Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
ScholesPanda · 24/08/2023 13:16

I don't have an issue with this, and would be more than happy if my uterus was donated when I have no further use for it, if it could bring happiness to an infertile couple.
I wouldn't want it implanted into a man though.

OhHolyJesus · 24/08/2023 12:31

ArabeIIaScott · 24/08/2023 11:53

I am an organ donor as I’m sure most are now and would have not problem with my womb or uterus being used to help a woman who couldn’t have children.

Everyone is now ASSUMED to be a donor, unless they opt out. The rules were changed in the past few years, from having to opt in and put yourself on the donor register, to the other way round.

I checked on my status today and can see that I opted out in 2020 as that's when the government introduced an automatic assumed opt-in approach to standard transplant (heart, lung, kidney, etc).

Limbs, uterus, face and other reproductive organs such as penis, ovary, testicles remain on the novel transplant list with no government plans to change this list but at the time I remember thinking I didn't want to risk it so opted out of the scheme entirely, which didn't sit right, so I had a conversation with my next of kin.

I don't think the government, this one or future, will sanction carving us up without consent, but since then we have had academics proposing crazy ideas about 'whole body gestation' and universities conducting feasibility studies for womb implants into trans identifying men so forgive my caution over the reproductive parts of my body.

And I'm not keen on someone taking my hands either.

stbrandonsboat · 24/08/2023 12:30

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 12:08

I don't buy the it isn't possible argument. Everything at one stage 'wasn't possible'. Everything. And whether people want to admit this or not, research is being done with the aim to have wombs transplanted into trans women. That's the ultimate aim. No way do they do all this research for nothing. And no way would the trans lobby write article after article after article after article if it wasn't a possibility. People are so naive. This is yet another thing that "won't ever happen" that WILL happen. You'll see.

You're right, of course it'll happen. Where there's a will there's a way. Someone somewhere will absolutely be doing this and will keep trying until the problems are partially solved - as in trans surgery the results will be shoddy and only partially functional in most people. The hapless embryos and foetuses which will be lost along the way won't be considered at all. The trans recipients will be thrilled with their ghastly statuses as 'mothers' of non viable genetically dubious teratogenic offspring and the frankenmarch will go on.

All those saying it can't be done are wrong because what men want, men absolutely get even if it results in disaster.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 12:21

Yes, and there are thousands of example of things that have been dreamed up but have turned out to not be possible. For every research paper that leads to a step forward, literally hundreds find dead ends. That’s literally the point of doing research like this, to understand possibility. There would be no point in conducting the research if you only ever researched things you already knew were possible.

That being the case, where are the research conclusions that it is likely to be prohibitively difficult?

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 12:16

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 12:08

I don't buy the it isn't possible argument. Everything at one stage 'wasn't possible'. Everything. And whether people want to admit this or not, research is being done with the aim to have wombs transplanted into trans women. That's the ultimate aim. No way do they do all this research for nothing. And no way would the trans lobby write article after article after article after article if it wasn't a possibility. People are so naive. This is yet another thing that "won't ever happen" that WILL happen. You'll see.

Yes, and there are thousands of example of things that have been dreamed up but have turned out to not be possible. For every research paper that leads to a step forward, literally hundreds find dead ends. That’s literally the point of doing research like this, to understand possibility. There would be no point in conducting the research if you only ever researched things you already knew were possible.

The trans lobby write article after article after article that flies in the face of things that are possible literally all the time.

Chersfrozenface · 24/08/2023 12:15

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 12:08

I don't buy the it isn't possible argument. Everything at one stage 'wasn't possible'. Everything. And whether people want to admit this or not, research is being done with the aim to have wombs transplanted into trans women. That's the ultimate aim. No way do they do all this research for nothing. And no way would the trans lobby write article after article after article after article if it wasn't a possibility. People are so naive. This is yet another thing that "won't ever happen" that WILL happen. You'll see.

Even if it turns out not to be successful or safe, I guarantee some "health care" provider will attempt it before long.

