Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 15:18

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 15:09

Again though this does not mean this kind of treatment would actually work - it’s never been studied or tested. It’s just guessing.

Yes, I know. Why do you think this womb transplant charity and Imperial College carried out this research? And why did they lie about it when asked?

They didn’t lie - they said there was no suggestion that anyone at any point was suggesting transplanting a womb into a man - this is true.

I think the charity and the researchers conducted this research in order to transplant wombs into biological women with mechanical reasons for infertility related to the function of their womb.

If you’re referring to the research about asking trans women if they want a womb transplant in a survey, any scientific research that is funded has a duty to demonstrate how it has made efforts to avoid discrimination, and investigated all possible applications for the research. Again it is in no way an indication that this is anything other than criterial fulfilment.

Chersfrozenface · 23/08/2023 15:17

Naunet · 23/08/2023 15:14

If women don’t want to donate their uterus, they are fully entitled to that view, no emotional blackmail should be applied to them, it’s not going to save anyone’s life. If women remove themselves from the register because they can’t opt out of donating their uterus, then there’s a problem WITH THE REGISTER, not women.

Exactly. Amend the register to make it possible to refuse specifically and unalterably to donate any part of the reproductive system, and a good few women would be back on it.

Ponoka7 · 23/08/2023 15:15

@MissKittyFantastico84, globally people don't wake up with their organs missing? Yes they do. Women have babies cut out of them, families have children stolen. Look at the case of the human body sculptor Von Hagen's, it came to light that he didn't have consent. You can buy anything from mental institutions in some countries. Where families get away with honour killings, locking women up and putting them into asylums (as they still are in these countries), this is going to add another element to exploitation.

Naunet · 23/08/2023 15:14

MissKittyFantastico84 · 23/08/2023 15:09

Hello! Person with a life-saving kidney transplant here!

Few points:

  • immunosuppressant therapy doesn't cause birth defects. There is one medication called MMF which does, but it can be easily replicated with those that don't, should you wish to become pregnant.
  • if you have dramatically removed your name from the organ donor list in response to this, I truly hope you never have to experience the devastating slow decline of one of your vital organs, as your body slowly dies in front of you and your only hope is making it to the top of a list with a multitude of deciding factors in your way. Best of luck!
  • I don't know what horror films you've been watching, or urban legends you've been hearing around the campfire, but people don't wake up in ice baths with harvested organs.
  • all organ donations come from brain dead donors. If they were dead, their organs would be useless. Although they're working on this - yay science!
  • mumsnet is fucking mental sometimes.

If women don’t want to donate their uterus, they are fully entitled to that view, no emotional blackmail should be applied to them, it’s not going to save anyone’s life. If women remove themselves from the register because they can’t opt out of donating their uterus, then there’s a problem WITH THE REGISTER, not women.

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 15:12

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 15:09

Again though this does not mean this kind of treatment would actually work - it’s never been studied or tested. It’s just guessing.

Yes, I know. Why do you think this womb transplant charity and Imperial College carried out this research? And why did they lie about it when asked?

They didn't lie.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 15:10

all organ donations come from brain dead donors.

Can't you have a kidney donation from a living donor?

Ponoka7 · 23/08/2023 15:10

indyocean · 23/08/2023 10:35

Christ alive

I see it coming. Pregnant blokes 😳

An upside would be better maternity care and pain relief, CS would be seen as the surgery that it is with adequate after care.

But, yes, I'm very sceptical about what the ultimate aim for this was.

MissKittyFantastico84 · 23/08/2023 15:09

Hello! Person with a life-saving kidney transplant here!

Few points:

  • immunosuppressant therapy doesn't cause birth defects. There is one medication called MMF which does, but it can be easily replicated with those that don't, should you wish to become pregnant.
  • if you have dramatically removed your name from the organ donor list in response to this, I truly hope you never have to experience the devastating slow decline of one of your vital organs, as your body slowly dies in front of you and your only hope is making it to the top of a list with a multitude of deciding factors in your way. Best of luck!
  • I don't know what horror films you've been watching, or urban legends you've been hearing around the campfire, but people don't wake up in ice baths with harvested organs.
  • all organ donations come from brain dead donors. If they were dead, their organs would be useless. Although they're working on this - yay science!
  • mumsnet is fucking mental sometimes.
Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 15:09

Again though this does not mean this kind of treatment would actually work - it’s never been studied or tested. It’s just guessing.

Yes, I know. Why do you think this womb transplant charity and Imperial College carried out this research? And why did they lie about it when asked?

