Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
AfterOpQn · 23/08/2023 13:25

UsernameNotAvailableNow · 23/08/2023 10:41

@WeetabixTowels it was funded by a charity, so not the NHS thankfully. The fella that did the op is head of the charity. So led by a bloke obviously.

Paid for by a charity but took something like 25 surgical staff and two operating rooms out of action for the day.

RethinkingLife · 23/08/2023 13:22

Why give an alcoholic another chance at life with a new liver, but not a woman the chance to be a mother?

Transplant rules indicate that a liver would be transplanted into somebody who is abstinent (whatever previous status of alcohol use).

Most people who meet these criteria will be eligible for a transplant, although there are a few situations where you may be considered unsuitable. For example, you may not be able to have a transplant if you are unable to stop misusing alcohol, or you have liver cancer that has spread beyond the liver.

https://www.nhsinform.scot/tests-and-treatments/surgical-procedures/liver-transplant

If it's from a living donor, the donor's liver will regrow/regenerate in the absence of other complication.

The NHS already rations IVF. I don't know how far reproductive justice would demand the provision of services on the NHS. It's an interesting area for discussion.

Liver transplant

A liver transplant is an operation to remove a diseased or damaged liver and replace it with a healthy one.

https://www.nhsinform.scot/tests-and-treatments/surgical-procedures/liver-transplant

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 13:21

@Megifer just to be clear, it is absolutely your choice whether to be on the organ donor list or not. It’s the fact that you would still take an organ that doesn’t sit right. I don’t see how you can justify that to be honest.

NM12345 · 23/08/2023 13:20

LakeTiticaca · 23/08/2023 13:13

My main concern is the amount of resources used. 17 hours of surgery, 2 surgical teams, 8 surgeons, performing an experimental, unnecessary surgery which has a high probability of not working, while 1000s of patients are stuck in a huge backlog, some needing treatment for life threatening conditions..
Is this what Nye Bevan foresaw when he launched the NHS?
I very much doubt it

Except none of this used NHS resources...Doctors gave own time for research, funded outside the NHS

TheWayoftheLeaf · 23/08/2023 13:20

Dibblydoodahdah · 23/08/2023 13:09

I’ve got an anal skin tag. Had it for ten years since my second pregnancy. Causes me discomfort as it gets sore and it makes me feel disgusting as I can never clean properly. The NHS won’t do anything about it as it’s “cosmetic” but they will do a womb transplant which involves a huge medical team for many hours. Honestly, I get more fucked off by the day…

Have you considered a bidet hose that can be attached to the loo or sink? Might be a more comfy way to clean it

Beowulfa · 23/08/2023 13:19

Glad it's not just me who's uneasy at this report, and bemused by how it's spun as a jolly story. The lack of discussion about what hysterectomies entail is particularly worrying.

54isanopendoor · 23/08/2023 13:19

Elphame · 23/08/2023 10:45

I opted out of donating any organs as soon as we were all deemed to be up for grabs.

I do not regret my decision.

I have no particular worries about this donation as it was done from a live donor to a very close blood relative who otherwise could not have children but I am absolutely against the use of brain dead donors for a uterine transplant and transplants from live donors to unrelated strangers. That is absolutely ripe for abuse.

@Elphame I think that is the closest to how I feel about it too.
In this particular circumstance, it is clearly a Good Thing.
But it is ripe for many much more morally nuanced situations.

I realise it's different, & don't want to cause upset, but I think that about IVF too.
Due to male factor, I had icsi IVF to have my 2 children. I am grateful that for us, it was just a 'plumbing issue' it was morally 'straightforward' (though I lost sleep about unselected embryos & those in frozen storage that my (now exH) refused to use. But I'm aware IVF has become much more complex, & embryos can now be created with more than 2 parents genetic material & a different donors egg.
I still feel that IVF is a wonderful thing. It's amazing. But 'straightforward IVF' was more emotionally & physically complicated than I expected, so how much more might it be in more complex circs? How might it be for the baby once grown up?

