Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

U.K. first womb transplant

719 replies

VestaTilley · 23/08/2023 10:29

The BBC has reported today that the first womb transplant has taken place in a hospital in England. A 40 year old woman donated her womb to her sister, hopefully enabling her to have children.

AIBU to be concerned about a potential dystopian future where women’s reproductive organs are harvested like car parts?

Journalists are treating this like it’s a positive, with few questions being asked about how the donor is recovering, how the foetus (if the recipient does conceive) will fare if the woman has to continue taking immuno suppressive drugs? Whether there is increased miscarriage risk?

Transplants are supposed to be life saving, not about wish fulfilment. Apparently 10 brain dead women are being lined up for future donation!

To me this all seems part of a bigger picture of surrogacy, synthetic embryo creation (reported earlier this year) and a drive to disassociate women from reproduction and the biology of our sex.

Am I alone in being bothered by this? I wish journalists would look more at the bigger societal picture.

Link here: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

The surgeons performing the womb transplant

Woman receives sister's womb in first UK transplant

The 34-year-old hopes to now become a mum as older sister donates her womb in pioneering transplant.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-66514270

OP posts:
Thread gallery
31
SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 16:23

Nanny0gg · 23/08/2023 16:21

I feel very sad when women desperately want children and can't have them

However - the NHS is on its knees and is this the best use of resources when people could be given a better quality of life if they received treatment?
It also took a team of 30 to do the procedure.

I just don't think we're in a financial position to do this

And then yes, the ethical questions. Where will it stop? Just for women? Or not...?

This procedure was not in any way funded or performed by the NHS.

Nanny0gg · 23/08/2023 16:22

WeetabixTowels · 23/08/2023 10:39

Also has the NHS struck gold? I’ve been waiting fucking years for very minor surgery that I had to beg for to ensure I’m not in pain every day. But they can spend money on what is essentially an experimental surgery

^^This

Nanny0gg · 23/08/2023 16:21

MsFannySqueers · 23/08/2023 10:37

I agree OP the whole situation is revolting. I am not a fan of surrogacy at all but surely this woman’s sister could have carried a baby for her? I was only able to have one child which makes me very lucky I guess. No one has the absolute right to have children.

I feel very sad when women desperately want children and can't have them

However - the NHS is on its knees and is this the best use of resources when people could be given a better quality of life if they received treatment?
It also took a team of 30 to do the procedure.

I just don't think we're in a financial position to do this

And then yes, the ethical questions. Where will it stop? Just for women? Or not...?

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 16:18

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 16:16

If they don't want people to opt out entirely, the NHS really do need to offer clarity in how people can opt out their genetic material or reproductive organs.

Wombs aren’t part of harvesting currently, it’s a separate register and I imagine will be added as a yes/no tick box along with everything else if it ever becomes viable and added to the main register. I agree this would need to be clarified though, it was the same when corneas were added. I remember people feeling very strange about donating loved ones eyes, but that seems to have become a lot more accepted now.

yetanotherchangeofnamey · 23/08/2023 16:18

indyocean · 23/08/2023 10:35

Christ alive

I see it coming. Pregnant blokes 😳

Wait till a pregnant man realises he doesn't have the hips to support a rapidly growing baby inside of him 😀

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 16:16

If they don't want people to opt out entirely, the NHS really do need to offer clarity in how people can opt out their genetic material or reproductive organs.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 16:16

Taketurn · 23/08/2023 16:13

Sometimes humans can be quite selfish. "How can it benefit me?"
without thinking about how detrimental it can be for others.
It's life and I don't think that can ever be eradicated.

Is this not the case for all transplants though? I wonder if we’re back at the train carriage problem - accept harm to a very few to benefit the many etc with transplant ethics generally?

I don’t see how the ethics of womb transplants are any different to other transplanted organs, and I say that as a member of the register.

SemperIdem · 23/08/2023 16:14

This sickens me, actually.

I will be making it clear that my womb, along with my face, and limbs, are not to be harvested upon my death.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 16:14

Sometimes humans can be quite selfish. "How can it benefit me?"
without thinking about how detrimental it can be for others.
It's life and I don't think that can ever be eradicated.

Indeed.

Taketurn · 23/08/2023 16:13

Iwantcakeeveryday · 23/08/2023 16:10

Completely agree with this. It is frustrating that people don't consider these possibilities that are outside our small bubble.