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 15:07

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 14:59

Yes of course, again you’ve not understood the context - that part of any research paper is a discursive section on feasibility of further research. ‘No clinical reason why it shouldn’t be’ is research short hand for ‘at this stage there’s no outright physiological reason why we couldn’t transplant a womb into a man’ - what it doesn’t mean and what you’re trying to suggest it means is ‘we should transplant wombs into men because it will allow them to have babies’.

In the pack given to the survey participants, they discuss how they could have babies in some detail, and also the "cyclical regime" of hormones that will allow them to experience periods, they suggest.

Yes, this would be to understand the hypothetical tolerance for treatment long term in order to achieve the desired womb transplant and the cost benefit relationship. It is a hypothetical (for want of a better word) ‘guesstimate’ about what treatment might involve to try and gain a realistic understanding of whom their treatment of this nature would be palatable. As it happens I think it’s flawed, given that if you ask a trans person if they’d cut off a leg in order to have a vagina they’d probably say yes, such is the dogma unfortunately.

Again though this does not mean this kind of treatment would actually work - it’s never been studied or tested. It’s just guessing.

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 15:05

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 14:29

And from the same paper:

(Note that the authors consider transwomen to be suffering from absolute uterine factor infertility (AUFI) i.e. lack of a womb, hitherto only recognised in natal women, snd that discrimination on the ground of "gender identity" is illegal, which is not the case in the UK.)

The bolding is mine.

And they lied about it. Ben Jones responded to Posie Parker which is quoted, he is an Imperial College researcher on that paper and part of the womb transplant charity. He told her categorically that there was no suggestion whatsoever that anyone was looking at uterus transplants into men.

Do you have links for where people are actively looking, or even thinking, about performing womb transplants into transgender women? Because that isn't what anything posted here, or elsewhere, says. Admittedly, you need an understanding of reading research papers and some people may see the discussion points at the end of papers to mean that it's actually being considered.

EsmaCannonball · 23/08/2023 15:05

All I know for certain is that poor women from poor countries are going to end up selling their wombs to rich women from rich countries. (And most of the money will go to middlemen.)

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 15:03

Cynicaltheorist · 23/08/2023 14:43

I think it’s acceptable to assume people have differing levels of strength of feeling around this particular topic and the drive to have children is as individual as anything else. ‘Making your peace with it’ may well have worked for you, it was never an option for me.

So what did you do and where would you draw the line? Would you use a surrogate? Would you have a woman in a baby factory in the Ukraine have a baby for you?

If you’re interested, surrogacy was my line. I did consider it for a long time when I was younger, probably about 5 years into trying but as I grew older I understood that my only route for surrogacy from the U.K. would have been effectively paying someone to carry a child. My personal politics by that time meant the morality of this was my line in the sand and I would have rather died. It’s alarming now how matter of fact I was about it all. As I say, totally lucid.

We also looked into adoption, fostering etc. For reasons I won’t go into we couldn’t have IVF or IVI. we were part way through the adoption process (early stages) when I fell pregnant in 2020. Having had a lot of miscarriages I thought nothing of it really, but this baby stuck around long enough for them to agree to a cerclage procedure and my gorgeous little boy is now 2, and we have continued with the adoption process for his sibling who will be joining our family soon Smile.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 23/08/2023 15:02

NM12345 · 23/08/2023 13:20

Except none of this used NHS resources...Doctors gave own time for research, funded outside the NHS

I wonder if the immunosuppressants required long term are funded privately or by the NHS.
And whether or not the removal of the uterus after two years is also funded privately or by the NHS - after all, by then it will be imperative it is removed due to the health risks of the continuous immunosuppressants required by the recipient.
And if the recipient manages to get pregnant, twice, as planned, will those pregnancies be fully funded privately or by the NHS?
And if the babies that are born are born prematurely, and/or otherwise affected detrimentally due to the fetal toxicity of the immunosuppressives they will be exposed to for the whole pregnancy - will all of that be funded privately or by the NHS? You can’t give up your time and resources for free only at the weekends to look after a premature baby in a NICU after all…

NutellaEllaElla · 23/08/2023 15:01

LittleMrsPretty · 23/08/2023 14:36

@NutellaEllaElla
Thats correct

Well that may be the case for you, but for others here, myself included, it is possible to see that while I may want something, there may be valid reasons as to why I can't have it. It's the same with other things too , though this one may be wanted more intensely. The principle is the same.

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 14:59

LadyKenya · 23/08/2023 13:45

That would hardly be likely to ensure that their names are included in footnotes of medical history though.

