Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
Ohhbaby · 23/08/2023 12:12

GrumpyOldCrone · 23/08/2023 10:44

I agree with this.
I also don’t see this as a slippery slope to implanting wombs in men.

This will age well. Once we actually do start implanting it into men.

Brokendaughter · 23/08/2023 12:11

I took myself completely off the donor list when they changed it to forcibly taking your body parts if you don't opt out (& still trying to emotionally blackmail relatives to override your wishes even if you do opt out because they are that disgusting.)

The govt is treating the bodies of citizens/subjects as a commodity.

If anyone thinks one woman getting a womb transplant means any other donations will be used to help women, they are a fool too.

That would be discrimination against men who want to use your body parts to have an abortion, as they crave that experience.

Being on the donor list means your womb could eventually be used to help a man murder an unborn child.

Are potential donors okay with that?
You don't get to chose which person gets your body parts or what they do with them.

KimberleyClark · 23/08/2023 12:11

Bonjovispjs · 23/08/2023 12:07

They were discussing it on Jeremy Vine this morning too. Again all raving about how amazing it is, I disagree.

Yes anything that enables a woman to have a baby is seen as an unalloyed Good Thing. Ethics seem to have gone out the window as far as reproductive technology is concerned. Even when it’s women in their 60s and beyond, it’s “yay brilliant”.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 23/08/2023 12:11

I'm uneasy about anything that puts the potential baby's health and welfare below that of the mother's desires and those articles posted by a pp definitely show that there are risks to a foetus from transplant organ anti rejection drugs. It seems like the baby is an after thought in the story. I could never ask my sister to undergo major surgery for something like this.

Like a pp I've just gone onto the organ donation site and registered that I don't want to donate 'tissue' because that sounds like it could mean anything.

RampantIvy · 23/08/2023 12:11

I agree with you @VestaTilley

I hate the way that having a baby is so commoditised these days:

Partner - tick
Home - tick
Fancy holidays - tick
nice car - tick
Baby (with or without a partner) - tick

Cynicaltheorist · 23/08/2023 12:11

So your against hand transplants for kids who have lost their hands? Face transplants for the completely disfigured? You want to ban research into eye transplants for blind people? None of this 'saves lives'.

The woman was born with Type 1 Mayer -Rokitansky , she had no uterus, if you deny her a chance to be a mum, I'm guessing you're against all forms of IVF.

Yours isn't a rational argument. Trying to replace a hand for a child who has had it severed or repairing disfigurements are absolutely not the same as removing an organ from one person to place inside another in order that that person, who could have lived a perfectly fine and normal life without it, achieves their wishes.

Some women who want children can't have them. I'm one of them. You can't always get what you want in life. No one has the right to a child. To extrapolate from this that anyone opposing a uterine transplant must be anti-IVF makes no sense at all. It's possible to support IVF and be very firmly against uterus transplants.

JudgeAnderson · 23/08/2023 12:10

Great that the adult gets what she wants, less great for the children who have been exposed to large amounts of immune-suppressing druge in utero.

Possimpible · 23/08/2023 12:09

MillWood85 · 23/08/2023 12:06

I'm a bit confused. I had 2 C sections with my last 2 children, and was told very firmly after the last that my uterus wouldn't hold through another pregnancy. The surgeon explained it was like a giant balloon, and once you'd cut through it twice, it just wouldn't hold and blow up again. So surely when they do a transplant, it has a cut somewhere even if at the base of the uterus? I don't understand how it then be safe to carry a term pregnancy.

I'm also horrified by the 9 hours it took to remove the uterus and then 8 hours to transplant it.... then it only lasts for 5 years?! How on earth can this be provided on the NHS if done. I don't agree with that at all. No one has the right to carry a child, sorry.

Cannot believe this post. So you're okay to accept medical advances and NHS resource when it benefits you (without the C section presumably you and/or the babies would have died), but not when it benefits an infertile woman? Speaking from your position of privilege. I find this post disgusting actually.

Also you can be confused all you like, you're not the operating surgeon, you don't need to understand!

BadNomad · 23/08/2023 12:08

If transplants are only supposed to be life-saving then I guess we'll have to stop transplanting corneas, limbs, hands etc.

