Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/08/2023 15:52

@Helleofabore see the linked video I posted of Helen Joyce interview with Megyn Kelly. Everyone should watch that.

x.com/j4ppleby/status/1694756969054167215?s=46&t=SPorwN-mokktL467rcZ57g

Helleofabore · 25/08/2023 14:53

Here is another reminder of how it is not hard to find male people with trans identities discussing their abortion fetishes:

@graceelavery
Just realized: someone alive today will
become the first trans woman to get an
abortion. <3
7:15 pm • 05/04/2021

Lavery is a very prominent trans academic who is British but lives and works in USA. And somewhat an author who dedicates books to Lavery's penis. It is really not hard to find comments like this when you start to notice them.

Teder · 25/08/2023 13:59

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 24/08/2023 18:55

Your heart could go to someone who has committed murder, your lungs could go to a rapist. If you gift organs, you gift them. If you don’t want to give them, then fine but you cannot assign morality to it. Either do or don’t.

Womb transplants that may happen to indulge male fetishes are Frankenstein surgery so yes, I will assign morality to it. I will gift heart, lungs etc. and I hope they don't go to someone undeserving but I will never agree to my reproductive organs being donated (along with skin, tissue etc.)

Perhaps I was not clear.

I did say you’re within your rights to choose not
to donate any organ for any reason. Some people choose not to donate at all for moral reasons. I’m saying if you donate organs (wombs aside) then you have no say on the type of human who receives them. So, if you do want a say, just don’t donate.

RethinkingLife · 25/08/2023 09:42

I didn't know that the live birth in Sweden was from the uterus of a 61 year old woman!

Case study was published if you'd like to see a little more.

The uterus was donated from a living, 61-year-old, two-parous woman. In-vitro fertilisation treatment of the recipient and her partner had been done before transplantation, from which 11 embryos were cryopreserved.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25301505/

Livebirth after uterus transplantation - PubMed

Jane and Dan Olsson Foundation for Science.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25301505

OhHolyJesus · 25/08/2023 09:20

Helleofabore · 25/08/2023 08:15

Fascinating link, lots more detail than found on the bbc website. The fact that this woman had her first period with the transplant is interesting because...

"The surgery went well, but after the 26 year old woman's second menstrual cycle, the blood supply to the new uterus failed and the uterus began to die, requiring surgeons to remove the organ just three months after the transplant."

Also I didn't know that the live birth in Sweden was from the uterus of a 61 year old woman!

A good find @Helleofabore

ArabeIIaScott · 25/08/2023 08:54

Well, we could do with a lot more information and awareness about how to prepare for death in general, tbh.

Perhaps a gov.uk website would help; this kind of thing could be signposted and explained and linked to.

Slothtoes · 25/08/2023 08:39

I’m on the organ donor register for taking anything at all. I’m happy with that.

They aren’t allowed to take my reproductive organs without consent plus my peri menopausal uterus full of fibroids is no good to anyone. This is because I believe you only get one life on earth and I want to benefit those I leave behind. I want to be able to accept a donor organ without qualm for me or anyone I love if needed. That’s just how I feel, but anyone else is completely free to feel how they feel.

I absolutely agree with all of the posters who think organ donation must be based on rock solid consent and that presumed consent with an opt out is in that light a worse arrangement than an active consent with a funded perpetual publicity campaign to recruit donors. However that consideration is Inope mitigated to an extent by lives saved. By this time culturally this presumption should be bedding in so people who want to opt out should be doing it.

However we all know that in practice there isn’t much information around this that you can’t miss seeing, which is a poor consent arrangement because most people have busy lives and lots of more urgent things to think about and they will easily not have ever thought about this.

However my understanding is that presumed consent means that any hint of disagreement from the bereaved family is respected so that’s another thing to think about and talk about( if you have a family) while you’re still fit and well and before you opt out, if that will be your decisIon.

ArabeIIaScott · 25/08/2023 07:44

OhHolyJesus · 25/08/2023 07:25

Yes I would think so, once the data has come through.

It would be interesting to see how much this story affects overall numbers.

This one from 2021, a year after the change to auto opt in, was refused on cost grounds.

https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/nooffswitchersfrommoptinntoo#incoming-1741680

You'd think they'd have figures already, really, it's not a complicated request!