I don't think that men will be able to have womb transplants or wombs will be harvested to be used by the rich / in labs (though I read The Handmaids Tale & thought it a possible direction that the US might one day take). But, where will it lead? Like IVF (I remember Louise Brown being born) we just don't know as it is the beginning of an experimental / new surgical procedure.

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 13:19

Megifer · 23/08/2023 13:18

Problem is, as you have sort of indicated with "currently", unless you check the website every day they could just update it

I think we’re a very long way from uterus and womb transplants being considered routine.

anotherside · 23/08/2023 13:18

@SquishyGloopyBum
I have to say I was disappointed with BBC coverage of this when I watched the breakfast news. It was very biased and portrayed positively

All BBC news has bias. It’s just more or less obvious depending on the existing prejudices of the audience.

ASGIRC · 23/08/2023 13:18

KimberleyClark · 23/08/2023 10:40

How long before poor vulnerable women are being prevailed upon or forced to sell their wombs?

Women with serious problems cannot get a hysterectomy, and you think anyone will be forcing them to get rid of theirs? Get a grip!

A uterus is an organ, like any other.
People donate kidneys and liver, while alive, all the time.

All other organs, including eyes, face and skin (none of which are life saving) also get donated post mortem. This changes nothing.
it is just another organ that can be successfully donated, if there is a need.

BungleandGeorge · 23/08/2023 13:18

all transplants aren’t live saving, what about corneal transplants? I’m personally happy to donate whether it’s to save a life or to considerably improve someone’s quality of life, if it’s a living donor clearly there is an informed consent process and donating the uterus is probably lower risk than a kidney or part of the liver which are well established. I’d have concerns around pregnancy and anti rejection treatment and the risk of cancer etc for those on those medicines and the ethics around that.
if you’re worried about non specified parts being taken surely you just use the tick boxes on the donor registration rather than withdraw altogether

Megifer · 23/08/2023 13:18

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 13:10

Just reposting the NHS article that @RethinkingLife linked to. Uterus and womb transplants clearly fall under non routine transplants and (currently) no one is in danger of having these organs taken from them without explicit and separate consent from your family.

https://www.organdonation.nhs.uk/helping-you-to-decide/about-organ-donation/consent/

Problem is, as you have sort of indicated with "currently", unless you check the website every day they could just update it

ElBandito · 23/08/2023 13:16

I've read the whole thread and come to the conclusion I might donate my uterus to another woman but not my ovaries.
I don't like the idea that someone else would be bringing up my genetic child and I would have no idea where that child was or how they were being treated.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 23/08/2023 13:14

Interesting how well the public relations people have played this. It’s a sister donating her already productive uterus to her sister who is physically unable to have a child

Let’s hope for them that the recipient is able to bear a healthy child to full term, which has a full genetic component for the family. That would be the perfect outcome.

Then when you have established public approval, even enthusiasm, you can start on the less ‘comfortable’ cases.

Scottishgirl85 · 23/08/2023 13:13

I see this as the same as any other organ transplant. In some cases, the chance to have children is literally life-saving. IVF enabled me to have my 3 children, if it hadn't worked I'm not sure how I'd have coped with a childless life.
Why give an alcoholic another chance at life with a new liver, but not a woman the chance to be a mother?

LakeTiticaca · 23/08/2023 13:13

My main concern is the amount of resources used. 17 hours of surgery, 2 surgical teams, 8 surgeons, performing an experimental, unnecessary surgery which has a high probability of not working, while 1000s of patients are stuck in a huge backlog, some needing treatment for life threatening conditions..
Is this what Nye Bevan foresaw when he launched the NHS?
I very much doubt it

Stormydayagain · 23/08/2023 13:12

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 23/08/2023 13:06

https://www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/body/health/a42771871/brain-dead-women-surrogate/

https://healthnews.com/news/brain-dead-women-should-be-used-as-surrogates-report-suggests/

ah, I knew that I couldn’t be the only one to consider this.
body gestational donation. Aka surrogacy with brain dead women!!

I think the brain and body tissues start to decay quite rapidly after brain death, so don't think surrogacy would be an option if strict brain stem testing rules are applied.