You obviously don't understand medical research very well

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 14:59

Yes of course, again you’ve not understood the context - that part of any research paper is a discursive section on feasibility of further research. ‘No clinical reason why it shouldn’t be’ is research short hand for ‘at this stage there’s no outright physiological reason why we couldn’t transplant a womb into a man’ - what it doesn’t mean and what you’re trying to suggest it means is ‘we should transplant wombs into men because it will allow them to have babies’.

In the pack given to the survey participants, they discuss how they could have babies in some detail, and also the "cyclical regime" of hormones that will allow them to experience periods, they suggest.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 14:56

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 14:48

Again, no suggestion here either that transplanting wombs into men is biologically feasible.

They said in the first paper that they don't see any clinical reason why it wouldn't be, and speculated about how it would probably be more risky and invasive for the donor. You read that, no?

Yes of course, again you’ve not understood the context - that part of any research paper is a discursive section on feasibility of further research. ‘No clinical reason why it shouldn’t be’ is research short hand for ‘at this stage there’s no outright physiological reason why we couldn’t transplant a womb into a man’ - what it doesn’t mean and what you’re trying to suggest it means is ‘we should transplant wombs into men because it will allow them to have babies’.

I think that fundamentally where the confusion has come from here.

Taketurn · 23/08/2023 14:55

Zipidydodah · 23/08/2023 14:18

Why? Why would that happen? There are thousands of people who need kidneys and die waiting for a transplant. There aren’t mass cases of women being kidnapped and having their kidney removed and the recipients die waiting so why would there be for a womb?

Why is it that some people ONLY think as far as their eyes can see?
Why is it that some people don't bother researching certain things?
Maybe read the whole thread, you may find some answers.

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 14:54

Dibblydoodahdah · 23/08/2023 13:09

I’ve got an anal skin tag. Had it for ten years since my second pregnancy. Causes me discomfort as it gets sore and it makes me feel disgusting as I can never clean properly. The NHS won’t do anything about it as it’s “cosmetic” but they will do a womb transplant which involves a huge medical team for many hours. Honestly, I get more fucked off by the day…

When have the NHS done a womb transplant?

Naunet · 23/08/2023 14:53

Slothtoes · 23/08/2023 14:51

Why are we even considering men (whatever their gender identity views) should ever get womb transplants? No way- too risky for man, way too risky for any baby- though it would never get to gestate to term because men’s bodies aren’t designed to carry pregnancies. Obviously.

There’s enough issues to think about with women donating wombs to other women and whether this safe for women or babies and is a good use of NHS resources, and what the wider social implications of all that might be.

Because men want it, and saying no to men is The Worst Thing Ever.

Judashascomeintosomemoney · 23/08/2023 14:53

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 14:45

Yes, this survey was mentioned up thread.

Again, no suggestion here either that transplanting wombs into men is biologically feasible. This is qual research into whether or not womb transplant is desirable for trans women. Shocker, it is.

Again with my toddler nipple tassels example - I could conduct research and ask a bunch of 3 year olds if they would like nipple tassels in their size. Many might say yes, it does not mean this would ever be considered for production.

Changing sex isn’t feasible (possible) either.
And yet, look at the multi million dollar industry that has been created pretending that it is.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 23/08/2023 14:53

Of course they'll be researching it 🤣🤣🤣 somewhere right now there will be a poor fucker of a mouse with a uterus growing on its back ready to transplant into a male mouse 🙄

Exactly, the naivety I see on here on a daily basis is breath taking. Like if it isn't happening in the UK then it isn't happening anywhere🙄

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 14:53

I can because it’s not comparable - that’s like saying ALL transplants are somehow exploitative because…. Feminism? Im not sure what your argument is or how you are drawing up a comparison between women paying other women to rent their bodies to have children, and a woman receiving a womb at great personal jeopardy to herself in order to put herself through pregnancy. It’s not the same.

FYI I’m not against altruistic surrogacy where no money is exchanged and the birthing woman and non birthing woman are matched anonymously; where the birthing woman presents herself as a surrogate with no coercion either financial or anything else.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 23/08/2023 14:52

KimberleyClark · 23/08/2023 14:13

In terms of quality of life, there’s nothing I can think of that could improve it more for a couple going through infertility than to hopefully have a child successfully. You really can’t know the pain of it unless you’ve been there.

I went through infertility and never had a child. But I have made my peace with it and enjoy my life now. I think we need to get away from this way of thinking that not being able to have a child is the worst possible thing that can happen to a woman and that it justifies anything and everything to prevent it.

This absolutely. It is sad but the fact someone can;t have a baby doesn't mean that anything that could enable it is the right thing to do.