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 12:08

ArabeIIaScott · 23/08/2023 11:50

'Prof Smith, who is Chairman of Womb Transplant UK, said the team had been authorised to carry out a total of 15 transplants - five with live donors and 10 with deceased, brain-dead donors'

What the FUCK?

I took my name off the donor register a few years back, partly because of exactly this type of risk. If you don't, consent is assumed.

https://www.organdonation.nhs.uk/

There is absolutely nothing there to suggest a problem - live donors have clearly consented and the 10 deceased will be organ donors and the families will have agreed also. Plus it’s not like this is all happening imminently and someone has gone out hunting for 10 brain dead women. As with any organ donation you’ll need a recipient first, who will go through testing and counselling, and then be on a waiting list should a donor come up. There is an implication on this thread that some people seem to think these 10 dead women are bodies that have been acquired in some nefarious manner rather than the lengthy and careful process it no doubt will be.

Bonjovispjs · 23/08/2023 12:07

They were discussing it on Jeremy Vine this morning too. Again all raving about how amazing it is, I disagree.

CwmYoy · 23/08/2023 12:07

That's me off the donor list.

It's grotesque.

MillWood85 · 23/08/2023 12:06

I'm a bit confused. I had 2 C sections with my last 2 children, and was told very firmly after the last that my uterus wouldn't hold through another pregnancy. The surgeon explained it was like a giant balloon, and once you'd cut through it twice, it just wouldn't hold and blow up again. So surely when they do a transplant, it has a cut somewhere even if at the base of the uterus? I don't understand how it then be safe to carry a term pregnancy.

I'm also horrified by the 9 hours it took to remove the uterus and then 8 hours to transplant it.... then it only lasts for 5 years?! How on earth can this be provided on the NHS if done. I don't agree with that at all. No one has the right to carry a child, sorry.

babbscrabbs · 23/08/2023 12:05

MsFannySqueers · 23/08/2023 10:43

@WeetabixTowels it was paid for by a charity apparently £25,000. The doctors involved gave up their time for free. Maybe the doctors could have given their time for free to clear some of the backlog of patients who actually need medical procedures.

Would you do your paid job for free then?

WeWereInParis · 23/08/2023 12:05

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 11:13

Agree @Tinysoxx and we bet nobody has done any research in to the effects on the foetus of the woman taking immuno suppressives.

What? Women who have received transplants (other transplants I mean, not wombs) have babies. The effects (or not) of anti rejection drugs is probably fairly well known.

MadamePickle · 23/08/2023 11:59

It makes me extremely uncomfortable. It's unnecessary, for one thing. And there seems to be very little consideration of the donor. Studies show that across the board, women who have hysterectomies die younger, regardless of the reason for the surgery (so it doesn't matter whether it was cancer or a benign condition). If they are premenopausal, they tend to go into menopause fairly quickly as the surgery seems to lead to ovarian failure. It's not clear why. It also impacts bladder, bowel, and sexual function. Oh, and leaves you irreversibly infertile. I think it's a surgery that is carried out very casually and everyone treats it that way when they shouldn't. (I had to have one in my 30's, BTW). I want to see that side of it talked about bluntly and openly when people are waffling on about if the woman consents to the donation what's the problem she doesn't need her uterus anyway.

LateSummerLobelia · 23/08/2023 11:59

Notmytiep · 23/08/2023 11:39

not in so many words

You said @Butritobaby that anyone who said it could happen were stupid and wearing tin foil hats.

Just own it.

Pencilsaremylife · 23/08/2023 11:58

When I had a complete hysterectomy with a full incision last year, if they asked at the time if they could use any bits in a transplant I would have said yes. Would I have agreed to a slightly longer operation time to make this possible, yes as long as it was reasonable and didn’t increase complications for me. My womb ovaries etc were of no further use to me. I’m also of the opinion that once I’m certified brain dead they can take whatever they want.

Spottyness · 23/08/2023 11:56

Stormydayagain · 23/08/2023 11:55

The disturbing thing with all this is that the only successful live birth via a uterus being transplanted into a male (rat) involved attaching the male rat to a female rat in a parasitic relationship for the duration of the pregnancy.

Very messed up that anyone is even considering this as a possibility for humans.