Sometimes humans can be quite selfish. "How can it benefit me?"
without thinking about how detrimental it can be for others.
It's life and I don't think that can ever be eradicated.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 16:13

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 16:06

The researcher here did not lie

Yes he did. At the very least he lied by omission in terms of the "illegal, impossible and no demand for it". He was also directly asked if they were carrying out a survey into putting wombs into men. He said no. I won't be engaging with your tedious gaslighting further.

He did not lie. It is illegal currently to transplant a womb into a man, it is likely impossible and currently, there is no demand for either the law or the possibility of it to change.

He is not researching putting wombs into men, he sanctioned a very small questionnaire investigating whether trans women would want a procedure like that if it existed as part of an existing study follow up to satisfy the further research criteria of that study. This is very common practice.

Pointing out where you have fundamentally misunderstood your own ‘evidence’ is not gaslighting, and throwing the word ‘gaslighting’ around like that is damaging to women in abusive circumstances. It also doesn’t further your position or make your point any more valid, or your declaration that trans women will be getting wombs in the future any more true.

Iwantcakeeveryday · 23/08/2023 16:10

Changeforachange · 23/08/2023 16:02

I've read the first and last page

Multiple women claiming (because it will never in a million years be a reality to them) how happy they'd be to give up their uterus to help another woman have a baby.

Super. But just like surrogacy, every lovely, consensual, benevolent 'donation' would pave the way towards coercive, pressurised, commercial ramifications for women in third and developing countries to sell their bodies and body parts. Which is here & happening right now.

But let's not consider that inconvenient truth that before announcing how brilliant it is, because we're first world and it's never going to affect us, so we're alright jack 👍

Completely agree with this. It is frustrating that people don't consider these possibilities that are outside our small bubble.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 16:09

I don't trust people who either lie, or hide behind semantics.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 16:06

The researcher here did not lie

Yes he did. At the very least he lied by omission in terms of the "illegal, impossible and no demand for it". He was also directly asked if they were carrying out a survey into putting wombs into men. He said no. I won't be engaging with your tedious gaslighting further.

Changeforachange · 23/08/2023 16:02

I've read the first and last page

Multiple women claiming (because it will never in a million years be a reality to them) how happy they'd be to give up their uterus to help another woman have a baby.

Super. But just like surrogacy, every lovely, consensual, benevolent 'donation' would pave the way towards coercive, pressurised, commercial ramifications for women in third and developing countries to sell their bodies and body parts. Which is here & happening right now.

But let's not consider that inconvenient truth that before announcing how brilliant it is, because we're first world and it's never going to affect us, so we're alright jack 👍

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 16:02

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 15:52

Anyway, we will have to agree to differ, @SunsetBeauregarde because I don't see the point of this back and forth any more.

This womb charity and several of the surgical team in the operation which is the subject of the OP carried out preliminary research and fact finding into whether male uterine transplants were something which could be considered for MTF. One of the senior researchers also lied about whether they were interested in this when asked.

I've linked to the thread and people are free to decide themselves to read it and what to think.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3605548-Imperial-College-Womb-Transplant-Survey-Redux

You don't think it's worthy of note, I do. That's fine.

I think this is a natural end to the chat and thanks for it, it’s been interesting to understand where a lot of this rhetoric is coming from.

You’re labouring under a false assumption that the presence of further research or suggestions of applications is a confirmation of belief or support in a particular world view - it is not. The researcher here did not lie and the fact (immutable) remains that there is no suggestion of transplanting a womb into a biological man, and therefore including the trans debate in whether or not women should receive womb transplants is a bit of a moot point. It’s like arguing unicorns shouldn’t be allowed to work in cloud factories - it’s just pointless rhetoric.

You have not understood the premise of the research you’ve put forward which is unfortunate but that doesn’t mean you’re wrong - you’re absolutely right to question stuff like this when it arises, I just wish people waited and fully interrogated things before they go fully frothy.

The fact some people have removed themselves from the donor register despite the donor register for womb transplants being a totally separate process and nothing to do with organ donation is just further evidence that people on this thread have absolutely no interest in fact and just love a bit of outrage to stampede about.

Frydaycryday · 23/08/2023 16:02

Naunet · 23/08/2023 15:46

And are you happy for them to use it for research on how to make implants into men possible? Not all donations are used for transplant.