OhHolyJesus · 25/08/2023 07:25

ArabeIIaScott · 24/08/2023 22:12

One could probably FOI that?

Yes I would think so, once the data has come through.

It would be interesting to see how much this story affects overall numbers.

This one from 2021, a year after the change to auto opt in, was refused on cost grounds.

https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/nooffswitchersfrommoptinntoo#incoming-1741680

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/08/2023 00:22

One of those noisy extremists discussed upthread in a revealing video shown in a recent interview with author of bestselling book Trans, Helen Joyce. Listen to the descriptions of a womb implant this person uses and have a think about what motivates them. She says what she feels in no uncertain terms.

x.com/bettscaro/status/1694784349659414908?s=46&t=SPorwN-mokktL467rcZ57g

ArabeIIaScott · 24/08/2023 22:12

One could probably FOI that?

OhHolyJesus · 24/08/2023 22:02

Just seen the GMB piece with one female presenter and an otherwise all male comment.

I wonder, after Dr Amir Khan told viewers that donated wombs can be harvested from dead and brain dead women, how many women actively opted out of organ donation.

I would genuinely like to see the numbers from today.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 24/08/2023 18:55

Your heart could go to someone who has committed murder, your lungs could go to a rapist. If you gift organs, you gift them. If you don’t want to give them, then fine but you cannot assign morality to it. Either do or don’t.

Womb transplants that may happen to indulge male fetishes are Frankenstein surgery so yes, I will assign morality to it. I will gift heart, lungs etc. and I hope they don't go to someone undeserving but I will never agree to my reproductive organs being donated (along with skin, tissue etc.)

Teder · 24/08/2023 18:49

EsmaCannonball · 23/08/2023 17:42

Some doctor somewhere will be willing to attempt a uterus transplant into a man, and the men who want this kind of thing will be in it purely for the fetish of having a womb inside them. Some of these men have a pregnancy fetish which, hopefully, will be completely futile and some of them will just get off on having what they see as the holy grail of womanhood harvested from an actual woman and implanted inside them.

The idea of poor women having to sell body parts so men can get their kicks is repellent, and I can't imagine many women would be happy to think that after death their uterus could be gifted to some creep after his ultimate thrill.

Your heart could go to someone who has committed murder, your lungs could go to a rapist. If you gift organs, you gift them. If you don’t want to give them, then fine but you cannot assign morality to it. Either do or don’t.

OhHolyJesus · 24/08/2023 17:18

Oh I see what you mean - I certainly don't remember that around the time.

I think a lot goes under the radar of even the biggest news outlets, and I don't follow them particularly.

Without Mumsnet I wouldn't have had prior warning.

ArabeIIaScott · 24/08/2023 16:56

OhHolyJesus · 24/08/2023 15:25

It's a huge shift, with very deep implications, and I didn't really hear many people discussing it.

I remember hearing about it on MN @ArabeIIaScott this could have been the thread at the time.

Opting out of organ donation | Mumsnet

Yeah, I meant that I thought there should have been a very well publicised campaign from the gov/NHS to survey people's feelings.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 15:44

Someone literally posted it further up, nothing in the research suggests it will be effective or possible.

Where? They have researched it, they made a point of saying there were no reasons clinically why it would definitely not work. I haven't seen anything of the nature you describe.

Sueveneers · 24/08/2023 15:39

DelurkingLawyer · 24/08/2023 15:14

The will absolutely is there. See this article from 2022: https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/doctor-planning-risky-womb-transplant-26882914.amp

From the earliest time that uterine transplants were discussed as a serious possibility the question has been framed in terms of “will transgender women be able to have children”. When I googled I was amazed at how many articles there were from 2016, 2017. I suspect it’s a big driver in the research. I don’t think the endgame was helping infertile women.

I don’t think the endgame was helping infertile women.

Exactly, of course it wasn't! I think most of us on this thread know that.

OhHolyJesus · 24/08/2023 15:25

It's a huge shift, with very deep implications, and I didn't really hear many people discussing it.

I remember hearing about it on MN @ArabeIIaScott this could have been the thread at the time.