Oh wow, that’s horrific, those poor rats! What a waste of research time and funding (re the rats), it makes me so frustrated.

Knickerbockerglories · 23/08/2023 11:56

Chersfrozenface · 23/08/2023 10:45

As soon as I first heard of womb transplants being mooted, I opted out of organ donation.

I'm very sorry about those who might have benefitted from any other of my usable body parts, but until there is a specific, cast-iron opt-out for reproductive organs, I'm a non-donor.

As an organ recipient, who would not be alive today without donation, I would just ask that anyone considering removing themselves from the donor register because of this to discuss it with the donor register and their family. There is an option to select what you donate I.e. heat only etc which would possibly solve this specific issue for you.

i firmly believe that organ donation is a gift and a choice (either way) and should not be judged BUT, please make you family aware of your wishes so that they can fulfil them knowing what you want… don’t leave them with difficult decisions and possible regrets because of not knowing what your wishes are (whatever they are) at a difficult time for them.

Stormydayagain · 23/08/2023 11:55

Spottyness · 23/08/2023 11:51

They had people on sky news this morning going on about how great it is and how it could be used to help trans women “give birth naturally” - males can’t give birth, aren’ we’re doing a disservice to give them hope otherwise. I’ll be opting out of organ donation this afternoon

The disturbing thing with all this is that the only successful live birth via a uterus being transplanted into a male (rat) involved attaching the male rat to a female rat in a parasitic relationship for the duration of the pregnancy.

Very messed up that anyone is even considering this as a possibility for humans.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 23/08/2023 11:54

TibetanTerrah · 23/08/2023 11:46

I'm on the register donating everything, I don't care, I'll be dead. But I'm pretty sure there was the option to tick what you did/didn't want to donate when I joined 15 ish years ago.

For that reason, I don't really think the '10 braindead women' should be put forward when they can't explicitly consent.

And there's a level of emotional manipulation, even if it's not deliberate between a living transplant like these sisters which I don't think is ethical.

When I went on the register years ago I asked whether the list of organs would be updated as time went on and whether potential donors would be told of this if they'd ticked all. I was told no so came off the register.

drivinmecrazy · 23/08/2023 11:53

I'm sure that if this were the 17th century they would be horrified at the thought of a heart transplant, on religious and societal grounds.

Now a days it's an accepted part of our medical arsenal.
Much like today where I know many people opt out of corneal retrieval.

Science has its frontiers and this is one.

I'm lucky enough to have had two healthy pregnancies resulting in two perfect children.

Who am I to deny that to another woman.

It has not used NHS resources.
It is completely consensual and I wish these women nothing but luck for the future.

As for the organ trafficking argument, what does it matter if they're grabbing people off the streets for kidneys or wombs, the problem is still the same.

'Ours is not to reason why: ours is but to do or die'

SunsetOverParadise · 23/08/2023 11:52

In the words of the infamous Dr Ian Malcolm:

“Yeah, yeah, but your scientists were so preoccupied with whether or not they could that they didn't stop to think if they should.”

This is precisely why I am not an organ donor.

U.K. first womb transplant | Mumsnet

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4878641-uk-first-womb-transplant

Quietisgood · 23/08/2023 11:52

When I saw this reported on BBC this morning, I found it chilling. I was disturbed by the cheery and upbeat way it was reported, even having an infertile woman on to discuss her hope for getting onto a waiting list for the surgery. There was little effort to balance the argument of the ethical issues around this, just what a "good news" story it was. Offering hope where they shouldn't be, as its very unlikely that this will become a easily available option for infertility any time soon. Aside from the moral question about this, there are huge risks involved with this type of surgery for the donor and recipient. It appears to be high risk to carry a pregnancy after transplant, and what are the side effects of immunosuppressive drugs on the developing foetus?
Like many others on here I am disturbed about reducing women to body parts, and where this leads us in the future.
Individual's wants and feelings should not be prioritised over moral and ethical medicine practice. I feel awful for someone experiencing infertility, but putting other people at risk to achieve what you want is morally wrong. Wouldn't this money be better used improving women's health care, for example earlier cancer screening, better cancer care, and investigating and developing better treatment and care for infertility and recurrent miscarriage etc?

Swipe left for the next trending thread