I work in organ Donation, that's not how organ donation works. It will always be to a recipient on a transplant list.

That would be a body donated to research.... Which I have actually left my body to research at a major university.

minasmemory · 23/08/2023 16:00

I agree it is worrying, like with all these things a line needs to be drawn somewhere. It is concerning when if feels like people may be seen as a potential resource of tissue and organs for rich people on the other hand if I did die an untimely death and my organs could help someone live who may other wise die or be left horribly disfigured or disabled then I would be happy with that. I am not sure womb transplants fit that criteria though.

Where I would draw the line is if there was any chance a male could potentially end up with my uterus or ovaries, if that were ever to be a possibility I would remove my consent for organ donation completely in protest.

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 15:53

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 23/08/2023 15:50

Brain dead people are the only people who can donate any organs though- you have to be on life support

They're referring to living donations - such as kidney or part of liver.

Toddlerteaplease · 23/08/2023 15:53

UsernameNotAvailableNow · 23/08/2023 10:35

I read that article and immediately went to update my organ donation so they can’t take my tissue. It was the only option that I figured covered reproductive organs. I’ve also told DH.

I can absolutely envisage a future where we’re harvested for our reproductive organs.

Just tried and you can't update that one!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 15:52

Anyway, we will have to agree to differ, @SunsetBeauregarde because I don't see the point of this back and forth any more.

This womb charity and several of the surgical team in the operation which is the subject of the OP carried out preliminary research and fact finding into whether male uterine transplants were something which could be considered for MTF. One of the senior researchers also lied about whether they were interested in this when asked.

I've linked to the thread and people are free to decide themselves to read it and what to think.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3605548-Imperial-College-Womb-Transplant-Survey-Redux

You don't think it's worthy of note, I do. That's fine.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 15:52

CraggyIslandTouristBoard · 23/08/2023 15:51

Would you be happy to give it to this trans identifying man, who wants a womb so he can be the first man to have an abortion, I wonder….?

Wondered when this would pop up. This is a single (fairly crackers) person making an inflammatory statement for clout on the internet. Let’s not pretend it’s more than that.

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 15:51

Ereshkigalangcleg · 23/08/2023 15:45

They didn’t lie when asked.

Yes they did. They said:

"We will never even consider performing womb transplants in men. This is not possible, legal, nor do I think there is a demand for it."

They may believe TWAW when they answer no to "men" but it's only illegal because men are male, and that includes "trans women", their gender identity notwithstanding.

They think it's "legally impermissible" to exclude them in a scenario where it was feasible to implant wombs into men. They don't actually think it's "impossible" and they are carrying out a study to see what the demand is, so they don't think there is none at all.

So his statement contained three lies. As well as the one where he answers that no they aren't carrying out this specific questionnaire on survey monkey. When they were.

Yes you’re will fully not understanding - that statement is correct. It’s factual. No one has considered transplanting a womb into a man and he has also gone a step further there and said he personally will never consider doing it. They have conducted preliminary research into the possibility of it in the least effortful way they can (a survey) to satisfy the criteria of their research grant.

Again, the statement is not a lie. Studying something does not mean you’re considering doing it, looking into it or in any way supporting it. Again again, nipple tassels for toddlers.

CraggyIslandTouristBoard · 23/08/2023 15:51

Frydaycryday · 23/08/2023 15:28

Well as a donor you can decline specific organs.

I have no problem with anyone using my womb after I clearly no longer need it.

Would you be happy to give it to this trans identifying man, who wants a womb so he can be the first man to have an abortion, I wonder….?

Man Wants Uterus So He Can Be First "Trans-Woman" To Abort A Baby

Like and subscribe for the best pro-life content! ________Follow Live Action:Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/liveactionorg/Facebook: https://www.faceboo...

https://youtu.be/1wR6xI_TQAU

justteanbiscuits · 23/08/2023 15:50

SunsetBeauregarde · 23/08/2023 15:25

They didn’t lie when asked.

I have explained why this kind of research was undertaken.

No one, at any point, has insinuated you’re anything other than an intelligent person asking good questions. Showing you where you’ve misunderstood something is not calling you thick, there is no point discussing these kinds of topics if you start from a position of misunderstanding. Misunderstanding is no indicative of a lack of intelligence or education, but correcting a misunderstanding relies on you actually wanting to understand better. If you’re happier with ignorant outrage.. I guess crack on?

Your response is excellent