Opting out of organ donation | Mumsnet

Opting out of organ donation | Mumsnet

So the law has changed and this spring the NHS will consider you to be an organ donor automatically if you don’t opt out. I haven’t had a chance to re...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3791909-Opting-out-of-organ-donation

DelurkingLawyer · 24/08/2023 15:14

stbrandonsboat · 24/08/2023 12:30

You're right, of course it'll happen. Where there's a will there's a way. Someone somewhere will absolutely be doing this and will keep trying until the problems are partially solved - as in trans surgery the results will be shoddy and only partially functional in most people. The hapless embryos and foetuses which will be lost along the way won't be considered at all. The trans recipients will be thrilled with their ghastly statuses as 'mothers' of non viable genetically dubious teratogenic offspring and the frankenmarch will go on.

All those saying it can't be done are wrong because what men want, men absolutely get even if it results in disaster.

The will absolutely is there. See this article from 2022: https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/doctor-planning-risky-womb-transplant-26882914.amp

From the earliest time that uterine transplants were discussed as a serious possibility the question has been framed in terms of “will transgender women be able to have children”. When I googled I was amazed at how many articles there were from 2016, 2017. I suspect it’s a big driver in the research. I don’t think the endgame was helping infertile women.

Doctor planning world's first womb transplant to allow trans woman to have baby

A doctor has told how he is &apos;optimistic&apos; about his plans to transplant a uterus into a transgender woman, so she could go on to carry a baby

https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/doctor-planning-risky-womb-transplant-26882914.amp

Stormydayagain · 24/08/2023 14:03

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 13:42

Someone literally posted it further up, nothing in the research suggests it will be effective or possible.

The fact that scientists have achieved a live birth via uterine transplant in rats is surely something to suggests it may be possible, and this was achieved in the most barbaric way at great expense to female rats.

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/study-that-impregnated-male-rats-stirs-controversy-68928

You seem to be in some serious denial about how pressing this issue is. It needs debating and stopping now not at some arbitrary point in the future deemed acceptable by you.

Study that Impregnated Male Rats Stirs Controversy

A combination of approaches, including uterus transplantation and the joining of two animals’ circulatory systems, allowed males to bear pups, according to a preprint. But some experts say the experiments were not justified.  

https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/study-that-impregnated-male-rats-stirs-controversy-68928

SunsetBeauregarde · 24/08/2023 13:42

Ereshkigalangcleg · 24/08/2023 12:21

Yes, and there are thousands of example of things that have been dreamed up but have turned out to not be possible. For every research paper that leads to a step forward, literally hundreds find dead ends. That’s literally the point of doing research like this, to understand possibility. There would be no point in conducting the research if you only ever researched things you already knew were possible.

That being the case, where are the research conclusions that it is likely to be prohibitively difficult?

Someone literally posted it further up, nothing in the research suggests it will be effective or possible.

ArabeIIaScott · 24/08/2023 13:23

OhHolyJesus · 24/08/2023 12:31

I checked on my status today and can see that I opted out in 2020 as that's when the government introduced an automatic assumed opt-in approach to standard transplant (heart, lung, kidney, etc).

Limbs, uterus, face and other reproductive organs such as penis, ovary, testicles remain on the novel transplant list with no government plans to change this list but at the time I remember thinking I didn't want to risk it so opted out of the scheme entirely, which didn't sit right, so I had a conversation with my next of kin.

I don't think the government, this one or future, will sanction carving us up without consent, but since then we have had academics proposing crazy ideas about 'whole body gestation' and universities conducting feasibility studies for womb implants into trans identifying men so forgive my caution over the reproductive parts of my body.

And I'm not keen on someone taking my hands either.

What I really am not happy with is the shift from what was a respectful position - encouraging people to add themselves to the register to help others - to a far more dictatorial and top-down approach - presuming everyone has given consent and - in my experience when I removed my name - scolding them if they decided to remove themself from the register.

The assumption that the NHS can lay claim to people's bodies without their consent is enormously alarming to me. It's a huge shift, with very deep implications, and I didn't really hear many people discussing it. These things are deeply personal and people's feelings and wishes and consent really must be respected.

More campaigns to encourage people to sign up to the register would have been far better.