Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
Megifer · 23/08/2023 12:25

Yanbu. I've now opted out of the donor list because of this.

I'd still happily receive a kidney or whatever.

Yea, I'm a hypocrit.

ScallyWaggyWoo · 23/08/2023 12:25

Absolutely horrifying tbh.

RampantIvy · 23/08/2023 12:24

Babies are a gift, not a commodity and nobody has a right to have one.

I agree. Reproducing is not a basic human right. I would argue that having the freedom to do so without extra intervention might be though.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 23/08/2023 12:23

They don't have "10 brain dead women lined up" - the article says that they have been authorised to carry out 15 womb transplants - 10 from brain dead donors, nowhere does it say that these donors are available immediately, much less "lined up".

MustardChair · 23/08/2023 12:22

I have just opted out of organ donation. It was really easy and I am sure I can opt back in at some point. I know the pp said that womb donation is separate but maybe for now. Governments have a habit of changing laws, I find.

Esmereldapawpatrol · 23/08/2023 12:22

Butritobaby · 23/08/2023 11:01

Yes because that’s rife with peoples livers and lungs currently

Exactly, It's hardly a back street procedure is it?

If you saw the woman being interviewed this morning who is hoping to receive a womb transplant you may change your mind. She had womb cancer in her early twenties, has her own embryos to use. I hope she gets the chance to carry her own child and feel the joy that brings.

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 12:22

Cynicaltheorist · 23/08/2023 12:16

There is absolutely nothing there to suggest a problem - live donors have clearly consented and the 10 deceased will be organ donors and the families will have agreed also. Plus it’s not like this is all happening imminently and someone has gone out hunting for 10 brain dead women. As with any organ donation you’ll need a recipient first, who will go through testing and counselling, and then be on a waiting list should a donor come up. There is an implication on this thread that some people seem to think these 10 dead women are bodies that have been acquired in some nefarious manner rather than the lengthy and careful process it no doubt will be.

This is sort of Womb Transplants - No Debate, isn't it? We've been here before with the Gender Recognition Act to enable a few sweet, muddled gender dysphorics to marry and live their lives as the opposite sex.

Don't worry, Ladies, nothing unusual going on here, just doctors exploiting the brain-dead for bits, perfectly normal. Trust me, I'm a doctor, and anyway it's not going to be happening next week. Women, Know Your Place – and it's not to be worrying about things you don't really understand.

I would be happy to donate my womb and uterus once I’m dead along with any other organ that is of use to someone still living (yes caveat not to a man, that is ridiculous and I would be totally against that) and I don’t think I’m the only one on here who would do that.

How is that exploitation?

WeWereInParis · 23/08/2023 12:22

TibetanTerrah · 23/08/2023 11:46

I'm on the register donating everything, I don't care, I'll be dead. But I'm pretty sure there was the option to tick what you did/didn't want to donate when I joined 15 ish years ago.

For that reason, I don't really think the '10 braindead women' should be put forward when they can't explicitly consent.

And there's a level of emotional manipulation, even if it's not deliberate between a living transplant like these sisters which I don't think is ethical.

"And there's a level of emotional manipulation, even if it's not deliberate between a living transplant like these sisters which I don't think is ethical."

Do you feel the same way about living donors for other organs eg kidneys?

ApiratesaysYarrr · 23/08/2023 12:21

UsernameNotAvailableNow · 23/08/2023 10:41

@WeetabixTowels it was funded by a charity, so not the NHS thankfully. The fella that did the op is head of the charity. So led by a bloke obviously.

While the organ retrieval was carried out by a male surgeon the team that implanted the womb was led by a woman "Transplant surgeon Isabel Quiroga, who led the team implanting the womb, said the recipient was delighted:"

readbooksdrinktea · 23/08/2023 12:21

WeetabixTowels · 23/08/2023 10:39

Also has the NHS struck gold? I’ve been waiting fucking years for very minor surgery that I had to beg for to ensure I’m not in pain every day. But they can spend money on what is essentially an experimental surgery

This would absolutely infuriate me if I was waiting for an operation.

Agree with you, OP.

Janiie · 23/08/2023 12:19

Just awful. Such a waste or time and resources. I know it was done privately but surely the team could've been put to better use with actual life saving ops.

A uterus is not a vital organ. I know plenty of people who have had fertility problems and I doubt any would consider this.

LBFseBrom · 23/08/2023 12:19

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

porridgecake · 23/08/2023 12:19

"Again, it’s simply stupid to think this will lead to women being snatched off the streets and their wombs ripped out."

You mean like what happens to children and vulnerable adults in parts of India, for example, for their kidneys?

RampantIvy · 23/08/2023 12:18

And I would still stand by it if I hadn't been able to have DC.

RampantIvy · 23/08/2023 12:17

TakeNoNoticeoftheNoise · 23/08/2023 12:14

I wonder how many of these comments are from non-infertile women who easily conceived?