Tacocatgoatcheesepizza · 23/08/2023 13:10

Just reposting the NHS article that @RethinkingLife linked to. Uterus and womb transplants clearly fall under non routine transplants and (currently) no one is in danger of having these organs taken from them without explicit and separate consent from your family.

https://www.organdonation.nhs.uk/helping-you-to-decide/about-organ-donation/consent/

U.K. first womb transplant
CrazyFrogDingDing · 23/08/2023 13:09

TheWayoftheLeaf · 23/08/2023 12:57

@CrazyFrogDingDing a transplant of a womb into a woman is very different from a man.

  1. men's bodies do not have the hormones required to support a womb, cause periods or sustain a pregnancy.

  2. a man's pelvis cannot shift, flex or change shape to make room for a pregnancy.

  3. a man's body doesn't have the innate processes to grow a placenta, to leech vitamins from the bones/blood for a fetus. It cannot double its blood supply.

  4. a male neo-vagina doesn't have a cervix or the ability to dilate for birth.

Therefore a womb being placed in a a woman with every structure in place for pregnancy is very very far away from a male body being able to carry a pregnancy with a transplanted uterus. It just won't happen.

I understand what you're saying, but as I said in my post, there are many medical procedures that happen today, which not that many years ago would have been thought impossible.
Being able to surgically turn a bio man into a woman for one.
As science and medicine advances, it makes anything in the future possible.
It may not happen in mine or your lifetime , but guaranteed that it will at some point in the future.

Dibblydoodahdah · 23/08/2023 13:09

I’ve got an anal skin tag. Had it for ten years since my second pregnancy. Causes me discomfort as it gets sore and it makes me feel disgusting as I can never clean properly. The NHS won’t do anything about it as it’s “cosmetic” but they will do a womb transplant which involves a huge medical team for many hours. Honestly, I get more fucked off by the day…

Iwantcakeeveryday · 23/08/2023 13:09

Megifer · 23/08/2023 13:03

There is a tick list but its ambiguous to me. It would need to specifically state female reproductive system as an organ for me to opt out of for me to feel comfortable to go back on it.

I asked them some time ago about it specifically and there is no option for it so I removed myself entirely. I would select to exclude specifically these organs if they had given me that option knowing my concerns, but they didn't.

PumpkinsAndCoconuts · 23/08/2023 13:06

TheWayoftheLeaf · 23/08/2023 12:49

@PumpkinsAndCoconuts brain dead people who are organ donors have been used for organs for decades. For hearts and lungs and eyes, faces and hands and kidneys and livers and veins with their families permission.

It's literally no different with this one! It would be a huge jump from organ donation to living incubator and one that is miles away from each other ethically.

https://www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/body/health/a42771871/brain-dead-women-surrogate/

https://healthnews.com/news/brain-dead-women-should-be-used-as-surrogates-report-suggests/

ah, I knew that I couldn’t be the only one to consider this.
body gestational donation. Aka surrogacy with brain dead women!!

Backlash over idea to use 'brain dead' women for surrogate pregnancies

"There is no obvious medical reason why initiating such pregnancies would not be possible"

https://www.cosmopolitan.com/uk/body/health/a42771871/brain-dead-women-surrogate/

JudgeJ · 23/08/2023 13:05

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Just the same as heart, liver etc transplants, women's reproductive organs are nothing special.

SirVixofVixHall · 23/08/2023 13:04

SirSamVimesCityWatch · 23/08/2023 10:38

It scares me. We already have a worldwide commercial surrogacy business, with poor women in 2nd and 3rd world countries being paid to carry babies for the rich. It's not a stretch to imagine that womb harvesting of poor women for rich is the next step. Not to mention deluded transwomen (natal males) demanding womb transplantation as gender affirming surgery.

I'm an organ donor but my reproductive system is left off the "ok to take" list.

Totally agree.

anotherside · 23/08/2023 13:04

Btw I’m not supporting transplanting wombs into men, but once you’ve taken that first step of saying transplanting child growing organs for non medical purpose is fine, then it’s hard to see a further logical or ethical argument against it.