U.K. based on the trans problem. I don’t trust that our current flailing, desperate government won’t weaponise womb transplants in their determination to appear to be ‘anti woke’ whatever that means. The headlines we have seen in response to the news the transplant has been carried out in the U.K. from some media is really, really tiresome. Apparently, talking about advancements in women’s healthcare isn’t interesting unless we spin it to make people angry. I think that is abhorrent.

If the treatment is to be banned in the U.K. or not, I want the reason for that to be because we have thoroughly investigated and found that the risk to women outweighs any benefit to us. It is only by separating this conversation from the trans debate that we’ll achieve this and if we continue to bring men into any conversation about women and our health, we are lost as feminists I think.

I understand. And I disagree with your insistence of excluding the discussion. I disagree that the “It is only by separating this conversation from the trans debate that we’ll achieve this.”

I fully agree the discussion on the female aspect should be had. I agree that the news reports should focus on the female aspect. However, again, the headlines for male uterus transplants are not new. They have not just sprung up with this surgery just happened. It is an ongoing discussion that you either are unaware of or wish to hive off.

How can you separate the two discussions at this point? I don’t believe it is even appropriate to do so. Narrowing the scope of discussion is where bad decisions are made.

Should the surgery be banned because potentially it could lead to male people having the surgery? No! However, discussion around how male people may end up recipients should be considered and planned for.

Sisterpita · 24/08/2023 08:55

@SunsetBeauregarde Theres another point on that too: I’d be very interested to understand how many transwomen actually opt to take up surgery vs how many say they would like the option.

Given the number of TW with paraphillia’s such as autogynaephilia, very few in % terms.

As I said on another thread the first transwoman would be shocked at the side effects of having a womb and the reality of periods and pregnancy and so would paint a very grim picture for others.