It took me 17 years to conceive DD, but I still stand by my opinion.

porridgecake · 23/08/2023 12:16

A family member has had a kidney transplant and has to take large amounts of immunosuppressive drugs every day. The side effects are really quite severe. Goodness knows what the effect would be on a fetus. When you consider that pregnant women are exhorted to avoid medication, alcohol, certain foods, I find it hard to believe that it is going to be ok to take all the necessary drugs all through pregnancy. What happens if organ rejection starts happening during the pregnancy?

SunsetOverParadise · 23/08/2023 12:16

Butritobaby · 23/08/2023 11:14

Again, it’s simply stupid to think this will lead to women being snatched off the streets and their wombs ripped out.

Silly but not surprising for many on here

Why? This is precisely what happens for less high stakes purposes, such as sex. Sec trafficked women and girls are a huge problem. And since we already know the lengths men will go to in order to skip U.K. surrogacy laws and buy women’s bodies elsewhere, not to mention the huge costs they’re willing to pay to make sure the child is biologically theirs, this is a huge concern.

Is your life so comfortably removed from women in poverty in other countries that you think none of this is happening?

UsernameNotAvailableNow · 23/08/2023 12:16

I had this response from the organ donation people:

“Womb transplantation is not part of the opt out system for donations (ie. you have to opt in and meet strict criteria). All adults in the UK are now considered to have agreed to be an organ and tissue donor when they die unless they have recorded a decision not to donate or are in one of the excluded groups. This is commonly referred to as an ‘opt out’ system. Womb transplantation is not part of this system.”

“Therefore unless you explicitly arrange with your family for womb/uterus donation to go ahead it absolutely will not be considered.”

Cynicaltheorist · 23/08/2023 12:16

There is absolutely nothing there to suggest a problem - live donors have clearly consented and the 10 deceased will be organ donors and the families will have agreed also. Plus it’s not like this is all happening imminently and someone has gone out hunting for 10 brain dead women. As with any organ donation you’ll need a recipient first, who will go through testing and counselling, and then be on a waiting list should a donor come up. There is an implication on this thread that some people seem to think these 10 dead women are bodies that have been acquired in some nefarious manner rather than the lengthy and careful process it no doubt will be.

This is sort of Womb Transplants - No Debate, isn't it? We've been here before with the Gender Recognition Act to enable a few sweet, muddled gender dysphorics to marry and live their lives as the opposite sex.

Don't worry, Ladies, nothing unusual going on here, just doctors exploiting the brain-dead for bits, perfectly normal. Trust me, I'm a doctor, and anyway it's not going to be happening next week. Women, Know Your Place – and it's not to be worrying about things you don't really understand.

TakeNoNoticeoftheNoise · 23/08/2023 12:14

I wonder how many of these comments are from non-infertile women who easily conceived?

daffodilandtulip · 23/08/2023 12:13

indyocean · 23/08/2023 10:35

Christ alive

I see it coming. Pregnant blokes 😳

This was my first thought.

KimberleyClark · 23/08/2023 12:13

Cynicaltheorist · 23/08/2023 12:11

So your against hand transplants for kids who have lost their hands? Face transplants for the completely disfigured? You want to ban research into eye transplants for blind people? None of this 'saves lives'.

The woman was born with Type 1 Mayer -Rokitansky , she had no uterus, if you deny her a chance to be a mum, I'm guessing you're against all forms of IVF.

Yours isn't a rational argument. Trying to replace a hand for a child who has had it severed or repairing disfigurements are absolutely not the same as removing an organ from one person to place inside another in order that that person, who could have lived a perfectly fine and normal life without it, achieves their wishes.

Some women who want children can't have them. I'm one of them. You can't always get what you want in life. No one has the right to a child. To extrapolate from this that anyone opposing a uterine transplant must be anti-IVF makes no sense at all. It's possible to support IVF and be very firmly against uterus transplants.

Agreed on all counts. I couldn’t have children either.

enchantedsquirrelwood · 23/08/2023 12:13

I took myself completely off the donor list when they changed it to forcibly taking your body parts if you don't opt out (& still trying to emotionally blackmail relatives to override your wishes even if you do opt out because they are that disgusting

This is a completely different point in my view. I don't agree with opt out, but I don't think relatives should be able to override your wishes - if you are on the register, that should be that.

SunsetOverParadise · 23/08/2023 12:13

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/08/2023 11:11

JudgeAnderson · Today 10:36
I don’t really see this as different to any other organ transplant really

I do. Other organ transplants are to keep you from dying or going blind”

Absolutely this. We have lost sight of what the NHS was intended for. Medical needs, not wants.

With millions on waiting lists for potentially life saving treatment I imagine a great deal more good could have been done with the funds and time of 20 surgeons.

This is partly why the NHS is screwed. It was never intended for non-life saving treatments, and as a nation we can’t afford it as it stands. It’s why I’m also against NHS-funded IVF or trans surgeries (there are also other reasons for the latter).

enchantedsquirrelwood · 23/08/2023 12:12

I have been on the organ donation register since I was about 18 and I doubt anyone would want my peri-menopausal uterus so I won't change anything - as someone says, once I'm dead I don't care who uses what.

But I do make a distinction between I "need" (corneas to save sight) and I "want" (a womb to grow a baby). Nobody "needs" to have a child, but eyesight is pretty important!