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 12:08

I don't buy the it isn't possible argument. Everything at one stage 'wasn't possible'. Everything. And whether people want to admit this or not, research is being done with the aim to have wombs transplanted into trans women. That's the ultimate aim. No way do they do all this research for nothing. And no way would the trans lobby write article after article after article after article if it wasn't a possibility. People are so naive. This is yet another thing that "won't ever happen" that WILL happen. You'll see.

ArabeIIaScott · 24/08/2023 11:53

I am an organ donor as I’m sure most are now and would have not problem with my womb or uterus being used to help a woman who couldn’t have children.

Everyone is now ASSUMED to be a donor, unless they opt out. The rules were changed in the past few years, from having to opt in and put yourself on the donor register, to the other way round.

girljulian · 24/08/2023 11:34

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 10:34

I don’t really see this as different to any other organ transplant really. I follow a lady on Instagram in the US who had a uterus transplant and she is just full of gratitude and joy for the baby she is now carrying after being told at 14 she had no uterus and would never have children.

10 deceased brain dead women - again, it’s organ transplant which their families will have had to agree to. I am an organ donor as I’m sure most are now and would have not problem with my womb or uterus being used to help a woman who couldn’t have children.

Edited

Agree totally

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 11:32

Given that non negligible numbers of transmen have had children and (as I understand) often choose not to have a hysterectomy even if they don’t intend to carry a child, I wonder who would be explaining these risks to them? It’s presented (deeply unappealingly IMO) as some kind of “straight swap” in the media, like oh you are transitioning so you won’t be needing this.

As ever, female people (however they identify) are conceived of as support animals for males.

And as I said on the other currently running thread in FWR that population, for several reasons, is likely to be particularly vulnerable to pressure to take the extra risks involved.

DelurkingLawyer · 24/08/2023 11:30

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 10:44

I had wondered whether this had been raised on the thread. I am sure I have read that there are greatly increased risks to the living donor above and beyond the average hysterectomy because it needs to remove considerably more connective tissue, including more of the vagina so as to be able to connect to the (female) recipient.

Exactly. They (as in the surgical team who performed this female transplant) say in their earlier paper that for an MTF uterus implant they need to take "as much donor vagina as possible".

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6492192/figure/bjo15438-fig-0001/

Thank you for the link. I am sure I recall reading that and other papers on FWR discussion in the past. Given that non negligible numbers of transmen have had children and (as I understand) often choose not to have a hysterectomy even if they don’t intend to carry a child, I wonder who would be explaining these risks to them? It’s presented (deeply unappealingly IMO) as some kind of “straight swap” in the media, like oh you are transitioning so you won’t be needing this.

As ever, female people (however they identify) are conceived of as support animals for males.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 11:29

If you put a paper out examining how you could potentially put a womb into a male trans person, it's quite obvious that the media (and male trans people) are going to be interested in that. Especially if you follow it up with a 30 question survey of 182 male trans people to gauge demand, and produce a paper based on that too.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 11:27

Yes I have read it, Sunset. Multiple times. I've discussed it on Mumsnet multiple times and further to our other conversation I don't believe "well it won't be possible anyway" is the point.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 11:22

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 11:10

Just to clarify there has been a lot of detailed thought given by one of the lead surgeons in this first female to female transplant as to how to surmount the anatomical barriers in implanting a womb into a "trans woman". It's not just some throwaway comments in the discussion section.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6492192/

Have you read it? The detailed thought you refer to basically runs through a number of reasons why it’s unlikely to ever be possible.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 11:11

The entire paper is concerned with "uterine transplantation into transgender women".

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 11:10

Just to clarify there has been a lot of detailed thought given by one of the lead surgeons in this first female to female transplant as to how to surmount the anatomical barriers in implanting a womb into a "trans woman". It's not just some throwaway comments in the discussion section.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6492192/

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 10:51

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:41

Oh, more things that "will not happen", am I right? Trans lobby say it WILL happen. Are you calling them liars?

I could say it the other way around. Scientists are wasting money on self-indulgent irrelevant garbage like this, than actually drive meaningful research into things that matter.

Yes, I am calling the trans lobby liars. They are wilfully misrepresenting the discussion section of the research they are referencing.

YouJustDoYou · 24/08/2023 10:47

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:20

Pink News (or Prick News, as some of us refer to it as, due to their misogyny) is 100% ALL ABOUT culture wars. That's the entire reason they exist.

Exactly, Pink News is a hugely bigoted and misogynistic media outlet that is ALL about culture wars.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 10:47

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:42

No, first mentioned by Pink News and Stonewall. They are the ones pushing it.

You really are out of the loop. I suggest you catch up, because the trans lobby have been pushing this, and were the first to break the news. What does that tell you?

You're in denial. Deeply in denial.

I am not in any way in denial and this transplant making the mainsteam news because the trans lobby have spoken about it is a damning insight into the priorities of the mainstream news, it does nothing to demonstrate that men are going to receive wombs at any point now or in the future, despite research in this area.

It seems you’re reading my posts and replying as you go - I’d suggest getting to the end of them and then coming back with any queries just because there’s a lot of posts and clarifications, and repeating myself yet again will become tiresome.

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 10:44

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:38

Yet this is where it is headed, implants in trans women. And the trans lobby are campaigning really hard for this. Really hard. For them, it has never been about women receiving a womb. It's about men receiving a womb. They couldn't give a stuff about actual women receiving it. They are rejoicing in it purely because it will be happening for men.

Not that it ‘will be happening for men’ - this is important. To say it’s definitely going to happen is a massive leap from where the research is at currently.

Just because the trans lobby are dragging the debate in one direction doesn’t mean we have to follow them. We have a responsibility to talk about how this impacts women, and if we follow the trans lobby down the garden path we lose sight of the very real issues this advancement throws up for us as women.

We do not have to discuss women’s health issues as they relate to men if we choose not to. I choose not to.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 10:44

I had wondered whether this had been raised on the thread. I am sure I have read that there are greatly increased risks to the living donor above and beyond the average hysterectomy because it needs to remove considerably more connective tissue, including more of the vagina so as to be able to connect to the (female) recipient.

Exactly. They (as in the surgical team who performed this female transplant) say in their earlier paper that for an MTF uterus implant they need to take "as much donor vagina as possible".

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6492192/figure/bjo15438-fig-0001/

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:42

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 14:12

Mentioned by this thread yes, that’s exactly my point. There has been no suggestion at all that this is on the cards or even possible (which it’s not).

No, first mentioned by Pink News and Stonewall. They are the ones pushing it.

You really are out of the loop. I suggest you catch up, because the trans lobby have been pushing this, and were the first to break the news. What does that tell you?

You're in denial. Deeply in denial.

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:41

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 14:12

i agree, we SHOULD be focusing on existing children and not on culture wars about stuff that hasn’t, will not and cannot ever (biologically) happen.

Instead though, the feminism boards are flooded with completely irrelevant trans threads because it’s more fun to be outraged than it is to actually drive meaningful conversations about change.

Oh, more things that "will not happen", am I right? Trans lobby say it WILL happen. Are you calling them liars?

I could say it the other way around. Scientists are wasting money on self-indulgent irrelevant garbage like this, than actually drive meaningful research into things that matter.

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 10:38

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 14:08

This thread is not about trans women, it’s about a woman who has received a donor womb from her sister.

Yet this is where it is headed, implants in trans women. And the trans lobby are campaigning really hard for this. Really hard. For them, it has never been about women receiving a womb. It's about men receiving a womb. They couldn't give a stuff about actual women receiving it. They are rejoicing in it purely because it will be happening for men.

DelurkingLawyer · 24/08/2023 10:34

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 09:51

I suspect it will be a blood supply taken with the uterus and rigged up somewhere. Again, it is a major vessel and that leaves a major weakness in that patients cardio vascular system.

Obv a female is highly likely to have an existing fit for purpose blood vessel so the risk is reduced. Still a risk, but less so.

Yes, they say exactly that in the Imperial College paper. They would need to take several blood vessels and connections. They say that it would probably be best with a deceased donor organ, but they speculate that "trans men" might be prepared to take the extra risk. Which is something else I found quite chilling. In and of itself.

I had wondered whether this had been raised on the thread. I am sure I have read that there are greatly increased risks to the living donor above and beyond the average hysterectomy because it needs to remove considerably more connective tissue, including more of the vagina so as to be able to connect to the (female) recipient.